← all systems · see it in The System
Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical)
A closed (K = +1) inflationary cosmology that originates as an Einstein static universe, then inflates and later reheats to a hot big bang era: 'The inflationary universe emerges from a small static state that has within it the seeds for the development of the macroscopic universe, and we call this the Emergent Universe scenario.' These cosmologies have 'no singularity, no beginning of time, and no horizon problem'. Walked as a projected model (representation): the content of a scenario held in cosmology, not an observed system.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Emergent Universe |
| boundary | Inside: one whole spatially closed universe (finite 3-sphere sections, K = +1) from its asymptotic Einstein static past, through past-eternal inflation with a finite number of e-folds, to reheating. Outside: nothing spatially (closed); after reheating the history belongs to the hot Big Bang. As an idea it is bounded by the papers that state it (Ellis and Maartens 2002; Ellis, Murugan and Tsagas 2003). |
| nested level | Built from an Einstein static initial state, a minimally coupled scalar field (a hypothetical inflaton) and optional ordinary matter in a closed FRW geometry. Embedded, as an idea, in human cosmology (sys:science); its content would hand on to the inflation epoch and the Big Bang. Rung 0, hypothesised; below the first fold. |
| representation | True |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (12) published science
| total density parameter that motivated the scenario (WMAP) | 1.02 +/- 0.02 Omega_0 |
| spatial curvature parameter (Planck 2018) | 0.0007 +/- 0.0019 Omega_K |
| curvature below which no planned experiment (e.g. SKA) can tell flat, open and closed apart | 1e-4 |Omega_K| |
| initial radius condition to avoid the quantum-gravity era | a_i > 1/M_p (a_0 >> L_Pl) length |
| primordial cosmological constant (scalar field only) | Lambda_i = 2/a_i^2 1/length^2 |
| maximum energy stored in the field for a_0 = 10^6 L_Pl | 1e63 GeV^4 |
| reheating temperature, efficient reheating, a_0 = 10^6 L_Pl | 1e16 GeV |
| density perturbation amplitude to be produced | 1e-5 dimensionless |
| stability of the Einstein static state against inhomogeneous linear perturbations | neutral when rho_i = 0, or when c_s^2 > 1/5 sound speed squared |
| isometry group of the Einstein static model (highest symmetry non-empty FRW model) | 7 dimensions |
| characteristic clock: e-folding time of the emerging inflation | about sqrt(2) a_i per e-fold (N_e ~ t_e/(sqrt(2) a_i), t_e >> a_i) Planck units of time |
| age of the emergent phase | infinite (past-asymptotic to Einstein static; finite-time variants exist) |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- not-diluting wins (structural)
In the infinite past curvature balances the field; going forward a slowly rolling field's potential stays while curvature falls off, so 'curvature will eventually win over a slow-rolling scalar field as we go back into the past' and the potential wins going forward. - lightning (partial)
A balanced state that releases on a perturbation: the Einstein static universe is 'unstable to homogeneous perturbations'; 'any slight change ... will result in a universe that either expands and accelerates forever or re-collapses to a singularity'. - seed (partial)
'The inflationary universe emerges from a small static state that has within it the seeds for the development of the macroscopic universe'; the explicit model's only parameter is the size of that state.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch) via sys:gravitational-field · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) gain
- Inflaton field via sys:inflaton-field · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) gain
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) loss
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:mental-representation · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) gain
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical) via sys:spacetime · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) even
- Einstein static universe via sys:gravitational-field · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) gain
- Eternal Emergent Universe via sys:gravitational-field · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) even
- Finite-time Emergent Universe via sys:gravitational-field · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) even
- Eddington-Lemaitre universe via sys:gravitational-field · Emergent Universe (Ellis-Maartens scenario; hypothetical) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (4)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- Gravitational field
- Cosmic inflation and reheating (inflationary epoch)
- Inflaton field
- Big Bang
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Closed universe (positive curvature)
- Cosmological constant (Lambda, vacuum energy)
- Stiff matter
- Perfect fluid
- Einstein static universe
represents (2)
Kinds (4)
Notes published science
- A universe with 'no beginning of time' that still has only a finite amount of inflation: infinite time, bounded e-folds, because the scale factor never goes to zero.
- Why start static? The Einstein static model 'maximizes the entropy within the family of FRW radiation models' and is 'the unique highest symmetry non-empty FRW model' (a 7-dimensional isometry group).
- Self-hiding: the more the emergent inflation flattens the universe, the less any observation can ever tell it from the standard flat picture.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
closed spacetime geometry: Einstein static state to inflation (gravitational field)
- L1: Closed Friedmann-Robertson-Walker geometry, K = +1 (positively curved, finite 3-sphere sections), governed by the Friedmann and Raychaudhuri equations: 'The only way to satisfy Eq. (9) with non-negative energy densities is if K = +1'.
- L2: Einstein static balance: curvature held against the energy density at a fixed radius a_i; with only a scalar field the primordial cosmological constant is Lambda_i = 2/a_i^2, and a_i can be chosen above the Planck scale (a_i > 1/M_p), so 'these models can in principle avoid the quantum gravity era'.
- L3: Instability gate: the Einstein static state 'is neutrally stable against inhomogeneous linear perturbations' (for no matter, or matter with sound speed c_s^2 > 1/5) but 'unstable to homogeneous perturbations, which break the balance between curvature and energy density. This instability is crucial for producing an inflationary era.'
- L4: Emergence and inflation: past-asymptotically Einstein static and ever-expanding; inflation for an infinite time to the past but a finite number of e-folds at any finite time, N_e ~ t_e/(sqrt(2) a_i), and curvature suppressed as Omega_e - 1 ~ 2 exp(-N_e); 'no singularity, no beginning of time, and no horizon problem'.
- L5: Exit into the hot Big Bang: inflation ends, the field reheats 'in the usual way', and the universe is 'subsumed into a hot Big Bang era'; the late universe is governed by Lambda = 8 pi G V_f << Lambda_i and can be told apart from the standard flat model 'only by high-precision observations'.
mental representation: the scenario as proposed, appraised and held in cosmology
- L1: Proposed: Ellis and Maartens (arXiv:gr-qc/0211082, submitted 25 Nov 2002; journal doi:10.1088/0264-9381/21/1/015) name 'the Emergent Universe scenario', 'a modern version and extension of the Eddington universe'; the explicit construction follows (Ellis, Murugan and Tsagas, 2003).
- L2: Appraisal: 'The model can be criticized because of its fine-tuned initial state'; the authors answer that the singularity theorems are not probabilistic and 'There is no scientifically based proof that the unique physical universe has to be probable'.
- L3: Tested against curvature data: motivated by Omega_0 = 1.02 +/- 0.02 (WMAP); Planck 2018 gives Omega_K = 0.0007 +/- 0.0019, 'consistent with a flat universe'; 'if the standard model is correct, the Emergent Universe with perturbatively small curvature cannot be falsified by observations'.
- L4: Held as a contender: 'We do not claim that the Emergent scenario is superior to the standard scenario, but simply that it is worthwhile investigating, since neither it nor the standard scenario are yet ruled out'; listed among speculative pre-inflation models in the Big Bang article.
scalar field on the emergent potential (inflaton field)
- L1: A standard, minimally coupled scalar field phi with energy density phi-dot^2/2 + V and pressure phi-dot^2/2 - V, possibly with ordinary matter p = w rho (-1/3 <= w <= 1): 'We do not require exotic physics or matter.'
- L2: Static start: the potential is asymptotically flat in the infinite past, V -> V_i; with no matter the field 'must have nonzero (but constant) kinetic energy, so that it rolls at constant speed along the flat potential' (dynamically a stiff fluid w = 1 plus Lambda_i).
- L3: Slow drop: e.g. V - V_f = (V_i - V_f)[exp((phi - phi_f)/alpha) - 1]^2; 'Provided that phi-dot^2 decreases more rapidly than the potential ... the universe accelerates'; in the explicit model V(phi) = (2/(kappa a_0^2))(e^{B phi} - 1)^2, matching an R^2-inflation-like plateau.
- L4: End and reheating: inflation ends at V_e = phi-dot_e^2; 'reheating takes place as the field oscillates about the minimum'; maximum stored energy 2/(kappa a_0^2) ~ 10^37 GeV^2 / a_0^2, so for a_0 = 10^6 Planck lengths T_RH can reach about 10^16 GeV.
- L5: Seeds: as in all inflation models, 'fine-tuning is necessary to produce density perturbations at the O(10^-5) level'; in the explicit model the fluctuation amplitude ties the two remaining parameters, so 'the only parameter in the model is the size of the Einstein static universe'.
Who fills each layer
- L1: Eternal Emergent Universe, Finite-time Emergent Universe
- L2: Einstein static universe, Eternal Emergent Universe
- L3: Einstein static universe, Finite-time Emergent Universe
- L4: Einstein static universe, Eternal Emergent Universe, Finite-time Emergent Universe
- L5: Eternal Emergent Universe