← all systems · see it in The System
Novikov self-consistency principle
A principle developed by Igor Novikov in the mid-1980s to solve the problem of paradoxes in time travel in solutions of general relativity that contain closed timelike curves: if an event exists that would cause a paradox or any 'change' to the past whatsoever, then the probability of that event is zero.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the set of local solutions of the ordinary laws of physics on a spacetime with CTCs that extend to a globally self-consistent solution, and the consistency constraints that pick them out (classically, and as a sum over self-consistent histories quantum mechanically). Outside: the laws themselves (unchanged: 'a principle of no new physics'); initial data posed before the Cauchy horizon, which it apparently does not constrain. |
| nested level | A rule that would act on the states carried round closed timelike curves (the CTC walk books it on its floor 2); embedded in CTC spacetimes such as wormhole time machines; a rival of the chronology protection conjecture as a remedy for time-travel paradoxes (Lobo). |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| developed | mid-1980s (Novikov books 1975 and 1983; principle named in Friedman et al. 1990) date |
| probability of a paradox-causing event | 0 probability |
| self-consistent extensions per initial trajectory (billiard ball) | more than one; infinitely many for every initial trajectory analysed (Echeverria et al.) count |
| initial conditions found with no consistent extension | 0 (searched, none found; not proven) count |
| computational power with negative delay | NP in polynomial time (Deutsch 1991); PSPACE (Aaronson) complexity class |
| characteristic clock: the loop time (time shift between wormhole mouths) | no value given s |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (5)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:stress-energy · Novikov self-consistency principle even
- Cauchy horizon via sys:spacetime · Novikov self-consistency principle mixed
- Traversable wormhole via sys:spacetime · Novikov self-consistency principle gain
- Closed timelike curve via sys:stress-energy · Novikov self-consistency principle gain
- Chronology protection conjecture via sys:spacetime · Novikov self-consistency principle mixed
floor filled by (7)
- Closed timelike curve
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Cauchy horizon
- Traversable wormhole
- Self-consistency as a sum over consistent histories
- Physical law
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
- Self-consistency as a sum over consistent histories
- Lloyd's post-selected CTCs (P-CTC)
- Deutsch's CTC model (D-CTC)
- Chronology protection conjecture
Notes published science
- Polchinski's paradox, billiard-ball version: the ball fired into a wormhole to knock its younger self away instead delivers a glancing blow that sends the younger ball in at exactly the needed angle, and there turn out to be infinitely many such consistent solutions.
- Carlini, Frolov, Mensky, Novikov and Soleng (1995) found the principle is not an extra law at all for a hard-sphere particle: least action alone picks out only the self-consistent paths.
- Time-loop logic: send a computer's answer back in time and the self-consistent outcome is the fixed point, 'a perfect answer', appearing 'by an extraordinary coincidence' the moment the machine is switched on.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
field states and histories on the loop (stress-energy)
- L1: Field configurations and particle states on the loop (single-valued fields)
- L2: Consistency constraints: 'certain conditions in local events are to be fulfilled, for the solution to be globally self-consistent' (Lobo); 'events in the future can influence, but cannot change, events in the past'
- L3: Quantum form: a sum over all and only self-consistent histories gives, formally (modulo convergence), 'unique, self-consistent probabilities for the outcomes of all sets of subsequent measurements' for any initial wave function before the Cauchy horizon
self-consistency on closed timelike curves (projected model, on the spacetime manifold)
- L1: Ordinary local laws on a CTC spacetime: 'a principle of no new physics'; it rules out CTCs triggering 'new kinds of local physics which we have not previously met'
- L2: Global extendibility: a local solution is allowed 'only if that local solution can be extended to a part of a (not necessarily unique) global solution, which is well defined throughout the nonsingular regions of the space-time'
- L3: Billiard-ball test: Polchinski's paradox (the ball knocks its younger self away from the mouth) is evaded by 'glancing blow' solutions; more than one consistent solution per initial trajectory, and for some trajectories infinitely many (Echeverria, Klinkhammer, Thorne 1991; Thorne and Forward); minimal action picks only globally self-consistent paths (Carlini et al.)
- L4: Reach: no initial condition outside the Cauchy horizon was found without a self-consistent extension (not proven); 'the Novikov self-consistency principle does not actually place any constraints on systems outside of the region of space-time where time travel is possible, only inside it'
- L5: Consequence: a paradox-causing event has probability zero; time travellers 'cannot change the past' ('free will' constrained); time-loop logic (Moravec) would make a computer's output appear at a fixed point; quantum computation with negative delay solves NP (Deutsch) and PSPACE (Aaronson) problems in polynomial time