← all systems · see it in The System
Bonnor-Steadman solutions
Exact solutions of the Einstein-Maxwell equations, by W. B. Bonnor and B. R. Steadman (2005), describing stationary electrovacuum spacetimes with closed timelike curves around ordinary spinning, charged sources: 'Bonnor-Steadman solutions describing laboratory situations such as two spinning balls'. They ask whether the CTC region survives when interior matter is fitted: with one charged spinning body (Kerr-Newman exterior) the CTC region is always covered by the source; with two electrically and magnetically charged spinning bodies (Perjes-Israel-Wilson exterior) it is not always covered, so the CTCs could in principle be detectable.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the stationary, axisymmetric, asymptotically flat electrovacuum around one or two spinning sources on the axis, its g33 component and the region where it turns positive (closed timelike curves), the strut between two sources, and the interior matter fitted to the sources. Outside: the sources' material make-up beyond charge, mass, spin and dipole; time-dependent processes; infinite cylinders and rotating universes (Van Stockum, Goedel), which need non-physical matter. |
| nested level | Exact solutions of the Einstein-Maxwell equations, built on the Kerr-Newman and Perjes-Israel-Wilson exteriors; members of the family of spacetimes with closed timelike curves. Field scale, rung 2, hypothesised. |
| scale | field |
Measures (6) published science
| condition for no CTC region on the axis (two spinning particles) | m1 h2 + m2 h1 = 0, i.e. a1 + a2 = 0 dimensionless |
| PIW sources | mass = charge, spin = magnetic moment (relativistic units) ratio |
| cases analysed | 2 (one body, Kerr-Newman exterior; two bodies, PIW exterior) count |
| approximate solutions in Bonnor 2001 (spinning particles; charge and dipole) | correct to quadratic terms in the parameters order |
| published | Gen. Rel. Grav. 37, 1833 (2005; online 13 January 2006) date |
| characteristic clock: none (stationary solutions; nothing changes in time) | none n/a |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (6)
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Bonnor-Steadman solutions gain
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature) via sys:stress-energy · Bonnor-Steadman solutions mixed
- Goedel universe via sys:spacetime · Bonnor-Steadman solutions even
- Kerr-Newman spacetime via sys:spacetime · Bonnor-Steadman solutions even
- Closed timelike curve via sys:spacetime · Bonnor-Steadman solutions even
- Perjes-Israel-Wilson spacetime (exterior of two bodies) via sys:spacetime · Bonnor-Steadman solutions even
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (9)
- Electromagnetic field
- Spacetime
- Stress-energy (matter and energy as the source of curvature)
- Kerr-Newman spacetime
- Closed timelike curve
- Perjes-Israel-Wilson spacetime (exterior of two bodies)
- Two spinning particles on an axis (approximate vacuum solution)
- Charge and magnetic dipole on an axis (approximate solution)
- Torsion singularity (Bonnor reading of a CTC region)
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Spacetime
- One charged spinning body (Kerr-Newman exterior)
- Two charged, magnetised spinning bodies (PIW exterior)
Notes published science
- A charge sitting on the axis of a bar magnet cannot be described by a static spacetime: the field forces the geometry to rotate, and near the axis time closes into loops. 'We surely cannot believe that ... a charge and a magnet constitute a time machine!'
- The time loops vanish exactly when the two spinning bodies' angular momenta per unit mass cancel, a1 + a2 = 0, and 'there is no obvious reason why CTC should be absent in this case'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Bonnor-Steadman spacetimes (own, stationary electrovacuum with spinning sources)
- L1: A stationary axisymmetric metric ds^2 = -f^-1 [e^nu (dz^2 + dr^2) + r^2 dtheta^2] + f (dt - w dtheta)^2 with f, nu, w functions of z and r; theta = 0 and 2 pi identified; sources fixed on the axis (z = +/- b)
- L2: g33 = -f^-1 [r^2 - f^2 w^2]: where g33 > 0 the cyclic coordinate theta is timelike, so the spacetime contains CTCs
- L3: The axis condition: on r = 0 the CTC region can be kept out 'either between the particles or outside them, but not both unless the parameters satisfy m1 h2 + m2 h1 = 0', i.e. a1 + a2 = 0 (angular momenta per unit mass); a strut singularity holds the sources apart
- L4: Interiors fitted: the interior charge is bounded by the gravity-electrostatics balance; one charged spinning body (Kerr-Newman exterior): CTC region always covered by the source; two charged, magnetised spinning bodies (PIW exterior): not always covered, so the CTCs could in principle be detectable
- L5: No accepted reading: 'We surely cannot believe that, for example, a charge and a magnet constitute a time machine!'; Bonnor's suggestion that a CTC region between particles 'represents a torsion singularity constraining their spin', which 'does not seem to apply to the case of the spinning rod'
charges, magnetic dipoles and spins of the sources (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Sources with electric charge and magnetic dipole moment; for PIW particles 'the mass of each particle equals its charge, and its spin is equal to its magnetic moment' (relativistic units)
- L2: A charge on a magnet's axis: 'The set-up looks static, but in fact one cannot solve the Einstein-Maxwell equations with an axially symmetric static metric - one needs the stationary' one
- L3: 'Once again, positive values of g33, and therefore CTC, must occur near the axis either between the particles or outside them'