borrowed-then-held our proposal
A regulation first supplied by the surroundings, later held inside the system.
Seen in 430 walked systems. Each sighting is our reading of that system's sourced walk, in that system's own terms; a shape that turns up everywhere is the finding, and how it differs from place to place is the detail.
Structural: the shape does the work here (111)
- Adaptive immune system
RAG1 evolved from a Transib transposase and the RSSs resemble the transposon's heptamer-spacer-nonamer ends (lancelet ProtoRAG); the source speaks of the 'domestication of RAG genes', now expressed only in developing lymphocytes. Also the newborn 'only borrows' maternal antibodies until it makes its - Alloy
Borrowed: people first used alloys nature made, meteoric iron 'used as it was' and native electrum, and the earliest bronzes were smelted from naturally mixed ores (stannite at Plocnik; native arsenical copper at Tal-i-Iblis). Held: people then mixed metals themselves, and tin replaced arsenic becau - Alphabet (one letter per phoneme)
Vowels first left to the reader and to context, then to 'weak' consonants doing double duty (matres lectionis, 'at first rare and limited'), then held by letters dedicated 'exclusively and unambiguously' to vowels in Greek. - Amino acid
Supplied by the surroundings, then made inside: the early ten came from prebiotic chemistry (discharge, meteorites), and 'The remaining amino acids were incorporated into proteins after pathways for their biochemical synthesis evolved'. Both phases shown (firing rule met). - Ancient Greek art
life-size stone sculpture: the impulse supplied by Egyptian statuary seen abroad, then held as Greece's own more dynamic tradition; Egyptian blue first made in Egypt, then made in Greek workshops (Kos) - Arithmetic (the practice of calculating, and the operations and laws it works with)
A child first does sums with the fingers and counting (borrowed from the body and the voice), then holds the facts in hippocampal-neocortical memory and retrieves them; abacus users go from beads to a mental abacus (rapid recall of number positions). Both phases are shown in the longitudinal data. - Art of ancient Egypt
glass first imported as ready-made ingots, then made in Egyptian workshops (Amarna, Pi-Ramesses) and exported by the end of the 18th Dynasty - Artificial intelligence
Game knowledge first supplied by people ('handcrafted evaluation functions that have been refined by human experts over several decades'), later made by the system itself from the rules alone, 'tabula rasa', by self-play. Speech: labels borrowed from transcribers, then representations learned 'from - Authentication
Borrowed: the first Unix password file held the actual passwords and its secrecy was supplied by the file system's protection (and lapses showed it). Held: a one-way transform stored inside the record itself, so 'neither the password file nor the password program itself needed to be protected'. Kerb - Bacterium (bacterial cell)
The gut community borrows the condition it needs from its host and then keeps it there: the butyrate the microbes make drives colonocyte oxygen consumption, and the hypoxia that follows is what keeps obligate anaerobes dominant. Raise the epithelial oxygen and facultative anaerobes expand instead. T - Bearing (mechanical)
Lubrication first supplied from outside (water mills where 'the water provides cooling and lubrication'; workers called oilers with oil cans from the late 1700s to the mid-1900s), later held inside: sealed-for-life bearings carry their own grease behind seals (rare before the 1970s), composite beari - Bilaterian animal (Bilateria)
The urbilaterian 'would presumably have been small enough for diffusion to do the job of transporting compounds through the body'; later, coelomic fluid 'circulated by mesothelial cilia or by contraction of muscles in the body wall' serves transport of gases, nutrients and wastes. Acoelomates still rely on diffusion via a large surface-to-volume ratio. - Bone
Mineral first laid down passively, then held by cells: 'The mechanism of mineral formation in bone is clearly distinct from the phylogenetically older process by which cartilage is mineralized': cartilage mineral forms diffusely 'in keeping with a passive mineralization mechanism', while in bone onl - Botnet
Storm first ran its command traffic over OVERNET, an existing benign Kademlia DHT, then newer versions ran their own XOR-encrypted Stormnet: the overlay first borrowed from the surroundings, then held by the botnet. - Bumblebee (Bombus)
A learner first gets its reward from the demonstrator's pull (scrounging, rewarded pull), then pulls alone and becomes a demonstrator; experienced bees no longer need the moving flower's feedback - Capuchin monkey (Cebus and Sapajus)
Juveniles first use the hammer stones adults carried to the anvils, the pits adults wore, and nut pieces left behind (borrowed); years later they crack with their own chosen stones (held). Both phases are shown - Cell
Energy gradient: the first cells may have used 'the natural geochemical proton gradient in its environment across a leaky membrane'; 'In modern cells, those proton movements are caused by the pumping of ions across the membrane, maintaining an electrochemical gradient.' Both phases are in the source - Cell membrane
LUCA could live on natural proton gradients 'only if the membranes were leaky' (borrowed); pumps and ion-tight membranes came later (held). Both phases shown, in a model; the vent setting is one account of life's origin. - Central bank
The nominal anchor first borrowed from outside, gold convertibility ("the amount of money banks could supply was constrained by the value of the gold they held"), later held inside the bank as its own inflation commitment, which "echoes the convertibility principle of the gold standard" (Bordo). Bot - Central processing unit
The fast store was outside, then inside: L1 caches were once on a separate die or chip, 'while bigger chips have allowed integration of it and generally all cache levels'; likewise the CPU itself went from thousands of SSI chips to 24 ICs (1968) to one microprocessor, and the MMU and power regulatio - Child development
Stress regulation borrowed then held: the infant's cortisol is buffered by the caregiver's responses, and later the child's own stress responsivity is set (BEIP: healthier at 12 after early family care); Vygotsky: a function first between people, then inside the child. - Chinese art
underglaze cobalt painting supplied by the Islamic world under the Yuan (potters moved, Islamic-taste exports driving it), then held as Jingdezhen's own: refined with manganese under Xuande and a Ming 'signature category'; Buddhist art received, then given strong Chinese traits - Chordate (Chordata)
Tunicate cellulose is made by an enzyme encoded by a gene horizontally transferred from an Actinobacterium; the borrowed gene now builds the animal's own tunic in every generation. - Columbian Exchange
Horses first came from Spanish herds (borrowed: landed, abandoned at Buenos Aires ca. 1536, feral by ca. 1580), then were held by Indigenous nations' own herding: pastorally managed and eaten by Aonikenk/Tehuelche before permanent European settlement, with isotopes showing horses raised and moved be - Compiler
Bootstrapping: the first compiler for a language is written in another language or run inside an existing interpreter (Hart and Levin, LISP, 1962), then the language compiles itself; NELIAC (1958) finally 're-compiled by itself, making the bootstrap obsolete'. Both phases shown. - Computer ethics
Borrowed phase: computer ethics problems first noticed inside Maner's medical ethics course; held phase: a branch of its own with its own course (1976), starter kit (1978), textbook and journal issue (1985), conferences, codes. For AI ethics only the borrowed phase is shown (principlism without medi - Computer hardware
The program was first set by people outside the machine, 'by setting switches and inserting patch cables' (ENIAC, Colossus); then held inside it, encoded with the data by one mechanism (the stored program). Both phases shown. - Computer law
Both phases shown. Borrowed: before computer crime statutes, prosecutors used trespass, burglary and theft law, and the UK charged Gold and Schifreen under the Forgery and Counterfeiting Act 1981 ('The fit proved a poor one'; the Lords upheld the acquittal, 1988). Held: the field's own statutes (Flo - Computer network
The bridge table was first kept by a person and is now learned by the bridge ('Having a human maintain this table is too burdensome, and there is a simple trick by which a bridge can learn this information for itself'); both phases shown (static configuration, then learning). Early networks borrowed - Computer-aided design
Engineering calculations were first done outside CAD, by hand or by people who could run programs, then held inside it ('Eventually, CAD provided the designer with the ability to perform engineering calculations'). Both phases sourced. Also Boeing borrowed an NC machine tool as a drafting machine be - Corporation
Both phases shown twice. Finance: the VOC first lived on a revolving fund replenished by returning cargoes and installments (borrowed from the trade's own timing), then obtained a permanent capital (1612). Force: corporations were 'essentially dependent on the Royal Navy's ability to control trade r - Culture
Bumblebee demonstrators were held up on the unrewarded first step by a temporary reward from the experimenters (borrowed); the reward was removed and observers then learned the step from demonstrators alone (held by transmission) - Database
Two phases shown twice. (1) Bookkeeping history: on cards and tape 'The old master was never updated', partly because 'writing a new tape was easier'; the medium kept the history. With update in place on discs, the database holds it itself, in logs and compensating transactions. (2) Tuning: done by - Developmental genetic toolkit (evo-devo gene toolkit)
Gastrulation 'may have been started by movements of sea water in the environment, later replaced by the evolution of tissue movements in the embryo'. - Digital forensics
Borrowed phase: in the 1980s examiners used the operating system's own sysadmin tools on live media, risking tampering claims. Held phase: from 1989 the field built its own imaging tools (IMDUMP, SafeBack, DIBS, Fixed Disk Image), then EnCase and FTK, so examination ran on copies without live forens - Digital signatures and certificates
Let's Encrypt borrowed trust (cross-signed by IdenTrust, October 2014), then held its own: ISRG's root accepted by all major root programs by August 2018, its own chain the default from July 2020. Earlier, RSA's 1978 directory key borrowed in-person presence before signatures carried the trust. - Ecological succession
Nutrients first borrowed from outside, later held: before autotrophs, 'a foodweb formed by heterotrophs built on allochthonous inputs of dead organic matter'; seabirds carry nitrogen in; at the climax 'uptake of nutrients from the soil and the return of nutrient by litter fall' balance inside the co - Education
Scaffolding: the teacher first carries part of the task (contingent support), then fades it as 'responsibility for the performance of a task is gradually transferred to the learner'; among Aka, play that emulates adult work gives way to real participation - Election
The ballot itself was first supplied by the surroundings: before 1856 ballots were party tickets, told apart by colour and size; then the election held it, as an official ballot printed at public expense (Victoria 1856, Massachusetts 1888, the US switch complete in 1950; seven states had no governme - Electrochemical gradient
Borrowed phase: LUCA is inferred to have used 'the natural geochemical proton gradient in its environment across a leaky membrane'; held phase: 'The emergence of Na+/H+ antiporters likely led to the later evolution of impermeable membranes', and modern cells keep their gradient by pumping ('In moder - Emotion (feelings)
Infants depend on caregivers to perform allostasis for them (borrowed); that support wires the infant's brain so it gradually performs allostasis on its own (held). - Engine
Valve timing first done by a person, then by the engine. Savery pumps 'required an attendant switching two valves'; early Newcomen valves 'were operated manually by the plug man'; then the plug tree let the beam open and close its own valves (before 1715). The same arc again with the governor (speed - English language: a West Germanic language of the Indo-European family, from its Old English beginnings to its varieties and its use as a global lingua franca, as linguistics and its history describe it
The job of official writing in England was done by French (and Latin) after 1066, then held by English from about 1430 (Chancery); Norse and French words first borrowed are now core words held as English (they, give, egg). - Firewall (computing)
Hosts first got protection from the network's boundary (restricted topology and controlled entry points); host-based, personal and distributed firewalls then held it on each host, which protects machines off any topological boundary. - Firm (the economic unit)
A transaction first supplied by the market (simple market contracting for generic assets) is taken inside and held by hierarchy as asset specificity builds; both phases are named in Williamson's statement. - Fishery
For centuries the gear itself limited the catch (local fishers' technology limited the volume and the area fished); from the 1950s trawlers with radar and sonar removed that limit, and the limit then had to be held by the fishery's own rules (catch limits, moratoria, TACs). Borrowed phase: the limit - Formal security policy model
Controls first held outside the computer by people and law, then held inside it: accounting's double entry and separation of duty ('derived long before computer systems came into existence') became Clark-Wilson's enforcement rules; the Stock Exchange's Chinese Walls, kept manually, became a mandator - Function (mathematics): the assignment of exactly one output to each input, and the practice of defining, drawing, composing and using it
Borrowed phase: the function concept arose as the tool for the quantitative study of nature, and what counted as a function was set by physical problems and their regularity (falling bodies, planets, the vibrating string, heat flow). Held phase: the concept 'began evolving on its own, moving away fr - Gastrulation (the embryo's cell sheet folds and moves into two or three germ layers)
Control of development borrowed from the mother's stored mRNA, then held by the embryo's own DNA at the midblastula transition, before gastrulation runs on the embryo's own genes - Geologic time scale (deep time)
The chart was produced by others (the GTS books, 1982-2012, 'in close association with the ICS' but without its oversight) and since 2013 is produced by the ICS itself; numerical dating likewise was borrowed from physics (Rutherford 1906, Boltwood 1907) and is held as geochronology. - Historiography
Source criticism was first done for history by philology (the Göttingen philological seminar, attended by many history students); then held inside history as its own standard method (Ranke 1824) and its own rule books (Bernheim 1889; Langlois & Seignobos 1898). Both phases shown. - History of science (the field and the story it tells)
The job of writing science's past was first done by scientists themselves (18th-century scientist-historians; practitioner histories), then held inside a profession of its own: Isis 1913, the History of Science Society 1924, the first US PhD 1947, departments by the 1970s. Both phases shown. - Honeybee (western honey bee, Apis mellifera)
The dance's direction reference: open-nesting dwarf bees dance under the sky pointing straight at the goal (the reference borrowed from the sky); cavity-nesting bees hold it inside the dark hive as an angle to gravity, corrected for the sun's movement by an inner clock - Human (Homo sapiens)
Fire was first borrowed from lightning: "the earliest human fires were probably embers from lightning-ignited wildfires, carried back to a cave", then tended and transported, and from ~400,000 years ago struck on demand with flint and pyrite. - Incident response
Both phases shown: after the 1988 worm one centre, the CERT/CC, answered for the whole Internet; as the network grew 'a single CSIRT is unable to effectively serve such a vast constituency', and hundreds of organisations formed their own teams. Inside an organisation the same move runs from outsourc - Inflation (economics)
Price stability first borrowed from outside (the gold supply set long-run inflation; under a peg the anchor country's inflation sets the domestic rate) and then held inside by a domestic rule: New Zealand's 1990 target, followed by 45 countries. - Internet
Congestion regulation was first supplied by the ARPANET's subnet ('the ability of the IMP system to throttle the transmissions of hosts', with 'substantial excess capacity'); once dissimilar networks were joined it failed (1986 collapses) and was taken into the hosts' own TCP (Jacobson's seven algor - Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
Reliability first supplied by the surrounding network, then held by the ends: 'instead of the network being responsible for reliability, as in the existing ARPANET protocols, this function was delegated to the hosts'. ARPANET IMPs had held each packet 'until it gets a positive acknowledgment from th - Islamic art
glass first supplied from the eastern Mediterranean (borrowed), then, after a rupture in supply, made locally from Cordoba's lead slag and refined (held); likewise Silk Road cities moved from imported raw glass to their own primary production - Laboratory dynamo (liquid-sodium dynamo experiments)
The field is first lent from outside, then held by the flow: at Riga an applied field was amplified up to 25 times, then 'the external field was switched off. This allowed the observation of a pure eigenstate'. VKS starts from the Earth's field and the disks' remanence. Same shape across domains: an - Lexicon: the stock of words and word parts of a language, and as each person holds it (the mental lexicon), as linguistics and psychology describe it
Words are first supplied by the speech around the learner (its hubs learned first) and then held in the learner's own lexicon; at the community scale a donor language supplies a word that is then assimilated and held as the recipient's own (guestword, then foreignism, then loanword: 'totally assimil - Literacy
Phoneme awareness and letter-sound mappings are first supplied from outside (reading instruction is necessary for phoneme awareness; phonics taught explicitly) and then held: the child reads independently and self-teaches further spelling regularities; the enhanced skills cannot be switched back. - LLM-based agent
Instructions first written by the developer (system prompts as 'text from an application developer') are later written by the agent itself (ACE optimises system prompts offline; Voyager writes its own skills). Both phases shown. - Lyric poetry
rhythm-keeping first done by the tune (meter 'required for song lyrics in order to match lyrics with interchangeable tunes'), then held by the words alone: 'the rhythmic forms have persisted without the music'; the ode likewise went from performed with music to 'personal lyrical compositions whether - Machine
Regulation first supplied by the people around the machine, then held inside it: mechanization relieves the muscles while operators still do the sensing and judging; automation 'greatly decreases the need for human sensory and mental requirements as well'. The governor (Huygens on mills, Watt 1788) - Mammal (class Mammalia)
Body heat: ectotherms borrow it ('by basking in the sun, the lizard absorbs solar heat'); endothermy, 'the ability to generate heat internally rather than via behaviors such as basking', made early mammals 'independent of solar radiation'. - Mathematics (the field: the practice and the structures it studies)
The problems were first supplied by the surroundings (counting, surveying, astronomy) and then held inside: 'both subjects quickly stood on their own'; in the 19th century Weierstrass and Dedekind 'increasingly focused their research on internal problems'. - Measurement (the practice of comparing a quantity with a unit, and the units and standards it uses)
Units first borrowed from the surroundings (a grain of wheat, the human body, the mean solar day), later held by the practice's own definitions fixed to constants (2019). - Money of account (the unit of account: number applied to exchange)
The unit was first borrowed from a commodity's weight (the shekel 'first a unit of weight'; 'a fixed quantity of barley'; coins stamped to certify metal) and later held by convention alone: the livre tournois ran 'whether or not livre coins were minted', the euro was 'just a unit of account' 1999-20 - Nervous system
The circadian clock is 'influenced by light but continues to operate even when light levels are held constant': an outside rhythm whose timekeeping is now held inside by a genetic clock shared by insects and vertebrates. - Nonverbal communication
Waggle dance: the correct dance is first borrowed from others (bees that followed dances danced correctly first time) and then held for life (distance encoding set for life); in humans, cues learned from the community become one's own - Numeracy
Number talk and formal home teaching by parents, and schooling, supply the counting the child later holds; adults then keep the skill only by using it. - Nursing (the field: the practice and the care it gives)
Henderson's definition is the shape run on the patient: activities the person holds for themselves (hygiene, eating, moving) are lent out to the nurse while strength, will or knowledge are lacking (borrowed), and handed back 'to help gain independence as rapidly as possible' (held again). Both phase - Open-source software
Linux began by reusing Minix's code and ideas (borrowed) and 'Eventually all the Minix code went away or was completely rewritten' (held); OpenSSL used SSLeay as its blueprint. More widely: the 1950s-60s sharing culture (a norm of the surroundings) was later held inside each work by its licence. - Operating system
Borrowed: transistor mainframes still needed professional operators 'who manually do what a modern operating system would do, such as scheduling programs to run'. Held: time-sharing and multiprogramming OSes schedule inside the machine ('Time-sharing operating systems schedule tasks for efficient us - Phonology: how languages organise the meaningless units their words are built from (phonemes in spoken languages; handshape, location and movement in signed ones), together with the field of linguistics that studies those systems
The contrast structure is first supplied from outside (the distribution of sounds in live caregivers' speech, gated by a social partner) and then held by the child as native categories that last for life. - Photography
Light was first borrowed from the sun (minutes-long street exposures; 'the subject must be illuminated'), then held by the practice itself: flash powder (1887), flash bulbs (1927-1930), studio light. Exposure judgement was first the photographer's (and the lab's: 'we do the rest'), then held inside - Placenta (eutherian, chorioallantoic)
The mother's spiral arteries are taken over by fetal cells: extravillous trophoblasts 'replace the endothelial cells in the uterine spiral arteries as they remodel these vessels into wide bore conduits that are independent of maternal vasoconstriction'. Progesterone: borrowed from the corpus luteum, - Planet
Atmosphere: protoplanets were 'stripped of their early atmospheres' of nebular gas (borrowed from the disk) and the lost gas was replaced 'by outgassing from the mantle' (held from inside), with comets adding more. - Police
Policing first borrowed from the surroundings, then held inside a body. Borrowed: every citizen 'entitled and obliged to join the pursuit'; tithings raising the hue and cry; private watchmen and reward-paid thief-takers. Held: constables became 'the first "police" official to be tax-supported'; the - Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
Experiments and game theory: borrowed (Gosnell's 1924 trial against Lowell's 1909 'impossibility of experiment'; Riker's Rochester school borrowing economics' formal methods), then held by the field's own sections and journal (APSA's Experimental Research section 2010, its journal 2014). - Positional (place-value) notation with zero
The empty place was first done by the surroundings, then by the rule's own sign: a space on the Babylonian tablet, a blank on the rod board, 'the absence of a knot' on the quipu; then three hooks at Kish (as early as 700 BC), two wedges by 300 BC, the Indian dot and circle; and only later zero as a - Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on)
Cicada timing: ancestors (and almost all cicadas) mature at a size reached at a rate set by their surroundings (root water, temperature); Magicicada hold the timing themselves and emerge after exactly 13 or 17 years whatever their size. Both phases sourced (Ito et al. 2015); the prime cycle is selec - Programming language
Bootstrapping: the first compiler is built in another language (or tested inside an existing interpreter: Hart and Levin, LISP, 1962), then the language compiles itself. Both phases shown. Thompson's escape '\v' is the same at small scale: first given as decimal 11 from outside, then held by the com - Proton-proton chain
The chain's second step first runs on deuterium the Big Bang left: in protostars 'deuterium is the most easily fused nucleus available' and fusion 'can also proceed from primordial deuterium'; once that supply is gone ('after a few million years'), the main-sequence chain makes its own deuterons thr - Public-key cryptography
Borrowed: key distribution was done by the surroundings, 'by sending the key in advance over some secure channel such as private courier or registered mail'. Held: the system does it itself; 'A public-key cryptosystem needs no private couriers; the keys can be distributed over the insecure communica - Real number (the practice of measuring the continuum, and the complete ordered field)
Continuity was first borrowed from geometry: calculus proofs appealed to geometric evidence (Dedekind 1858). Then it was held in arithmetic itself: the cut principle on the rationals, and by 1900 a real number cut loose from measurement (Hilbert's axioms). Both phases are shown. - Redox
Borrowed: native iron in serpentinizing vents reduces ferredoxin with H2 'without the help of enzymes', and metal minerals can replace the 127 proteins of the acetyl-CoA pathway in vitro. Held: cells do the same job with flavin-based electron bifurcation. Both phases shown, as the authors' origin re - Reinsurance
German fire insurers first covered surplus by coinsurance and facultative reinsurance with other direct writers; after 1842 they founded subsidiaries that 'operated only with the parent companies', holding the job in-house; today a significant share of reinsurance is affiliated (non-affiliated cessi - Religion
Religious concepts first ride on mechanisms "functional outside of the context of religion" (agent detection, theory of mind: a spandrel or exaptation, Gould), then cultural traditions "have recruited such beliefs to motivate prosocial behaviour" (dual inheritance). - Reproductive system (human, as physiology describes it)
From the pregnancy's side: progesterone is first supplied by the mother's corpus luteum (borrowed, kept going by hCG), then 'the placenta eventually takes over progesterone production and the corpus luteum degrades into a corpus albicans without embryo loss'. Both phases shown. - School
Teaching first borrowed a host's space and was later held in its own: 'schooling at first was in the mosques ... but then schools later became separate institutions next to mosques'; by the 9th century 'a school that was built independently from the mosque'. Both phases shown. - Silk Road
Silk first bought through middlemen, then made at home: Byzantium smuggled silkworm eggs and won a European silk monopoly. In the highlands, the paths were first laid by herders' seasonal flows (borrowed), later held by states' garrisons and protectorates. - Social norm
Regulation first supplied by the surroundings (sanctions, external obligations), later held inside the person: 'Individuals internalize these persistent social pressures from external forces to internal preferences'; internalized norms are then followed 'even when others around them do not'. Both ph - Socialization
Regulation first supplied from outside, then held inside: the pre-conventional child's moral decisions reflect pain and pleasure (outside consequences); at the conventional stage society's conventions are accepted 'even when there are no consequences'; newcomers 'internalize and obey' - Software
Thompson's compiler: the meaning of '\v' is first supplied from outside (an ASCII chart: decimal 11) and written into the source; once compiled, the binary 'knows' it and the source can use the self-referencing definition: 'You simply tell it once, then you can use this self-referencing definition.' - Star cluster (open and globular)
Binding first lent by the natal gas, later held by the stars alone: clusters are 'born embedded within giant molecular clouds' and gas expulsion 'places the remaining stellar population in a super-virial state'; only 'the densest parts of the hierarchy ... remain bound after gas removal'. Both phase - Steel
Two jobs moved inside. Heat: earlier furnaces supplied the heat from burning fuel; in the Bessemer blow the melt makes its own heat by burning its carbon, 'a temperature hitherto unattainable in our largest furnaces'. Rust protection: borrowed from a zinc coat (galvanizing) or from concrete's alkali - Superconductivity
a magnet's current is first driven by an outside power supply (borrowed); once energised, a superconducting persistent switch closes the winding into a loop, the supply is turned off, and the loop holds the current and field itself for months (held). The same move at the cooling: bath-cooled MRI bor - Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
Pressure-quench: the anvil's pressure makes the higher-Tc phase (Tc 158 K under 18.9 GPa), and after release at 4.2 K the material holds it as a metastable phase at ambient pressure (151 K on warming): 'stabilizing at ambient pressure the high-pressure–induced/–enhanced metastable phases' (Deng et a - Surveillance
Agencies first borrow companies' data (AT&T's call records, requested without a warrant), then hold it: the FBI stores all information received in its own databases; fusion centres consolidate state, hospital, school and bank records in a central database. - Synapse
The PSD scaffold backbone 'emerged in a unicellular context', probably linking Ca2+ signalling to the actin cytoskeleton and not cell-cell communication, and 'later became integrated into the evolving synapse' by added receptors and adhesion molecules. - Tax
Collection first borrowed from private tax farmers: Rome auctioned the right to collect, and the publicani paid in advance and kept what they collected; then held by the state: Augustus replaced it with a direct tax and a regular census. - Teacher
Learning to teach: the regulation of practice is first supplied by others (children learn to teach in teaching interactions with socialising agents; student teachers train under an accredited, experienced practitioner and induction mentors) and then held (the 'fully responsible teacher') - Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers)
The base of the web was first supplied by geochemistry, then made by life itself: the earliest mats 'relied on hydrothermal vents to supply both energy and chemical "food"'; photosynthesis let them spread on sunlight, and after oxygenic photosynthesis 'life itself would have produced significantly m - Turing machine: the abstract machine that reads and writes one symbol at a time on an unbounded tape by a finite table of rules, the model of computation of logic and computer science
Turing's choice machine waits for an external operator to settle ambiguous configurations (borrowed); his automatic machine instead runs through the choices itself, 'proof 1, proof 2, proof 3' (held). Both phases in the 1936 paper. - V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule)
Repair first, then diversity: the breaks are joined by the ubiquitous NHEJ pathway whose components are 'found in other cell types and even ubiquitously', and its inaccuracy is kept because 'error-prone repair in V(D)J recombination is beneficial in that it maximizes diversity'. - Vertebrate (Vertebrata)
Neural crest: a bilaterian lateral-border programme and generic EMT machinery 'served as a gene regulatory scaffold', then multipotency was held by retaining part of the blastula pluripotency state (heterochronic shift). - Wetland
Water and minerals first borrowed from the landscape, then held by the wetland itself. A lake or marshy flat is fed by ground and surface water; peat builds until that water cannot reach the centre, which becomes wholly rain-fed and acidic, a bog whose peat dome holds its own water ('As it accumulat - Word: the unit of a language's lexicon (spoken, signed or written) as linguists describe it, and as it is held, learned and retrieved in each speaker's mental lexicon
A word is first supplied from outside, named by others in daily life (infants know common nouns from 6 months; gifted dogs learn names in play), then held in the learner's own lexicon and retrieved without the outside cue; held only after consolidation in sleep. - World population (human population)
Regulation of numbers moved from the surroundings to the population itself. Borrowed: in Stage 1, births and deaths fluctuate with 'natural events, such as drought and disease' and Malthus's positive checks (hunger, disease, war) hold numbers. Held: after the transition, births are set by desired fa
Partial: part of the shape (248)
- Accounting (the field and practice)
Checking first done by a listener outside the books (oral audits; auditors who 'hear the accounts read out'), later held in the books' own structure: Pacioli's method 'enabled merchants to audit their own books'; double entry's 'partial check'. - Acid-base reaction
In Sojo et al.'s model LUCA ran on natural (geochemically sustained) proton gradients through leaky membranes (borrowed); ion pumps and ion-tight phospholipid membranes 'arose later and independently in separate populations' (held). Today parietal cells and every cell pump their own proton gradients - Action potential (nerve impulse, spike)
The spike's Ca2+ arc began as an 'emergency response' to Ca2+ flooding in through a ruptured membrane (an outside-made hole), later run by gated channels as a sensory-effector arc (Brunet & Arendt, abstract); and plant/animal excitability first served osmotic regulation 'under changing salinity cond - Affine connection
Named from flat space, where tangent spaces are identified 'by translation'; the connection then lets any manifold 'look infinitesimally like Euclidean space ... as an affine space', a rule held on the manifold itself. - Air pollution
The emitters first borrowed the air's dilution (tall stacks, Best Practical Means), then held control in their own plants (flue-gas desulfurisation from Drax 1988, catalysts); both phases shown, but the regulation belongs to the economy and government, not to the pollution. - Algebra (the practice of solving for unknowns and transforming expressions, and the structures it works with)
Maruyama et al. 2012: mathematical syntax, 'although arising historically from language competence, becomes "compiled" into visuo-spatial areas in well-trained mathematics students'. Both phases are named (borrowed from language, held in visual-parietal circuits), but the borrowed phase is historica - Algebraic (local) quantum field theory in curved spacetime (walked as a projected model)
Flat space borrows its covariance from the Poincare group; on curved backgrounds the theory holds it itself as local covariance (natural transformations). - American literature
literary standards first supplied from outside (British models imitated; London presses printing New England authors), later held inside (American critics, styles, prizes, the academy); both phases named, the hand-over traced only in outline - Ancient Greek philosophy
Borrowed then held, twice: the Greeks borrowed ideas from Near-Eastern cosmology ('many suggestive ideas') and then 'taught themselves to reason' (contested); falsafa borrowed the Greek corpus and then held works the Greek world lost. - Anthropocene
Holocene stability was supplied by the Earth System's own negative feedbacks (carbon uptake by land and ocean), now 'weakening relative to human forcing'; one regulation is now held by people (ozone, by agreements cutting CFCs), and a held Stabilized Earth 'is not likely to exist ... without human s - Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
The signal ends: first the transposon's own terminal inverted repeats ('resembling V(D)J recombination signal sequences', ProtoRAG), later the loci's own RSS beside every segment, with a nonamer that came later ('indicating the nonamer's more recent evolution'). Both phases shown, but what was borro - Aqueous solution
Life's first aqueous environment is the open solution (pond, vent fluid); cells later hold their own solution behind a membrane and correct its volume with osmolytes ('restoring normal cell volume'). - Archaeon (Archaea)
The lipid divide as one reading: a chemically derived heterochiral membrane, then chiral enzymes holding one hand in each domain (contested, C-2538). The reverse case is booked too: Nanoarchaeum equitans borrows its membrane lipids from its host and never holds their synthesis. - Architecture
Comfort first borrowed from outdoor air and the building's mass (natural ventilation drawn by the building form; air cooled by courtyard water), later held by mechanical systems against a set-point. - Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
Argumentative skill supplied first by dialogue with partners is then held by the individual: electronic dialogues transferred to individual essays on new topics; children's group answers transferred to individual transfer problems. - Aristotle
The school: a metic who could not own land, he rented the Lyceum building (borrowed); Theophrastus later bought land and buildings by the gymnasium (held). In his ethics too: virtue first habituated by teachers (supplied from outside), then chosen by the person (held). Both phases are shown in each. - Art history (the field)
Borrowed: early writing about art was done by makers themselves (Xenokrates, a sculptor; Chinese canon-makers 'were artists themselves'; Vasari, a painter). Held: from the 19th century an academic discipline of its own; technical study likewise moved from conservation labs ('an auxiliary science') t - Attention
Regulation first supplied from outside, then held inside: developmental psychology names self-regulation in contrast to 'the regulation that occurs through the caregiver or other external sources'; executive attention develops between infancy and childhood, infants relying on orienting. - Biology (the field)
Methods borrowed then held: Weaver's grants applied physics and chemistry methods to biological problems (1938), and the borrowed methods became molecular biology, a discipline of its own by the 1960s; physiological chemistry, using chemistry's chromatography and electrophoresis, became biochemistry - Bird song culture
A song ending borrowed from western neighbours on wintering grounds becomes the region's own: the doublet rose from a rare variant to the sole regional song type - Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
Selection first comes from outside (einselection 'imposed on the quantum system through its continuous interactions with the environment'; the RNA strand scored by its surroundings), later held inside a body: self-reactive lymphocytes 'are destroyed at an early stage', before any outside test. - Blood
Iron is borrowed from food (1-2 mg a day) but held and recycled (20-25 mg a day) by the body; EPO is made by the liver in the embryo and the kidney in the adult (a move, not a borrowing). - Bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops)
A calf's identity whistle: first borrowed (copied from whistles it hears), then changed and held as its own, stable for life - Brand
Quality assurance was first imposed from outside: compulsory guild and statutory marks (England's 1266 bread law) to trace defective goods and punish makers; later held by the brand itself, whose value depends on consistent quality (Landes and Posner's self-enforcing feature), with the 17th-century - Bureaucracy
Administration once done by the nobility around the ruler is taken into dedicated offices: Qin 'assigned administration to dedicated officials rather than nobility, ending feudalism in China'. Both phases named, the borrowing only in one clause. - Business
Coordination first done for the firm by the price mechanism, then held inside it by direction: firms form 'when the transaction cost of coordinating production through the market exchange ... is greater than within the firm'. Historically: Chandler's railway-era distribution was first done by outsid - Calcium atom
Seawater calcium (calcite and aragonite seas set by ridge Mg/Ca) is the outside chemistry shell-builders first used; bodies later hold their own calcium pool within narrow limits (plasma 1.3-1.5 mmol/L, skeleton 99% of body calcium, read by PTH and calcitonin). - Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers)
Precambrian organisms used the same elements as later skeletons 'for a different purpose, perhaps to avoid the inadvertent precipitation of calcium carbonate from the supersaturated Proterozoic oceans'; a magnetite pathway of the bilaterian ancestor may have been 'duplicated and modified in the Camb - Carbon dioxide (CO2)
CO2 reduction first happens across vent mineral walls 'if driven by an applied voltage' (hydrothermal-vent walk), then inside cells by CODH/acetyl-CoA synthase in the Wood-Ljungdahl pathway (LUCA walk); the CO2 article names CODH as the catalyst of the 'difficult and slow' CO2-to-CO step. - Chemical kinetics
Rate borrowed from the surroundings, then held: 'In the warm surroundings in which life first appeared, ... elevated temperatures would have reduced the kinetic barriers to reaction' (o66); as the world cooled, an enzyme that lowers the enthalpy of activation gained rate enhancement 'automatically' - Chemical reaction
Catalysis first borrowed from the surroundings (native metals, small cofactors in the food set) and later held by enzymes the network makes itself; the source's premise is 'reactions catalysed by simple molecules and inorganic compounds preceded metabolic reactions catalysed by enzymes', and its RAF - Chemistry (the field: the practice of chemists and the structure of substances and their reactions it works on)
Substances were first taken from what nature made (chemicals extracted from plants for medicine and perfume, metals from ores); synthesis then made compounds itself, from the early 19th century and by 1900 as the established tool. - Circulatory system
The channel's wall: at first 'Blood probably percolated through spaces in the extracellular matrix' and 'Invertebrate vessels are always lined by extracellular matrix'; later the vessels hold their own lining: 'The endothelium evolved in an ancestral vertebrate some 540–510 million years ago'. - City
Water was first supplied by the site (cities placed near coasts and rivers; half of humanity within 3 km of fresh water), later held by the city's own pumps, pipes and canals that bring it from far away. - Classroom
Bell borrowed the pupil-teacher system and writing in sand from the Madras Pial schools and held it as the Bell system ('The school teaches itself'), adopted at the Royal Military School - Cloud computing
Power: data centres draw on the grid (borrowed) and increasingly hold supply on site, 'behind-the-meter generation and storage within a single facility', or contract their own plant (Three Mile Island). The held phase is partial: sites stay grid-tied. Read from the tenants' side the cloud is the rev - CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle)
In most stars the catalysts are borrowed from earlier generations (the gas is pre-enriched); in metal-free first stars the star makes them itself: 'pregalactic stars activate sooner the triple alpha reaction self-producing their own heavy elements'. - Combinatorics: the practice of counting, arranging and choosing finite structures (permutations, combinations, partitions, designs, graphs), the structures it studies, and the people and machines who work with them
Problems and their solutions were first supplied by other parts of mathematics, solved ad hoc 'in isolation'; later the field held its own general methods and became 'an independent branch'. - Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it
Contested both ways (C-2476): one view has interpersonal communication first, used by parents to regulate the child, who then applies the same technique to itself (borrowed, then held); the other has egocentric speech first. In turn-taking, mothers adjust formats to infants and marmoset parents' con - Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA)
Every DNA chain starts on a borrowed RNA primer ('DNA polymerases in general cannot initiate synthesis of new strands'), later removed and 'replaced with DNA'. Both phases are shown, at every replication. - Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin)
Organic carbon first borrowed from the surroundings (the soup; heterotrophic first life) and later made inside (autotrophs, 'evolutionary pressure to become autotrophic'), then held inside again by engulfing autotrophs. - Computer memory
Error correction first done outside the chip (ECC in server memory systems), then held inside: since sub-20 nm DRAM 'the introduction of in-DRAM ECC'. Both phases shown, but the borrowed phase is a partner's (the memory system and controller), not the surroundings'. - Computer science (the field: the practice and the computation it studies)
Borrowed: early computer science was shaped by mathematicians and run inside mathematics or engineering settings; 'computer' first named people. Held: own degree programs (1953) and departments (1962), though departments still lean mathematical or engineering. - Contract
Enforcement first supplied from outside the agreement (courts, the state) and then held inside it: Szabo's smart contracts embed collateral and bonding in hardware and software so that the contract enforces itself ('a program enforces the contract built into the code'). Both phases are shown, but as - Corporate law
Borrowed: corporate status granted one charter at a time by the Crown, with a 'lively trade in the charters of defunct companies' and investors trading in unincorporated associations around the Bubble Act. Held: general incorporation by registration (1844), limited liability by statute (1855), avail - Corpus Juris Civilis (Justinian's codification: Codex, Digest, Institutes, Novels)
Law first made outside the state by private jurists, then held by it: the fragments 'were just private opinions of legal scholars ... The Digest, however, was given full force of law'; two-thirds of the Institutes is Gaius verbatim. - Covalent bond
Removing water to make a backbone bond: first borrowed from the setting (wet-dry cycles 'promote the formation of peptide bonds'; drying shifts the landscape toward condensation), later held by the cell with ATP, ribosomes and the PPi ratchet. Both phases are sourced; the borrowed phase is a laborat - Covariant derivative
For a manifold embedded in Euclidean space the covariant derivative is 'the orthogonal projection of the Euclidean directional derivative onto the manifold's tangent space'; later 'a covariant derivative could be defined abstractly without the presence of a metric', held by the manifold's own connec - Cryptographic hash function
Timestamping first borrowed publication from newspapers and Usenet ('widely publishing the hash, such as in a newspaper'); Bitcoin holds the same job inside its own proof-of-work hash chain 'rather than newspaper or Usenet posts'. Both phases shown, in the timestamp service that runs on the hash. - Crystal
For a mineral crystal the surroundings set its polymorph, habit and the pH it grows in; in otoliths the organism holds them: Otopetrin1 keeps the milieu alkaline and Starmaker picks aragonite (calcite forms without it). Within conodonts, early paraconodonts had poorly mineralised, organic-rich tissu - Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
'Once culture became adaptive, genetic selection caused a refinement of the cognitive architecture that stores and transmits cultural information': a job first done socially is later partly held in the genome. - Curriculum
Borrowed phase: Northwest Territories and Nunavut use Alberta's curriculum and tests; Australia's states each set curricula before one national curriculum (2014) - Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota)
Cloud's hypothesis: the first cyanobacteria 'would have been protected from their own poisonous oxygen waste through its rapid removal via the high levels of reduced ferrous iron' (borrowed: the ocean's iron did the oxygen-clearing), until they 'evolved enzymes (such as superoxide dismutase) for liv - Cyber threat intelligence
The method was borrowed from military and government intelligence (and its people moved to vendors), then held by an industry 'in its own right' after 2013. - Cyberwarfare
States borrowed capacity from patriotic hackers and the private sector (2008 'nationalist hackers'; 'harvesting the talents of its private sector') and then held it in standing cyber commands (US, France's fourth corps 2013, many others). Both phases shown across states, not traced within one state - Data centre
Power borrowed from the grid, then partly held: UPS and generators bridge gaps; some AI campuses run their own off-grid gas plants. Cooling borrowed from outside air in mild hours, held by compressors in hot-humid ones. - Desert ant (Cataglyphis)
The geostable magnetic field gives the reference on the first learning walks (borrowed); the learned solar ephemeris and views are then held inside and used for foraging (held) - DGP gravity (Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati braneworld; walked as a projected model)
Brane matter's loop corrections can generate the brane's own four-dimensional curvature term ('it may be generated on a brane by quantum corrections'): gravity first carried by the bulk, then held on the brane at short distances. - Digital identity
Identity first borrowed from paper documents and states (validated online against licences and passports), then held as digital credentials in a personal wallet; both phases named, the handover not dated. - Dissolved ferrous iron (Fe2+, notably in the early ocean)
Cloud: early oxygen producers 'had not yet evolved enzymes (such as superoxide dismutase)' and were protected by the ocean's ferrous reservoir, which removed their oxygen waste; later the cells held antioxidant enzymes themselves. Both phases are in the sources; the timing part of the hypothesis is - Domestic dog (Canis familiaris)
Reading human gestures: in wolves it can be learned with intensive human rearing (supplied from outside by upbringing); in dog puppies it is there on the first trial without training (held). Borrowed phase is shown in modern wolves, the sister lineage, not in the ancestral population itself - Domesticated germline (crop and livestock lines held and propagated by people)
Reversed: the plant once held its own dispersal and dormancy ('Wild wheat shatters and falls to the ground to reseed itself'); domestication gave both to the keeper ('relies on farmers for its reproduction and dissemination'; 'less seed dormancy'), and storage moved to granaries and then genebanks a - Doplicher-Fredenhagen-Roberts quantum spacetime
A limit first set from outside by gravity (collapse forbids sharp localisation) and then built into the algebra itself: 'the impossibility of giving an operational meaning to spacetime in the small is incorporated in the mathematical structure of the model'. - Drama (the literary form)
the chorus and its leader came from non-dramatic poetry (dithyramb); the speaking, impersonating actor was drama's own addition; Rome first took Greek originals (palliata, crepidata), then made its own (Octavia, praetexta) - Early childhood education
Care first supplied by private founders' means (Oberlin, Owen's mills, Brunszvik's angel gardens, Froebel's institute) is later held by public law and budgets (St. Louis 1873, Head Start 1965, 43 states, compulsory from three in Hungary) - Earth in the Archean eon
The earliest photosynthesis may have used modified versions of pigments whose original function was to detect infra-red heat emissions from hydrothermal vents; mats first depended on vents for energy, then sunlight let them proliferate away from vents. - Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
Plants went ashore on fungal supply: mycorrhizal fungi 'facilitated early plant colonization ... by releasing mineral nutrients'; later deep-rooted plants and their rhizosphere did the weathering themselves ('deep-rooted vascular plants, on the other hand, had drastic erosional impacts'). - Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma)
Cloud: the first cyanobacteria 'would have been protected from their own poisonous oxygen waste through its rapid removal via the high levels of reduced ferrous iron', until they evolved enzymes (such as superoxide dismutase) for living with oxygen. The source says improved dating made the timing un - Earth's core
The dynamo's seed may have been borrowed: 'For the Earth, this could have been an external magnetic field' (the young Sun's wind, much of it screened by the mantle); the field is then held by the core's own induction. The borrowed phase is a hypothesis (or the seed came from boundary currents), so b - Electrical grid
A microgrid draws on the wide-area grid, then islands and holds its own supply; a power station borrows its own service power from the grid, and in a blackout must hold it locally (black-start diesels). - Electromagnetic radiation
vitamin D first forms by enzyme-free photochemistry, done by UV-B on sterols about 1.2 billion years ago; in animals 'this ancient photochemical by-product was subsequently co-opted into a highly regulated endocrine network' (src:raczyk-carlberg-2026). The making stays borrowed from the light; what - Emotional contagion
Schreckstoff "evolved as a defense against environmental stressors such as pathogens, parasites, and UVB radiation and ... was later co-opted by predators and prey as a chemical signal"; selection for the alarm response is primarily at the level of the receiver. - Engineering design process
Borrowed from other systems: Lean ideas 'developed in manufacturing' applied to development; agile from software proposed for product development. Held: the Toyota Product Development System incorporates Lean and SBCE. Both phases shown only in outline. - English literature
the job of a high literary language in England was done by French and Latin ('the dominant literary languages in England were still French and Latin'), then held by English itself from Chaucer's legitimising of the vernacular onward - Entrepreneurship
Serial founders: skills and patterns first borrowed from employers' industries and parents (Azoulay; 75% of male founders in their father's industry), then held as their own experience across ventures (owners with a prior business exit less). Both phases shown at the person level, not the practice's - Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
Borrowed: the questions were handled inside natural history and medicine (Enlightenment); held: the field's own degrees (1956, 1965), agencies and journals from the 1960s-70s - Epic poetry
the poem's stability is first held by singers' memory and performance, then by the written redaction (Peisistratus' order; Alexandrian editors); Altschuler: the date may be of production or of writing down - EPRL model (Engle-Pereira-Rovelli-Livine spin-foam model; projected model)
The discrete area spectrum is LQG's (canonical) and is held again by the covariant model's own boundary: 'the area operator has the same discrete spectrum as in loop quantum gravity'. - Essay
structure first supplied from outside (set formats; 'learners need the constraints of certain rules', the deficit-model reading) and later held by the writer (knowledge-crafting holds the reader in working memory); both phases named, the hand-over not traced in one writer - Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies)
The source of moral authority first supplied from outside (divine commands, medieval period), later held inside reason itself (Kant: the categorical imperative has its source in practical reason) in the modern secular turn. - Eukaryote
the metabolic partner's work first borrowed by syntrophy (hydrogen/formate passed between cells), later held inside as the organelle (the E3 model: entangle, engulf, endogenize) - Extracellular matrix
Biofilm cells attach to a surface they find (tooth, rock, pipe); animal epithelia rest on a surface they make themselves, the basement membrane, synthesized by cells on either side. - Flux energy condition (FEC)
The light cone's sorting of vectors (spacetime's causal layer) is held here as a rule on energy flux, without the cone's time orientation. - Fourier analysis (the practice of splitting signals into waves and rebuilding them, and the structure it works on)
The integral form was first supplied from outside the practice and then held inside it: Laplace's solution of his probability equation "immediately revealed to Fourier that he could seek integral solutions to the heat equation in addition to the series solutions", and Fourier wrote them into his own - Fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster)
Microbes borrowed from the mother: she coats the eggs with faeces "to establish the same microbial composition in the larvae's guts", and the larva then keeps that community, which promotes its growth - Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls)
The fungal side of paleozoic-earth's sighting: rootless early land plants 'would have been incapable of absorbing recalcitrant ions from mineral substrates, such as phosphate', and mycorrhizal fungi released them (borrowed); later deep roots weathered rock themselves (held, in sys:paleozoic-earth). - Galactic magnetic field
The field starts from a seed made by something else (the first cosmic rays' current, a battery, a primordial field) and is then kept by its own dynamo, regenerated on about the rotation period. - Gender
Regulation of gendered play first supplied by others (peer ridicule, teachers' correction, parents' rules) and later held inside (girls 'internalize these norms'; norms 'nested in the mind'). - Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
Stereochemical model: amino acids first matched codons or anticodons by affinity; 'Later during evolution, this matching was gradually replaced with matching by aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases' (or ribozymes first, then synthetases). - Geology (the field)
Radioactivity was a physicists' discovery (Curie and Laborde showed its heat in 1903); dating by it was borrowed, then held: 'geochemistry (a branch of geology) determines their absolute ages', and Holmes, 'Father of Modern Geochronology', made it geology's own. - Germ theory of disease with Koch's postulates (one microbe, one disease, four tests)
Miasma did the job first for the wrong reason ('motivated improvements in urban hygiene ... thereby in fact reducing the spread of germs'); the germ rule then held the same job with its own reason (Snow's boiling and filtering, Lister's carbolic acid). - Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary)
The method was first done by Scripture teaching and the dialectic of the schools, then held by the law school as its own ('taught along lines firmly established in the teaching of Scripture'). - Government
Administration done first by generalists ('chiefs and subchiefs', coded as no full-time bureaucrats) and leadership that becomes institutional only in some domains, then held by full-time bureaucrats, examination and merit systems once control reaches beyond a day's round trip. - Graph theory: the practice of studying vertices joined by edges (problems, proofs, algorithms, its people and books) and the graphs it works on
The word and early ideas borrowed from chemistry's molecular diagrams (Sylvester 1878, Cayley's trees), then held as graph theory's own standard terminology. A vocabulary, not a regulation. - Grassland
Openness first supplied from outside, then held by the grassland's own fuel: climate (drought, seasonality) and lightning or people set early fires; where grasses build a continuous fuel bed, the grass-fire feedback itself holds trees out, and at intermediate rain 'only fire differentiates between s - Great Acceleration
Borrowed: the Holocene's stable state, kept by the Earth System's own negative feedbacks, was the surroundings' regulation the enterprise grew in. Held (proposed, not shown): a Stabilized Earth 'basin of attraction that is not likely to exist ... without human stewardship to create and maintain it'. - Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event (GOBE)
Carbonate making moved from the environment into animals: 'Unlike Cambrian times, when calcite production was dominated by microbial and non-biological processes, animals (and macroalgae) became a dominant source of calcareous material in Ordovician deposits.' At planet scale: the calcite sea first - Great Oxidation Event (the oxygen crisis and what it released)
Cloud: early cyanobacteria 'had not yet evolved enzymes (such as superoxide dismutase)' and were protected from their own oxygen waste by the ocean's ferrous iron; later the survivors held antioxidants themselves. The environment's iron did the antioxidant job first. The source calls the timing part - Grey parrot (Psittacus erithacus)
The teaching role first supplied by humans (model, rival, corrective feedback) later held by a parrot: Alex acted as model and rival for another bird and corrected its mistakes - Gross domestic product
The first official US estimate was made by the NBER, a private research bureau, under Kuznets (1931-34) for the Department of Commerce; the Department under Milton Gilbert then embedded the work in its own institutions. Borrowed from a private body, then held by the state; the hand-off is inside one - Hawking singularity theorem
Hawking 'borrowed from Riemannian geometry the concept of focal and conjugate points' and their meaning by the variation of length. - Higgs boson
The idea came from a fridge: Anderson (1963) took the superconductor's cure for Goldstone modes (coupling to electromagnetism turns them into plasmons) to particle physics; Higgs (1964) wrote 'the Ginzburg-Landau type Lagrangian' in Lorentz-invariant form, and the scalar left over became the boson p - Human anatomy
Anatomy's knowledge was first borrowed from other animals' bodies (Galen's apes, oxen and pigs; the rete mirabile of ungulates read into humans) and later held from human bodies (Vesalius's human dissection). Both phases are shown, but it is the practice's knowledge, not a regulation, that moves ins - Human physiology
Salt and water were once set by the sea: most species descend from marine ancestors, and salt-water (hydrosaline) regulation is what let reptiles and mammals live on land. Both phases named, the borrowed phase not walked in the source. - Human voice
The voice's targets are borrowed from other voices, then held: the mother's voice is learned in the womb (stronger brain coupling to it at birth), the native language already shapes the cry, and children learn laryngeal voicing contrasts 'by listening only to the voices of adults around them'; once - Humpback whale (Megaptera novaeangliae)
Where to go, first followed and later held: baleen calves spend their first year travelling with their mother, a window for vertical transmission; humpback migratory culture is rated maternally directed and horizontal (Garland 2025, Table 1); whaled-out grounds were lost 'for many decades' with the - Humpback whale song
A song first supplied by a neighbouring population (borrowed in a revolution) becomes the population's own song and then evolves locally as its own lineage, growing more complex - Infinity: the boundless or endless as mathematics and philosophy describe it (potential and actual infinity, Cantor's sizes of infinity, infinity in calculus, geometry, physics and computing) and the practice of the people who argue over it
The meeting of parallel lines was first supplied from outside mathematics, by painters' perspective; later it is held inside geometry as points at infinity defined on their own terms. - Information security
The same move read as regulation: protection first supplied by the surroundings (buildings, guards, the national clearance apparatus: 'adequate standards and techniques exist and are used by the cognizant authority to insure the reliability of those cleared'), later held by the system's own tamper-p - Insect (class Insecta)
Chemical defence borrowed from food: larvae 'obtain their toxicity by sequestering chemicals from the plants they eat'; held: 'Some manufacture their own toxins.' - Institution (social)
New Mexico acequias took inter-community disputes to external territorial courts; those courts' agreements, over 100 years old, are now the basis of the communities' own working water-sharing agreements. - Insurance
Captives: insurance first bought from outside carriers is taken in-house as 'an in-house self-insurance vehicle', against 'heavy and increasing premium costs'. Both phases are named, but the timing for any one parent is not sourced. - Intergalactic magnetic field
Galaxies' fields 'are produced via the amplification of seed magnetic fields', seeds 'which might exist in their initial form in the intergalactic medium': the field a galaxy first takes from intergalactic space is later held by its own dynamo. Both phases named in one source; the borrowed phase is - Interpersonal communication
Turn timing borrowed then held: 8.5-month-olds take their timing from their mothers' latency; alternation becomes stable in the second year and is suggested adult-like by about 6 - Intonation
Pitch meanings start as effects of the body's physics (larynx size, effort, the falling breath) and are then 'brought under control': the speaker makes the effect without the physiology, and grammars turn them into discrete tones. The borrowed phase is the body's, not the surroundings'. - Intrinsic magnetosphere
'A dynamo can amplify a magnetic field, but it needs a "seed" field to get it started. For the Earth, this could have been an external magnetic field' (the T Tauri Sun's wind): a field first supplied from outside, then held by the body's own dynamo. - Intrusion detection system
Spotting intruders was first done by the people around the machine ('discovered by security officers or other users ... who have noticed the alleged user behaving strangely'; audit trails handed weekly or monthly to people to review), then held inside it by real-time detection; the borrowed form nev - Iron atom
Iron-sulfur chemistry on mineral surfaces (the iron-sulfur world hypothesis: 'early life may have formed on the surface of iron sulfide minerals') is later held inside proteins: Fe-S clusters 'are found in all forms of life' and 'the last universal common ancestor had many iron-sulfur clusters'. Fro - Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata)
Feeding borrowed from the mother (milk, carried for over a year) then held: independent foraging from seven weeks, weaning by eighteen months - Kinship
Kin sorting first supplied by the surroundings, later held by the system: in 'viscous populations' kin cooperate without active discrimination because neighbours share origin; species with held kin recognition (kinship index, phenotype matching, scent, faces) do the sorting themselves. - Lanthanides (the 4f series, La-Lu; as an opacity source in kilonovae)
Lanthanide use 'like that of iron, may have evolved in an environment in which lanthanides were more soluble and bioavailable than currently', and is now held by secreted lanthanophores and selective uptake. - Large language model
Knowledge first held by the written record (the corpus), then held in the weights ('store factual knowledge in their parameters'); retrieval and tools later lend part of the job back to the outside (the reverse case). - Learning a second language (second-language acquisition)
Sociocultural theory: what the learner can do first with more advanced users (the zone of proximal development) is later internalised as their own L2 knowledge. - Levi-Civita connection
Levi-Civita first took the derivative from an ambient Euclidean space ('He interpreted the intrinsic derivative in the case of an embedded surface as the tangential component of the usual derivative in the ambient affine space'); the notions then 'make sense on an abstract Riemannian manifold', held - Limit (mathematics): the value a sequence or function approaches, and the practice of approaching, bounding and proving it
Borrowed phase: the limit first leaned on motion and figure from outside arithmetic (polygons filling a circle, Newton's and d'Alembert's kinetic notion, vanishing quantities). Held phase: the epsilon-delta definition states it in inequalities alone (Weierstrass 1861; "the canonical history" of arit - Linguistics (the field: the practice and the languages it studies)
Borrowed: phylogenetic comparative methods 'from computational biology'. Held: typology now builds its own global language phylogeny and treats families and isolates alike in its own models. - Local Lorentz invariance
The flat-space Lorentz symmetry of the whole of Minkowski spacetime is held, under gravity, only frame by frame: 'local' means small against tides. - Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
The judging of an argument was first supplied by the audience (preclassical India: how persuasive or authoritative an answer sounded) and later held inside logic as stated conditions for a proper reason (the canonical syllogism, Dignaga's wheel of reasons). - Lymphatic system
Reverse order in birds: lymph propulsion held by the embryo's own lymph hearts, then after hatching borrowed from skeletal-muscle contraction and breathing; in frogs, posterior lymph hearts form in tadpoles and regress. Booked as the reverse case. - Magnesium atom
Mg2+ is 'highly bioavailable in the hydrosphere' (ocean ion inventory) and then held inside every cell at a buffered free concentration, with transport proteins and storage compartments; in plants it is moved from older to growing tissue. - Management
Borrowed: consultants diagnosed and implemented 38 practices for five months. Held: firms spread them to their own other plants. Partial because some treated plants later lost practices when plant managers left. - Materials science (the field)
Reduction of metal first done by geology, later held in the furnace: cold metallurgy with native copper (7th-6th millennia BCE, Anatolia and Iraq) came before smelting (late sixth millennium, Balkans) (Metallurgy encyclopedia page); the Mehrgarh amulet's 'very pure copper, possibly native copper' (T - Mathematical logic: the field that studies logic within mathematics (model theory, proof theory, set theory, computability theory) and the formal systems, structures and limit results it works on
Consistency borrowed from an outside model (a sphere for elliptic geometry), then held inside by proof theory; the hold is only partial, since Gentzen's proof had to borrow transfinite induction from outside finitary means. - Mathematical proof: the practice of showing that a statement follows from axioms and earlier theorems, how it is written, checked (by people and machines) and accepted, and the derivations it works on
Demonstration probably arose in land measurement (the surroundings) and was later held by the axiomatic method inside mathematics; the borrowed phase is given only as 'likely'. - Matrix (mathematics): the rectangular array of numbers and its algebra, determinants and eigenvalues, matrices as linear maps, their history, and their use in physics, graphics and machine learning; the practice and the structure both booked
An array's meaning was first supplied by the equations around it (arrays used almost only for determinants and systems), then held by the matrix itself once Cayley defined its operations independent of equation systems. - Matter bounce (nonsingular bouncing cosmology with matter-dominated contraction)
The 2012 build borrows the ekpyrotic contraction (from the ekpyrotic universe) to hold isotropy that a plain matter bounce cannot. - Maxwell's equations (classical electromagnetism as a codified law set)
The rule first leaned on an assumed outside medium for its constant speed ('only valid in inertial frames fixed in an aether'); after 1905 it held c by its own symmetry ('Lorentz invariance as a hidden symmetry'), and the aether was discarded. - Mechanical engineering (the field)
The centrifugal governor was borrowed: Watt adopted it 'after Watt's partner Boulton saw one on the equipment of a flour mill'; held, it regulates the admission of steam inside the engine. At field scale, engineering science was borrowed from physics in the 19th century and held as mechanical engine - Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule)
On the transformation origin: bacteria take DNA from the surroundings and recombine it; meiosis pairs two parental genomes held inside one cell, with the same enzyme family (RecA, RAD51, DMC1). - Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell)
Borrowed: 'Iron-sulfur surfaces, which are abundant near hydrothermal vents, can drive the production of small amounts of amino acids and other biomolecules' (no enzymes); held: 'Metal cofactors are bound tightly to specific sites in proteins', and LUCA's pathways ran on enzymes. Both phases shown, - Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)
Computer science borrowed ontology's categories (upper ontologies) and now holds its own principles and automated checks for them (OBO). From metaphysics' side the reverse also shows: cosmology and theology were its subfields and are now held elsewhere. - Metric space
A Riemannian manifold borrows its distance from path lengths of its metric tensor, and the distance then holds the whole geometry: 'all information about a Riemannian manifold can be recovered from its distance function'. - Middle English literature
A written standard first supplied from outside literature (the King's English signet letters from 1417, Chancery clerks) is later held by the literature's own printers (Caxton printing in it; Pynson). Both phases shown, but the source says the Chancery's influence is disputed. - Mineral
Crystal order in a skeleton: in mineral precipitation the order is set by physics and the setting; through conodont evolution the animal holds it ever more tightly ('increasing dental crystallographic order through conodont evolution'). Partial: the held phase is shown rising; a borrowed phase in th - Mineral surfaces (rock and grain surfaces at a planet's surface)
Mineral surfaces 'may have been needed as templates to bring organic molecules together; as catalysts for chemical reactions'; montmorillonite catalyses RNA polymerisation and membrane formation. The borrowed phase is shown (in the laboratory); the held phase (cells doing these jobs themselves) is n - Mitochondrion
From the host's side: aerobic energy first supplied by a separate partner, then held inside as a part whose division the host controls; which phase came first relative to the host's own complexity is debated (mitochondria early or late). - Morphology (linguistics): how a language builds its words from smaller meaningful parts (roots, affixes, compounding, inflection and derivation), how languages differ in this, how speakers learn and use it, and the field that studies it
The plural first comes from outside (pairs like witch:witches heard and memorised), then is held as a pattern the child applies to a word it never heard (wugs). - Motivation
Regulation first supplied from outside (rewards, punishments, a school's rules) is taken in and held as one's own: children internalize school's extrinsic regulations when they feel secure; at the far end, integrated regulation is assimilated into the self (SDT's account). - Museum
Collections first lived in borrowed buildings (temples and their precincts, royal palaces, the Louvre Palace) and then in museums planned and built for them (Dana's planning; Ashmolean's purpose-built building) - Nationalism
Moral education, done by the Church, was taken into the state's laic school by the Ferry Laws (teachers as 'priests of the Republic'); and the rubric of nationalism, borrowed by postcolonial elites from Europe, was then held as their own state's founding narrative. Both phases shown for the school c - Natural environment
Conditions first set by the geosphere and outside forcings, later held through geosphere-biosphere interactions: photosynthesis 'is responsible for the modern Earth's atmospheric composition'. The borrowed phase is named as forcings, not shown as a phase. - Neocortex (six-layered isocortex)
A job first done by the tectum is later held by the cortex: the superior colliculus 'shrinks to a small size in mammals, and many of its functions are taken over by visual areas of the cerebral cortex'. - Neuron (nerve cell)
Voltage-gated channels from the common ancestor were 'cross-purposed to provide a communication mechanism'; plant excitability is read as an osmotic function in a common unicellular ancestor, and rapid signalling as 'a newer accomplishment of metazoan cells in a more stable osmotic environment'. - Neutron star magnetosphere
The plasma supply is first borrowed from the star (the induced field 'extracted particles from the stellar surface') and then made in place: those particles' curvature photons 'converted to e± pairs', the cascade that fills the magnetosphere; Zhang: a pair plasma is 'required in an otherwise charge- - New Caledonian crow (Corvus moneduloides)
Hooks borrowed from plants (pandanus barbs, vine thorns) and hooks the crow carves into twig nodes: the job a plant's form does is also done by the crow's own craft - Newspaper
Distribution first borrowed the imperial postal couriers ('posts'); later papers ran their own delivery people and trucks (and still also use the mail). The reverse also shows: printing, once held, is now often outsourced so a small paper's press does not sit idle. - Novel
holding the story: first done by oral tellers ('novella that remained part of a European oral culture of storytelling'; Song-dynasty oral storytelling, chuanqi and huaben), later held in the fixed, printed text of the long novel - Number and counting (the number sense, the practice of counting, and the structure it works on)
The hand and body borrowed as the counting device (handful, one hand, two hands, Oksapmin body tally), later held in words and marks that keep the base: the hand 'used as external representations of number' shapes 'numerical structure and organization, as well as aspects of numerical language'. - Ocean currents (the ocean circulation)
From the borrowed side: hydrodynamic strain 'reminiscent of soft marine flow' triggers invagination; 'genetically regulated internal morphogenetic movements (gastrulation) possibly replaced external environmental (i.e., seawater) mechanical strains'. - Old English literature
Script borrowed from Irish missionaries (Insular half-uncial and minuscule); when Caroline minuscule was adopted for Latin in the 10th century, the Insular minuscule "continued to be used for Old English texts", keeping "distinctively Insular letter-forms": a borrowed tool held as the vernacular's o - Orangutan (Pongo)
Borrowed phase shown (milk for 6.5+ years; diet breadth reached only with social learning) and held phase shown (independent foraging on an adult repertoire of about 248 foods) - Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
A new niche first entered by plastic behaviour, kept by social learning, then held in the genome as selection acts on diet and climate genes - Organization
Coordination first supplied by the surroundings (prices in the market; families, churches and small groups that once 'control[led] these problems') and later held inside the organisation by direction and rules. Both phases are named in the sources, the borrowed one first, but as reasoning and as a c - Painting
colour first taken from the ground (ochre, hematite, manganese, lapis) and later made by people (Egyptian blue c. 3250 BC, Prussian blue 1704, synthetic ultramarine) - Patent specification (the enabling disclosure traded for a term-limited right to exclude, and its prior-art and improvement rules)
Disclosure was first done by people and use: letters of protection (from 1331) on condition that foreign workmen 'train English apprentices and pass on their knowledge', and in France 'Actual use of the invention was deemed adequate disclosure'; later the rule held it in its own text, a 'complete sp - Peptide-RNA world (RNA-peptide coevolution)
Mg2+ does the counterion job first: the RNA polymerase ribozyme 'strictly depends on' it; the partnership's K10 peptide then takes part of that job: 'K10 can substitute in part for Mg2+ as counterion (but not in catalysis)'; 'K10 lowers the amount needed but does not replace it'. Partial: the held l - Perception
A sensory substitution device first does the conversion for its user; training makes decoding automatic, like reading. The held phase is the skill, the device stays outside. - Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
Borrowed: Arabic-Persian philosophy took Greek texts into a theological debate (al-Kindi translated Aristotle). Held: Avicenna's own comprehensive system. Both phases shown; the 'regulation' is a body of method rather than a control loop. - Phonetics: the study of speech sounds (how they are made, carried through the air and heard, and how they are recorded and transcribed) together with the speech sounds it studies
Regulation of the infant's vocalising first comes from outside: mothers' contingent responses make babbling more mature (8 months), and live people, not television, teach phonetic categories; later the speaker holds the regulation inside, in auditory and somatosensory feedback control against learne - Physical security
Response is borrowed from the police at small sites and held on the premises at large ones (IAEA: sites with more than 500 g of plutonium must have alarm control centre and response force on the premises, as Anderson reports); private guards act as police 'until official authorities arrive'. Both fo - Placozoan (Placozoa, Trichoplax)
Coordination of locomotion is supplied by the physics of the coupled sheet ("completely coordinated by mechanical interactions"); in Planulozoa the same peptidergic cell program gains projections, post-synaptic genes and ion channels and becomes the neuron. - Plato
Borrowed: philosophy done in public places in Socrates' circle (the palaestra). Held: Plato's own Academy on inherited property, an exclusive circle where problems were posed. Both phases shown. - Play
Play signals run from signals borrowed from other functional contexts to signals unique to play; the borrowed and the held forms are both shown across taxa, not in one lineage over time. - Pollution
Dispersal by the air was first relied on (tall stacks: the surroundings dilute and carry the sulphur away); later the job was held at the source by controls and protocols, with emissions down 80% or more. Both phases in one source; the held phase is regulation by people, so partial. - Pragmatics
Borrowed: carers supply the timing (contingent responses within 1 s at 3 months; marmoset turn-taking shaped by caregivers); held: by 3 years children predict turns themselves by anticipatory gaze and keep speeding up. - Precedent (stare decisis: the rule that a decided case binds later like cases)
The legal citator was borrowed by science and then the web: Garfield's Science Citation Index (1960) 'was heavily influenced in several ways by Shepard's Citations', and in turn inspired the PageRank link analysis 'which became the heart of the Google search engine'. - Primate (order Primates)
The grip came from branches: opposing thumbs, nails and inward-closing fingers are 'a relict of the ancestral practice of gripping branches', and thumbs now 'allow some species to use tools'. - Primate social group
Grooming is traditionally thought to be hygiene (it targets body parts inaccessible to self-grooming), yet allogrooming scales with group size, not body size, across 44 species: a cleaning act held as the group's bonding channel. - Primordial magnetic field
A galaxy's field first borrowed from outside, then held by its own dynamo: a primordial relic 'subsequently amplified and maintained by a dynamo in collapsed objects' (Subramanian); 'Without a small-scale dynamo the seed fields in protogalaxies would be much weaker' (Beck). Both phases are named in - Privacy
A boundary first kept for the child by the group's social ritual of respecting its barriers, later kept by the person (control of who can access them); both phases named, the handover not dated. - Protein domain (and the tertiary fold it builds)
Stability borrowed, then held: domains of multidomain proteins 'incapable of independent stability are stabilized by favourable interactions with tethered domains'; their stable single-domain homologues hold it themselves through 'selective non-polar to polar mutations'. - Protein folding (a chain reaching its working shape)
In the protein-first hypothesis, chains are first made on a mineral catalyst (the 'Founding Rock'), then 'catalysis is mostly carried out by foldcat proteins and is no longer reliant on the Founding Rock'. - Proteostasis (the cell's network that makes, folds, repairs and clears its proteins)
The folding chamber's lid: Group 1 chaperonins 'rel[y] on an extra cochaperone to act as a lid' (GroES), Group 2 carry 'an additional helical component which acts as a lid'. Both phases are shown, but no source says the borrowed lid came first. - Proton
Hypothesis: natural proton gradients across vent walls drove early carbon fixation, and cells later pumped ions themselves ('forcing cells dependent on natural H(+) gradients to pump Na(+) ions'). - Psychology (the mind and behaviour as psychology describes them)
Development: social interaction drives cognitive development (Vygotsky), and theory of mind is an innate potential that 'requires social and other experience over many years'; the other people first do part of the job, then it is held. Partial: the held phase is shown, the borrowed phase only named. - Public speaking (oratory)
Memory first borrowed from paper or note cards, later held in the speaker's own memory (the canon of memory); feedback first supplied by evaluators and audiences, later carried as beliefs about one's own performance. Both phases named, but no source follows one speaker through the change. - Quantum dominant energy condition (QDEC)
The dominant condition held loosely: a classical rule kept inside a quantum tolerance hbar N/L^4. - Quantum flux energy condition (QFEC)
The classical light-cone rule for energy flow (DEC's flux half, borrowed from the causal structure) is held here in a relaxed form, inside a hyperboloid set by hbar. - Quantum spin chain
In single-chain magnets a field supplies the magnetisation and the chain then holds it, relaxing only slowly 'on a macroscopic time scale'. Partial: the held phase is shown (slow relaxation); the borrowed phase (a set field) is the protocol, not described in the passage read. - Radio
Power first borrowed from the signal, later held: a crystal set has only 'the energy available ... gathered by the antenna system' (the transmitter's energy powers the listener's set); later sets held their own supply, batteries, then the 1926 battery eliminator and mains-powered tubes. Both phases - Recursion: defining or computing a thing in terms of smaller versions of itself, as computer science and mathematics describe it, with its base cases, call stack, recursive data, induction, and its sightings in language and nature
A recursive procedure is hard for humans to run because it needs administration of the pending instances; the machine's call stack (Turing 1946, Bauer and Samelson 1957) holds that administration, and written texts hold deeper nests than speech. - Renewable energy
Storage was borrowed, now is being held. The fossil system ran on a store nature made ('ancient energy derived from sunlight by organisms that later died'); variable renewables first borrow dispatchability from gas plants kept on standby, 'until there is enough energy storage'; the held phase is bei - Respiratory system
Skin and gills exchange directly with the outside medium; the alveolar lung holds its own 2.5-3 litre 'portable atmosphere' that the blood sees instead. - Science (as a human social and cultural system)
The first telescope record "did not appear in a work of natural philosophy but rather in a patent filed by a spectacle maker"; instrument making later sat "near a center of learning or research, such as a university". - Scientific method (conjecture, predict, test, report for retest)
The gate was first built for the society's own needs ('create collective editorial responsibility, protect institutional finances, and guard the award of prestige') and later held as 'a touchstone of the scientific method'. - Secure software development
A protection first supplied by the surroundings (patches and mitigations from vendors and the OS after release) later held by the code's own language and design. Both phases are shown in Google's generations, but the 'surroundings' and the 'system' are both the vendor's own practice, so the borrowed - Security audit and compliance
Assessment borrowed from outside and held inside: PCI Level 2 merchants can use their own Internal Security Assessors, certified by the council, instead of external QSAs; organisations lacking skills outsource audits to consultants. Both phases exist in the scheme, not shown in sequence for one orga - Security information and event management (SIEM)
Log analysis first borrowed, then held: syslog servers 'did not perform any analysis'; administrators used separate add-on programs; later implementations built correlation in, and the SIEM holds it as its own floor. The correlation job is still partly borrowed from the analysts' heads ('analysts ar - Security operations center (SOC)
Monitoring first bought from an MSSP (or done jointly to uplift skills), later held in-house; also the reverse and back again (the in-house/outsourced oscillation). Both phases shown, but it runs both ways, so partial. - Security policy and governance
Leadership borrowed, then held: a virtual or fractional CISO, external, can serve as 'interim' CISO while the organisation hires its own; small firms borrow the role outright. The held phase is shown only as intent (the search). - Semantics: meaning in language (the meanings of words and sentences, sense and reference, how meanings combine, how they are held in minds and brains and shared in a community) and the field of linguistics and philosophy that studies it
A word's meaning is first supplied by the community's use around the infant and is later held in the child's own semantic memory (known from 6 months). - Separation of powers
Control first supplied from outside the government (the people, the "primary control"; written boundaries) and then held inside it by auxiliary precautions after "experience has taught mankind" that the outside control and parchment alone failed (Federalist 48, 51). Both phases named; the held phase - Series (mathematics): sums of infinitely many terms, and the practice of summing, testing and using them
Borrowed: divergent series' results were first vouched for from outside, by agreement with observation (Laplace's orbits verified experimentally; Abel: the results are mostly right, 'which is very strange'). Held: summation theory now justifies them from inside (Borel summation, multisummability). B - Set theory: the study of sets (collections taken as single objects), membership, Cantor's infinities and the axioms, and the practice of the people and machines who work with them
What counted as a set was first supplied from outside the theory, by analysis (Riemann's trigonometric series, Cantor's point sets) and by intuition (any defining property); after the paradoxes it was held inside by axioms, and the cumulative hierarchy gave the axioms their own motivation. - Sign language (the natural signed languages)
A word first supplied by the surrounding spoken language (fingerspelled 'for concepts for which no sign is available at that moment') later held as the language's own sign: 'Fingerspelling can sometimes be a source of new signs, such as initialized signs'. - Signals intelligence
Collection first borrowed from others (a codebook passed by Russian allies began Room 40; Western Union and other carriers gave the Black Chamber their cables), then held in permanent agencies with their own stations, satellites and taps (GC&CS 1919, NSA 1952, ECHELON's ground stations). - Skeletal system
Cartilage before mineral, a head skeleton before an axial one; the axial skeleton began as cartilage around the notochord and was later mineralised and replaced by bone. - SL(2, C) (Spin(1,3))
Matter's spin is held by the cover, not by the Lorentz group itself: 'representations of SO(1, 3) are not able to describe fields with spin 1/2', so fermions are carried by SL(2, C), whose image is the Lorentz group. - Social change
Smaller societies take money and writing from larger neighbours (borrowed), and modernity diffuses as a world culture that is then combined with traditional values and continuously reshaped (held and remade locally); Italy's writing and coins, kept after Rome fell. Both phases named; the held phase - Social stratification
Inequality first comes from outside the family (windfalls, accidents, theft: the disturbance term) and is then held inside by transmission (bequest rules, ownership rights), which blows the shocks up into steady-state inequality. - Social structure
Norms: first supplied from outside by others' approval and disapproval, then internalised and held 'for granted' (Bourdieu's internalizing the external). Held at the member's scale, both phases named. - Society as sociologists see it (sociology's object: social structure and social action)
Social control is first supplied from outside (family, sanctions) and later held inside each member: informal control is 'the internalization of norms and values through socialization', and internalized norms take on a 'for granted' quality. The holding is in the member (a part), so this is a part's - Software engineering
The discipline borrowed its name and methods from established engineering (1968, 'deliberately chosen as being provocative'), then built its own body of knowledge (SWEBOK, ISO standard), degrees (1979 master's, 1987 bachelor's) and licence exam (2013-2019). Both phases shown; whether the held phase - Software vulnerability
Numbering first done by MITRE for vendors, later held by vendors themselves as CVE Numbering Authorities (designation from 1 February 2005; Red Hat requests blocks of 500). Finding first borrowed from outsiders (bounties) while vendors keep their own teams. - Solution (chemistry)
Concentrating solutes: before cells, a thermal gradient across a rock pore did it ('for life to evolve, complicated active membrane transport is not required for the initial steps', Baaske 2007); in living things the composition is held by the organism (osmolytes, ECF homeostasis, fetuin-A). Two sou - Sorting algorithm
Randomness first borrowed from outside (randomized pivot selection draws random numbers), later held inside: pdqsort makes its own deterministic 'noise' by swapping well-chosen elements after a bad partition, 'similar to how a random quicksort would behave'. - Special relativity
the Lorentz transformations were first a symmetry supplied by electrodynamics ('known to be compatible with Maxwell's equations'; Lorentz's electron theory), and the theory then held them as its own, a symmetry of all local spacetime: the 1905 theory 'revealed Lorentz invariance as the universal sym - Speech (human spoken language)
Targets are first borrowed from other speakers' speech and production at first leans on sensory feedback; with practice the correction is folded into feedforward commands held in the speech sound map, and feedback is needed only when something unexpected happens (the DIVA model's account). - Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
A calf's dialect is first supplied by its unit (learned within the matriline), then held and voiced by the whale itself - Stochastic semiclassical gravity (semiclassical gravity with fluctuations and decoherence; walked as a projected model)
The parent's mean-field floor (semiclassical Einstein equation) is borrowed as is; the noise floor is the extension's own. - Story (narrative)
A life story is first co-authored by others (negative co-authoring in early adversity, supportive co-authorship in recovery) and then held inside as narrative identity; a heard tale becomes part of the listener's own tale stock. - Sulfur atom
Iron-sulfur chemistry first done on mineral surfaces is later held inside proteins: catalytic transition-metal centres on FeS/NiS in a volcanic hydrothermal flow (proposed), and 4Fe-4S and 2Fe-2S clusters 'spontaneously formed in low concentrations of cysteine and alkaline pH'; 'It is supposed that - Supply chain security
Signing first supplied by the registry's mandate (borrowed), then kept by the maintainer: 'once a maintainer begins to sign, they tend to continue doing so'. Whether it is kept once the mandate is lifted is not shown. - Supreme Court of the United States
Judicial review: the job of striking statutes was done before Marbury by state and federal courts (31 cases, Treanor), and then held by the Supreme Court as 'supreme expositor'. Housing too: meeting rooms borrowed in the Royal Exchange, Philadelphia's City Hall and the Capitol until 1935, then its o - Sustainability
For 10,000 years the planet's own resilience held the stable Holocene conditions agriculture and civilisations grew in (borrowed). Steffen et al. propose the next phase: a 'Stabilized Earth' held by 'human-created feedbacks to a quasistable, human-maintained basin of attraction'. The held phase is p - Syntax: how a language combines words into phrases and sentences (constituency and dependency, word order, agreement, recursion), how speakers build and parse it, how children learn it, how it differs across languages, and the field that studies it
Children's early combinations are taken over as concrete strings from caregivers' speech (item-based at 2) and become a productive grammar of their own by 3; whether this is the right reading is contested (Yang: productive from the start). - Tangent space
First pictured with the manifold embedded so that tangent vectors 'stick out' into an ambient R^m ('the traditional approach toward defining parallel transport'), then defined 'based solely on the manifold itself' (curves, derivations, I/I^2). - Telephone
Borrowed: early telephones were leased in pairs on lines a telegraph contractor built, used single-wire ground return as telegraphs did, and Western Union's telegraph exchange principle; held: the telephone companies' own exchanges, twisted pairs and four-wire long lines. Reverse case now: VoIP and - Television
Cable began by borrowing broadcast stations' signals through hilltop community antennas (1948), then carried its own cable channels ('non-broadcast channel'); the producing of programming changes hands, so the borrowed job and the held job are not quite the same. - The archive and the historical record
Authenticity was first borrowed from the place a document was kept (temples, public offices, archives); diplomatics then read it from the document itself. Both phases are named in the source; the switch-over is not dated, so partial. - The world through the senses (sensory environment)
In water, buoyancy carried organisms' weight; on land they became gravitationally loaded and new structures arose (bone mechanosensing osteocytes) - Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
Body heat taken from outside (ectotherms 'use external sources of temperature'), then made inside (endotherms 'create most of their heat via metabolic processes') (o78, o79). Partial: the two are kinds side by side; the source does not show one lineage's borrowed phase before its held phase. - Thermodynamics
The information engine's regulation is first borrowed: in the 2010 engine the measurement and feedback are done by the experimenters' apparatus (o27); in the 2015 autonomous demon 'the measurement and feedback operation takes place internally', in a second single-electron device on the same chip (Ko - Time orientation
The direction is borrowed from physics ('a choice of an arrow of time') and then held by the geometry as a continuous structure that orients every causal curve. - Tool
The edge and the anvil are first borrowed from the surroundings and later made: early tools "likely ... unmodified stones that cannot be distinguished from other stones"; otters use fixed shoreline rocks (emergent anvils) beside carried chest anvils; capuchins get sharp flakes unintentionally. Later - Trigonometry (the practice of tying angles to lengths, and the structure it works on)
The sine: Hellenistic chord study reached India as part of Hellenistic astronomy, where the half-chord (jya) became a working function with its own table; it was borrowed into Arabic as a sound (jiba, 'meaningless in that language') and then replaced by a real word (jaib, 'fold'), translated into La - Unemployment
Support for the jobless was first supplied from around the labour market (the Church helped the poor until the monasteries closed in the 1530s; families) and later held by its own institutions tied to the unemployed status (insurance from 1911, registration at employment agencies). The job moves bet - Vascular plants (tracheophytes)
Before roots, the uptake of water and phosphorus was done by fungi: 'Appearing as they did before these plants had evolved roots, mycorrhizal fungi would have assisted plants in the acquisition of water and mineral nutrients'; rootless Aglaophyton 'may have relied on arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi'. T - Vector calculus (the calculus of fields: gradient, divergence, curl; the practice and the structures it works on)
Borrowed: the vector and its products came out of Hamilton's quaternions (vector calculus 'was developed from the theory of quaternions'); held: the scalar and vector parts were kept apart for good ('once a vector always a vector', Heaviside) and the new system stood on its own, then displaced its p - Vector space: sets whose elements can be added and scaled, as mathematics describes it, with bases and dimension, linear maps, inner products, and their use as the state spaces of physics and data
Dimension was borrowed from geometric space (degrees of freedom, three dimensions) and later held inside the theory (Weyl's dimensional axiom, then the invariance theorem). - Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus)
Judgement of danger borrowed, then held: infants look to adults' reactions and juveniles rely on audiences when deciding to call, while adults call selectively and never called at unfamiliar raptor models - Voting
The ballot's form was first borrowed from what was to hand (raised hands, shouts, coloured pencils, party-printed tickets, marbles), then held as an official ballot in a secret booth. - Water pollution
Borrowed: the river carried and diluted London's sewage downstream (and to sewage farms). Held: treatment plants run inside the city the microbial work rivers and wetlands do outside; constructed wetlands use "the same biogeochemical processes dominant in natural wetlands". Both phases are in the so - Weathering
Mineral nutrient release is done for ecosystems by abiotic weathering; regrowing forests take it up as their own job, investing photosynthate belowground to amplify weathering when phosphorus runs short. Both phases are in the sources, but not as one lineage's history. - William Shakespeare
The company first played in The Theatre on a landlord's ground; after a dispute it pulled the building down and raised the Globe, 'the first playhouse built by actors for actors', owned by its sharers. Both phases shown; the holder is the company, he one sharer. - Wireless network
Avoiding interference was first done for the radios from outside, by regulators' fixed allocations ('legacy command-and-control regulation'); cognitive radios are to do it themselves, sensing spectrum holes and adapting. Haykin (2005): cognitive radio 'is still at a conceptual stage', though IEEE 80 - Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
Counting first held by clay tokens sealed inside clay envelopes, then by impressions of the tokens on the envelope, then by signs alone on flat tablets (Schmandt-Besserat; the causal link to cuneiform is 'widely contested'). - Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules)
Retribution first done by the injured party or his kin ('feuds and vendettas'), then held by the rule and an enforcing body that ensures 'this was the only punishment' (an origin idea the source calls 'a common one').
Candidate (3)
- Neutron star
The field: one hypothesis is flux freezing, 'conservation of the original magnetic flux' of the collapsing star (borrowed from the progenitor's dynamo field), which 'does not fully explain' the strengths; for magnetars the fields 'then persist due to persistent currents in a proton-superconductor ph - Normal coordinates
Flatness held only at a point: the flat chart of special relativity is borrowed at p (g = eta, Gamma = 0), and curvature takes over from second order on. - Riemann normal coordinates
Flat geometry borrowed at one event (g = eta, Gamma = 0), curvature held from second order: 'small enough regions of spacetime look like flat (Minkowski) space'.
Surface: a resemblance (68)
- ABJM theory (projected model: N = 6 Chern-Simons-matter theory on M2-branes)
Supersymmetry the construction does not have is held by the infrared theory: the brane set-up preserves only N = 3, the low-energy theory has N = 6, and at k = 1, 2 'additional supersymmetries (N = 8) that are not apparent in the Lagrangian'. - Algebraic quantum gravity (AQG; walked as a projected model)
Topology and background are not held by the theory: they are borrowed from outside through coherent states and held only as the choice of sector. - Annelid (segmented worm; phylum Annelida)
Siboglinids absorb the gases their bacteria need: worms 'extend their palps into the gas flows to absorb the gases needed by the bacteria', while the host lives on what the bacteria make. - Bacteriophage
Reverse case, borrowed and never held: the phage encodes a held loop (cI's negative feedback) but can only run it on the host's polymerase and ribosomes; 'viruses do not have their own metabolism and require a host cell to make new products'. - Bumblebee colony
The nest's shelter is first borrowed (an old rodent burrow or sheltered place) and then partly built by the colony (wax canopy over the nest, held climate). - Business continuity
Many businesses lean on government aid instead of having plans (borrowed); others hold their own plans and savings (held). Surface: both phases are shown across different firms, not one firm's sequence. - Canonical (Noether) stress-energy tensor
The Belinfante term is an analogue of the bound current J_bound = curl M of a magnetization: 'just as it is the sum of the bound and free currents that acts as a source of the magnetic field, it is the sum of the bound and free energy-momentum that acts as a source of gravity'. - Cauchy temporal function
Smoothness was long borrowed: Hawking and Ellis cited Seifert's smoothing and 'This is one of the folk theorems of the subject' (Sachs and Wu 1977), until Bernal and Sanchez proved it (2003); the smooth level is now held by the theory itself. - Causal arrow of time
The direction is borrowed from the thermodynamic arrow (correlations) and then held as the ordering of every cause before its effect, which memory and volition inherit. - Chemical bond
H2 in space borrows its stabiliser (a grain surface as third body); molecules with more modes are read elsewhere as holding the excess themselves, but no source read here shows that held phase for bonds. - Cnidarian (Cnidaria)
Kleptocnidae: sea slugs, flatworms and comb jellies keep eaten nematocysts as their own defence (borrowed, not inherited). - Comet
The comet's magnetosphere is all borrowed: the solar wind's field drapes over the ionised coma; 67P has no field of its own, and the borrowed one is cut off when reconnection severs the tail. Booked as the dark twin's reverse case. - Condensed matter physics
Methods borrowed from quantum field theory after 1945 became the field's own (quasiparticles, diagrams, renormalization), and ideas went the other way (Anderson-Higgs). Surface: an exchange of ideas between practices, not a job the surroundings did for a system and the system later did itself. - Cosmic dust
H2 forms on a grain surface where the gas phase alone does not make it; the job is borrowed from the grain (a solid made elsewhere) and later done inside the gas by other routes in dense, dusty clouds. Recorded as the grain-as-surface-medium shape the Lead may compare with mineral surfaces at rung 5 - Cryptography
Codebreaking first supplied from outside, then held: the Polish Cipher Bureau 'handed reconstructed Enigma machines and their techniques for decrypting ciphers to the French and British' on 25 July 1939, and Bletchley then did the job with its own huts and machines ('Hut 6 Ultra would never have got - Ctenophore (Ctenophora, comb jelly)
Haeckelia keeps eaten jellyfish nematocysts in its tentacles in place of colloblasts (kleptocnidae); and Stromatoveris suggests cilia first used for filter feeding became the comb-row propulsion system. - Data structure
Ordering pages by catchwords was first done on the page for human copyists and printers; computers hold the same next-pointer inside each node. - de Sitter spacetime
The same exponential geometry appears twice in the universe's history: borrowed by inflation's false vacuum at the start ('an initial de Sitter phase') and approached again under dark energy at the end. - Endoplasmic reticulum
Reverse case: the ER never holds ATP making; it 'requires ATP import from mitochondria'. Borrowed and kept borrowed. - Equivalence principle
Newton held the equality as 'an accident of nature encoded in empirical law'; in Einstein's gravity it is 'a consequence of physics', held by the geometry itself. - Ferrous iron in the ocean (the reservoir)
Iron was 'a lot more abundant' and bioavailable while the pool lasted; in today's oxic ocean iron 'is a limiting nutrient in most regions'. A review reads lanthanide use 'like that of iron' as taken up when soluble and then retained. - Fossil fuel
Storage across time was done by geology (deposits keep sunlight's energy for hundreds of millions of years); the energy system now stores gas itself, injecting it into depleted reservoirs and salt domes in low demand and drawing it in high. Surface: the held store reuses the geological one. - Gear
Lubrication supplied from outside (oil and grease for metal gears) and later done by the gear's own material in kinds that need none (plastic gears 'do not need lubrication'). Surface: different kinds, not one lineage shown taking the job in; the source does not say the plastic lubricates itself. - General covariance
Special relativity's global Lorentz covariance, held only between inertial frames, is extended by tensor calculus to local Lorentz covariance in all frames: the flat theory's invariance is kept, now held locally inside the curved one. - Globalization
Know-how 'lent' through supply chains ('technology lending', created 'in a matter of months') against Korea's decade-long domestic build; the held phase is shown for the earlier builders, not for the joiners. - Hair cell
Reverse case: tuning held in the cell's own channels (electrical resonance, all non-mammals, almost all of the turtle's tuning) is handed in mammals to the cochlea's mechanics plus OHC motors. - Hamiltonian and Lagrangian mechanics (analytical mechanics: classical mechanics built from energy functions and the stationary action, and the practice of using them)
Hamilton's method was first done in optics (systems of rays, 1828-1831), then held by mechanics as its own (1834), then lent back to optics (electron focusing 1925) and on to wave mechanics. - Horava-Lifshitz gravity (walked as a projected model)
Borrowed from condensed matter: Lifshitz-point (quantum critical) anisotropic scaling, first a description of condensed systems, then held as the short-distance structure of gravity ('uses concepts from condensed matter physics such as quantum critical phenomena'). - Human cultures (anthropology)
Moralizing high gods came into Austronesian cultures by diffusion from complex societies; the held phase is not shown in the abstract. - Human society (from local community up to societies)
Smaller societies adopt money and writing from larger neighbours; the held phase (their own systems) is not shown for those cases. - Hydrogen bond
Solvation work that water does around a reaction in solution is done in an enzyme by a preorganised site ('lower reorganization energy than their solution counterparts'): the job borrowed from the solvent is held by the protein. The borrowed phase in early life is not shown by the source. - Information warfare
States borrowed the press's and journalists' craft (Creel was a journalist; propaganda rode commercial media), then held it in standing bodies (the CPI 1917-1919, IW squadrons since the 1980s, the IRA 2013-2023). The hand-over itself is not traced in the sources read. - Intra-ISCO plunge (accretion-disc gas falling from the ISCO)
The parent plunging orbit's light floor was booked from this kind; here the light is held by the kind that makes it (gas, not test particles). - Intrinsically disordered protein (no single fold)
A folded protein holds its own fold; many IDPs take a fold only from a partner ('may acquire a stable structure only on binding to a ligand or other macromolecular surface'). - Journalism
Checking was held in-house first (fact-checkers from the 1920s, Time) and only later also supplied from outside (external fact-checkers, early 2000s): the reverse order, booked as surface. - Labour market
Wage floors were first set by unions among their members, the state recognising the unions, then held in statute as national minimum wages (New Zealand 1894, Australia 1896, the UK 1909). The job moves between parts of the market, not from surroundings to the system: surface. - Lipid (amphiphile)
Clay surfaces speed vesicle formation 100-fold (o58), a job the surroundings do; no held phase is shown. - Lorentz covariance
Global Lorentz covariance of special relativity held only locally inside general relativity: 'Lorentz covariance applying only locally in an infinitesimal region of spacetime at every point' (as the general-covariance walk also books it). - Marketing
Research, media and advertising work is contracted to agencies or done in a marketing department; and a trade association or government can market a whole industry or place. Both arrangements are shown side by side, not one after the other. - Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
Coordination of mind and body first supplied from outside (God in occasionalism and pre-established harmony), later held inside the system (one substance; circular causality within the organism). A historical sequence of positions, not one system's development. - Molecular chaperone
Reverse case (the catalog's dark twin): phage T4 borrows the host's GroEL ring and holds only its own lid, gp31, to make 'a taller container' for gp23. - Molecular hydrogen (H2, dihydrogen)
In the early universe free electrons left over from recombination did the catalysis (H- channel); in today's clouds the job is done on dust grains, which first had to be made by stars. - Music
Proto-musical behaviours first 'arose and spread as cultural inventions', then fed back on biological evolution: a job first supplied by the group's culture, later held in the body (one hypothesis). - Number-flux four-vector
The flow's number budget borrows baryon-number conservation (a property of the particles) and holds it as a field law nabla(nu) = 0. - Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it)
Magnetotaxis is held by free-living magnetotactic bacteria and borrowed by a ciliate from its symbionts; 'its magnetotaxis mirrors that of free-living magnetotactic bacteria and euglenozoans'. - Palatial twistor theory
A structure from quantum theory (non-commuting algebra, suggested by Atiyah) is borrowed to become the theory's own underlying arena. - Pancreas
Surface: the islet hormone cells are said to have come 'from the brain to the gastrointestinal track mucosa' and then into islets, and Arntfield and van der Kooy title it 'How the pancreas borrowed from the brain' (shared neural genes). The borrowed phase is a toolbox, not a regulation the surroundi - Penetration testing
Red teams 'work for the organization or are hired by the organization': the adversary role is bought from outside and also held in-house (a permanent in-house red team improves security culture). No source shows one organisation moving from the first to the second. - Plant seed
Orchid dust seeds carry 'no significant energy reserves' and 'depend on mycorrhizal fungi for nutrition during germination': the job other seeds hold inside is borrowed from a partner. - Quasar
The jet's launching field 'may be advected inward from the interstellar medium or generated by a magnetic dynamo within the disk': a field borrowed from the surroundings or held by the disc itself. The sources give these as alternatives, not as a sequence. - Reading
Reading first borrows the spoken language (understanding a text usually needs the spoken language) and the visual system; with practice it holds its own route (lexico-semantic reading, a word-specific VWFA). - RNA
Reverse case: RNA held storage and catalysis in the RNA world; DNA and protein enzymes now hold them ('a role fulfilled today by DNA'). - Sculpture
form first found in the material and then made: the Willendorf carver turned a broken-off concretion's cavity into a navel; later figures carry the navel as made form - Security awareness
Awareness is first supplied from outside (vendor material, a filter's warning, rules) and meant to be held inside as habit and culture ('thinking becoming a habit'). - Semiclassical gravity (quantum matter on classical curved spacetime; walked as a projected model)
Built the way QED was first built: quantum matter in a classical field ('when physicists considered quantum mechanics in classical electromagnetic fields'), the field quantized later. - Simple machine
Hills and slopes did the inclined plane's job before ramps were built, and the nuthatch borrows a found bark piece as wedge and lever; the made machine holds the geometry itself. - Slow clock transport
The setting is borrowed from clock 1 and then held by the carried clock until it reaches clock 2. - Social class
Class markers set by law (sumptuary rules, legal orders) are later held without law, in taste, speech and norms; the outside rule came first, the held marker after. - Sodium atom
Sodium is the ocean's dominant dissolved cation (10.8 g/L), leached from rock over eons; animal bodies hold their own extracellular sodium (the kidney keeps blood sodium and chloride near 9 g/L; renin-angiotensin restores it). The sources do not draw the line from sea to body; recorded as a surface - Sponge (Porifera)
Ambient current over the osculum does some of the pumping 'for free' by Bernoulli suction, alongside the choanocytes' own pump. - Startup company
Functions borrowed in the early phase: startup studios provide 'HR, finance and accounting, marketing, and product development'; infrastructure is rented from cloud providers; VCs hire board members and employees. The held phase (the grown firm doing these itself) is not shown in the sources read fo - Steep Cauchy temporal function
Smooth Cauchy splitting was cited from Seifert (1977) by Hawking and Ellis (1973) before a correct proof existed ('A previous incorrect proof'); Bernal and Sanchez and then Muller and Sanchez (steep) proved it, so the theory now holds what it had borrowed. - Stratigraphy
The global sea-level curve first rested on industry data the field could not check (the Vail curve, 1977), later rebuilt on public outcrop data (Haq et al. 1987-88 onward). - Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model)
The criteria were first read off string theory's own vacua ('universal patterns in string theory') and are then held as rules for any theory of quantum gravity. - Theatre
Pretend play in children ('an ontogenetic precursor to theatre') is later held as trained practice; Roman theatre borrowed Greek drama, then held its own forms (fabula palliata to Seneca). - Vagus nerve
The fish route kept: the recurrent laryngeal nerve still runs brain-heart-gills order, so neck and heart moving apart stretched it to ~4.6 m in giraffes - Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture)
Memory first held only in the mind is moved onto a wall and held there: drawing makes 'the invisible contents of mental life visible', and a panel is returned to after 35 kyr. - Water cycle (hydrologic cycle)
Rain on a basin is partly borrowed (ocean vapour carried in) and partly held (its own evapotranspiration recycled: Amazon 24-56%).