← all systems · see it in The System
Globalization
The process of increasing interdependence and integration among the economies, markets, societies and cultures of different countries worldwide; economic historians test it as commodity-market integration (a falling wedge between export and import prices: commodity price convergence), and historians and sociologists as the extension and intensification of social relations across world-space, carried by goods, capital, people, information, organisms and ideas.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 1820s (O'Rourke and Williamson) / 1571 (Flynn and Giraldez) / 1492-1498 (world historians) / third millennium BCE (Frank) |
| born precision | contested across about 4,000 years (C-2275) |
| boundary | Inside: the joining of separated markets, peoples and cultures across world-space: the carriers and networks that cross distance (ships, railways, containers, aircraft, cables), the flows they carry (goods, capital, people, information, organisms, ideas), the convergence of prices and the spread of shared forms, the institutions that open or close the flows (gold standard, Bretton Woods, GATT and WTO, trade blocs, visas), and the meanings and quarrels it raises. Outside: the separate societies, states and markets that are joined (sys:human-society, sys:state, sys:market, sys:economy), the Earth system the flows load (sys:earth, sys:atmosphere-of-earth), and the older regional exchange systems it grows from (sys:silk-road, sys:columbian-exchange). |
| nested level | Runs on human societies' trade, travel and talk (their L7 action); historians cut it into waves: archaic (to about 1600), proto- or early modern (about 1600-1800), modern (1820s-1914), a collapse (1914-1945), a second wave (1945 on, hyperglobalisation 1986-2008), then slowbalisation (contested). The Great Acceleration rides on its post-1945 wave. |
| scale | social |
Measures (36) published science
| Liverpool over Chicago wheat price gap | 57.6 (1870); 17.8 (1895); 15.6 (1912) % of Chicago price |
| Liverpool over Bombay cotton price spread | 57 (1873) to 20 (1913) % |
| clove price spread, Europe over Asia, 1820s vs 1730s | one-fourteenth ratio of spreads |
| Atlantic transport cost decline | about 1.5 per annum; 45 points to 1913 % per year; percentage points |
| freight toll on Rangoon rice to Europe (share of the Rangoon price) | 73.8 (1882) to 18.1 (1914) % of the Rangoon price |
| per-hand-off efficiency, Rangoon rice to Europe (value of the rice / its cost delivered) | about 0.58 (1882) to about 0.85 (1914) eta (derived from the freight shares: 1/1.738 and 1/1.181) |
| transatlantic information lag before the cable | 7 to 15 (about 10 on average) days |
| transatlantic information lag after the cable | 1 (1 to 6 with breakdowns) days |
| New York-Liverpool cotton price difference | 2.56 (16% of the New York price) to 1.65; a 35% fall pence per pound |
| telegraph welfare gain (tariff equivalent) | about 6 % ad valorem tariff abolished |
| Atlantic crossing time | up to 5 weeks (18th century) to 8 days (about 1900) travel time |
| Japan-China wage ratio, 1985 | 40 times |
| G7 share of world GDP | 67% (1988) to 50% (2010); 22% (1820), 43% (1950) % of world GDP |
| containerisation's cumulative effect on North-North trade | about 700 % over 20 years |
| share of a break-bulk ship's productive time spent in port | often two-thirds fraction of productive time |
| container crane productivity vs a longshore gang | 400 tons per hour; more than 40 times t/h; ratio |
| exports as a share of gross world product | 8.5 (1970) to 16.2 (2001) % |
| share of 50-year trade/GDP growth in 1986-2008 | 80 % |
| China's share of world manufacturing exports | 2.3 (1991) to 18.8 (2013) % |
| US employment reduction from Chinese import growth 1999-2011 | 2.4 million workers |
| local labour-market adjustment time after a trade shock (characteristic clock) | at least a full decade years |
| global Gini index, 2008 | about 70.5 (down about 2 points since 1988) Gini points |
| global Gini index, 2008, top-adjusted | almost 76 Gini points |
| KOF Globalisation Index coverage | 203 countries and territories, 1970-2016, 43 variables panel |
| emigrants from Europe, Age of Mass Migration | about 55 million (nearly 30 million to the US), 1850-1920 people |
| US foreign-born share | 10 (1850) to 14 (1870, held to 1920) % of population |
| share of alien-species first records 1970-2014 | 37 (of 45,813 first records of 16,926 species) % |
| alien-species first records, peak year | 585 in 1996 (more than 1.5 a day) first records per year |
| CO2 emissions embodied in traded goods | 4.3 Gt (20%) in 1990 to 7.8 Gt (26%) in 2008 Gt CO2 (share of global) |
| net emission transfer, developing to developed countries | 0.4 (1990) to 1.6 (2008) Gt CO2 per year |
| air passenger growth rate since 1960 | nearly 9 % per year |
| air network passengers a year | over three billion; more than 4,000 airports; more than 50 million flights per year |
| share of goods carried by the cargo-ship network | up to 90; about 60,000 ships, more than 5,000 ports % of international exchange of goods |
| values survey coverage | 76 national cultures, 1981-2022, n = 406,185 survey |
| wave length of modern globalization's first wave | 1820s to 1914, about 90 years |
| hyperglobalisation phase | 1986 to 2008, 22 years |
Open contentions (5) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2261 Does globalization make cultures alike?
booked: The map keeps it open.
the other reading: homogenization: Westernization or Americanization of cultures (critics; KOF's original definition); convergence of values with modernization (modernization theory); hybridization and fusion (the encyclopedia's fusion genres) - C-2263 Is the world deglobalising now?
booked: The map keeps it open.
the other reading: globalization has run its course and gone into decline (the encyclopedia's 'modern consensus'); trade volume is still increasing; the fall is in prices (some economists, as reported) - C-2273 Is global inequality rising or falling?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: falling global inequality as developing countries grow (Wolf, as reported); flat or rising when top incomes are counted - C-2274 What drives globalization?
booked: The map lists the drivers and rules none.
the other reading: late-19th-century globalization 'cannot be assigned to more liberal trade policy' (O'Rourke and Williamson: Atlantic tariffs did not fall 1870s-1914); capitalism and neoliberal policy as the engine (the encyclopedia's 'since the 1980s' reading); the ICT revolution, not trade costs, after 1980 (Baldwin) - C-2275 When did globalization begin?
booked: The map books the 1820s from price evidence and keeps the other starts beside it.
the other reading: third millennium BCE, Sumer-Indus trade (Frank); 1492 and 1498 (world historians; Adam Smith's two most important events); 1571, Manila and the global silver trade (Flynn and Giraldez, via the circumnavigation); a fragmented, deglobalized world before the 19th century (the third view O'Rourke and Williamson test)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (23) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Globalization. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (structural)
One job, carrying news of a distant market across the ocean: done by mail steamships (7-15 days), the cable (about a day), then low-cost networks and the Internet. One job, moving goods between continents: sail, steam with Suez, the container ship, air freight. One job, reading how integrated the wo - templating (structural)
The standard container: 'international standardization in 1965' let one box move between ships, cranes, railways and trucks of different owners and countries; containerisation's cumulative effect on North-North trade was about 700% over 20 years, larger than GATT or free-trade agreements. - The carry (structural)
Two faces. The wait: before containers 'often two-thirds of a ship's productive time was spent in port'; the chain moved at the pace of the slowest hand-off (break-bulk loading), and a crane at 40 times a gang's rate removed that wait. A second wait: local labour markets hit by import competition st - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Every crossing pays a toll. Material/transport form: shipping Rangoon rice to Europe cost 73.8% of its Rangoon price in 1882 and 18.1% in 1914 (eta about 0.58 to 0.85, derived); break-bulk handling lost cargo to 'the pilferage that always took place along the way'. Signal form: information frictions - trade one property for another (structural)
The trilemma: a policy regime 'can include at most two elements of the inconsistent trinity' (open capital, fixed exchange rate, own monetary policy); the gold standard bought open capital and fixed rates with monetary autonomy, Bretton Woods bought fixed rates and autonomy with capital controls, th - who opens the door (structural)
Ports opened ahead of time by the receiving side: KOF's de jure globalization 'measures policies and conditions that, in principle, enable, facilitate and foster flows'; container cranes installed by ports to the 1965 standard wait for the box; visas are 'a conditional authorization granted by a cou - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
In the industrialisation model, 'temporary protection that raised p ... would shift labour to M', and once past the critical minimum effort 'protection can be removed'; without it the nation is 'stuck at point A'. The model shows the without-barrier case; the record shows ISI's 'widespread failure' - conservation law plus closure (partial)
Emission accounting: territorial emissions leave open where the goods are consumed; the trade-linked database (113 countries, 57 sectors) closes it, giving consumption-based emissions and the net transfer (1.6 Gt CO2 in 2008). - nested ladder (partial)
Regional integration as rungs, each including the last: a free-trade area (tariffs and quotas cut), then an open border when people are also free to move, then the EU's single market of goods, services, capital and people. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
Baldwin's industrialisation model: an unstable equilibrium U, Leibenstein's 'critical minimum effort'; below it labour drains back to agriculture, past it 'the market will complete the nation's industrialization'. The interwar spiral (downturn, beggar-thy-neighbour, less trade) is a runaway away fro - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
The air network and the cargo-ship network were built separately for different uses, yet 'both networks exhibit striking statistical similarities despite significant differences in topology and connectivity', each segregating into two classes of nodes and links. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
Before: a 'multi-polar' archaic globalization driven by Gujarat, Bengal, coastal China and Japan as well as Europe. The cut: steam's 1st unbundling. After: 'the Great Divergence in the nineteenth century, where Western Europe pulled ahead', the G7 share of world GDP rising from 22% (1820) to 67% (19 - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Before the cable, 'only Liverpool prices lagged by ten or more days are relevant in determining New York prices': the central market set the local price, read through a lag. The global income distribution is a whole whose reading (global Gini falling about 2 points, 1988-2008) does not close with na - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
One world of flows, carved differently by each reader: economic historians read prices ('historians rarely look for evidence of such convergence'), historians read ships, ports and routes; KOF splits de facto flows from de jure policies; values researchers read 76 cultures' survey answers. Each slic - borrowed-then-held (surface)
Know-how 'lent' through supply chains ('technology lending', created 'in a matter of months') against Korea's decade-long domestic build; the held phase is shown for the earlier builders, not for the joiners. - holding / entrainment (surface)
The gold standard as a whole set its members' monetary stance ('an exchange-rate-subordinated monetary regime', 'a disciplining or commitment device'). Alien first records 'only slowing during the two World Wars' is a shared driver, the dark twin. - lightning (surface)
The transatlantic cable opened on 28 July 1866: overnight the news lag fell from about ten days to one and the price gap and its volatility fell; a step that changed what followed. The Great Recession 'brought to an abrupt halt' the post-war process. - outside-to-inside (surface)
The reverse direction: production stages that had to be 'inside a single factory or industrial district' moved outside the factory and across borders with the 2nd unbundling. Booked as the reversed case (inside first, then outside). - partner-becomes-part (surface)
Separate national markets in gain/gain trade become 'a global marketplace or a single world market'; the EU's single market under one system of laws. - red-queen (surface)
Biosecurity rules tighten while introductions keep rising: 'past efforts to mitigate invasions have not been effective enough to keep up with increasing globalization'. Introductions are winning, not a stalemate: the dark twin. - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
The price wedge moved by protection and by transport costs in opposite directions: in the Atlantic economy tariffs 'did not fall from the 1870s to World War I' while freight fell; in Asia, liberal opening with no offsetting tariff hikes. Two different causes acting on one wedge, so surface under the - seed (surface)
The 2nd unbundling opened stage-by-stage location choices ('one pair of shoes can be produced by six countries'; Thai cars with Japanese components and vice versa); the trigger was a cost fall in ICT, not a small information packet. - spin-up on contraction (ice skater) (surface)
Robertson: 'the compression of the world and the intensification of the consciousness of the world as a whole': contraction of distance comes with an intensifying held whole. No rotation and no resistance to further contraction are shown.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (27) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Corporation via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Earth via sys:biosphere · Globalization even
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Globalization even
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Globalization gain
- Religion via sys:human-culture · Globalization gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840) via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Internet via sys:electromagnetic-field · Globalization gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:sensory-environment · Globalization gain
- Money via sys:financial-market · Globalization gain
- Sport via sys:sensory-environment · Globalization gain
- Market and trade via sys:world-trade-web · Globalization gain
- United States (the country across time) via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Black Death (the mid-fourteenth-century plague pandemic) via sys:biosphere · Globalization loss
- Silk Road via sys:earth · Globalization gain
- Human culture via sys:human-culture · Globalization gain
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · Globalization loss
- Great Depression via sys:economy · Globalization loss
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:human-society · Globalization loss
- Cold War via sys:human-society · Globalization mixed
- Economy via sys:world-trade-web · Globalization gain
- Great Acceleration via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Columbian Exchange via sys:biosphere · Globalization gain
- Atlantic slave trade via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Colonialism via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- Human migration via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
- International trade via sys:human-society · Globalization gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (7)
- World trade web
- Telecommunication
- International migration
- Global transport networks (air and cargo ship)
- Global capital market
- Global supply (value) chains
- International economic institutions
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (20)
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Overcome Barrier
- Speed
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Proactive Defense
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
floor filled by (19)
- Earth
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Internet
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Market and trade
- Human culture
- Railways (and canals and turnpikes)
- The electrical telegraph
- Global transport networks (air and cargo ship)
- Global capital market
- Global supply (value) chains
- International economic institutions
- Anti-globalization (alter-globalization) movement
- Multinational corporation
- Steamship
- Shipping container
- Suez Canal
- Gold standard
represents (1)
Kinds (16)
- Economic globalization
- Cultural globalization
- Political globalization
- Archaic globalization
- Proto-globalization (early modern)
- Modern globalization's first wave (the 1st unbundling)
- The 2nd unbundling (hyperglobalisation, 1986-2008)
- Slowbalisation
- Embodied globalization (movement of people)
- Agency-extended globalization
- Object-extended globalization
- Disembodied globalization
- Environmental globalization
- Military globalization
- De facto globalization
- De jure globalization
Notes published science
- On 28 July 1866 the transatlantic telegraph cut the time for New York cotton news to reach Liverpool from 7-15 days to about one; the average price gap between the two markets fell 35%, a gain worth about the same as abolishing a 6% tariff (src:steinwender-2014).
- Before containers, a cargo ship often spent two-thirds of its working time sitting in port; the first container crane (1959) lifted 400 tons an hour, more than 40 times a longshore gang, and over 20 years containerisation raised trade between rich countries by about 700%, more than GATT or free-trade agreements did (src:bernhofen-2013).
- Trade carries hitchhikers: of 45,813 first records of alien species worldwide, 37% came after 1970, the yearly count peaked at 585 in 1996, and the only times it slowed in 200 years were the two World Wars, when trade itself collapsed (src:seebens-2017).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
globalization as historians and economists describe it (reader's view: the separated world and its price gaps, the carriers and doors that cross it, routes and networks, markets joined, institutions and rules, shared meanings and the quarrel over them, decisions to open or close and the world they reshape)
- L1: The separated world: regions with different goods, prices, peoples and cultures, kept apart by distance and barriers (the wedge between export and import prices); before steam each village made most of what it consumed
- L2: Carriers and doors: sailing ships, steamships, railroads, the Suez Canal, the container and its crane, the jet; ports and airports
- L3: Routes and networks: shipping lanes, the air network, cables and the Internet carrying goods, capital, people, information, organisms and ideas
- L4: Markets joined: commodity price convergence, the Law of One Price, supply chains spanning countries, capital mobility
- L5: Institutions and rules (the board): gold standard, Bretton Woods, GATT and WTO, trade blocs, visas and quotas
- L6: Meaning: the world as one place, its ideology and the quarrel over it; cultural convergence or divergence
- L7: Decisions to open or close and where to place things, and the world they reshape: incomes, jobs, species and emissions moved
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Institutions and rules that open or close the flows: the gold standard (discipline), Bretton Woods, GATT and the WTO, trade blocs and single markets, visas and immigration quotas, biosecurity acts, sanctions
- L6: Meaning: the world seen as one place (Giddens, Robertson), the ideology and narratives about globalization (Steger), the free-trade consensus and its critics, cultural convergence or divergence
- L7: Decisions to open or close, and where to place things: states liberalise or protect, admit or exclude, sanction; firms choose where to source; people choose where to move
way in: Capital (lending, investment, money across borders)
- L1: Savings, claims and money in separate national markets, joined by the gold standard after 1870
- L2: Cross-border lending and investment, centred on London before 1914
- L3: Capital mobility over time: an upswing to 1914, a collapse to 1945, a slow rise after, faster after Bretton Woods
- L4: Financial globalization measured: de facto flows rose strongly while de jure openness barely rose
way in: Earth-system feedback: emissions and impacts carried in trade
- L1: CO2 released in production for export
- L2: Net transfer from developing to developed consumers: 0.4 Gt (1990) to 1.6 Gt CO2 (2008)
- L4: Accounted: consumption-based against territorial emissions
way in: Goods and their prices (commodity markets)
- L1: Price gaps between markets: the wedge set by transport costs and protection
- L2: Exports and imports: first only high value-to-bulk goods (spices, silks, silver), from the 19th century bulk goods (wheat, cotton, rice)
- L3: Trade's share of output: exports 8.5% of gross world product in 1970, 16.2% in 2001
- L4: Commodity price convergence: Liverpool over Chicago wheat 57.6% (1870) to 15.6% (1912); Liverpool over Bombay cotton 57% to 20%
way in: Ideas, values and culture (religions, music, norms)
- L1: Ideas, images, knowledge and information: disembodied globalization, today's dominant form
- L2: Carried by force, migration, evangelists, imperialists and traders; later by media and the Internet
- L3: Spread and mixing: traditions lost or fused
- L4: Taken up into shared norms and identities, measured as Western value spread (KOF) or as values (World Values Survey)
way in: Information and news (mail ship, telegraph, telephone, internet)
- L1: News of distant markets, carried as long as couriers carried it: speed limited by horses and ships until the mid-19th century
- L2: Mail steamships, then the transatlantic telegraph (28 July 1866), then low-cost networks and the Internet
- L3: The information lag: 7-15 days before the cable, mostly 1 day after
- L4: Read on the exchanges: exporters forecast selling prices from the latest foreign news
way in: Organisms and pathogens carried by trade and travel
- L1: Regional species pools and pathogen reservoirs, kept apart by distance
- L2: Hitchhiking on carriers: eggs and larvae in shipped tyres, insects and algae with goods and people
- L3: The flow tracks trade: first-record rates of accidental taxa correlate with import values; 585 first records in 1996
- L4: Arrival on the network: disease arrival time follows effective (network) distance, not geography
way in: People (migrants, travellers, students)
- L1: People who move: embodied globalization, the oldest form
- L2: Falling migration costs: shipping revolutions and migrant finance from the mid-19th century
- L3: The flows: about 55 million left Europe 1850-1920, nearly 30 million to the US; 1 billion tourist arrivals in 2012
- L4: Settlement in receiving societies: the US foreign-born share 10% (1850) to 14% (1870)
way in: Production stages and supply chains
- L1: Production bundled with consumption (before steam), then bundled inside factories (until ICT)
- L2: Coordination by ICT: stages separated without much loss in efficiency or timeliness
- L3: Offshoring to near low-wage nations (40-fold Japan-China wage gap in 1985); one pair of shoes from six countries
- L4: Supply-chain trade taken in: China's share of world manufacturing exports 2.3% (1991) to 18.8% (2013)
way in: Shocks: wars, depressions, pandemics, eruptions
- L1: Wars, depressions and pandemics: 1914-1945 destroyed the first global economy
- L2: Network disruption: the 2010 Eyjafjallajokull eruption closed European airports for days; 2020 lockdowns cut trade in vehicles
- L3: The collapse spreads: the Great Recession halted the post-war process
- L4: Felt in measures: depth of integration fell about a tenth after 2008, recovered by 2013
way in: Transport technology and its costs (sail, steam, rail, container, jet)
- L1: Distance itself: up to 5 weeks across the Atlantic in the 18th century; before steam each village made most of what it consumed
- L2: Carriers: steamships, the Suez Canal and railroads; later the container ship and crane (1956-1966) and the jet airliner
- L3: Networks: the global cargo-ship network (about 60,000 ships, more than 5,000 ports) and the air network (over 4,000 airports)
- L4: Freight cost as a share of price, falling: Atlantic costs down about 1.5% a year to 1913; Rangoon rice freight 73.8 to 18.1% of its price
way out: Borders for people: admit or exclude
- L1: People moved or stopped: borders closed in 2020
- L5: Written as visas and agreements
- L7: Decide who may enter: quotas, visas, Schengen, closures
way out: Capital regime: choose two of three
- L1: Capital flows open or controlled
- L5: Gold standard, Bretton Woods controls, the float
- L7: Choose two of the inconsistent trinity: open capital, fixed rate, own monetary policy
way out: Culture sent out: goods, media, sport, religion
- L1: Received or resisted: values diverge globally, converge regionally
- L6: Shared forms sent abroad: Western trendsetting (McDonald's, IKEA in the index), world music, the Olympics
way out: Emissions moved with production
- L1: CO2 in the air from traded production: 7.8 Gt in 2008
- L7: Production placed in developing countries for developed consumers
way out: Organisms carried and established
- L1: Established alien species and pandemics: 37% of first records since 1970
- L3: Introductions follow trade and transport
- L7: Choices to import, plant and travel (ornamental plants, traded birds), and to regulate (New Zealand's 1993 Biosecurity Act)
way out: Sanctions and blockade: detach a country
- L1: Artificial detachment from world markets
- L7: Impose sanctions; blockade ports
way out: Shipments: goods sent where they fetch more
- L1: Goods arrive; the price difference narrows
- L4: Average trade flows rise and become more volatile after the cable, a more efficient response to demand
- L7: Exporters decide how much to ship from the latest foreign news
way out: Sourcing: firms place production stages abroad
- L1: Local labour markets: depressed for at least a decade
- L4: Imports compete with local producers: US employment down 2.4 million (1999-2011)
- L7: Lead firms offshore stages and move their know-how with them; the decisions are sticky
way out: The reshaped world: who gains
- L1: The global distribution goes from twin-peaked to almost single-peaked
- L4: Winners near the global median (90% Asian); losers near the 85th percentile (90% mature economies)
- L7: Integration of developing countries into the world economy
way out: Trade policy: liberalise or protect
- L1: The wedge widened or narrowed at the border
- L5: Written as rules: trade agreements and dispute settlement
- L7: Choose to open (GATT rounds, the WTO in 1995, bilateral deals) or close (tariffs, the 2018 US-China trade war)