← all systems · see it in The System
Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
The term 'thermal energy' is often used ambiguously in physics and engineering. It can denote internal energy (the energy contained within a body of matter or radiation, excluding the potential energy of the whole system), heat (energy in transfer between a system and its surroundings by mechanisms other than thermodynamic work and transfer of matter), or the characteristic energy kBT, twice that associated with each degree of freedom.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Thermal energy (heat as particle motion and heat flow) |
| born at | Planck epoch (hypothesised); reheating at the end of inflation (established) |
| born precision | epoch |
| boundary | Inside: the disordered microscopic motion of the particles of a body (translations, rotations, vibrations of molecules, atoms, ions and electrons; lattice oscillations in solids) and the thermal radiation they emit, together with its transfer between bodies down temperature differences. Outside: ordered (macroscopic) motion and work, chemical and nuclear potential energy until converted, and transfer of matter. 'Heat refers to a quantity in transfer between systems, not to a property of any one system, or contained within it' (src:wp:thermal-energy), so the boundary of this system is the set of paths heat takes between bodies plus the internal energy stocks at their ends. |
| nested level | Built from moving particles and the photons they emit (rung 2-3 carriers), with phonons and free electrons carrying it in solids; it is the energy currency every hotter-than-surroundings system spends (stars, planets, endotherms) and the reservoir every process drains into under the second law. |
| scale | field |
| why | Heat appears as a carrier in many walks (vents, tidal dissipation, cooling) with no key of its own; here it concentrates solutes, sets the energy window and dec; heating and cooling of gas (and other bodies) carries energy across stacks; no in-use key holds heat as a medium, and the brief lists thermal or cooling stacks ; Reheating's product is a thermal bath; no key in use holds heat as its own m |
Measures (36) published science
| absolute zero | 0 K = -273.15 C |
| energy per classical degree of freedom | kB T / 2 J |
| Stefan-Boltzmann constant | 5.670 374 419e-8 (exact) W m^-2 K^-4 |
| thermal conductivity, diamond / copper / water / air (near 0 C) | 2000 / 390 / 0.6 / 0.023 W/(m C) |
| visible glow threshold (incandescence) | about 525 C |
| thermal equilibrium of all Standard Model particles | above about 1e15 K |
| QGP effective medium temperature (Pb-Pb, 5.02 TeV) | 219 +/- 8 (syst) MeV |
| plasma cools enough for atoms (recombination) | below 3000 K at about 379,000 years |
| CMB black-body temperature | 2.72548 +/- 0.00057 K |
| CMB colour temperature drop since decoupling | factor 1,089 ratio |
| Dark Ages cooling | about 4000 K to about 60 K |
| Sun core / surface temperature | about 15.7 million / about 5,800 K |
| Earth interior heat flow | 47 +/- 2 TW |
| solar radiation at Earth's surface budget | 173,000 TW |
| normal human body temperature | about 37 C |
| characteristic clock: photon travel time from the solar core to the surface | 10,000 to 170,000 years |
| characteristic clock: crossing the Sun's radiative zone | about a million years |
| characteristic clock: solar heat penetration into the ground | a few dozen cm per daily cycle; a few dozen m per annual cycle depth per period |
| inflationary epoch duration (before reheating) | 1e-33 to 1e-32 s |
| highest room-temperature thermal conductivity measured | above 2000 (cubic boron arsenide, on par with single-crystal diamond) W m^-1 K^-1 |
| ultralow lattice thermal conductivity (Cd3As2) | 0.3 to 0.7 at 300 K W m^-1 K^-1 |
| Boltzmann constant | 1.380 649e-23 (exact since the 2019 SI) J K^-1 |
| acoustic gas thermometry uncertainty | as low as 1e-6 T over 7 K to 552 K relative |
| Landauer bound at 300 K | about 3e-21 (k_B T ln 2 per erased bit) J |
| atmospheric heat engine efficiency | less than 1% of incoming solar radiation (per-hand-off efficiency, sunlight to motion) fraction |
| photosynthetic conversion efficiency | less than 3% (per-hand-off efficiency, sunlight to chemical energy) fraction |
| Earth heat gain 1971-2020 | 381 +/- 61 ZJ |
| Earth energy imbalance 1971-2020 | 0.48 +/- 0.1 W m^-2 |
| Earth energy imbalance 2006-2020 | 0.76 +/- 0.2 W m^-2 |
| share of Earth heat gain stored in the ocean (1971-2020) | about 89% (land 6%, cryosphere 4%, atmosphere 1%) fraction |
| base of the solar convection zone | 0.713 +/- 0.001 solar radii |
| thermal boundary layer thickness (7 m cell, Ra = 1e14) | about 1 mm |
| TRPV1 (noxious heat) activation threshold | above 43 C |
| TRPM8 (cold) activation threshold | below 27 C |
| pit viper infrared detection distance | up to 1 m |
| second sound in graphite | observed above 100 K on 5-20 micrometre scales K; micrometre |
Open contentions (3) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-121 Is the universe headed for heat death?
booked: The map keeps both: heat death as the theorised end, and recent work showing the maximum possible entropy is still far from reached.
the other reading: B: in an expanding universe 'the temperature of the universe is continually changing and the issue shifts substantially' (src:adams-laughlin-1997) - C-722 Does erasing information always cost energy (Landauer's principle)?
booked: The map follows the principle: erasing a bit costs a minimum amount of heat, while reversible steps can in principle avoid it. The objections are kept alongside.
the other reading: B: the principle is contested (C-722 registry) - C-1452 What exactly is 'thermal energy'?
booked: The map books it as heat flow together with the energy stored at each end, and keeps the readings that split heat and internal energy apart alongside.
the other reading: B: internal energy and heat as two keys ('The term "thermal energy" is often used ambiguously', src:wp:thermal-energy); C: kT as the characteristic energy per degree of freedom (a scale, not a stock)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (15) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
Shedding body heat by evaporation, built differently: 'humans achieve evaporative heat loss primarily by sweating, whereas dogs rely on panting and rodents spread saliva on their fur' (o64). And holding a body warm: brown fat in some, shivering in muscle (o59). - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Heat engine and heat pump are one four-body cycle run in opposite directions: the engine 'uses heat transfer to produce work', the pump 'uses work to produce heat transfer' up the gradient; and in radiation 'a good absorber is necessarily a good emitter' (emission and absorption mirror each other). - templating (structural)
One spectrum for every body: Planck's law depends only on temperature, so 'The blackbody temperature uniquely characterizes the intensity of the radiation at all wavelengths' for the CMB as for a hot metal or a star. - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Thermal energy is where the toll lands. Every channel in is a hand-off that ends as heat: friction (o2), sound against a wall (o32), an erased bit at no less than kT ln 2, about 3e-21 J at 300 K (o38, o39). The way out to work pays again: the atmosphere's heat engine turns under 1% of incoming sunli - trade one property for another (structural)
Heat flux bought with temperature difference: more convection carries more heat but cools the surface and lowers the Carnot efficiency, so power peaks at 'an optimum heat flux and an intermediate temperature difference' (o45, o44). - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
One shared medium, heat, carved into different slices: a mammal's 11 thermo-TRP channels split it into noxious heat above 43 C (TRPV1) and cold below 27 C (TRPM8) (o55-o57); a pit viper's TRPA1, the most heat-sensitive vertebrate channel, reads the radiant heat of prey up to 1 m away through a pit m - who opens the door (structural)
Heat crosses most doors as open field: any body in contact or in view takes it (o11, o23). At the fold into life the receiver builds the door ahead of time: thermo-TRP channels on sensory neurons (o55, o56), TRPA1 in a pit membrane tuned as an antenna (o65, o66). - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Body heat taken from outside (ectotherms 'use external sources of temperature'), then made inside (endotherms 'create most of their heat via metabolic processes') (o78, o79). Partial: the two are kinds side by side; the source does not show one lineage's borrowed phase before its held phase. - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
Convection organises itself into rolls and cells with no map: Rayleigh-Benard convection 'had been paradigmatic in pattern formation'; the Sun's thermal columns are Benard cells (old GRAV 3). Partial: coordinated flow, read by the sources as pattern formation, not as coordination of parts. - lightning (partial)
Thermal runaway: a rise in temperature speeds the process that releases more heat, 'uncontrolled positive feedback', 'often leading to a destructive result' (o80, o81). A stored difference released all at once. Partial: the source gives the shape, not one dated discharge. - not-diluting wins (partial)
The relic radiation bath cools and thins as the universe expands (temperature inversely proportional to the scale factor), and 'After around 50,000 years, as the universe cools, its behavior begins to be dominated by matter rather than radiation'. - outside-to-inside (partial)
Body heat taken from outside, then made inside: 'Ectotherms use external sources of temperature to regulate their body temperatures', while 'Endotherms create most of their heat via metabolic processes', with 'a larger number of mitochondria per cell'. - The carry (partial)
Two faces. Overflow passed on: in the Sun radiation carries the heat until the gradient it needs exceeds the adiabatic one, and there convection takes the excess (the convection-zone base 'where the temperature gradient changes from being adiabatic to radiative', 0.713 solar radii; o16, o17). The wa - runaway from an unstable balance (surface)
Thermal runaway's self-feeding rise (o80); the balance point it leaves is not shown in the source read. - the whole sets the local reference (surface)
Temperature is defined by a shared reference: two bodies each in equilibrium with a third agree (o26), and since 2019 every thermometer's kelvin is fixed by one assigned constant (o27). Surface: no source shows local readings that fail to close.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (117) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Water molecule via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Atom via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Hydrogen-bond network (water) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) loss
- RNA via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Protein via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Cell membrane via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Lipid (amphiphile) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Water cycle (hydrologic cycle) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Competition: inflationary dilution via sys:spacetime · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Mitochondrion via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Circulatory system via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Residual strong force (nuclear force) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Quark–gluon plasma via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- White dwarf via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Earth via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) loss
- Sun via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Mammal (class Mammalia) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Ocean via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Entropy via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Pit viper via sys:electromagnetic-field · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Energy via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Computer memory via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Covalent bond via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Radioactive decay via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- QCD vacuum via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Collision (encounter) event via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Observation or absorption event via sys:electromagnetic-field · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Primordial Era (the universe before the first stars) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Mineral via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Molecule via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Hydrogen bond via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble bounce (spinor-torsion big bounce) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Matter bounce (nonsingular bouncing cosmology with matter-dominated contraction) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Laser via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Planck epoch (Planck era) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- State of matter via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) loss
- Decoherence via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Arrow of time via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) loss
- Thermodynamic arrow of time via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) loss
- Compressible Euler equations via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Four-force via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) loss
- Black hole thermodynamics via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Matter via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Laplace's equation via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Equation of state via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Laplace operator via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Wave via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Poisson's equation via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Harmonic oscillator via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter) via sys:acoustic-wave · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Large Hadron Collider (LHC) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Force via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Ideal gas via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Hydrophobic effect via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Molecular chaperone via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Proteostasis (the cell's network that makes, folds, repairs and clears its proteins) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Plate tectonics via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) mixed
- Blood via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Enzyme via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Weathering via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Metamorphic rock via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Fold (geology) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- Crystal via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) gain
- Folding funnel (a protein's folding free-energy landscape) via sys:thermal-energy · Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) even
- … 37 more
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (28)
- Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression)
- Competition: inflationary dilution
- Electron
- Photon
- Atom
- Quark–gluon plasma
- Phonon
- Fire
- Grand unification epoch
- Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934)
- Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty)
- Planck epoch (Planck era)
- State of matter
- Decoherence
- Arrow of time
- Thermodynamic arrow of time
- Compressible Euler equations
- Equation of state
- Entropy
- The world through the senses (sensory environment)
- Weather
- Exchange order against thermal disorder (the Curie point)
- Competition for a fusion plasma's heat (alpha heating vs radiation and conduction losses)
- Thermal motion against binding over the early universe's electrons and protons
- Gravity against pressure for a gas cloud (the Jeans criterion)
- Sink against dissociation for a new bond's excess energy
- Conduction down the adiabat against convection, for the heat leaving the core
- Attraction against thermal motion for a gas's molecules (ideal or condensed)
Sits inside / holds (5)
- Big Bang
- Baryonic matter
- Collision (encounter) event
- Entropy
- Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (156)
- Photon
- Atom
- Residual strong force (nuclear force)
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Planet
- Cosmic microwave background
- Molecular cloud
- Hydrogen-bond network (water)
- White dwarf
- Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression)
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite)
- RNA
- Amino acid
- Protein
- Cell membrane
- Bacterium (bacterial cell)
- Aqueous solution
- Competition for cloud gas (competitive accretion and stellar feedback)
- Competition for a solute's hydrogen-bond sites (possible only)
- Sun
- Water cycle (hydrologic cycle)
- Intergalactic medium
- Competition: inflationary dilution
- Mitochondrion
- Circulatory system
- Hypothalamus
- Electron
- Gravitational field
- Electromagnetic field
- Neutrino
- Quark–gluon plasma
- Earth
- Baryonic matter
- Atmosphere of Earth
- Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Phonon
- Ultimate fate of the universe
- Thermal conduction
- Convection (heat carried by fluid motion)
- Thermal radiation
- Latent heat
- Heat engine
- Black-body radiation
- Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry)
- Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation)
- Dinosaurs (Dinosauria)
- Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers)
- Fire
- Lepton (the class of six)
- Computer memory
- Radioactive decay
- Cyclic model (Steinhardt-Turok, periodic brane collisions; hypothetical)
- Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical)
- Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical)
- Moduli (moduli fields; projected model)
- Interacting dark energy (coupled dark sector; hypothesised)
- QCD vacuum
- Casimir-Polder force
- Radiation stress-energy (ultra-relativistic, w = 1/3)
- Collision (encounter) event
- Emission event
- Observation or absorption event
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical)
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical)
- Electromagnetic radiation
- Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy)
- Charm quark
- Mineral
- Observer (frame of reference, physics sense)
- Sphaleron
- Molecule
- Quark epoch
- Grand unification epoch
- Hydrogen bond
- Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble bounce (spinor-torsion big bounce)
- Matter bounce (nonsingular bouncing cosmology with matter-dominated contraction)
- Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934)
- Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty)
- Cosmic time
- … 76 more
represents (2)
Kinds (8)
- Energy
- Thermal conduction
- Convection (heat carried by fluid motion)
- Thermal radiation
- Latent heat
- Sensible heat
- Primordial thermal bath
- Caloric theory
wired (16)
- Photon
- Residual strong force (nuclear force)
- Inflaton field
- Atom
- Stellar magnetic field
- Closed universe (positive curvature)
- Brane-world scenario (projected model: our universe as a brane in a higher-dimensional bulk)
- Quantum tunnelling
- Planck-scale black hole
- Equation of state
- Entropy
- Ideal gas
- Quantum entanglement
- Radioactive decay
- Harmonic oscillator
- Wave-particle duality
Notes published science
- Heat can travel as a wave. In graphite above 100 K, on scales of a few micrometres, a pattern of hot and cold stripes doesn't just fade: the hot and cold places swap, something ordinary diffusion can't do because heat only runs from hot to cold (src:huberman-2019-second-sound).
- Pit vipers see your warmth with a channel your body uses for something else. Their pit membrane is 'a passive antenna for radiant heat', and their TRPA1 is the most heat-sensitive vertebrate ion channel known, finding prey up to a metre away; in mammals the same channel mainly detects chemical irritants (src:gracheva-2010-snake-ir).
- Earth's weather is a heat engine running at under 1%: the surface-to-sky temperature difference drives the winds, but the power it makes is less than 1% of the sunlight coming in (src:kleidon-2020-earth-whole-system). Meanwhile 89% of the 381 ZJ of heat the Earth gained from 1971 to 2020 went into the ocean (src:von-schuckmann-2023).
- Earth as a heat engine runs between 282 K (sunlight in) and 259 K (infrared out), so its best possible efficiency is only 8.5% (src:kato-rose-2020).
- A superconducting current in a gravimeter in Belgium ran for 28 years, 7 months and 27 days (1995-2024) with no power source: a hand-off that paid no measurable toll to entropy, because an energy gap larger than the lattice's thermal energy keeps the electrons from being scattered (src:wp:superconductivity).
- Fermilab's muon g-2 team analysed its data without knowing the answer: the clock frequency at the heart of the measurement was set and kept secret by physicists outside the collaboration, and revealed only after everything was frozen (src:muon-g2-2025).
- Forgetting costs heat. Erasing one bit of memory must dump at least kT ln 2, about 3 x 10^-21 J at room temperature, and when Berut's team erased a one-bit memory made of a single glass bead in a laser trap, the measured heat settled right on that bound for slow erasures (src:berut-2015-landauer).
- Stars run thermodynamics backwards: a star or star cluster that loses energy gets hotter, and two such systems touching never reach equilibrium, 'one gets hotter and hotter by losing energy, the other gets for ever colder by gaining energy'. Lynden-Bell recalls that statistical physicists first 'thought I was talking nonsense' (src:lynden-bell-1999-negative-heat-capacity).
- The same ten programming problems cost 120 joules on average in compiled languages, 576 in languages on a virtual machine and 2,365 in interpreted ones; on the global table Python used about 76 times the energy of C. Each layer of translation between the program and the chip pays its toll in heat (src:pereira-2017-energy).
- Of the energy the tides drain from Earth's spin (3.78 TW), only about 1/30 reaches the Moon's orbit; the rest is heat in shallow seas. Yet the toll is what does the work: without friction the bulge would re-align in two days and the Moon would stop receding (src:wp:tidal-acceleration).
- Forgetting has a price set by physics: erasing one bit must give off at least kB T ln 2 of heat, about 3e-21 J at room temperature, and a single bead in a laser trap measured it at 0.72 kB T against the bound's 0.693 (src:berut-2015).
- Precision has a price tag in heat: any molecular machine's wasted heat times the square of its output's relative scatter is at least 2 kB T, so a motor that wants to step more regularly must burn more (src:barato-seifert-2015-tur).
- In a tall box at equilibrium the bottom is hotter than the top, and heat still doesn't flow: gravity makes the 'redshifted' temperature the one that evens out (Tolman), something that 'continues to cause confusion' outside relativity (src:santiago-visser-2019-tolman).
- The cold sky is a heat sink: a cooler facing the sky stayed 33 to 42 C below the air through a winter day-night cycle, because the air has a window at 8-13 micrometres that opens onto the 3 K of space (src:chen-2016).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
cosmic thermal bath (equilibrium, decoupling and cooling with expansion)
- L1: Made by reheating: 'the large potential energy of the inflaton field was released at the end of the inflationary epoch ... This heating effect led to the universe being repopulated with a dense, hot mixture of Standard Model particles.'
- L2: Equilibrium: 'Above a temperature of around 10^15 K, all the particles of the standard model were in thermal equilibrium'; the quark-gluon plasma, 'the remains of reheating', whose temperature is reached in the lab (219 +/- 8 MeV in Pb-Pb collisions, src:cms-2024-qgp-speed-of-sound).
- L3: Decoupling: 'different types of particles fall out of thermal equilibrium with each other. This occurs as a result of the expansion of the universe, as their interaction rates decrease'; photon and neutrino decoupling 'led to the cosmic microwave background and cosmic neutrino background'.
- L4: Cooling with expansion: the CMB colour temperature 'stays inversely proportional to' the scale factor and has 'dropped by an average factor of 1,089' since decoupling, to 2.725 K today; during the Dark Ages the universe 'cooled from some 4000 K to about 60 K' (src:wp:chronology-of-the-universe).
electromagnetic field (thermal radiation: emission and absorption)
- L1: 'Thermal radiation is electromagnetic radiation emitted by the thermal motion of particles in matter. All matter with a temperature greater than absolute zero emits thermal radiation.' The emission 'arises from a combination of electronic, molecular, and lattice oscillations'.
- L2: Rate set by temperature: 'The total radiation intensity of a black body rises as the fourth power of the absolute temperature, as expressed by the Stefan-Boltzmann law' (src:wp:thermal-radiation), with sigma = 5.670 374 419e-8 W m^-2 K^-4 (src:nist-codata-stefan-boltzmann); emission depends on 'its temperature and its spectral emissivity, as expressed by Kirchhoff's law'. Across gaps narrower than the thermal wavelength, evanescent fields carry 'several orders of magnitude' more than the black-body rate (src:ottens-2011-near-field).
- L3: Spectrum: 'not monochromatic ... a continuous spectrum of photon energies'; for a black body Planck's law gives the spectrum and Wien's law the peak: 'At room temperature, most of the emission is in the infrared (IR) spectrum, though above around 525 C ... enough of it becomes visible for the matter to visibly glow'.
- L4: Absorption at another body: 'In Radiation, the hotter body loses heat, and the colder body receives heat by means of a process occurring in some intervening medium which does not itself thereby become hot' (Maxwell, in src:wp:heat); 'a good absorber is necessarily a good emitter, and a poor absorber is a poor emitter' (src:wp:thermal-radiation).
gravitational field (convection: buoyancy of heated fluid)
- L1: Gravity acting on density differences made by heat: Rayleigh-Benard convection is 'the buoyancy driven flow of a fluid heated from below and cooled from above' (natural convection).
- L2: Onset: 'Convection is the dominant mode of energy transport when the temperature gradient is steep enough so that a given parcel of gas within the star will continue to rise if it rises slightly via an adiabatic process ... if the rising parcel is cooler than the surrounding gas, it will fall back to its original height.' The heat crosses thin thermal boundary layers at the walls: 'The thermal BLs play a crucial role in determining the heat transfer' (src:ahlers-2009-rayleigh-benard); in the Sun the convection zone's base is 'the layer where the temperature gradient changes from being adiabatic to radiative' (src:basu-2016-global-seismology-sun).
- L3: Cells: in the Sun 'The Sun's thermal columns are Benard cells and take the shape of roughly hexagonal prisms'; in the Earth internal heat 'drives mantle convection'. The same buoyancy-driven flow runs in 'Earth's mantle ..., in Earth's outer core ..., and in stars including our sun' (src:ahlers-2009-rayleigh-benard).
- L4: What the flow does on the way out: surface granulation and small-scale dynamo action in the Sun ('Turbulent convection ... sustains small-scale dynamo action'); on Earth it powers 'plate tectonics, mountain building, rock metamorphism, and volcanism', and 'Convective heat transfer within the planet's high-temperature metallic core is also theorized to sustain a geodynamo'.
lattice vibrations (phonons and free electrons in solids)
- L1: Thermal phonons: 'A lattice at a nonzero temperature has an energy that is not constant, but fluctuates randomly about some mean value. These energy fluctuations are caused by random lattice vibrations, which can be viewed as a gas of phonons'; at absolute zero 'a crystal lattice lies in its ground state, and contains no phonons'.
- L2: Two carriers in solids: 'Electrons and phonons, or quantized lattice waves, are the major fundamental carriers of heat in solids'; 'While electrons have the dominant contribution to the thermal conductivity in metals, phonons play the primary role in semiconductors and insulators' (src:quan-2021-electron-phonon); 'Thermal phonons can be created and destroyed by random energy fluctuations' (src:wp:phonon). At room temperature 'heat spreads macroscopically by diffusion', but on micrometre scales in graphite above 100 K heat moves as a wave, second sound (src:huberman-2019-second-sound).
- L3: Integration: 'The entire set of all possible phonons ... combine in what is known as the phonon density of states which determines the heat capacity of a crystal'; thermal phonons behave like the photon gas of a cavity, 'Both gases obey the Bose-Einstein statistics'.
- L4: Edge case: phonon tunnelling, 'across gaps up to a nanometer wide, heat can flow via phonons that tunnel between two materials', at distances 'too large for conduction to occur but too small for radiation'.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Equilibrium and temperature: whatever came in, bodies in contact settle to one temperature (zeroth law); temperature is the shared state variable, the kelvin fixed since 2019 through the Boltzmann constant; latent heat changes state at a fixed temperature.
- L5: Readout: temperature shows in what bodies do: gas pressure in proportion, the speed of sound (read back as the most accurate thermometry), the glow of thermal radiation, phase changes.
- L6: Run-down: transfer as heat is one-way; the hot reservoir only supplies and the cold only receives; extrapolated to the whole universe, heat death (contested, C-121).
- L7: Work from differences: heat flowing down a temperature difference can be partly turned into work, natural (the atmospheric heat engine) or built (a power plant), capped by the Carnot limit.
thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- L1: The carriers: random motion of the particles of a body. Temperature 'reflects the average kinetic energy of the particles in a system, providing a quantitative measure of how energy is distributed among microscopic degrees of freedom'; molecules 'undergo rotational and vibrational motions as well as translations'. In an ideal gas the internal energy 'is just the sum total of the gas's independent particles' kinetic energies'.
- L2: Conversion in: heat can enter a body 'by thermal conduction, by electromagnetic radiation, or through friction ... or due to electrical resistance ... known as Joule heating, or due to repeated magnetization and demagnetization' (src:wp:heat); chemical potential energy 'converted into thermal energy' ('heat of reaction', src:wp:thermal-energy); absorbed radiation; nuclear energy released as motion of products.
- L3: Routing: the modes. Conduction ('the diffusion of thermal energy (heat) within one material or between materials in contact', src:wp:thermal-conduction; carried by electrons in metals and phonons in insulators, src:quan-2021-electron-phonon), convection ('the buoyancy driven flow of a fluid heated from below and cooled from above', src:ahlers-2009-rayleigh-benard) and radiation (no medium needed; Maxwell's 'intervening medium which does not itself thereby become hot', src:wp:heat). Direction is fixed: 'pure heat transfer occurs only down a temperature gradient, never up one' (src:wp:heat).
- L4: Integration into one state: thermal equilibrium and temperature. Zeroth law: 'if two systems are each in thermal equilibrium with a third system, then they are also in thermal equilibrium with each other'; equipartition: 'each classical degree of freedom ... has an average kinetic energy of kBT/2'; heat capacity (a diatomic gas 'will have a greater heat capacity than a monatomic gas'); latent heat changes state 'without changing its temperature or pressure' (src:wp:latent-heat).
- L5: Readout: temperature shows in what bodies do. 'The pressure exerted by a fixed volume and mass of an ideal gas is directly proportional to its temperature'; the speed of sound in a gas 'can be calculated from the gas's molecular character, temperature, pressure, and the Boltzmann constant'; thermal radiation's spectrum is set by temperature (Wien's displacement law: peak frequency proportional to absolute temperature).
- L6: Run-down: transfer as heat is irreversible. A heat engine needs 'two thermal reservoirs ... because transfer of energy as heat is irreversible' and 'The hot reservoir always and only supplies energy, and the cold reservoir always and only receives energy' (src:wp:heat); the second law 'states that any process will result in either no change or a net increase in the entropy of the universe' (src:wp:temperature); extrapolated, heat death: 'no thermodynamic free energy ... maximum entropy'.
- L7: Work from differences: heat flowing down a temperature difference can be partly turned into work. Built engines ('The power plant generates electric free energy from the heat of combustion') and natural ones (the surface-to-atmosphere difference 'drives an atmospheric heat engine that generates the energy to sustain convective motion'), all capped: 'The most power that this heat engine can generate is set by the Carnot limit'. Where no difference is left, 'no heat engine can operate' (src:adams-laughlin-1997).
way in: Chemical energy released as heat (combustion, metabolism, brown fat, shivering)
- L1: Chemical potential energy, spoken of as becoming thermal energy ('heat of reaction')
- L2: In endotherms, metabolism made faster on purpose: brown fat thermogenesis and shivering
- L3: Endotherms make most of their body heat this way
way in: Contact: heat conducted in from a hotter body
- L1: A hotter body in contact: its molecules carry more kinetic energy
- L2: The carriers that take it in: electrons in metals, phonons in semiconductors and insulators
- L3: Spreading through the body: diffusion at ordinary scales, wavelike (second sound) on micrometre scales in graphite above 100 K
way in: Cosmic expansion (makes and cools the universe's bath)
- L1: Inflation ends by turning its energy into particles (reheating)
- L2: Expansion redshifts the bath's photons
- L3: The bath's temperature falls inversely with the scale of the universe
way in: Dissipation: ordered energy degraded into heat (friction, viscosity, resistance, sound, erased bits)
- L1: Work done against friction
- L2: An oscillating gas against a wall: irreversible heat exchange takes the sound's energy
- L3: The floor for information: erasing a bit releases at least kT ln 2 of heat
way in: Fluid flow: heat carried in by convection
- L1: A fluid heated from below and cooled from above, moved by buoyancy
- L2: Thin thermal boundary layers at the walls, where heat crosses into or out of the flow
- L3: Where convection takes over: the gradient turns from radiative to adiabatic (the Sun's convection-zone base)
way in: Nuclear energy released as heat (stellar fusion, radioactive decay)
- L1: Radioactive decay in the mantle and crust (and fusion in stellar cores)
- L2: Released energy appears as heat that travels along geothermal gradients
- L3: In a star the released heat keeps the pressure gradient that balances gravity
way in: Radiation absorbed
- L1: Photons from a warmer body crossing a medium that does not itself get hot
- L2: Absorption: absorptivity equals emissivity at each wavelength
- L3: Across gaps narrower than the thermal wavelength, evanescent fields carry far more than the black-body rate
way out: Buoyant flow driven by heat
- L1: The flows it drives: mantle, outer core, stars; associated with Earth's magnetic field
- L3: Boundary layers and plumes set the flow's heat transfer
- L5: Heated fluid is lighter and rises
way out: Heat conducted to a colder body
- L1: The colder body's molecules speed up until both are uniform
- L3: Diffusion
- L6: Only down the gradient
way out: Radiation emitted
- L1: Photons leave: infrared at room temperature, a visible glow above about 525 C
- L2: Rate: the fourth power of absolute temperature (sigma = 5.670 374 419e-8 W m^-2 K^-4)
- L5: Temperature sets the emission
way out: States changed: melting, evaporation, unbinding
- L1: Bound states form when the bath cools: hydrogen atoms below 3000 K
- L3: Evaporation as a heat route (sweating)
- L5: Latent heat changes state without changing temperature
way out: Work extracted (engines natural and built)
- L1: Air set moving; electricity from a power plant
- L3: At maximum power the heat flux and the temperature difference settle at an optimum
- L7: An engine converts part of the heat flow into work, capped by Carnot
Who fills each layer
- L1: CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical), Ekpyrotic universe (colliding-brane origin of the hot Big Bang; hypothetical), Primordial Era (the universe before the first stars), Arrow of time, Einstein-Cartan-Sciama-Kibble bounce (spinor-torsion big bounce), Matter bounce (nonsingular bouncing cosmology with matter-dominated contraction), Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934), Four-force, Thermodynamic arrow of time, Decoherence, Plasma, State of matter
- L2: Radiation stress-energy (ultra-relativistic, w = 1/3), Compressible Euler equations, Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay), Grand unification epoch, Charm quark, Ultracool dwarf
- L3: Primordial Era (the universe before the first stars), Laplace's equation, Laplace operator, Poisson's equation, Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression), Jupiter
- L4: Primordial Era (the universe before the first stars), Arrow of time, Black hole thermodynamics, Cosmic time, Laplace's equation, Equation of state, Mineral
- L5: Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay), Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation), Plant seed
- L6: Arrow of time, Baum-Frampton cyclic model (phantom energy; the universe comes back empty), Oscillating universe (Friedmann 1922; Einstein 1930; Tolman 1934), Thermodynamic arrow of time, Decoherence