← all systems · see it in The System
Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical)
'A speculative cyclocosmic cosmological model in the framework of general relativity, proposed by the theoretical physicist Roger Penrose. In CCC the universe iterates through infinite cycles, with the future timelike infinity ... of each previous iteration being identified with the Big Bang singularity of the next.' Walked as a projected model (representation): the content of a scenario held in cosmology, not an observed system.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose) |
| boundary | Inside: a countable sequence of aeons, each an open FLRW spacetime from a Big Bang to an infinite future expansion, joined so that the future conformal boundary of one is the Big Bang of the next; what crosses the joins (massless radiation, gravitational radiation) and what does not (fermions). Outside: nothing; the sequence is the entire universe. As an idea it is bounded by Penrose's papers and his 2010 book 'Cycles of Time'. |
| nested level | Built from FLRW aeons and the conformal boundaries that join them; embedded, as an idea, in cosmology (sys:science). Rung 0, hypothesised; below the first fold. |
| representation | True |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (8) published science
| characteristic clock: one aeon | infinite in its own metric (Big Bang to future timelike infinity); finite after conformal rescaling |
| claimed significance of concentric low-variance circles (WMAP 7-year) | up to about 6 sigma (disputed) |
| Hawking point angular radii | 0.03 to 0.04 radians |
| Hawking point angular diameters | about 3 to 4 degrees |
| Planck channel in which the spots were first found | 70 GHz |
| independent groups failing to reproduce the circles | 3 groups |
| year proposed / book | 2010 (Cycles of Time) year |
| status of CMB signatures | 'as of 2020, these have not been detected'; 2024 re-analysis found no low-variance circles qualitative |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same shape, opposite sign (structural)
The model's key identification: the remote future of an aeon (infinitely large, cold, scale-free radiation) and the Big Bang of the next (infinitely small, hot) are the same conformal geometry: 'to match up an infinitely large universe to an infinitely small universe'. - templating (partial)
Every aeon is the same construction (an open FLRW spacetime from Big Bang to infinite expansion), repeated through a countable sequence. - barrier-gates-complexity (surface)
The join passes massless bosons and holds fermions ('Fermions ... remain confined to a given aeon'), so only scale-free radiation seeds the next aeon's structure.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Electron via sys:gravitational-field · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) even
- Photon via sys:electromagnetic-field · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) gain
- Cosmic microwave background via sys:electromagnetic-field · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) even
- Supermassive black hole via sys:electromagnetic-field · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) gain
- Matter-antimatter balance (baryon asymmetry) via sys:matter-antimatter-balance · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:mental-representation · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) mixed
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) gain
- Ultimate fate of the universe via sys:mental-representation · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) gain
- Conformal boundary (conformal infinity) via sys:spacetime · Conformal cyclic cosmology (Penrose; aeons joined by conformal rescaling; hypothetical) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (10)
- Photon
- Cosmic microwave background
- Big Bang
- Supermassive black hole
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Friedmann-Lemaitre-Robertson-Walker spacetime
- de Sitter spacetime
- Light cone (null cone)
- Gravitational wave
- Conformal boundary (conformal infinity)
represents (2)
Kinds (2)
- Big Bang
- Big Bounce (contraction, bounce and expansion in place of the initial singularity; hypothetical)
Notes published science
- No contraction needed: the end of one universe and the beginning of the next are the same shape once you forget scale; a universe of pure light has no clocks and no rulers, so 'infinitely big and cold' and 'infinitely small and hot' can be glued together.
- Messages through the Big Bang: Hawking points would be the last breath of supermassive black holes from before our Big Bang, 3 to 4 degrees across on our sky; Gurzadyan and Penrose even discussed the CMB as a channel for 'information transfer from one aeon to another'.
- The fight over the rings came down to how the comparison skies were simulated, not to the data: the same WMAP maps, two simulation methods, two verdicts.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
conformal geometry joining aeons (light-cone structure; spacetime)
- L1: A countable sequence of open FLRW spacetimes, 'each representing a Big Bang followed by an infinite future expansion'; Penrose calls the sectors 'aeons'.
- L2: Conformal structure: 'light-cone structures being preserved under conformal rescaling'; bosons obey 'conformally invariant quantum theory'.
- L3: Rescaling: each metric g_ab multiplied by Omega^2, with Omega approaching zero at timelike infinity, 'squashing down' the future conformal boundary to a regular hypersurface, 'spacelike if there is a positive cosmological constant'.
- L4: Crossover: the past conformal boundary of one aeon is attached to the future conformal boundary of the previous; it 'satisfies the Weyl curvature hypothesis, thus providing a certain kind of low-entropy past'.
- L5: The whole: 'a new solution to Einstein's equations, which Penrose takes to represent the entire universe, and which is composed of a sequence of sectors'.
gravitational radiation across the crossover (gravitational field)
- L1: Encounters of supermassive black holes in the previous aeon emit 'spherical gravitational waves caused by colliding black holes'.
- L2: Preserved across the join: 'Penrose has calculated that a certain amount of gravitational radiation should be preserved across the boundary between aeons'; it 'may be enough to explain the observed cosmic acceleration without appeal to a dark energy field' (citation needed).
- L3: Imprint: concentric circles of low temperature variance in WMAP 7-year maps 'at up to about 6 sigma', also in BOOMERanG98 (Gurzadyan and Penrose, paraphrased); 'three groups have independently attempted to reproduce these results, but found that the detection ... was not statistically significant'.
massless radiation across the crossover (electromagnetic field)
- L1: Late aeon: 'all massive particles eventually vanish from existence'; 'all matter decays and ultimately turns to light', so 'nothing in the universe would have any time or distance scale associated with it'; Penrose later allows insignificant amounts of mass in 'a conformal geometry dominated by photons'.
- L2: Evaporation: Hawking evaporation of supermassive black holes; fermions 'must be irreversibly converted into radiation during black hole evaporation' (citation needed in the source).
- L3: Crossing: for bosons the boundary 'is not a boundary at all, but just a spacelike surface that can be passed across like any other'; fermions 'remain confined to a given aeon'.
- L4: Imprint: 'Hawking points', hot spots with 'angular radii between 0.03 and 0.04 radians' ('angular diameters between about 3 and 4 degrees'), first found in Planck 70 GHz data against 1000 then 10000 simulations; a 2020 analysis found them 'consistent with the standard inflationary picture once the look-elsewhere effect is taken into account'.
mental representation: conformal cyclic cosmology as proposed, appraised and held
- L1: Proposed: Roger Penrose; advanced in 2010 and popularised in 'Cycles of Time: An Extraordinary New View of the Universe' (2010).
- L2: Appraisal: proton decay 'has never been observed'; electrons must decay or lose charge or mass and 'no conventional speculations allow for this'; skeptics: 'all particles must lose their mass when the universe gets old'; Penrose moderated the no-mass requirement in his Nobel lecture.
- L3: Tested: circles claimed (2010), disputed (the disagreement 'tracked down to an issue of how to construct the simulations'); sky-twist (2013) and Planck (2015) by the authors; Hawking points (2018); look-elsewhere (2020); 2024 re-analysis found no low-variance circles; 'The absence of such distinct features in the CMB does not disprove CCC.'
- L4: Held: speculative and 'not been accepted in the wider cosmological community'; extended by its authors to the Fermi paradox ('information transfer from one aeon to another').