← all systems · see it in The System
Misner string
'a Misner string singularity on the polar axis (the gravitational analogue of the Dirac string for the magnetic monopole), with still debated features'; in Lorentzian and Euclidean Taub-NUT 'a conical singularity which form a one-dimensional string analogous to Dirac string. It is called Misner string'; in d dimensions Misner strings are 'surfaces of dimension d - 2', 'Dirac strings in the Kaluza Klein reduction with respect to the time translation Killing vector'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the polar axis (theta = 0 and/or pi, set by the parameter C) where the metric term -f(dt - 2n(cos theta + C) d phi)^2 is singular, and the charges said to sit along it. Outside: the closed-timelike-curve neighbourhood around it (bounded by Sigma = 0), the horizons, the regions at spacelike infinity. |
| nested level | A line (or d - 2 surface) feature of the Taub-NUT spacetime, a kind of Dirac string (in the Kaluza-Klein reading); runs through the NUT regions. Rung 1, hypothesised. |
| representation | True |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (7) published science
| time period under Misner's identification | 8 pi n (8 pi l; Euclidean beta = 8 pi n) time (geometric units) |
| CTC region boundary | Sigma(r, theta) = rho^2 sin^2 theta - 4 n^2 f (cos theta + C)^2 = 0 surface |
| no closed causal geodesics | |C| <= 1 parameter range |
| closed null geodesic example | m = 0, C = -sqrt(3): circle t = const, r = sqrt(3) n, theta = arctan sqrt(2) coordinates |
| Taub-Bolt Misner-string Hamiltonian; entropy | H_MS = -N/8; S = pi N^2 geometric units |
| Misner string named (Misner 1963, J. Math. Phys. 4, 924) | 1963 year |
| characteristic clock: the geodesic's angular period, 2 pi/J in the parameter lambda (North crossings at lambda = 2k pi/J) | 2 pi/J affine parameter |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-028 Is Taub-NUT spacetime complete, or is it riddled with time loops?
booked: The map keeps both readings, using each where its sources speak: the older view with time loops everywhere, and the 2015 view of a complete spacetime with a transparent string.
the other reading: the other reading
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (6)
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Misner string even
- Taub-NUT spacetime via sys:spacetime · Misner string even
- NUT gravitational dyon via sys:gravitational-field · Misner string even
- Geodesic via sys:spacetime · Misner string even
- Closed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Misner string loss
- NUT region via sys:spacetime · Misner string even
floor filled by (7)
- Taub-NUT spacetime
- Gravitational field
- Misner space
- NUT gravitational dyon
- Geodesic
- Closed timelike curve
- NUT region
represents (1)
wired (3)
Notes published science
- The string that made most theorists call Taub-NUT unphysical turns out, in Clement et al.'s analysis, to be 'completely transparent': free-falling particles pass straight through it.
- Hiding the string has a price: Misner made time periodic (period 8 pi n), which fills the whole spacetime with closed timelike curves.
- In Euclidean gravity the string carries entropy, as horizons do (Hawking and Hunter).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Misner string (own, singular axis of the NUT metric)
- L1: The polar axis where -f(dt - 2n(cos theta + C) d phi)^2 is singular: 'a conical singularity which form a one-dimensional string' (Lorentzian), surfaces of dimension d - 2 in general
- L2: Placement by C: C = -1 south, C = 1 north, C = 0 both; 'C should be considered as physical rather than pure gauge parameter, since it changes the asymptotic behavior of the metric'
- L3: Transparency: geodesics cross it periodically (North at lambda = 2k pi/J, South at (2k + 1) pi/J); 'Clearly the Misner string is completely transparent to the geodesic motion!'
- L4: The CTC neighbourhood: Sigma(r, theta) = rho^2 sin^2 theta - 4n^2 f (cos theta + C)^2 < 0 outside the horizon; the surface Sigma = 0 is 'a causal singularity ... where the signature of the spacetime changes'; for |C| <= 1 'no closed timelike or null geodesics'
- L5: Removal by identification (Misner 1963): time periodic with period 8 pi n; two coordinate patches for the hemispheres; then 'closed time-like curves everywhere' and the extension is 'either geodesically incomplete ... or ... non-Hausdorff'
charges along the Misner string (gravitational field)
- L1: The NUT charge n, a 'magnetic-type mass', whose string the Misner string is
- L2: Bonnor's reading: 'the Misner string should be interpreted as a singular material source of angular momentum'
- L3: Charges along it: 'additional mass, nut, angular momentum, electric and magnetic charge densities distributed along Misner string', needed for the difference between horizon and infinity values; 'Misner string charges play an essential role in the first law, without them the first law is not satisfied'
- L4: Euclidean reading: an obstruction to foliation that carries entropy, S = (A_bolts + A_MS)/4G - beta H_MS; Taub-Bolt: Misner-string area -12 pi N^2 (relative), H_MS = -N/8, S = pi N^2
Sources (4) published science
Nouri-Zonoz M., Lynden-Bell D. (1998) Gravomagnetic lensing by NUT space, arXiv:gr-qc/9812094 (MNRAS) (behind its links)