← all systems · see it in The System
Chronology protection conjecture
'Simply put, chronology protection is the assertion that nature abhors a time machine. In the words of Stephen Hawking: It seems that there is a Chronology Protection Agency which prevents the appearance of closed timelike curves and so makes the universe safe for historians.' 'Some physicists speculate that the CTCs which appear in certain GR solutions might be ruled out by a future theory of quantum gravity which would replace GR, an idea which Stephen Hawking labeled the chronology protection conjecture.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the projected mechanism that would stop closed causal curves forming locally: the chronology horizon and its fountain, the classical energy boost of light circulating on it, the semiclassical divergence of vacuum stress-energy on polarized hypersurfaces, its back-reaction, and the limit where semiclassical gravity fails (Kay-Radzikowski-Wald). Outside: cosmological time machines such as Goedel's ('best viewed as an example of the GIGO principle'), which are 'intrinsically and equally sick everywhere'; the rival responses (radical re-write, Novikov consistency, 'boring physics'); the full quantum-gravity theory that would settle it. |
| nested level | A conjectured mechanism of quantum fields on curved spacetime at a chronology horizon (a kind of Cauchy horizon), to be settled in quantum gravity. Field scale, rung 1, hypothesised; walked as a projected model. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (9) published science
| energy boost per circuit of the fountain | E -> e^h E, h = -2 Re (loop integral of epsilon dt) factor |
| leading divergence of renormalized stress-energy | <T>_R ~ sum over non-trivial geodesics of Delta^(1/2) / sigma^2 energy density |
| proposed (Hawking, Phys. Rev. D 46, 603-611) | July 1992 date |
| general semiclassical proof that the stress-energy is infinite or undefined on the horizon | 1997 year |
| technical articles on chronology protection by 2002 | well over 200 count |
| classes of temporally ill-behaved standard spacetimes listed | 7 (Goedel; Van Stockum/Tipler/spinning strings; Kerr and Kerr-Newman; Gott; Wheeler wormholes; Morris-Thorne wormholes; Alcubierre) count |
| community reactions to time machines | 4 (radical re-write; Novikov consistency; chronology protection; boring physics) count |
| scale of the deciding region | self-intersecting geodesics shorter than the Planck length, M(L_Planck) - M(0) |
| characteristic clock: one circuit of the fountain | effectively zero 'elapsed' time |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
- Cauchy horizon
Sits inside / holds (1)
Trades with (valence) (11)
- Misner space via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture mixed
- BTZ black hole via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture gain
- Novikov self-consistency principle via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture mixed
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Chronology protection conjecture gain
- Kerr spacetime via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture gain
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model) via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture loss
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture even
- Cauchy horizon via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture even
- Traversable wormhole via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture gain
- Closed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture gain
- Cosmic censorship hypothesis via sys:spacetime · Chronology protection conjecture even
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- Tipler cylinder
- Misner space
- BTZ black hole
- Traversable wormhole
- Photon
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Kerr spacetime
- Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
- Chronology horizon
- Ring of wormholes (Roman ring)
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
- 'Radical re-write' conjecture
- 'Boring physics' conjecture
- Chronological censorship
- Novikov self-consistency principle
Notes published science
- Hawking's own phrasing: a 'Chronology Protection Agency' that 'makes the universe safe for historians'.
- On the fountain a single photon goes round infinitely many times in effectively zero elapsed time, gaining energy by a fixed factor each lap: an infinite energy in no time, unless the lens-like defocusing wins.
- The decision is pushed to below the Planck length: the region that decides is the one covered by loops of space shorter than the Planck length, where no current theory works.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
chronology protection (projected model: back-reaction at the chronology horizon)
- L1: The chronology-violating region (points with a closed causal curve through them) and the chronology horizon, 'the boundary of the future of the chronology violating region'; for locally built time machines it is compactly generated and contains a 'fountain', 'essentially the first closed null curve to come into existence as the time machine is formed'
- L2: Classical argument: a photon on the fountain 'will circulate around the fountain infinitely many times; in effectively zero "elapsed" time', its energy boosted E -> e^h E each circuit (h = -2 Re of the loop integral of the Newman-Penrose epsilon); against it, defocusing ('a diverging lens'); 'it depends'
- L3: Semiclassical argument: self-intersecting null geodesics define the N-th polarized hypersurfaces approaching the horizon; <T>_R ~ sum Delta^(1/2) / sigma^2 'diverges at the fountain'; 'infinite stress-energy implies, via the Einstein equations, infinite curvature'; the standard reading was that the horizon 'is destroyed'
- L4: Exceptions: a ring of wormholes where 'the renormalized stress-energy tensor (and the quantum-induced back reaction) can be made arbitrarily small'; toy models from Grant and Misner spacetimes finite 'all the way up to the chronology horizon'
- L5: The limit: Kay-Radzikowski-Wald, 'semiclassical Einstein equations fail to hold' at points of the horizon; the deciding region M(L_Planck) - M(0) is covered by self-intersecting spacelike geodesics shorter than the Planck length; 'Chronology protection must then be settled ... at the level of a full theory of quantum gravity'
protection seen in exact solutions (hidden or walled-off time loops)
- L1: Hidden loops: Kerr and Kerr-Newman time loops 'safely hidden behind the Cauchy horizon' (inner horizon classically unstable); in the 2+1 black hole 'the closed timelike lines are hidden behind the horizon at r = r+'; chronological censorship
- L2: Walled-off loops: in the 2+1 black hole matter couplings bring 'a barrier of infinite curvature' at r = 0, which 'makes the closed timelike lines not reachable'; 'In this sense we see that "chronology is protected" in the 2+1 black-hole'
vacuum polarization near a chronology horizon (quantum vacuum)
- L1: Quantum fields on the curved background, gravity kept classical; the two-point function (a measure of the mean square fluctuations) 'of any quantum field is of Hadamard form'
- L2: Renormalization removes the trivial geodesic; non-trivial geodesics from x to itself remain, and null ones add 'an additional infinity in the stress-energy'; for a wormhole time machine an ordinary beam is 'defocused', but vacuum fluctuations 'would spontaneously refocus on the trip between the mouths' (encyclopedia)
- L3: Back-reaction versus fluctuation: 'Does the back-reaction ... become large before the quantum fluctuations in the metric completely invalidate the manifold picture?' (Hawking-Thorne debate); 'It is now generally accepted that typically the back reaction becomes large before metric fluctuations invalidate the manifold picture, but that there are exceptional geometries'
Sources (7) published science
Chronology protection conjecture (Wikipedia, rev 1374708700, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Closed timelike curve (Wikipedia, rev 1372229033, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Lobo, F. S. N. (2010) Closed timelike curves and causality violation, arXiv:1008.1127 (review) (behind its links)
Banados M., Henneaux M., Teitelboim C., Zanelli J. (1993) Geometry of the 2+1 black hole, submitted to Phys. Rev. D (arXiv:gr-qc/9302012) (behind its links)
Misner space (Wikipedia, rev 1268320897, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)