red-queen our proposal
One side's progress lowers the other's fitness, so both keep running to stay in place.
Seen in 182 walked systems. Each sighting is our reading of that system's sourced walk, in that system's own terms; a shape that turns up everywhere is the finding, and how it differs from place to place is the detail.
Structural: the shape does the work here (18)
- Adaptive immune system
Pathogenic coevolution: common MHC alleles are under greatest pathogen pressure, favouring uncommon ones, 'moving targets, so to say, for pathogens'; V(D)J lets the body answer pathogens 'that frequently change (e.g. seasonal influenza)'; HIV and measles strike the memory itself. - Animal (kingdom Animalia, Metazoa)
Predator and prey keep running: "an evolutionary arms race between predator and prey"; in air, wasps' charge selects for tuned caterpillar setae. - Art history (the field)
Forgers against authenticators. Both sides improve: dating and analysis 'have made the identification of forged artwork much simpler', while forgers are 'often proficient in the current methods of art forgery authentication' and reverse-engineer them (old canvases scraped by van Meegeren, supports b - Botnet
IRC takedowns pushed bots to domains, domains to DGAs and fast-flux, centralised C&C to P2P with signatures; defenders answered with sinkholes, crawlers and peer-list poisoning, botnets with sinkhole blacklisting and reputation. Both sides improve; botnets persist (Emotet resurfaced; P2P botnets liv - Business
Firms adopt health actions 'in order to keep pace with competitors', each following the last; the source names it the Red Queen, after the character who 'ran as fast as she could just to “keep in the same place”', and finds firms trying to escape it with credence goods. Both sides moving, neither ga - Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin)
Host and parasitic RNAs in a lab replication system: the parasite free-rides the host's replicase, host and parasite oscillate, and 'successive counter-adaptive evolution (i.e. evolutionary arms races)' follows; host lineages and parasite lineages both persist and diversify ('at least two and three - Cybercrime and its underground economy
Both sides improve and neither gains ground: defenders speed takedowns and freeze payments, attackers move across borders, adopt fast-flux, spread shops across markets; marketplace volume stays around $300,000-500,000 a day through takedowns and scams, and 'many cybercrime patterns appear to be fair - Earth in the Mesozoic era
The MMR is called an 'evolutionary arms race': shell-crushing 'forced shelled marine invertebrates to develop defences against such predation or face extinction'; prey answered with infaunal habits, conchiolin layers, sculpture and jumping, and predators perfected crushing by the Late Cretaceous. - Fishery
The race to fish: short seasons drove the industry to bigger, faster boats, which drove regulators to shorten seasons again, to a few days a year; both sides kept improving and neither gained ground (Alaska halibut: four months to two or three days, until ITQs ended the race in 1995). - Inflation (economics)
Workers and firms each reprice toward the relative price they want; with staggered prices 'the conflict over relative prices are largely frustrated', a stalemate in relative prices while all prices keep rising. - Information warfare
Three races where both sides improve and neither gains ground: the Cold War 'power race' (broadcasters and jammers alike kept raising transmitter power and frequencies until the Soviets stopped in 1987, by decision, not defeat); deepfake creators against detectors (a 'tug-of-war'); detectors against - Intrusion detection system
Attackers and defenders each improve their tools in answer to the other: new signatures, then pattern-change evasion; anomaly models, then adversarial examples crafted by evolutionary search. 'A constantly changing library of signatures is needed' to stay level. - Life (the living world, as biology describes it)
The host-virus arms race: 'the perennial arms race between viruses and their hosts is one of the defining factors of evolution'; LUCA already had an early Cas system. - Malware
Virus authors and anti-virus developers both improve, and in 1994 the race was 'roughly even': signatures answered by packing and repacking (a family repacked at least every 11 days), detectors that decay over time (TESSERACT), and in 2017 still about a third undetected. Both running, neither winnin - Mammal (class Mammalia)
Moths hear bat calls; 'these moth adaptations provide selective pressure for bats to improve their insect-hunting systems and this cycle culminates in a moth-bat evolutionary arms race' (whispering bats, jamming clicks). - Programming language
The memory war: attackers develop new attacks, defenders new protections; protections 'make the exploitation of memory corruption bugs much harder, but several attack vectors are still effective', and the problem 'has existed for more than 30 years'. Both sides improving and neither gaining ground: - Secure software development
The war in memory: offence develops new attacks, defence new protections; mitigations raised exploit costs while tooling lowered the bar, and memory-safety vulnerabilities sat on a 'stubbornly high plateau' through three generations of defence (patching, mitigation, discovery): both sides improving, - Social engineering
Both sides improve and neither gains ground: filters, sender authentication, warnings, training and phishing-resistant authentication on one side; kits, relayed codes, new channels and AI-written lures on the other. Phishing reported since 1995 'showed no sign of slowing down'; APWG counted 3.76 mil
Partial: part of the shape (86)
- Access control
Lock makers and pickers keep answering each other (Portsmouth burglary, Chubb's competition, Bramah's 67-year challenge, Hobbs, Blaze's master-key attack); broken access control rose to first place in 2021. Both sides improving is sourced; the stalemate is not. - Acoustic wave (sound: pressure waves in matter)
Moths and bats: 'a long-standing arms race'; moths evolved ears and ultrasound (hawkmoth stridulation 'evolved independently multiple times', tiger moths that jam sonar), bats evolved stealthy low-amplitude 'whispering' calls and 20-60 kHz calls 'less conspicuous to insects'. Both sides improving is - Advocacy group (interest group)
Competing groups resist each other's pushes so radical change is met with resistance and the whole sits in a 'democratic equilibrium' (pluralism); adversarial pairs run for decades (the Automobile Association against the Pedestrians' Association since 1929). The stalemate is stated by the theory; bo - Ancient Greek philosophy
The Stoic-Academic debate: Arcesilaus attacks the Stoic criterion, Chrysippus revises Zeno's epistemology to defend it, Carneades continues the attack; both sides improve over generations. The sources read do not say neither gained ground, so the stalemate is not shown. - Artificial intelligence
GAN: G and D each improve against the other and the game's solution is the stalemate, D 'equal to 1/2 everywhere'. Adversarial attack and defence: new defences, then attacks that circumvent 6 of 7 completely; the stalemate is not shown there (one side winning each round), so that half is partial. - Authentication
A 'continuing competition' between attack and defence 'of long standing', like armour plate and armour-piercing shells: each defence (one-way storage, slow DES, salt, the altered E-table) answered by new attacks (dictionaries, DES chips). The stalemate is stated as long-standing, not measured. Dark - Blood
Malaria as 'an evolutionary arms race': human red-cell variants (HbS, O group, Dantu) protect, and parasite genotypes associated with HbS appear to overcome that protection; the stalemate itself is not shown in the source. - Brand
Mark and copy keep running: factory marks imitated through the ages, rustlers' running irons met by brand registers and inspections, counterfeits at USD 467 billion met by enforcement. In the nature twin, drongo egg signatures keep the upper hand on near-perfect cuckoo mimics. No source shows the st - Business continuity
Ransomware attackers keep finding new ways through, and the attack rate in 2023 was about twice 2021's; defenders keep adding backups and workflows. Stalemate not measured. - Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers)
Van Valen: 'the evolutionary progress of one species deteriorates the fitness of coexisting species, but because coexisting species evolve as well, no one species gains a long-term increase in fitness'; predator and prey 'were one of the two to stop evolving, it would go extinct'. The Cambrian artic - Cave painting
keepers and fungi at Lascaux: each treatment or climate change is followed by a new outbreak (Fusarium 2001, black stains 2007, Ochroconis named 2018); 'the problem is ongoing'. The stalemate is stated; improvement on the fungal side is not shown - Cell
'newly incorporated spacers driving phages to mutate their genomes to avoid the bacterial immune response, creating diversity in both the phage and host populations'; 'Phages can continue to infect their hosts' given point mutations in the spacer.' Both sides improve; the stalemate is implied, not s - Central bank
Discretion against expectations (Barro and Gordon): the policymaker keeps the power to surprise, people keep adjusting expectations "to eliminate a consistent pattern of surprises"; neither gains ground and average inflation ends higher. Both sides move, the stalemate is shown. - Central processing unit
Speculative-execution attacks and countermeasures: 'makeshift processor-specific countermeasures are possible in some cases', sound fixes need new designs and ISAs. Both sides moving is shown; the stalemate is not shown in the sources read. - Columbian Exchange
Crops escaped their coevolved pests and yielded more in new regions, then the pathogens caught up through continued exchange and yields fell back toward endemic levels: neither side gains for good. Firing rule only half met: the sources show the catch-up, not both sides improving. - Compiler
Trusting-trust attacks and their countermeasures: attackers subvert compiler binaries; defenders answer with diverse double-compiling and bootstrappable and reproducible builds. Both sides improve; the stalemate is not shown (Wheeler claims the attack is 'effectively countered'). - Computer law
Lawmakers keep amending (CFAA 1986, 1989, 1994, 1996, 2001, 2002, 2008, each widening its reach) and reviews call for legislation to be updated 'with the rapid advancement of technology in order to address the rising number of cybercrime': both sides keep moving and cybercrime is still described as - Computer memory
RowHammer: tens of attacks since 2015 (VM takeover, mobile, browsers, RDMA) against mitigations (raised refresh, PARA, ECC); new memory technologies bring new failure mechanisms. Both sides improve; the stalemate is not stated in the sources read for memory itself (the programming-language walk book - Computer network
Attacks and defences grow together ('The vital role firewalls play in network security grows in parallel with the constant increase in cyber attacks'); Mirai's authors added evasion and new targets as defenders responded. Partial: both sides improving is shown; the stalemate is not measured. - Computer security
An attack-defense arms race in adversarial malware detection: each side's success depends on knowing the other's set (feature set, manipulation set). Both improve; the stalemate is not measured in the abstract read; the kill-chain paper describes adversaries 'that continually adapt their operations - Covalent bond
Covalent antibiotics and bacteria: beta-lactams acylate PBPs, bacteria evolve resistance, next-generation drugs are made 'to overcome resistance mechanisms that the bacteria have evolved', then beta-lactamase inhibitors (2015, 2017). Both sides improve; the stalemate is implied, not stated. - Cryptographic hash function
Designers and cryptanalysts keep improving against each other: SHA-1 collision cost fell from 2^64.7 to 2^61.2 (identical prefix) and 2^67.1 to 2^63.4 (chosen prefix); NIST answered with a competition and SHA-3. MD5 and SHA-1 lost outright, so the stalemate holds only for the field as a whole, not f - Cryptography
Codemakers and codebreakers each improve: computing for attackers doubles every 18 months, and keys must be 'approximately 14 bits longer than required to protect against an attack today' to keep the same protection (Blaze et al.); 'the security parameter could be seen as growing linearly with time' - Cyber threat intelligence
Attackers 'driven to innovate and diversify' while defenders 'must continually monitor'; defenders keep the advantage only 'faster than their known adversaries evolve'. Both run; whether either gains ground is contested (C-1118). - Cyberwarfare
Offence and defence both improve (exploits and patches, AI on both sides) while the literature finds no single answer on who gains; a 'Digital Cold War' of prolonged low-intensity conflict 'while a play balance is pursued'. - Database
SQL injection: 'In spite of the development of different approaches to prevent SQL injection, it still remains an alarming threat'; defences and 'innovative attacks' both advance (survey title). Stalemate stated from one abstract only. - Denial-of-service attack
Both sides keep improving: amplifiers are cleaned (NTP -92%), new vectors appear (+500%); booters are seized, return on new domains; mitigation grows to a $1.94 billion market while attacks grow 'faster than network growth'. Whether neither gains ground is contested: Osterweil et al. say defenders a - Digital forensics
Both sides improve: anti-forensic techniques are used more, and the same research helps 'remedy weaknesses in forensic tools'; counter-anti-forensics appears; attackers move to a new layer (the reasoning of LLM-assisted analysis). The sources show the running, not a sourced stalemate. - Digital identity
Fingerprinters and defenders in a 'continual arms race': defences add noise and diversity, linkers follow devices through changes; the 2018 study's 33.6% unique against 2010's 83.6% shows defenders gaining on desktops, so the stalemate is not shown. - Digital signatures and certificates
Designers and forgers both improve (MD5 to SHA-2, DSA retired, ML-DSA; collisions, stolen keys, quantum estimates) and the system keeps moving to stay trusted. The stalemate is read in the bacterial analogue's source, not stated for signatures: restriction-modification diversity read as the Red Quee - Economics (the field)
The Lucas critique: a policymaker who exploits the inflation-unemployment relation raises inflation, firms raise their forecasts, and unemployment does not stay lower. Both sides adjust; neither gains ground for long. The source shows the stalemate for the policymaker; it does not show both sides im - End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released
The recovery turned into an arms race: increased predation pressure and durophagy 'led to the Mesozoic Marine Revolution'; prey answered by infaunal habit, mobility, sculpture and autotomy, while sessile forms that could not reattach were 'picked off as easy prey'. - Entrepreneurship
Escape competition: neck-and-neck firms innovate to get ahead of each other; Aghion et al.'s steady state has both sides innovating, with leadership changing hands. Both sides improve; whether neither gains ground over the long run is a model result, not a measured stalemate, so partial. - Epistemology (the theory of knowledge: the study and the knowing it studies)
The analysis of knowledge and its counterexamples: each proposal refined, each 'undermined by further counterexamples'; both sides improve and no analysis gains consensus (Shope 1983; still no consensus). - Firewall (computing)
The Great Firewall and circumvention tools move in turn: active probing, then fully encrypted protocols, then passive detection (November 2021), then payload prefixes that dodge it (January 2022); attacks moved up to the application layer as firewalls added application inspection. The sources show t - Firm (the economic unit)
Creative destruction is 'what every capitalist concern has got to live in'; entrants come in above exiters, and competition goes with better management. Both sides improving is shown; the stalemate (neither gaining ground) is not measured in the sources read, so partial. - Free will
Prediction against unpredictability: predators exploit predictable escape responses (snakes and fish C-starts, worm grunting, redstarts and fly jumps), so selection keeps favouring variability; and the philosophical debate in which each side refines arguments while some lament no progress over centu - Fruit fly (Drosophila melanogaster)
Fly larvae and parasitoid wasps: flies encapsulate wasp eggs, virulent wasps suppress encapsulation, flies eat ethanol, the specialist wasp resists ethanol better than the generalist - Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls)
'As plant cell walls have become more efficient, so have the peroxidases that destroy them': both sides improving. The stalemate (neither gaining ground) is not shown, so the firing rule is only half met. - Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
Viruses "must use the same genetic code as their hosts", so a host code change "could interfere with viral protein synthesis", and totiviruses "have adapted to the host's genetic code modification". - Gross domestic product
The measure keeps changing its conventions 'in an attempt to keep up with industrial advances', and still the information sector's share of GDP stood at 4-5% in 2016 as 35 years before while free digital goods spread: both sides move, the gap stays. A second race: autocracies' overstatement against - Incident response
Attackers subtly modify attacks to slip rules ('nearly half of the current SIEM rules could be easily evaded'); teams 'should evolve to reflect new threats'; incidents have grown more frequent and damaging. Partial: both sides improving is shown; the stalemate (neither gaining ground) is not measure - Information security
New threats and vulnerabilities 'emerge every day', so risk management 'must be repeated indefinitely'; phishing 'showed no sign of slowing down' over two decades of research. Both sides improve; the stalemate is implied rather than measured (C-1118). - Insect (class Insecta)
Bats and moths: moths hear ultrasound and evade; tiger moths warn with clicks, palatable moths mimic the clicks, and some jam sonar (the Wikipedia article cites a paper titled 'acoustic aposematism in the bat-tiger moth arms race'). - International trade
The terms-of-trade theory: each government's tariff improves its own terms of trade at the partner's expense; both set tariffs and both end at an inefficient non-cooperative point. 2018: retaliation reduced real income on both sides. Partial: the stalemate is shown, but both sides worsen rather than - Intruder (burglar and trespasser)
Security and burglars both improve: households fit better devices, offenders adapt to new vulnerabilities and innovate; but in burglary the defence gained ground (a 64% drop), so the stalemate the firing rule asks for is not shown. - Japanese macaque (Macaca fuscata)
Farmers escalate (scarecrows, then electric fences) as macaques learn that deterrents are harmless; both sides improve, but macaque entries keep rising, so no stalemate is shown - Language (human language)
Primates "often attempt to deceive each other, while at the same time remaining constantly on guard against falling victim to deception themselves"; listeners discount words that prove false, so trust must be rebuilt by costlier means. - Late Devonian mass extinction (Kellwasser and Hangenberg events), with the Carboniferous radiation it released
Crinoids and shell-crushing fishes in a 'classic predator-prey (Lotka-Volterra) cycle' after the Hangenberg; earlier, productid spines 'more resistant to predation' replaced smooth shells. - Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule)
Sex kept against parasites: sexual hosts 'continually "running" (adapting) to "stay in one place"'; snail and C. elegans studies support it, geckos do not. - Mind–body problem (how mental states relate to physical states)
Positions and objections improve in turn with neither side gaining ground: physicalism holds the majority (51.9%) while 62.4% call the hard problem genuine; IIT and GNWT each partly confirmed and both challenged. The stalemate is in the surveys; that each side improves is shown for the theories of c - Movable type (reusable cast sorts x the alphabet; the European press)
Licensing and the Indexes against secret presses and smuggled books, escalating for three centuries: 'authorities seeking to regulate the press often came into conflict with those seeking to circulate forbidden material'; when 'the English took control of type founding in 1637, printers fled to the - Operating system
Defenders harden (ASLR, control-flow integrity, verification) and attackers move down to the hardware (Meltdown: 'The root cause of Meltdown is the hardware'); Linux's faults per line fall while the code doubles, and the average fault lifespan stays 'comparable to that observed for previous versions - Painting
forgers and authenticators each improve: aged canvas reused against canvas dating, then the binder itself dated; no stalemate measure in the source - Penetration testing
The authors name it: 'the struggle between red and blue teams — lead to a Red Queen's Race: participants must run to stand still'. Both sides improve (frameworks and defaults made injection attacks rare; testers move to OT, internal networks and business logic); the stalemate is stated by the author - Perception
Perception and what it perceives co-evolve: bat hearing and moth hearing; prey camouflage and mimicry exploit perception's ambiguity. Escalation shown; the stalemate is not shown in the sources read. - Periodic table (the periodic system of the elements and its law, as chemistry describes it)
LBNL and JINR both claimed elements 102-106; the naming controversy 'lasted decades' until a third party set criteria. - Phishing
Both sides keep improving: two-factor authentication spread, and MITM kits came to relay codes and cookies; blocklists sped up, and cloaking and one-character URL changes answered; yet counts hold level (3.76 million attacks in 2024, 3.8 million in 2025). Contested: Thomas et al. saw a remarkable la - Physical security
Both sides keep improving: vault makers against bank robbers, lock vendors against bumpers and pickers, preventers against adaptive offenders 'in a never-ending arms race'. The stalemate is not general: the crime drop (an 80% theft fall for immobilised cars) shows ground gained, so partial. - Prairie dog (Cynomys)
Prairie dogs evolving plague resistance under fluctuating selection for 25-50 generations; the pathogen's side of the race not shown in the sources read - Prime numbers (the practice of number theory that finds, proves and uses them, and the structure of the primes it works on)
Factoring records (RSA-768 in 2009, RSA-240 in 2019, cheaper than predicted) push key sizes up; longer keys are the next targets; RSA stays in wide use (90% of TLS certificates in late 2019). Both sides improve. The stalemate (neither gaining ground) is implied by key sizes set to stay ahead of the - Privacy
Tracking and protection: ATT stopped identifier tracking, apps moved to fingerprinting and server-side identifiers, and the number of tracking libraries stayed about the same; both sides moved, neither cleared the field (protection did gain some ground: tracking individuals is 'more difficult now'). - Public-key cryptography
Both sides improve: factoring records rose to RSA-240 and RSA-250 (2019-2020), quantum estimates for RSA-2048 fell twentyfold (2019-2025), 'attacks always get better'; defenders lengthen keys and change problems (elliptic curves, lattices). Whether neither gains ground (the stalemate) is not stated - Radio
The Cold War 'power race': jammers and broadcasters 'alike repeatedly increased their transmission power', added antennas and frequencies, and the rising noise hurt even stations neither side targeted. Both sides improving is shown; the stalemate (neither gaining ground) is implied by the race conti - Risk management
Threat shifting: adversaries change time, target, resources or method in response to controls; cyber insurers must frequently issue new policy versions as threats evolve. Both sides move; the stalemate is not measured in the sources read. - RNA
RNAi 'continues to defend against viruses and transposons' (s39); herpesvirus ncRNAs answer by destroying host miRNAs, which is 'critical for virus production' (s46); small silencing RNAs carry a 2'-O-methyl that 'prevents tailing' (s47). Both sides' moves are shown; the stalemate is not stated in t - Security awareness
Both sides improve and phishing stays: lures grow more sophisticated and kits copy websites automatically, while filters, training and warnings spread; 'during the last two decades phishing showed no sign of slowing down', and twenty years of filtering research leave phishing the largest single sour - Security information and event management (SIEM)
Public rules are improved by a large community; adversaries test attacks against them and modify them to evade; defenders add rules or adaptive detection; Uetz et al. find evasions 'an intrinsic problem' and fixing every rule 'practically impossible'. Both sides keep moving; whether either gains gro - Security operations center (SOC)
Both sides keep running: the threat landscape keeps evolving, so analysts need periodic training and rules need tuning; whether either side gains ground is not shown for SOCs. - Separation of powers
Each branch's defence is built to match the others' attack ("the provision for defense must in this, as in all other cases, be made commensurate to the danger of attack"), and by design neither gains ground (Polybius: none outgrows the others). The stalemate is the design; the US record swings (C-23 - Sequential information (the order of units along a linear polymer)
Hosts write new spacers while phages fix escape mutations in the same week; 'coevolution of host and viral genomes'. Both sides shown improving; the stalemate (neither gaining ground) is not shown by this source, so the firing rule is only half met. - Signals intelligence
Sigint is an arms race: each new method of interception meets low-probability-of-intercept communication, new cipher machines (the 4-rotor Enigma blacked out U-boat traffic from 1 February 1942) and encryption by default; agencies answer with captured material, provider demands and calls for excepti - Software engineering
Lehman: an E-type program must be continually adapted to its changing environment just to stay satisfactory; the environment it mechanizes changes because of it. Both sides change, neither gains ground. The second side is the world, not a rival improver: partial. - Software vulnerability
Defenders improve (faster patching, memory-safe new code, bounties) and attackers keep finding and buying flaws ('any serious attacker can always get an affordable zero-day for almost any target', RAND as quoted); old vulnerabilities age out yet fixed ones get older on average. In the lamprey, mimic - Songbird (oscines, suborder Passeri)
Hosts and brood parasites each improve (defences select counter-strategies), with outcomes from resistance to tolerance; whether hosts' varied defences are adaptive or evolutionary lag is unclear - Steel
Stainless steel's passive film was thought to make it immune to microbes; electroactive microbes now 'aggressively corrode' it by passing electrons across the intact film, and alloy designers answer (Cr-Cu modified pipeline steels). Both sides move; no source shows a stalemate, and the microbes are - Stored-program principle (instructions held in the same memory as data)
Viruses and exploits against defences: 'Viruses use complex anti-detection/stealth strategies to evade antivirus software'; overflows met by NX, layout randomisation and canaries, and Cohen showed 'there is no algorithm that can perfectly detect all possible viruses'. - Supply chain security
Attacks evolve (XZ 'a particularly sophisticated evolution'; obfuscation and evasion) as safeguards multiply (33 safeguards, ten frameworks), and vendor counts keep rising; both sides improving is shown, the stalemate only in vendor counts that are contested. - Surveillance
Surveillance and countersurveillance both improve: phones encrypt after Snowden, law enforcement must break codes; countersurveillance grew in scope and complexity as databases and drones did. The sources show both sides moving, not a measured stalemate. - Tax
Evaders and enforcers each improve: a supply of evasion services that grows with wealth, offshore accounts, carousel fraud; leaks, information exchange, letters and automated VAT. Both sides moving is shown; the stalemate is not. - Telephone
Phreakers learned the published 2600 Hz and MF tones and seized trunks; operators moved control out of band. Robocallers adapted to STIR/SHAKEN authentication; unsolicited calls are in slow decline though complaints and volumes remain high. Both sides moving; the stalemate is only partly shown (call - Threat actor
Defenders force the adversary to change every phase; adversaries evolve; a takedown of 15 booters cut traffic only for a while and one booter was back in three days. Both sides moving, the contest continuing (who has the advantage is C-1118). - Vertebrate brain
Predators "who have to implement various hunting strategies against the ever changing anti-predator adaptations, tend to have larger brains relative to body size than their prey". - Vervet monkey (Chlorocebus pygerythrus)
SIV and vervets have co-evolved for over half a million years with strong polygenic selection on viral-process genes, and infection persists at high loads without progression: both sides shaped, neither ousting the other; the virus's own improvement is not shown in the sources read - Vulnerability management
Patch and exploit race: each patch arms attackers (exploits in minutes, Exploit Wednesday); defenders answer with faster cadence (home updates as soon as ready from 2015) and exploit prediction; time-to-patch stays months long. The stalemate is read from the sources, not measured as such. - Wireless network
Link security against its attackers: WEP broken, replaced by WPA (2003), WPA2 (2004); the 4-way handshake, 'proven secure', stood 14 years until key reinstallation attacks found 'every Wi-Fi device is vulnerable to some variant'; WPA3 followed in 2018. Both sides improve; whether either gains ground
Surface: a resemblance (78)
- American literature
abolitionist and anti-Tom novels both bestsellers in the 1850s; the Booker as a British countermove against US publishers: contests with answers on both sides, but neither source shows both improving with no ground gained - Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
Two-sided pressure without a shown stalemate: antibodies 'drive mutations in viral surface proteins' and immune escape, and IGH haplotypes are under putative positive selection. The firing rule needs both sides improving and neither gaining ground; no source read shows that, so surface. - Archaeon (Archaea)
Arms-race material without the stalemate shown: defence genes enriched in archaea and hyperthermophiles, CRISPR-Cas likely born there; most archaea-specific viruses keep a chronic infection. - Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
Persuasion and vigilance: arguers produce arguments that look valid but are not, hearers develop ways to spot them (fallacy lists, critical questions); manuals taught both the tricks and how to rebut them. - Bumblebee colony
Cuckoo bumblebees and hosts coevolve (cuckoos resemble their hosts more than by chance), but no stalemate is shown. - Cephalopods (octopus, squid, cuttlefish, nautilus)
Mesozoic Marine Revolution: 'coevolution between marine predators and prey' with coleoid turnover around 100 Ma. - Chaos and nonlinear dynamics (the practice, and the chaotic behaviour it studies)
Gene-for-gene co-evolution of crop and pathogen sometimes shows chaotic allele frequencies. Surface: the stalemate is not shown in the source. - Climate change
About half of species assessed are moving polewards or upslope, and warm-edge populations die out (47.1% of 976 species): running to stay in a climate that moves. The firing rule fails: one side is a physical driver, not an improving opponent, so there is no stalemate between two improving sides. - Cloud computing
Attackers find co-residence 10x easier than a secure placement; providers change placement and isolation; the sources read do not show both sides improving to a stalemate. - Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest)
Two generators race for share of one pool; the faster (EI, 'very short time scale') wins by number, the slower (CNS) answers by changing how members are counted (by ancestry), not by going faster. - Computer science (the field: the practice and the computation it studies)
Modern cryptography studies 'distributed computations that can be attacked': attack and defence both improve. - Condensed matter physics
Neutron and X-ray sources both improve (instruments 10-fold per decade; synchrotrons and X-FELs brighter), each holding its ground in its own slice (hydrogen, bulk, 0-0.1 eV for neutrons; small samples and sensitivity for X-rays). Surface: the source shows co-improvement and partition, not a stalema - Corporate law
Delaware must amend every year and states keep adding protections (antitakeover statutes; Texas's business court 2024; Nevada's director protections) — but the stalemate is not shown: Delaware's share held or grew (58-59% in 2002; over two-thirds of the Fortune 500 in 2025). Arms-race language witho - Critical infrastructure
Supply and demand compete and tune grids to a critical point where neither margin nor load wins (Odor); attackers and defenders both advance as digitalisation grows (encyclopedia). Neither source shows both sides improving with neither gaining ground, so surface. - Cumulative culture (cumulative cultural evolution)
Memes 'could well be in conflict with their biological host's genetic interests'; DIT models conflicts between cultural and genetic evolution (Boyd & Richerson 1985). - Data centre
Efficiency gains kept US data-centre electricity nearly flat while services grew (2010-2016); accelerated servers then outran them. Two trends, not two adversaries. - Data structure
Workloads and hardware keep changing and designs keep being remade to stay in place: 'even small changes in the workload or the hardware lead to a redesign of access methods'. - Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma)
Acritarch species survived for hundreds of millions of years, 'but after 1 Ga, species duration dropped to about 100 Ma, perhaps due to increased herbivory by early protists', consistent with a further drop after the Cambrian explosion. One side only; no escalation stated. - Electrical grid
Loads rise and infrastructure is extended; in Dobson's reading neither gets ahead and the grid stays near its critical point. - End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released
Checked and not found: Brusatte 2008 saw no coupled rate change between dinosaurs and crurotarsans over about 30 Myr, so the rise reads as contingency, not an escalating race. - Essay
mills against detection and adversarial answers against automated scorers: each side improves (mills' use 'appears to be increasing'; detectors compare against databases; neural scorers shown vulnerable); the stalemate itself is not shown in the sources - Eukaryote
the nucleus as a defence against invading self-splicing introns from the endosymbiont (an arms race named, no stalemate shown) - Eye
Predators' eyes and prey's concealment escalate (the Cambrian arms race; the pressure for transparent eyes); the sources read show escalation, not the stalemate the firing rule needs. - Financial statement
Manipulation and detection both improve (accrual to real-activity techniques; M-scores, Benford tests, machine learning), but no source read shows the stalemate. - Fish school (shoal)
Predators select for coordinated prey; predators counter with herding, slashing, tail-stunning and lunging. - Formal security policy model
Covert channels and models keep running: storage channels closed by proof, timing channels then only reduced in bandwidth ('the best that can be expected is to reduce channel bandwidth'); a bandwidth bar (100 bits per second) rather than a win. Neither side's improvement shown as stalemate over time - Globalization
Biosecurity rules tighten while introductions keep rising: 'past efforts to mitigate invasions have not been effective enough to keep up with increasing globalization'. Introductions are winning, not a stalemate: the dark twin. - Grammar (the structure of a language, as linguistics describes it)
Language as a 'moving target' changing faster than genes could adapt to it. - Historiography
Rival schools and journals keep running: Revue des questions historiques and Revue historique 'would continue to duel at least until' 1915; narrative and quantification each counter-attack (Graff, Stone). No stalemate measure in the sources read. - Honeybee (western honey bee, Apis mellifera)
Varroa and bees: feral bees slowly select for Varroa resistance while mites become resistant to miticides - Insider threat
The insider reads the watcher (Hanssen searched case records) while the organisation adds monitoring; both sides adapt, but no source shows a stalemate. - Insurance
Cyber insurers and attackers: the constantly evolving nature of cyber-threats keeps loss distributions moving and data never complete; fraud and fraud detection likewise. No source read shows the stalemate (both improving, neither gaining). - Internet protocol suite (TCP/IP): the layered datagram protocols every host and router runs, the RFC record that specifies them, and the community that keeps them
Middleboxes adapt to the wire image; protocols encrypt and grease to evade them; neither side is shown gaining for good. - Interpersonal communication
Liars against lie catchers: detection near 54% across 206 documents, with rates varying little; no source read shows both sides improving - Intrinsically disordered protein (no single fold)
Viruses mimic and hijack host linear motifs. - Japanese tit (Parus minor)
Snakes and cavity nesters: snake-specific calls and an unlearned escape possibly as old as the tit family, born in snake-rich Asia; snakes still take eggs and adults each season (up to 8% of incubating females) - Journalism
Misinformation and its checkers both improve (bots, automated fact-checking), with no stalemate shown in the sources read. - Large language model
Prompt injections and jailbreaks against an instruction hierarchy trained to resist them; the stalemate is not shown in the source read. - Lateral line
Predators and prey both read flow: prey larvae escape strikes by sensing the predator's flow; predators hunt by their lateral lines; schooling may confuse predators' lateral lines. - LLM-based agent
Prompt injection against the instruction hierarchy: attacks and trained defences both improve; no stalemate shown in the abstract read. - Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
Persuaders and evaluators: on the argumentative theory reasoning devises arguments to persuade and evaluates others' arguments, given people's vulnerability to misinformation; an arms race is implied, the stalemate not shown. - Marketing
Sellers each try to satisfy customers 'more effectively than its competitors'; in the product life cycle entrants push prices down at maturity. Both sides improving with no ground gained is not measured in the sources read. - Mathematical logic: the field that studies logic within mathematics (model theory, proof theory, set theory, computability theory) and the formal systems, structures and limit results it works on
A treadmill without a second side: adding the undecidable sentence as an axiom makes a new system with a new undecidable sentence, so axioms added never gain ground. Surface: no two improving sides. - Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)
Lasting disagreement on metaphysical issues read by critics as lack of progress; the sources do not show both sides improving. - Middle English literature
Wycliffite Bible against the licensed alternative: both copied widely, the Wycliffite texts the most common and Love's Meditations the second most common surviving manuscripts. Neither displaced the other, but both sides improving is not shown. - Modified gravity
Tests tighten and theories adjust: 'As experimental tests get more accurate, the deviation of the scalar-tensor theories from general relativity is being squashed to zero'; GW170817 removed many at once. - Neocortex (six-layered isocortex)
'The neocortex increased in size in response to pressures for greater cooperation and competition in early ancestors' (primate-lineage statement). - Nonverbal communication
Liars and lie catchers: liars add eye contact and use tone and face to seem truthful while lie catchers watch the body; cues stay faint and catchers mediocre - Numeracy
Looked: rising school attainment and rising numerical demands of adult life could hold the share of low-numerate adults in place; no source read shows both sides moving. - Open-source software
Attackers and maintainers both improve (xz's years-long trust building; supply-chain scrutiny), but no stalemate is sourced. - Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca)
Bigg's go silent because their prey listen; seals learn which orca calls mean danger - Organism (the living thing, as biology describes it)
'cellular life was already involved in an arms race with viruses at the time of LUCA'. - Organization
The field names the shape for organisations (Barnett and Hansen, 'The red queen in organizational evolution', read title-only). Both sides improving with neither gaining ground is not shown in what was read. - Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
Schools improve their arguments for centuries without one winning: 'different philosophers often defend mutually incompatible claims'; the 2020 survey splits three ways on normative ethics. Both sides improving is not measured, so surface only. - Photography
Image forgers and detectors: synthetic faces have 'passed through the uncanny valley' while detection 'is not efficient or accurate enough'; sensor fingerprints are suppressed by pipelines, then recovered by better comparison - Plant (kingdom Plantae)
Neighbours shade each other and each grows quickly to keep its exposure. - Plant seed
Seed defences (hard coat, compounds 'to discourage herbivores and seed predators') against predators that take 'around 60% of all dispersed seeds within a few days' (Myrmecochory). - Play
Play fighting: both partners improve and neither wins, but the stalemate is held by cooperation (turn taking), not by an arms race. - Political party
Two-party competition pulls both parties toward the centre, each moving against the other with neither pulling ahead (the Hotelling-Downs tendency); the source shows the convergence, not a sourced stalemate in fitness. - Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies)
Out-group polarization: across nine countries both sides' audiences escalate toxicity toward each other while out-group talk gets less engagement; neither gains ground. Not shown as both improving. - Primate (order Primates)
'Predators of primates have diverse hunting strategies and as such, primates have evolved several different antipredator adaptations', including separate alarm calls for air-borne and ground predators. - Quantum entanglement
each closed loophole is answered by a narrower local-realist escape (detection, locality, freedom of choice pushed back 600 years, then 7.8 billion years; superdeterminism 'might never get closed'). Surface: the experiments gain ground; there is no stalemate between two improving sides - Rock
Not seen as a stalemate here: rock is always forced out of equilibrium and always changing toward the next setting, but nothing on the other side is improving; booked as a near miss (moving target without two improving sides). - Science (as a human social and cultural system)
Fraud and defence escalate: fake reviewer contacts exposed in 2014, then a COPE warning and 107 retractions in 2015; p-hacking met by pre-registration and result-blind review. The sources do not call it an arms race. - Security policy and governance
Both sides keep moving: governance standards evolve and 'new legislation is frequently introduced' while threats evolve; policy revised to keep up. The stalemate (neither gaining) is not shown. - Skin
S. aureus has evolved responses to the acidic skin surface that is less accommodating to it - Social class
Class conflict read as an arms race: 'an uninterrupted, now hidden, now open fight' between oppressor and oppressed, each epoch replacing old classes with new ones ('new forms of struggle in place of the old ones'), the antagonism kept rather than won (Marx and Engels' reading, C-2445). - Sorting algorithm
Adversarial inputs against quicksort's pivot rules (deliberate attacks, DoS) answered by randomization and pattern breaking; pdqsort forces an attacker to generate good quicksort progress. - Sound
Bats hunt with ultrasound; night insects listen for it and tiger moths click back 'which may disturb bats' echolocation'. Both sides' moves are shown; the stalemate (neither gaining ground) is not, so the firing rule is unmet - Sperm whale (cachalot, Physeter macrocephalus)
Orcas and sperm whales described as 'fairly evenly matched'; attacks on bulls documented and none successful - Spiders (order Araneae)
Spiders and sphecid wasps: non-orb webs' greater success 'may be because sphecid wasps, which are often the dominant predators of spiders, much prefer to attack spiders that have flat webs'. - String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
Critics read the programme race as escalating: competition for scarce positions drives bandwagons (Penrose, Woit); rival programmes answer (Smolin's prescriptions for diversity). - Strong cosmic censorship hypothesis
Exterior damping against interior blueshift: the outcome is a race between how fast the outside rings down and how fast the inside amplifies. - Syntax: how a language combines words into phrases and sentences (constituency and dependency, word order, agreement, recursion), how speakers build and parse it, how children learn it, how it differs across languages, and the field that studies it
Two pressures pull against each other (simple for the speaker, unambiguous for the hearer) and grammars settle at a balance; no source shows both improving with neither gaining, so only the tug is seen. - The world through the senses (sensory environment)
Jurassic singing insects and early mammalian predators: an arms race likely drove insect song diversity and both auditory systems (stalemate not shown) - Truth
Liars and lie detectors: deception is met by detection that stays slightly above chance; in monkeys deceptive alarms rise with competition but no counter-deception is found. Both sides improving is not shown. - Voting
Franchise contests: Jim Crow restrictions 1888-1908, then the VRA's protections and preclearance (1965), then post-Shelby (2013) cuts to early voting and roll purges: each side improving its tools over decades. - William Shakespeare
Rival companies and the War of the Theatres: playwrights satirising one another, the boy company a 'genuine rival'; no stalemate of mutual improvement is shown.