← all systems · see it in The System
QCD vacuum
'The QCD vacuum is the quantum vacuum state of quantum chromodynamics (QCD). It is an example of a non-perturbative vacuum state, characterized by non-vanishing condensates such as the gluon condensate and the quark condensate in the complete theory which includes quarks. The presence of these condensates characterizes the confined phase of quark matter.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | QCD vacuum (gluon and quark condensates) |
| born at | about 1e-5 s after the Big Bang, as the expanding universe cooled through the crossover and the condensates formed |
| born precision | order of magnitude |
| boundary | Inside: the non-perturbative ground state of QCD: its condensates (gluon, quark, mixed and higher order), the broken chiral symmetry and its anomalies, its short-distance structure (instantons, centre vortices) and the confined phase it characterizes. Outside: the hadrons that sit in it (their own walk), the gate of confinement as booked, the Higgs vacuum, and hot or dense phases of QCD matter where the condensates melt. Re-walk 2026-11-20: inside also its topological sectors and theta; outside the electroweak vacuum (no comparable topological sensitivity, per Lee et al.) and the cosmological reading of its energy, booked as an outlet under contention. |
| nested level | The strong-field component of the quantum vacuum; built from the quark and gluon condensates and instanton-like structure; the medium hadrons sit in (bag model) and the source of the pions as pseudo-Goldstone bosons. |
| scale | field |
Measures (44) published science
| gluon condensate <g^2 G G> | ~0.5 GeV^4 |
| quark condensate <psi-bar psi> | ~(-0.23)^3 GeV^3 |
| higher gluon condensate <(gG)^4> | ~5:10 x <(gG)^2>^2 |
| Goldberger-Treiman relation accuracy | 2.5 % |
| chiral crossover Tc(0) | 156.5 +/- 1.5 MeV |
| evidence eras: quark condensate / gluon condensate | 1950-1973 (pre-QCD) / after 1974 years |
| BPST instantons found | 1975 year |
| Savvidy instability of the zero-field vacuum | 1977 year |
| characteristic clock: strong-interaction timescale (resonance decay) | ~10^-24 s |
| share of nucleon mass from chiral symmetry breaking and the conformal anomaly | ~99 % |
| string tension (from Regge slope) | ~0.18 (~0.9 GeV/fm) GeV^2 |
| physical string tension used to set lattice units | (440 MeV)^2 MeV^2 |
| instanton density (instanton liquid) | ~1 fm^-4 |
| instanton size (instanton liquid) | ~1/3 fm |
| Lambda_QCD (scale where the perturbative coupling blows up) | ~0.2 (~(1 fm)^-1) GeV |
| Lambda_QCD as used in the QCD-DE estimate | ~100 MeV |
| chiral symmetry breaking scale Lambda_chiSB ~ 4 pi f_pi | ~1 GeV |
| quark condensate <q-bar q> (SVZ sum rules) | -(230 MeV)^3 MeV^3 |
| gluon condensate <g^2 G^2> (SVZ sum rules) | (850 MeV)^4 MeV^4 |
| gluon condensate <O_G> (lattice, pure SU(3)) | ~0.077 (intrinsic ambiguity ~0.087) GeV^4 |
| gluon condensate <O_G> (one- and two-loop sum rules) | 0.01 to 0.02 GeV^4 |
| topological susceptibility chi(T=0) | 0.0216(21)(11) fm^-4 = [75.6(1.8)(0.9) MeV]^4 |
| axion mass estimate (post-inflation, from chi(T)) | 50 to 1500 micro-eV |
| naive neutron EDM expectation | ~1e-13 e cm |
| neutron EDM per unit theta (leading order) | ~3e-16 theta e cm |
| neutron EDM (PSI, 2020) | (0.0 +/- 1.1 stat +/- 0.2 sys) x 1e-26 e cm |
| theta bound from the neutron EDM | <~1e-10 rad |
| condensates form (cosmic time) | ~1e-5 s after the Big Bang |
| deconfinement temperature as quoted by Brodsky and Shrock | ~200 MeV |
| QCD condensates' contribution to Omega_Lambda if uniform | ~1e45 x observed |
| chemical-freeze-out boundary energy density | 0.42(6) GeV/fm^3 |
| curvature of the crossover line kappa_2^B | 0.012(4) |
| c_H (Lee et al. estimate) | ~0.01 to 0.02 (proportional to m_q / Lambda_QCD) |
| QCD-DE estimate of H | (0.56 to 1.12) x 1e-33 eV = 26 to 53 km/s/Mpc |
| QCD-DE estimate of rho_DE | ~[(1.5 to 2.2) x 1e-3 eV]^4 eV^4 |
| QCD vacuum energy in flat spacetime (R3 x S1) | -Lambda_QCD^4 |
| phantom-crossing redshift (QCD-DE fit) | 0.67 +0.15/-0.12 (CPL fit: 0.35 +0.08/-0.07) z |
| ln B, QCD-DE vs LambdaCDM (CMB-SPA+DD+DESI) | 2.02 +/- 0.02 (w0waCDM: 1.02 +/- 0.02); CMB-SPA alone -0.72 +/- 0.01 |
| Delta chi^2 vs LambdaCDM (CMB-SPA+DD+DESI) | -11.21 (w0waCDM: -12.85); CMB-SPA alone +0.30 (w0waCDM -3.51) |
| Urban-Zhitnitsky 2010 vacuum energy estimate (Veneziano ghost) | ~(3.6e-3 eV)^4 eV^4 |
| theta vacuum discovered | 1976 year |
| lattice simulations persuade sceptics of confinement (Creutz) | 1980 year |
| instanton liquid model proposed (Shuryak) | 1982 year |
| pion decay constant f_pi (strength of chiral symmetry breaking) | ~93 MeV |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-031 Is the cosmological constant the energy of empty space, or a separate constant of nature?
booked: The map includes the cosmological constant but leaves its origin open, listing both ideas.
the other reading: A: the cosmological constant as the vacuum's zero-point energy; B: an independent constant of the field equations; and, on the QCD vacuum's own contribution: the condensates live inside hadrons and add nothing to Omega_Lambda (Brodsky and Shrock), see C-3124 - C-095 Is dark energy a true constant, or does it change over time?
booked: The map treats dark energy as a cosmological constant (w close to -1) for now, and keeps the 2025 DESI hint of change over time alongside.
the other reading: A: w near -1 (a cosmological constant); B: w0wa evolving dark energy (DESI DR2), crossing near z = 0.35 in the CPL fit - C-1559 What happens to the strong force at low energy?
booked: The map books the textbook's infinity as an artefact, and keeps the readings that the force levels off, vanishes or grows.
the other reading: the coupling freezes at an infrared fixed point; it vanishes in the deep infrared - C-2704 Was the early universe's quark-hadron transition smooth or sudden?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a first-order little inflation in a QCD false vacuum (as booked on the QGP walk) - C-3124 Does the strong force's vacuum energy fill space, or live inside protons and neutrons?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: in-hadron: the condensates have 'spatial support within hadrons, not extending throughout all of space', counted in the hadrons' masses and adding nothing to Omega_Lambda (Brodsky and Shrock 2011; Brodsky, Roberts, Shrock and Tandy 2010) - C-3125 What keeps quarks confined?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: centre vortices (string tension vanishes on vortex removal; percolate in the confined phase); dual superconductor / abelian monopoles ('t Hooft, Mandelstam; Greensite: wrong representation dependence); instanton liquid ('unlikely' per the encyclopedia; 'still very poor' understanding per Schaefer-Shuryak); merons - C-3142 How big is the gluon condensate?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: one- and two-loop sum rules: 0.01 to 0.02 GeV^4; SVZ: <g^2 G^2> = (850 MeV)^4 (different normalisation; the old walk's ~0.5 GeV^4)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Quark condensate (chiral condensate)
- Gluon condensate
- Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling)
- Centre vortex (QCD vacuum)
- Theta vacuum (the superposition of topological sectors)
Sits inside / holds (4)
Trades with (valence) (18)
- Dark energy via sys:gravitational-field · QCD vacuum even
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · QCD vacuum mixed
- Weak field via sys:weak-field · QCD vacuum even
- QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram) via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum loss
- Higgs field via sys:higgs-field · QCD vacuum gain
- Quark–gluon plasma via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum mixed
- Neutron via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum even
- Color confinement via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum even
- Pion (pi meson) via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum even
- Quark condensate (chiral condensate) via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum gain
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · QCD vacuum loss
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state) via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:baryonic-matter · QCD vacuum even
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy) via sys:quantum-vacuum · QCD vacuum even
- Axion via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum even
- Hadron via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum even
- Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling) via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum gain
- Quantum tunnelling via sys:strong-field · QCD vacuum mixed
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (22)
- Dark energy
- Quantum vacuum (vacuum state)
- Gravitational field
- Weak field
- Strong (colour) field
- QCD matter (quark matter and its phase diagram)
- Higgs field
- Neutron
- Color confinement
- Baryonic matter
- Pion (pi meson)
- Rho meson
- Quark condensate (chiral condensate)
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Axion
- Gluon condensate
- Hadron
- Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling)
- Centre vortex (QCD vacuum)
- Theta vacuum (the superposition of topological sectors)
- Quantum tunnelling
represents (1)
Kinds (2)
wired (2)
Notes published science
- Most of your mass is the vacuum's doing: up and down quarks weigh about 2.3 and 4.8 MeV, but in the condensed QCD vacuum they act as if they weighed about 300 MeV, and with the conformal anomaly that accounts for about 99% of a proton.
- Physicists can take confinement apart on a computer: remove the vortex-like 'centre vortices' from simulated QCD vacua and the force that holds quarks together disappears (src:greensite-2003).
- Almost all the weight you feel when you lift something comes from the structure of 'empty' space: about 99% of a proton's or neutron's mass comes from the QCD vacuum's broken chiral symmetry and the conformal anomaly (src:wp:chiral-symmetry-breaking).
- A 2026 paper proposes that dark energy is the strong force's vacuum responding to the expansion of the universe: the QCD energy scale, about 100 MeV, cubed and times the expansion rate gives roughly the observed dark energy. It fits current data a little better than a constant on the full data set, but the key step is still a conjecture (src:lee-2026-qcd-dark-energy).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
QCD vacuum: non-perturbative ground state of the colour field (strong field)
- L1: Ground state of SU(3) gauge theory: Poincare, CPT, local SU(3); 'the QCD vacuum with zero field strength is unstable, and decays into a state with a calculable non vanishing value of the field' (Savvidy 1977)
- L2: Condensates (sum rules): <g^2 G G> ~ 0.5 GeV^4, <psi-bar psi> ~ (-0.23)^3 GeV^3, <(gG)^4> ~ 5:10 <(gG)^2>^2; 'many mixed and higher order condensates'
- L3: Broken symmetries: chiral SU(Nf) x SU(Nf) broken to the diagonal SU(Nf); axial U(1) broken by the chiral anomaly (instantons, the strong CP problem); scale symmetry broken by the scale anomaly, 'giving rise to asymptotic freedom'; baryon number exact
- L4: Short-distance structure: the scalar condensates are 'an effective long-distance description'; below the QCD scale 'the vacuum may have structure': instantons found on the lattice; centre vortices that percolate in the confinement phase; condensed chromomagnetic monopoles in the dual-superconductor picture
- L5: Confined-phase response: the condensates characterize the confined phase; colour flux between quark and antiquark 'collapses into a string' of constant tension, which breaks above a meson's energy into a new quark-antiquark pair (Lund model fits e-e and hadron-hadron data)
- L6: Melting: 'In other phases of quark matter the full chiral flavour symmetry may be recovered'; the chiral crossover at Tc(0) = 156.5 +/- 1.5 MeV; 'It is not clear yet whether this [gluon] condensate is related to any of the known phase changes in quark matter'
colour charges placed in the vacuum (strong field: static sources, a quark pulled away)
- L1: A colour charge and its anticharge (static test charges on the lattice; a quark and antiquark flying apart); the confining force between them is known mainly from lattice calculations
- L2: The colour-electric flux does not spread like a Coulomb field: it 'collapses into a string'; in the dual superconductor model, condensed chromomagnetic monopoles squeeze it into tubes
- L3: The vacuum's disorder reads the loop the charges trace: centre vortices percolate in the confined phase; removing them from lattice configurations sends the Creutz ratios to zero
- L4: Linear potential: energy per unit length between the charges, the string tension sigma ~ 0.18 GeV^2 ~ 0.9 GeV/fm (from the Regge slope)
currents applied to the vacuum (strong field: hadronic correlation functions)
- L1: A symmetry current acting on the vacuum makes particles: J_mu|0> = k_mu|pi>; experimentally, hadron production by currents (e+e- annihilation, tau decays) feeds the correlators
- L2: Operator product expansion: the short-distance behaviour of correlators is tied to a few vacuum expectation values; from data SVZ deduced the quark and gluon condensates (QCD sum rules)
- L3: Direct instanton contributions to correlators in the channels that feel them
hadrons and the matter they make (mass from the broken vacuum)
- L1: Protons and neutrons, and so the mass of all ordinary matter
- L2: Hadrons as collective excitations of the vacuum, 'like phonons in solids'
- L6: The broken vacuum and the conformal anomaly give about 99% of a nucleon's mass
heat: the hot bath of the early universe or of a heavy-ion collision (thermal energy)
- L1: A thermal bath of quarks, gluons and hadrons: the universe younger than about 1e-5 s, or a heavy-ion collision; the QCD phase boundary at Tc(0) = 156.5 +/- 1.5 MeV, near which chemical freeze-out happens
- L2: Heat screens the vacuum's structure: instantons 'should be suppressed by Debye screening'; near Tc the random instanton liquid rearranges into instanton-anti-instanton molecules; the topological susceptibility chi(T) falls above the transition (computed to a few GeV)
pions as stand-ins for the axial weak current (weak field)
- L1: The weak axial current of the nucleon, whose coefficient G_A 'determines the neutron decay rate'
- L2: Goldberger-Treiman: g_piNN F_pi = G_A M_N, 'obeyed to 2.5% accuracy'; pions interact 'as surrogates of sorts of the axial weak currents'
- L3: PCAC: with small quark masses the axial divergence does not vanish and 'the right hand side involves the mass of the pion, now a Pseudo-Goldstone boson'
pions out of the broken vacuum (residual strong force: pion exchange)
- L1: Pion exchange between nucleons (the residual strong force)
- L2: Light because the quark masses are small; strictly massless in the chiral limit
- L4: The broken chiral symmetry's Goldstone bosons: three pions (Nf = 2), the pseudoscalar octet (Nf = 3)
pseudo-Goldstone mesons drawn from the vacuum (strong field)
- L1: A symmetry current acting on the vacuum: 'the current J applied to the vacuum produces particles. The particles must be spinless': J_mu|0> = k_mu|pi>
- L2: Goldstone bosons: Nf = 2 gives the three pions; Nf = 3 'all eight pseudoscalar mesons of the quark model'; actual masses from the small quark masses (chiral perturbation theory, checked by lattice QCD)
- L3: The eta' exception: the singlet is tied to the axial U_A(1) 'explicitly broken through the chiral anomaly, and thus its mass is not "protected"'; the eta-eta' splitting through the 't Hooft instanton mechanism (Witten-Veneziano at large N)
- L4: Readout: 'the masses of the octet of pseudoscalar mesons is very much lighter than the next lightest states; i.e., the octet of vector mesons (such as the rho meson)'
string breaking: new quark-antiquark pairs from the vacuum (strong field)
- L1: Mesons and jets of colour-neutral hadrons (Lund model)
- L2: The two new ends become a quark-antiquark pair
- L5: The colour string has constant tension; above a meson's energy it breaks
the QCD vacuum as particle physicists describe it: the strong force's ground state, from its fields to what it gives the world (reader's view)
- L1: The fields in their lowest-energy state: the gluon (colour) field and the quark fields with no particles present, which are not empty: 'a non-perturbative vacuum state, characterized by non-vanishing condensates'; what touches it: heat, colour charges, the quarks' masses, probing currents, the expansion of space
- L2: What enters: heat screens instantons; colour charges source flux that collapses into strings; quark masses tilt the vacuum; currents excite pions; the expansion cools it (and, contested, shifts its topological sectors)
- L3: Topology: winding sectors, instanton tunnelling, the theta vacuum, the topological susceptibility
- L4: Condensates and broken chiral symmetry; Goldstone pions
- L5: Confinement: flux tubes, string tension, only colour singlets; mechanism contested
- L6: What it gives the world: hadron masses (~99% of the nucleon's), pions and the nuclear force, the crossover in the early universe, a vacuum energy with a contested role in cosmology
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L3: Topology: the vacuum comes in sectors labelled by a winding number, separated by energy barriers; instantons tunnel between them (a dilute liquid, n ~ 1 fm^-4, rho ~ 1/3 fm); the true vacuum is the theta superposition, theta a superselection label; the topological susceptibility chi(T=0) = (75.6 MeV)^4
- L4: Condensates and broken chiral symmetry: the quark condensate (order parameter, about -(230 MeV)^3) and the gluon condensate; chiral SU(Nf) x SU(Nf) broken to the diagonal SU(Nf); the axial U(1) broken by the anomaly; the pseudoscalar mesons as (pseudo-)Goldstone bosons
- L5: Confinement and the mass gap: only colour-neutral states; flux tubes with constant tension; demonstrated on the lattice since 1980, with no first-principles derivation; the mechanism (instantons, merons, abelian monopoles, centre vortices) contested
- L6: What it gives the world: about 99% of the proton's and neutron's mass (chiral symmetry breaking and the conformal anomaly), hadrons as its collective excitations, the light pions that carry the nuclear force, its phase history (the crossover ~1e-5 s after the Big Bang), and a vacuum energy whose gravitational role is contested (in-hadron condensates; the QCD-DE reading)
the expansion of space (gravitational field)
- L1: An expanding universe with Hubble rate H; lattice QCD has been run in a Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker background
- L2: Two readings. Established: expansion cools the universe through the crossover and the condensates form about 1e-5 s after the Big Bang. Contested (Lee et al. 2026; Zhitnitsky): the topological sectors are 'slightly modified' in an expanding background, so tunnelling adds a vacuum energy proportional to H through the contact term, which is not limited to microscopic distances; the extension from a hyperbolic space to an expanding universe is a conjecture
the quarks' masses, given by the Higgs field (Higgs field)
- L1: Current quark masses, set by the Higgs field's Yukawa couplings; small for the up, down and strange quarks
- L2: Explicit breaking: the masses make the Goldstone bosons light instead of massless, and weight the tunnelling between topological sectors (the suppression factor proportional to m_q; a massless up quark would make theta unphysical)
the theta angle read through the neutron's electric dipole moment (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Measured: d_n = (0.0 +/- 1.1 stat +/- 0.2 sys) x 10^-26 e cm, so theta <~ 1e-10; no strong-only CP violation ever seen (the strong CP problem)
- L2: A theta-dependent neutron EDM, ~3e-16 theta e cm at leading order (naive classical estimate 1e-13 e cm)
- L3: The theta term: physics depends on the vacuum angle because instantons make the topological charge an integer
the vacuum's energy as a source of gravity (gravitational field)
- L1: Enters the Friedmann equation as dark energy: a background effect only, effective w crossing -1 near z = 0.67; the order of magnitude matches today's values; its proposed lab test (the topological Casimir effect) is unmeasured
- L2: QCD-DE reading (Lee et al. 2026): the vacuum-energy difference between an expanding universe and flat spacetime, rho_DE = beta(z) c_H Lambda_QCD^3 H, switched on at late times by the adiabatic condition (the switch beta(z) is fitted with two parameters)
- L6: If the condensates are constant throughout space they would carry an energy density ~ Lambda_QCD^4, about 10^45 times the observed dark energy; Brodsky and Shrock read them as living inside hadrons instead (counted in the baryons' mass); Reinhardt and Weigel defend their vacuum nature
way in: Colour charges placed in the vacuum (static sources; a quark pulled away)
- L1: A colour charge and its anticharge (static test charges on the lattice; a quark and antiquark flying apart); the confining force between them is known mainly from lattice calculations
- L2: The colour-electric flux does not spread like a Coulomb field: it 'collapses into a string'; in the dual superconductor model, condensed chromomagnetic monopoles squeeze it into tubes
- L3: The vacuum's disorder reads the loop the charges trace: centre vortices percolate in the confined phase; removing them from lattice configurations sends the Creutz ratios to zero
- L4: Linear potential: energy per unit length between the charges, the string tension sigma ~ 0.18 GeV^2 ~ 0.9 GeV/fm (from the Regge slope)
way in: Currents applied to the vacuum (how physicists probe it: hadronic correlation functions)
- L1: A symmetry current acting on the vacuum makes particles: J_mu|0> = k_mu|pi>; experimentally, hadron production by currents (e+e- annihilation, tau decays) feeds the correlators
- L2: Operator product expansion: the short-distance behaviour of correlators is tied to a few vacuum expectation values; from data SVZ deduced the quark and gluon condensates (QCD sum rules)
- L3: Direct instanton contributions to correlators in the channels that feel them
way in: Heat (the hot bath of the early universe, or a heavy-ion collision)
- L1: A thermal bath of quarks, gluons and hadrons: the universe younger than about 1e-5 s, or a heavy-ion collision; the QCD phase boundary at Tc(0) = 156.5 +/- 1.5 MeV, near which chemical freeze-out happens
- L2: Heat screens the vacuum's structure: instantons 'should be suppressed by Debye screening'; near Tc the random instanton liquid rearranges into instanton-anti-instanton molecules; the topological susceptibility chi(T) falls above the transition (computed to a few GeV)
way in: The expansion of space (cosmic cooling; a proposed direct response to the expansion rate)
- L1: An expanding universe with Hubble rate H; lattice QCD has been run in a Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker background
- L2: Two readings. Established: expansion cools the universe through the crossover and the condensates form about 1e-5 s after the Big Bang. Contested (Lee et al. 2026; Zhitnitsky): the topological sectors are 'slightly modified' in an expanding background, so tunnelling adds a vacuum energy proportional to H through the contact term, which is not limited to microscopic distances; the extension from a hyperbolic space to an expanding universe is a conjecture
way in: The quarks' masses (from the Higgs field)
- L1: Current quark masses, set by the Higgs field's Yukawa couplings; small for the up, down and strange quarks
- L2: Explicit breaking: the masses make the Goldstone bosons light instead of massless, and weight the tunnelling between topological sectors (the suppression factor proportional to m_q; a massless up quark would make theta unphysical)
way in: The weak axial current (the nucleon's beta decay)
- L1: The weak axial current of the nucleon, whose coefficient G_A determines the neutron decay rate
- L2: Goldberger-Treiman: g_piNN F_pi = G_A M_N, obeyed to 2.5%: pions stand in for the axial weak current
- L3: PCAC: with small quark masses the axial divergence does not vanish and brings in the pion mass
way out: Light pions (Goldstone bosons) and the nuclear force they carry
- L1: Pion exchange between nucleons (the residual strong force)
- L2: Light because the quark masses are small; strictly massless in the chiral limit
- L4: The broken chiral symmetry's Goldstone bosons: three pions (Nf = 2), the pseudoscalar octet (Nf = 3)
way out: Mass for hadrons and the matter they make
- L1: Protons and neutrons, and so the mass of all ordinary matter
- L2: Hadrons as collective excitations of the vacuum, 'like phonons in solids'
- L6: The broken vacuum and the conformal anomaly give about 99% of a nucleon's mass
way out: String breaking: pairs from the vacuum, hadrons out
- L1: Mesons and jets of colour-neutral hadrons (Lund model)
- L2: The two new ends become a quark-antiquark pair
- L5: The colour string has constant tension; above a meson's energy it breaks
way out: The vacuum's energy as a source of gravity (contested)
- L1: Enters the Friedmann equation as dark energy: a background effect only, effective w crossing -1 near z = 0.67; the order of magnitude matches today's values; its proposed lab test (the topological Casimir effect) is unmeasured
- L2: QCD-DE reading (Lee et al. 2026): the vacuum-energy difference between an expanding universe and flat spacetime, rho_DE = beta(z) c_H Lambda_QCD^3 H, switched on at late times by the adiabatic condition (the switch beta(z) is fitted with two parameters)
- L6: If the condensates are constant throughout space they would carry an energy density ~ Lambda_QCD^4, about 10^45 times the observed dark energy; Brodsky and Shrock read them as living inside hadrons instead (counted in the baryons' mass); Reinhardt and Weigel defend their vacuum nature
way out: Theta read through the neutron's electric dipole moment
- L1: Measured: d_n = (0.0 +/- 1.1 stat +/- 0.2 sys) x 10^-26 e cm, so theta <~ 1e-10; no strong-only CP violation ever seen (the strong CP problem)
- L2: A theta-dependent neutron EDM, ~3e-16 theta e cm at leading order (naive classical estimate 1e-13 e cm)
- L3: The theta term: physics depends on the vacuum angle because instantons make the topological charge an integer
Who fills each layer
Sources (17) published science
Gluon condensate (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Greensite, The confinement problem in lattice gauge theory, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 51 (2003) 1, arXiv:hep-lat/0301023 (behind its links)
Theta vacuum (Wikipedia, rev 1374376723, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Hook, TASI lectures on the strong CP problem and axions, PoS TASI2018 (2019) 004, arXiv:1812.02669 (behind its links)
Hadron (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Chiral symmetry breaking (Wikipedia, rev 1374866725, 2026-09-14) (behind its links)
Schaefer & Shuryak, Instantons in QCD, Rev. Mod. Phys. 70 (1998) 323, arXiv:hep-ph/9610451 (behind its links)
Bali, Bauer & Pineda, Model-independent determination of the gluon condensate in four-dimensional SU(3) gauge theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113 (2014) 092001, arXiv:1403.6477 (behind its links)
Borsanyi et al., Calculation of the axion mass based on high-temperature lattice quantum chromodynamics (Lattice QCD for cosmology), Nature 539 (2016) 69, arXiv:1606.07494 (behind its links)
Abel et al., Measurement of the permanent electric dipole moment of the neutron, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (2020) 081803, arXiv:2001.11966 (behind its links)
Brodsky & Shrock, Standard-Model condensates and the cosmological constant, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 108 (2011) 45, arXiv:0803.2554 (behind its links)
Urban & Zhitnitsky, The cosmological constant from the QCD Veneziano ghost, Phys. Lett. B 688 (2010) 9, arXiv:0906.2162 (behind its links)