← all systems · see it in The System
Dark fluid
The dark fluid theory 'attempts to explain dark matter and dark energy in a single framework' (Arbey 2005): dark matter and dark energy 'are not separate physical phenomena, nor do they have separate origins', but 'two facets of a single fluid'. 'At galactic scales, the dark fluid behaves like dark matter, and at larger scales its behavior becomes similar to dark energy.' Realised as a complex scalar field with a conserved U(1) charge (Arbey 2006), a vector field of variable norm (Zhao and Li), or a fluid of negative masses (Farnes 2018).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | not stated (idea: 2005) |
| boundary | Inside (as the theory projects it): one dark component filling space, whose 'attractive and repulsive behaviors depend on the local energy density'. Outside: the baryons it gathers around, the voids where it repels, and spacetime it bends. |
| nested level | One theory of the dark sector that folds dark matter and dark energy into a single substance; booked on the interacting-dark-energy shelf as a kind; a member of the class that treats 'dark energy and dark matter as different facets of the same unknown substance'. Its special cases reproduce inflation, quintessence, k-essence, f(R), Einstein-aether, MOND and TeVeS. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (4) published science
| Chaplygin gas equation of state (the ideal fluid model named) | p = -A / rho^alpha, alpha = 1 (generalized: 0 < alpha <= 1) |
| Farnes halo extent | several galactic radii |
| first proposed | 2005 (Arbey, arXiv:astro-ph/0506732) date |
| characteristic clock | not stated (sources looked at: the encyclopedia, Arbey 2006 and 2008, Farnes 2018, Zhao and Li, Socas-Navarro; none give a time constant) |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-098 Are galaxy rotation and cosmic acceleration caused by unseen matter and energy, or by gravity behaving differently?
booked: The map follows the mainstream view of unseen components (dark matter and dark energy), and keeps modified gravity alongside.
the other reading: gravity behaving differently: the class 'modifies the laws of gravity at various scales' and reproduces MOND, f(R), TeVeS
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (4)
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Dark fluid even
- Galaxy via sys:gravitational-field · Dark fluid gain
- Baryonic matter via sys:gravitational-field · Dark fluid gain
- Cosmic void via sys:gravitational-field · Dark fluid mixed
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (15)
- Gravitational field
- Dark matter
- Dark energy
- Galaxy
- Baryonic matter
- Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- k-essence (kinetic quintessence; hypothesised)
- Cosmic void
- f(R) gravity (modified gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Einstein-aether theory
- TeVeS
- MOND (relativistic forms)
- Complex scalar field dark fluid (Arbey)
- Negative-mass dark fluid (Farnes)
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
- Unified dark matter and dark energy (single-substance theories)
- Complex scalar field dark fluid (Arbey)
- Negative-mass dark fluid (Farnes)
- Vector-field dark fluid (Zhao and Li)
Notes published science
- One substance with two faces: near a galaxy it clumps and pulls like dark matter; out in the voids it relaxes and pushes like dark energy, and the switch is just how much ordinary matter is nearby.
- The coagulation is a stated self-feeding loop: fluid gathered around matter draws in more fluid, 'thus amplifying the force of gravity near it'.
- The negative-mass version got a sharp reply: if it were true, the critic argues, every galaxy would end up flying off in a random direction at nearly the speed of light.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
complex scalar field with a conserved U(1) charge (Arbey; hypothetical, on the vacuum-energy medium like the other dark-energy scalar fields)
- L1: 'a complex scalar field with a conserved U(1)-charge', 'associated to a specific potential' (Arbey 2006); scalar fields used because the full fluid equations are 'as of yet too difficult to solve'
- L2: 'additional attractive gravitational effects' in galaxies and clusters and 'a repulsive effect at cosmological scales'
- L3: Tests: Type Ia supernovae, large-scale structure, CMB and big-bang nucleosynthesis constrain the fluid's parameters (Arbey 2008); local-scale constraints too
dark fluid (projected model: one fluid whose attraction or repulsion follows the local density; gravitational field)
- L1: One dark fluid as a source of gravity: it 'bends spacetime while general relativity's covariant form is kept' (Zhao and Li, abstract paraphrase)
- L2: Density-dependent response: 'attractive and repulsive behaviors depend on the local energy density'; dark-matter-like on galactic scales, dark-energy-like on larger scales
- L3: High baryon density: the fluid slows, coagulates around matter and draws in more, 'amplifying the force of gravity near it'; noticeable only near a very large mass such as a galaxy
- L4: Low density (voids between superclusters): the fluid 'relaxes and acquires a negative pressure' and becomes repulsive, like dark energy
- L5: A continuous range between the two; special cases reproduce inflation, quintessence, k-essence, f(R), Einstein-aether f(K), MOND, TeVeS, BSTV; a suggested f(K+R) model corrects MOND with redshift and density
negative-mass fluid with continuous creation (Farnes; projected model, gravitational field)
- L1: 'gravitationally repulsive negative masses', 'continuously-created', so they 'can resemble the cosmological constant' (modified LCDM)
- L2: N-body simulations: haloes 'that extend to several galactic radii'; 'These haloes are not cuspy'; rotation curves flattened
- L3: A cyclic universe with a time-variable Hubble parameter, possibly tied to current measurement tensions
- L4: Critique (Socas-Navarro 2019): 'the predicted shape and density of galactic dark matter halos are incorrect'; haloes more massive than their baryons 'would become gravitationally unstable'; a large-scale runaway