← all systems · see it in The System
Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry)
In physical cosmology, the baryon asymmetry problem, also known as the matter asymmetry problem or the matter-antimatter asymmetry problem, is the observed imbalance in baryonic matter and antibaryonic matter in the observable universe. Baryogenesis is the physical process hypothesized to have taken place during the early universe to produce it; the imbalance has to be exceptionally small, on the order of 1 in every 1,630,000,000 particles a small fraction of a second after the Big Bang.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Matter-antimatter balance (baryon number budget of the universe) |
| boundary | Inside: the universe's net baryon number (n_B - n_Bbar) and lepton number, the processes that can change them (the three Sakharov conditions: baryon number violation, C and CP violation, departure from thermal equilibrium) and the excess they leave (eta roughly 6 x 10^-10 per photon). Outside: the particles that carry the numbers (quarks, antiquarks, leptons), the photon bath the excess is counted against, and the nuclei and atoms later built from the excess. |
| nested level | A conserved-number budget of the whole universe, set during the first fraction of a second (GUT epoch or electroweak transition) and fixed since. Built on the Standard Model's numbers and its anomaly; embedded in the Big Bang, whose walk carries a stack on this key. Also an approved medium key (Sakharov conditions as floors), now walked as a system. Rung 2, below the first fold. |
| scale | cosmological |
| why | Baryogenesis acts on a conserved-number budget, not on one force field; the Sakharov conditions are its floors and no existing key holds it |
Measures (16) published science
| baryon-to-photon ratio eta | roughly 6 x 10^-10 (BBN determination to 1% uncertainty; CMB concordant) ratio |
| size of the imbalance | on the order of 1 in 1,630,000,000 (~2 x 10^9) particles; one excess quark per billion quark-antiquark pairs ratio |
| photon number density today | about 411 per cm^3 at 2.725 K (n_gamma ~ 20.3 (T/1 K)^3 cm^-3) |
| entropy density today | s = 7.04 n_gamma ratio |
| matter-radiation decoupling | roughly 3000 K (0.3 eV) |
| antiprotons among protons today | about 1 in 10,000, consistent with cosmic-ray production ratio |
| antihelium-to-helium flux ratio limit (AMS-01, 1998) | < 1.1 x 10^-6 ratio |
| sphaleron minimum energy | around 10 TeV |
| electroweak crossover | at 159.5 +/- 1.5 GeV; width ~5 GeV with a 125 GeV Higgs |
| Fermilab 2010 collision asymmetry | generated matter approximately 1% larger than generated antimatter (reason not yet known) fraction |
| LHCb Lambda_b CP asymmetry | up to 20% in CP-sensitive quantities (first three years of LHC); baryon CP violation at 5.2 sigma announced March 2025 fraction |
| characteristic clock: when the excess is set | during or shortly after the grand unification epoch (10^-43 to 10^-35 s) for GUT baryogenesis, or at the electroweak transition (~10^-12 s, when W and Z cease to be created) |
| characteristic clock: lepton pair freeze-out | about 10 s after inflation |
| characteristic clock: lower bound on the proton lifetime (how long the excess holds) | 2.4 x 10^34 (p -> e+ + pi0) yr |
| Sakharov conditions proposed | 1967 year |
| CP violation discovered (neutral kaons) | 1964; direct CP violation 1999 year |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same shape, opposite sign (structural)
Antiparticles carry the same magnitude of charge but opposite sign; protons and neutrons have baryon number +1, antiprotons and antineutrons -1: the budget is the difference between two mirror builds that 'form and behave in nearly identical ways'. - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
After the transition sphalerons are 'unobservably rare' and baryon number is conserved perturbatively (no proton decay seen), so the excess is sealed; nuclei and atoms are built on the sealed count. - who opens the door (partial)
Electroweak baryogenesis needs a door that only a first-order transition installs (a domain wall along which the Higgs vev changes, through which quarks transmit more than antiquarks). With a 125 GeV Higgs the transition is a crossover: the installer never builds the door, so the port stays shut in
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (24) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) even
- Higgs field via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) loss
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:electromagnetic-field · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) even
- Big Bang via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- Standard Model of particle physics via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) mixed
- Baryonic matter via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) even
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) loss
- Kaon (K meson) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) even
- Antimatter (antibaryons, antinuclei, antiatoms) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) even
- Lepton (the class of six) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) mixed
- Primordial magnetic field via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) even
- Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) loss
- Electroweak baryogenesis via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- CP violation via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) mixed
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) mixed
- Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy) via sys:thermal-energy · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- Sphaleron via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) mixed
- Grand unification epoch via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- Time reversal T and T-symmetry via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- CP symmetry (and its violation) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- Arrow of time via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) gain
- CPT symmetry via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) mixed
- Universe via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Antiquark
- Quark
- Lepton (the class of six)
- CP violation
- X boson (X and Y bosons; hypothetical GUT gauge bosons)
- Sphaleron
- Baryons and leptons over the conserved B - L budget (sphaleron washout)
- Matter-antimatter annihilation contest
Sits inside / holds (6)
- Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)
- Big Bang
- Standard Model of particle physics
- Electroweak baryogenesis
- CP violation
- Sphaleron
expressed by (2)
floor filled by (34)
- Meson
- Higgs field
- Antiquark
- Big Bang
- Standard Model of particle physics
- Baryonic matter
- Kaon (K meson)
- Antimatter (antibaryons, antinuclei, antiatoms)
- Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)
- Photon
- Inflaton field
- Electroweak interaction
- Cosmic microwave background
- Quark
- Cosmic rays
- Magnetic monopoles (hypothetical relics)
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Lepton (the class of six)
- Baryons and leptons over the conserved B - L budget (sphaleron washout)
- CP violation
- X boson (X and Y bosons; hypothetical GUT gauge bosons)
- Sphaleron
- Grand unification epoch
- Seesaw mechanism (hypothetical)
- Primordial magnetic field
- Electroweak baryogenesis
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical)
- Time reversal T and T-symmetry
- State of matter
- CP symmetry (and its violation)
- Arrow of time
- CPT symmetry
- Matter
- Universe
Kinds (8)
- GUT baryogenesis
- Electroweak baryogenesis
- Leptogenesis
- Affleck-Dine mechanism
- B-mesogenesis
- Asymmetric dark matter
- Separated matter and antimatter regions
- CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical)
wired (3)
Notes published science
- Everything rests on about one part in 1.6 billion: 'if the model is computed with equal amounts of baryons and antibaryons, they annihilate each other so completely that not enough baryons are left to create nucleons'.
- Sakharov (1967) saved CP symmetry by mirroring time: events before his 'initial singularity' run with the opposite CP violation, so the matter excess after the Big Bang is an antimatter excess before it; Boyle and Turok's mirror universe runs the same shape, an antiuniverse flowing backward in time.
- The matter of the universe may have been made as leptons first: in leptogenesis decays of heavy right-handed neutrinos make a lepton excess, and sphalerons (Greek 'slippery') turn it into baryons; Tegmark notes a 'sphalerizer' converting baryons to antileptons would beat fusion's energy efficiency by orders of magnitude.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
early-universe thermal bath (reaction rates against expansion)
- L1: The hot, dense bath left by reheating, expanding and cooling; above about 10^15 K all Standard Model particles in thermal equilibrium, matter and antimatter continually produced and annihilated
- L2: Temperature against mass scale: the grand unification epoch (about 10^-43 to 10^-35 s) at GUT energies of 10^15 GeV (above 10^27 K); the rate of baryon-violating X or H0 reactions is set largely by the intermediate particle's mass, giving a maximum mass above which the rate is too slow
- L3: Out of equilibrium: the rate of the reaction that generates the asymmetry must be less than the expansion rate, so particles and antiparticles do not reach thermal equilibrium as expansion lowers pair-annihilation
- L4: Freeze-out of the pairs: as radiation no longer makes hadrons or anti-hadrons, the anti-hadrons annihilate with hadrons, leaving a small remainder; at about 10 s new lepton pairs stop forming and antileptons annihilate, leaving a small residue of leptons
electromagnetic field (annihilation radiation and the photon count)
- L1: Cosmic background photons: matter decoupled at roughly 3000 K (0.3 eV); afterwards the total number of photons stays constant while expansion lowers their density, about 411 per cubic centimetre at 2.725 K
- L2: Annihilation: a particle meeting its antiparticle gives gamma rays, neutrinos and sometimes lighter pairs, most of the energy as ionizing radiation; a positron annihilation gives two gamma rays of 511 keV each
- L3: The count: eta = (n_B - n_Bbar) / n_gamma; the preferred parameter divides by the entropy density s, which stayed reasonably constant through most of the universe's evolution (s = 7.04 n_gamma today)
- L4: Watch for antimatter: boundaries between matter and antimatter regions would annihilate and shine in gamma rays; none detected in 30 years of searches; about 1 in 10,000 protons are antiprotons, consistent with cosmic-ray production; AMS-01 set an antihelium-to-helium limit of 1.1 x 10^-6 (AMS-02 has eight unverified antihelium-3 candidates as of 2021)
matter-antimatter balance (baryon and lepton number budget of the universe)
- L1: Conserved numbers carried by the hot bath: baryon number (+1 for protons and neutrons, -1 for antiprotons and antineutrons; 1/3 per quark) and lepton number (+1 electron, -1 positron); perturbatively [B,H] = 0, so every observed reaction has equal baryon number before and after
- L2: Sakharov condition 1, baryon number violation: in the Standard Model a U(1)_B Adler-Bell-Jackiw anomaly (the sphaleron: three baryons into three antileptons, B - L conserved, minimum ~10 TeV); in GUTs and SUSY models via hypothetical massive X bosons, which would also make protons decay (unobserved, lifetime above 2.4 x 10^34 years)
- L3: Sakharov condition 2, C and CP violation, so baryon-making interactions are not counterbalanced by antibaryon-making ones: a complex phase in the CKM quark-mixing matrix (observed since 1964, 'a small portion' of what is needed); strong-sector CP violation too small (no neutron electric dipole moment seen); a PMNS phase in the lepton sector unmeasured (T2K 2020 indications); CP violation in baryons first seen by LHCb in 2025
- L4: Sakharov condition 3, departure from thermal equilibrium (otherwise CPT symmetry compensates): an asymmetry-making rate below the expansion rate, or the domain wall of a first-order electroweak transition; with a 125 GeV Higgs the transition is a continuous crossover about 5 GeV wide, so there is no Standard Model electroweak baryogenesis (extensions such as supersymmetry and two-Higgs-doublet models have a first-order transition but need extra CP violation)
- L5: The kept excess: one excess quark per billion quark-antiquark pairs (on the order of 1 in 1.63 x 10^9 particles); after most matter and antimatter annihilated, what remained was all the baryonic matter of today; no evidence of primordial antimatter, and no antimatter-dominated region within the observable universe
- L6: Read out by later physics: eta (roughly 6 x 10^-10) is proportional to the baryon density and controls the entropy of the universe, which sets the temperature at which BBN fusion can begin; with equal baryons and antibaryons 'not enough baryons are left to create nucleons'; deuterium fixes eta to 1%, and the CMB about 400,000 years later gives the same value (Lambda-CDM passes the consistency test)
Who fills each layer
- L1: CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical), Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy), Sphaleron, Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)
- L2: Unified interaction (fundamental forces merged into one at high energy), Sphaleron, Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry), Grand unification epoch
- L3: Arrow of time, CP symmetry (and its violation), Time reversal T and T-symmetry, Sphaleron, CP violation, Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)
- L4: CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical), Antimatter (antibaryons, antinuclei, antiatoms), CPT symmetry, Electroweak baryogenesis
- L5: CPT-symmetric (mirror) universe (Boyle-Finn-Turok universe/anti-universe pair; hypothetical), Electroweak baryogenesis, Sphaleron, Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)
- L6: Quarks and antiquarks for survival out of the early-universe plasma (the baryon asymmetry)