← all systems · see it in The System
Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity)
The expansion rate of space: matter's attraction slows it, dark energy's negative pressure speeds it; from ~9.8 Gyr dark energy dominates and inhibits larger structures.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's braking) |
| boundary | Inside: the contested quantity, the expansion history of the scale factor a(t) (its rate H = adot/a and the sign of its acceleration), and the taking layers of each side: the energy density and pressure each component presents in the second Friedmann equation (matter: positive density, essentially pressureless, decelerates; radiation: positive pressure, decelerates more; dark energy: negative pressure p = -rho c^2, accelerates), and the growth of unbound large-scale structure that the outcome decides. Outside: what each taker is (dark energy's identity, dark matter's particle, baryon physics), gravitationally bound systems once bound ('the increase in distance between gravitationally unbound parts'; the Local Group 'would all remain virtually undisturbed'), and the light by which the contest is read (supernovae, BAO, CMB), which carries the score out but does not take part. |
| compete fns | fn:divide-isolate |
| nested level | Built from its pool (the expansion of spacetime) and its takers (dark energy on the accelerating side; dark matter and baryonic matter, and earlier radiation, on the decelerating side), through the gravitational field. Embedded in the Big Bang universe's expansion history (radiation era to ~47 ka, matter era 47 ka-9.8 Ga, dark-energy era since). Its loser is unbound large-scale structure (the cosmic web beyond bound groups); its outcome nests into the fate of the universe. |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (27) published science
| dark-energy share of the budget (Planck 2018) | 0.6847 +/- 0.0073 Omega_Lambda |
| dark-energy share (Dark Energy Survey 2018, SNe Ia) | 0.669 +/- 0.038 Omega_Lambda |
| budget split (Planck 2013) | 68.3% dark energy, 26.8% dark matter, 4.9% ordinary matter fraction of mass-energy |
| radiation share today | ~10^-4 Omega_rad |
| deceleration parameter today (Planck parameters) | ~ -0.55 (Omega_Lambda = 0.7, Omega_m = 0.3) q0 |
| deceleration parameter from the first supernova effort | ~ -0.6 +/- 0.2 q0 |
| pre-1998 expectation | q0 = Omega_m/2: 1/2 for Omega_m = 1, ~0.1 for a low-density zero-Lambda model |
| radiation-to-matter crossover (first round) | ~47,000 (redshift 3600) years after the Big Bang |
| matter-to-dark-energy crossover (acceleration begins) | ~9.8 (4 billion years ago) Gyr of cosmic time |
| acceleration onset, other estimates | 'roughly 5 billion years ago'; z ~ 0.4 and t ~ 10 Ga (Frieman et al. 2008); 'about five or six billion years ago' (inflection point) time |
| dark energy dominates the energy density | around 3 billion years ago, at ~11 Gyr of cosmic time |
| era boundaries (Frieman et al. 2008) | radiation z > ~3000; matter ~3000 > z > ~0.5; dark energy z < ~0.5 redshift |
| outcome: dilution per doubling of scale | matter density / 8; dark energy nearly unchanged ratio |
| cosmological constant | ~2 x 10^-35 s^-2 |
| Hubble constant (Planck, CMB) | 67.4 +/- 0.5 km/s/Mpc |
| Hubble constant (Type Ia supernovae) | 73.24 +/- 1.74 km/s/Mpc |
| growth index for a cosmological constant | gamma = 0.55 + 0.05[1 + w(z=1)], ~0.55 for w = -1 (fit better than 0.05% for Omega_m 0.22-1) dimensionless |
| distance to the cosmic event horizon (cosmological constant) | ~16 billion light years |
| clusters grow isolated | ~120 Gyr |
| galaxies outside the Local Supercluster pass behind the horizon | ~150 billion years from now |
| galaxies outside the Local Supercluster undetectable | ~2 x 10^12 years from now |
| Local Group merges into one galaxy (bound survivor) | 10^11 to 10^12 years from now |
| earliest Big Rip (phantom variant, w = -1.5, H0 = 70) | 22 billion years from now |
| evidence for evolving dark energy (DESI, March 2025) | 2.8 to 4.2 sigma; dark energy ~10% lower than 4.5 billion years ago significance |
| characteristic clock: dark-energy-era e-folding of the scale factor | a(t) proportional to exp(H0 t); H tends to H0 sqrt(Omega_Lambda); H0 ~ 70.88 km/s/Mpc 1/H |
| characteristic clock: duration of the matter lead | 47 ka to 9.8 Ga cosmic time |
| who wins how often | one universe, one contest: dark energy leads from ~9.8 Gyr; the ratio Omega_Lambda/Omega_m ~ 0.68/0.32 today outcome |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- not-diluting wins (structural)
'When the scale of the universe doubles, the density of matter is reduced by a factor of 8, but the density of dark energy is nearly unchanged'; the side that keeps its density takes the contest. Seen inside the loser too: expansion is 'the increase in distance between gravitationally unbound parts' - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
One term, two signs: in addot/a = -(4 pi G/3)(rho + 3p/c^2) a positive density and pressure decelerate, and 'sufficiently negative pressure with p < -rho c^2/3 leads to accelerated expansion'; the two takers are the two signs of the same source term. - templating (partial)
The same law twice: 'the Hubble parameter is also thought to be constant [during inflation], so the expansion law of the dark energy-dominated era also holds for the inflationary prequel of the big bang'. The early contest (sys:competition-inflationary-dilution) and this one end in the same exponent
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (16) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Dark energy via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) mixed
- Photon via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) gain
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) gain
- Supernova via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Dark matter via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) gain
- Spacetime via sys:spacetime · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) gain
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Baryonic matter via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) gain
- Cosmic web via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Bound structures (the survivors, e.g. the Local Group) via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Galaxy cluster via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Cosmological component via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Ultimate fate of the universe via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Arrow of time via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
- Cosmological arrow of time via sys:gravitational-field · Competition over the expansion (dark energy vs matter's gravity) even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Photon
- Gravitational field
- Dark matter
- Dark energy
- Spacetime
- Baryonic matter
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Dust stress-energy (pressureless matter, w = 0)
- Anti-stiff matter
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (23)
- Dark energy
- Photon
- Gravitational field
- Supernova
- Neutrino
- Dark matter
- Spacetime
- Cosmic microwave background
- Galaxy
- Baryonic matter
- Galaxy cluster
- Big Freeze (heat death)
- Cosmic web
- Bound structures (the survivors, e.g. the Local Group)
- Supercluster
- Cosmic void
- Dark matter halo
- de Sitter spacetime
- Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
- Cosmological component
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- Arrow of time
- Cosmological arrow of time
Kinds (4)
- Competition dilution
- The contest with phantom dark energy (w < -1)
- The contest with evolving (weakening) dark energy
- The contest with a negative cosmological constant
Notes published science
- The winner takes the rate before it takes the budget: the expansion started accelerating at ~9.8 Gyr of cosmic time, but dark energy only came to dominate the energy density at ~11 Gyr (Expansion of the universe). In q = Omega_m/2 - Omega_Lambda, matter's vote counts half, so dark energy needs only half matter's density to flip the sign.
- Radiation lost the same contest first: it dilutes as a^-4 against matter's a^-3 and handed over the expansion at ~47,000 years. Every round goes to the component that dilutes slowest, and dark energy, which does not dilute at all, is the last possible winner (unless it is phantom).
- The loser keeps one refuge, and it is the winner's own trick: expansion separates only unbound parts, so bound groups stop diluting and the Local Group stays 'virtually undisturbed' while everything beyond the Local Supercluster passes behind the horizon in ~150 billion years.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
expansion rate (spacetime metric / gravitational field)
- L1: Homogeneous, isotropic expansion on the FLRW metric: the scale factor a(t) (a = 1 now), 'independent of location and direction', governed by the Friedmann equations
- L2: What each taker presents: energy density and pressure in the second Friedmann equation, addot/a = -(4 pi G/3)(rho + 3p/c^2) + Lambda c^2/3. Matter w = 0 and radiation w = 1/3 decelerate; p < -rho c^2/3, and the cosmological constant (w = -1), accelerate
- L3: The running score: each side dilutes as rho proportional to a^-3(1+w): matter a^-3, radiation a^-4, dark energy constant (w = -1); 'when the scale of the universe doubles, the density of matter is reduced by a factor of 8, but the density of dark energy is nearly unchanged'
- L4: The decision: deceleration parameter q = Omega_rad + Omega_m/2 + (1+3w)/2 Omega_DE; q > 0 before dark energy dominated, q0 ~ -0.55 today (Omega_Lambda = 0.7, Omega_m = 0.3). Eras: radiation to ~47 ka, matter 47 ka-9.8 Ga, dark energy from ~9.8 Ga (acceleration 'roughly 5 billion years ago'; z ~ 0.4, t ~ 10 Ga per Frieman et al.)
- L5: Outcome on the pool: a(t) proportional to exp(H0 t), approaching a de Sitter universe; q tends to -1 and H to H0 sqrt(Omega_Lambda); galaxies outside the Local Group recede ever faster; a cosmic event horizon ~16 billion light years away
growth of structure (gravitational instability against Hubble drag)
- L1: Density ripples in matter, seeded by inflation, on which 'structure formation applies models of gravitational instability'
- L2: Hubble drag: 'the Hubble drag is increased, and hence growth is suppressed, for an accelerating universe'; 'within general relativity the linear theory growth factor depends purely on the expansion history'; growth index gamma = 0.55 + 0.05[1 + w(z=1)]
- L3: Hierarchical assembly: stars and clusters, then galaxies, groups, clusters (from ~3 Ga, z = 2.1) and superclusters (from ~5 Ga, z = 1.2); filaments, halos and voids in a web; most efficient while matter dominates
- L4: Freeze-out: 'growing cosmological perturbations will freeze out on all scales'; 'every halo grows isolated in the long term'; clusters isolated in about 120 Gyr; the bound Local Group merges into one galaxy in 10^11 to 10^12 years
light crossing the contest (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Light from distant sources crossing the expanding universe: Type Ia supernovae, galaxies mapped for BAO, the CMB
- L2: Cosmological redshift: the scale factor at emission is a = 1/(1+z)
- L3: Distance against redshift: high-redshift SNe Ia 'on average, 10% to 15% further than expected in a low mass density Omega_M = 0.2 universe without a cosmological constant'; q0 ~ -0.6 +/- 0.2; BAO voids of ~150 Mpc as standard rulers to z = 0.6
- L4: Late integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect: accelerated expansion flattens potential wells and hills as photons cross them, leaving CMB cold and hot spots aligned with supervoids and superclusters; light from beyond the event horizon never arrives
Who fills each layer
- L1: Arrow of time
- L2: Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
- L3: Cosmological component, Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime, Galaxy cluster
- L4: Dark matter, Cosmological component, Ultimate fate of the universe, Perfect fluid
- L5: de Sitter spacetime, Arrow of time
Sources (14) published science
Linder 2005, Cosmic Growth History and Expansion History (arXiv:astro-ph/0507263) (behind its links)
Dark energy (Wikipedia, 2026-10-21) (behind its links)
Scale factor (cosmology) (Wikipedia, rev 1373815790, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Ultimate fate of the universe (Wikipedia, rev 1379769907, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-27) (behind its links)
Accelerating expansion of the universe (Wikipedia, rev 1382263506, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-27) (behind its links)
Future of an expanding universe (Wikipedia, rev 1381370483, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-27) (behind its links)
Cosmic inflation (Wikipedia, 2026-10-10) (behind its links)
Lambda-CDM model (Wikipedia, rev 1379855309, 2026-10-12): Planck 2018 parameter table (behind its links)
Deceleration parameter (Wikipedia, rev 1314525862, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-27) (behind its links)
Busha, Adams, Wechsler & Evrard 2003, Future Evolution of Structure in an Accelerating Universe, doi:10.1086/378043 (arXiv:astro-ph/0305211) (behind its links)
Arrow of time (Wikipedia, rev 1381236792, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Structure formation (Wikipedia, rev 1376287164, 2026-09-23) (behind its links)