← all systems · see it in The System
Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox)
'A tachyonic antitelephone is a hypothetical device in theoretical physics that could be used to send signals into one's own past'; 'According to the current understanding of physics, no such faster-than-light transfer of information is possible.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Tachyonic antitelephone |
| boundary | Inside: two senders in relative motion, each with a transmitter of signals faster than light, and the two signal legs between them; the loop closes when the reply arrives before the first message was sent ('if v > 2a/(1 + a^2) then T < 0'). Outside: everything else in spacetime. |
| nested level | A projected model built from two observers' world lines, hypothetical faster-than-light signals and the Lorentz transformation of Minkowski spacetime; its legs join spacelike-separated events. Hypothesised, rung 1. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (9) published science
| relative speed of the ships (numerical example) | 0.8 c |
| Lorentz factor at 0.8c | 1/0.6 dimensionless |
| tachyon signal speed in the sender's frame | 2.4 c |
| the same signal's speed in the receiver's frame (back in time) | about 1.739 (400/230) c |
| Alice sends at / receives the reply at (her clock) | 300 / 243 days after passing Bob |
| Bob receives at / reply reaches Alice at (Bob's frame) | t' = 270 / t' = 405 days |
| condition for the reply to arrive before the send | v > 2a / (1 + a^2) speed (c = 1) |
| years: Einstein thought experiment; Ehrenfest diagram; Einstein-Sommerfeld "telegraph into the past"; Tolman; Benford-Book-Newcomb | 1907; 1911; 1910; 1917; 1970 year |
| characteristic clock: flight time of the first signal in the sender's frame (300 to 450 days) | 150 days |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
A route into one's own past built two ways: two spacelike faster-than-light legs in flat spacetime (antitelephone) or a closed timelike curve in curved spacetime ('return to the same place and time that it started'); both open the grandfather paradox. - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
The two legs mirror each other: each sender sees its own signal go forward at 2.4c, each receiver sees the other's go back at 1.739c.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (6) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Simultaneous hyperplane via sys:spacetime · Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox) gain
- Spacelike separation (spacelike interval) via sys:spacetime · Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox) gain
- Lorentz group (homogeneous Lorentz group, O(1,3)) via sys:spacetime · Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox) gain
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense) via sys:spacetime · Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox) gain
- Tachyon (string mode with imaginary mass; projected model) via sys:spacetime · Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox) loss
- Tachyonic particle (faster-than-light) via sys:spacetime · Tachyonic antitelephone (Tolman's paradox) mixed
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
- Spacelike separation (spacelike interval)
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Tachyonic particle (faster-than-light)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (14)
- Spacelike separation (spacelike interval)
- Absolute elsewhere (spacelike region)
- Spacelike curve
- Speed of light
- Lorentz group (homogeneous Lorentz group, O(1,3))
- Minkowski spacetime
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Closed timelike curve
- Instantaneous communicator (Special relativity Fig. 4-7)
- Tachyonic particle (faster-than-light)
- Logically pernicious self-inhibitor
- Reinterpretation principle
- Grandfather paradox
- Preferred frame
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Instantaneous communicator (Special relativity Fig. 4-7)
- Logically pernicious self-inhibitor
- Reinterpretation principle
- Tachyonic particle (faster-than-light)
- Time travel to the past
Notes published science
- Signals only slightly faster than light are enough: with the train pushed near light speed 'even signals only slightly faster than the speed of light will result in causality violation'.
- Benford, Book and Newcomb's version is two hours long: 'A will send a message at three o'clock if and only if he does not receive one at one o'clock ... the exchange of messages will take place if and only if it does not take place.'
- Feinberg coined 'tachyon' after James Blish's story 'Beep', where a faster-than-light communicator's final beep turns out to hold all future messages.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
projected model: signals into the past across spacelike separation (spacetime)
- L1: Two inertial senders and their transmitters: Alice and Bob 'moving inertially with a relative speed of 0.8c'; 'Each one also has a tachyon transmitter aboard their ship, which sends out signals that move at 2.4c in the ship's own frame' (gamma = 1/0.6)
- L2: One leg backwards in another frame: 'if a > c, then certain values of v can make Delta t' negative. In other words, the effect arises before the cause in this frame' (Einstein 1907, Tolman 1917); in Bob's frame Alice's signal 'moves back in time ... (he received it at t' = 270, but it was sent at t' = 500)'
- L3: Symmetry from the relativity principle: 'the observer who sends a given signal measures it to move forward in time at 2.4c, the observer who receives it measures it to move back in time at 1.739c'; 'if tachyons were allowed to have a preferred frame in violation of the first postulate of relativity, in that case it could theoretically be possible to avoid causality violations'
- L4: The loop closes into the past: reply received at T = (1/a + (1 - a v)/(a - v)) L; 'if v > 2a/(1 + a^2) then T < 0 and Alice will receive the message back from Bob before she sends her message'; numbers: sent at 300 days, reply received at 243 days in Alice's frame
- L5: Paradox and its readings: 'A will send a message at three o'clock if and only if he does not receive one at one o'clock ... the exchange of messages will take place if and only if it does not take place'; Benford et al. concluded tachyons 'are therefore not allowed to convey signals'; the reinterpretation principle (a backward tachyon is a forward one) 'is not universally accepted as resolving the paradoxes'
Sources (3) published science
Tachyon (Wikipedia, rev 1381675153, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)