← all systems · see it in The System
End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released
The Permian–Triassic extinction event was an extinction event that occurred around the boundary between the Permian and Triassic geologic periods, and with them the Paleozoic and Mesozoic eras. It is Earth's most severe known extinction event, with the extinction of 57% of biological families, 62% of genera, 81% of marine species, and 70% of terrestrial vertebrate species. Walked here as a release: 'In the wake of the extinction event, the ecological structure of the present-day biosphere evolved from the stock of surviving taxa.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the crisis around the Permian-Triassic boundary (the main marine pulse between 251.941 +/- 0.037 and 251.880 +/- 0.031 Ma, with land and precursor stress from the late Changhsingian), the doors and loops that broke (the carbon thermostat, ocean oxygen, seawater carbonate saturation, the ozone shield, the vegetation-soil cover), the survivors and refugia, the disaster taxa, and the Early to Middle Triassic recovery and radiation, to the Anisian and its long tail. Outside: the mantle plume that fed the Siberian Traps, Pangaea's layout, the Capitanian crisis 7-10 Myr earlier, and Earth's long-term carbon cycle that sets the event's terms. |
| nested level | Built from a trigger (Siberian Traps magmatism into carbon-rich basin rocks), the kill chains it set running through air, sea and land (heat, acid, anoxia and euxinia, UV, metals, aridity), the losers (the Paleozoic evolutionary fauna, the forests), the winners and survivors (microbes, disaster taxa, archosauromorphs, cynodonts, bivalves) and the emptied ecospace they refilled. It ends sys:paleozoic-earth and opens sys:mesozoic-earth; it is the largest of the Big Five within the Phanerozoic Eon. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (55) published science
| main extinction interval (U-Pb zircon, Meishan) | 251.941 +/- 0.037 to 251.880 +/- 0.031 Ma |
| characteristic clock: duration of the main extinction | 60 +/- 48 thousand years |
| major marine pulse | 60,000-100,000 year interval around 251.902 Ma |
| Permian-Triassic boundary (base of the Triassic and Mesozoic) | 251.902; GSSP Meishan, China, marked by the first appearance of the conodont Hindeodus parvus Ma |
| Triassic Period (the recovery's span) start-end | 251.902 to 201.4; 50.5 Myr Ma |
| Early Triassic thermal events: Dienerian Cooling / Latest Smithian Thermal Maximum / Latest Olenekian Cooling | 251-249 / about 249-248 / 248-247 (LOC cooled about 6 C) Ma |
| losses: families / genera / marine species / terrestrial vertebrate species | 57% / 62% / 81% / 70% |
| older estimate of marine species loss (conflated with the end-Capitanian) | 90-96 % |
| South China marine invertebrate genera lost in the final two Permian conodont zones | 286 of 329 genera |
| genus extinction by group: trilobites, blastoids, hyoliths / crinoids, gastropods / ammonites, foraminiferans / brachiopods, anthozoans / radiolarians / bryozoans / ostracods / bivalves | 100 / 98 / 97 / 96 / 99 / 79 / 74 / 59 % of genera |
| hypercapnia-vulnerable calcareous genera lost; conodont genera lost | about 81; 33 % |
| negative carbon isotope excursion: magnitude; duration | 4-7 (the source writes %); about 500,000 years per mil (as written: %); years |
| atmospheric CO2 before to after (one study); alternative estimate | about 400 to 2,500; 500-4,000 to about 8,000 ppm |
| carbon added to the ocean-atmosphere system | 3,900 to 12,000 gigatonnes C |
| lag between volcanic CO2 rise and global warming (one study) | 12,000 to 128,000 years |
| global average surface temperature: latest Permian / peak | about 18.2 / up to 35 C |
| hyperthermal duration | as long as 500,000 years |
| warming: Gondwana high-latitude air / low-latitude surface water (South China) | about 10-14 / about 8 C |
| tropical sea surface temperature, Iran: Changhsingian / PTME | 27-33 / over 35 C |
| ocean pH decrease | up to 0.7 pH units |
| CO2 solubility in water relative to oxygen | 28 times |
| ozone production reduction; UV flux increase equator / poles | 60-70%; 400% / 5,000% |
| Siberian Traps lava extruded (area) | over 2,000,000 km2 |
| Siberian Traps today: basalt area / volume | about 7 million / about 4 million km2 / km3 |
| characteristic clock: Siberian Traps eruptions duration | roughly two million years |
| Siberian Traps volatiles (Yang 2013): CO2 / CO / H2S / SO2 | 8.5 x 10^7 / 4.4 x 10^6 / 7.0 x 10^6 / 6.8 x 10^7 Tg |
| halogen content released; hydrochloric acid emitted | as much as 70%; about 18 %; teratonnes |
| Siberian Traps output as pyroclastic ash | 20 % |
| CO2 emission rate relative to the Capitanian (Emeishan) crisis | about five times faster ratio |
| characteristic clock: mercury poisoning surges | a thousand years each; surge lasting 500 kyr after the initial spike |
| Choiyoi Silicic LIP: span / volume / area / size relative to Siberian Traps | about 286 to 247 Ma / 1,300,000 km3 / 1,680,000 km2 / 40% |
| Araguainha crater age; methane released; impact energy | 254.7 +/- 2.5 Ma; about 1.6 teratonnes; 10^5 to 10^6 Mt TNT (about two orders of magnitude below that thought needed for a mass extinction) |
| terrestrial onset before marine (one view); Kuznetsk forest loss | 60,000-370,000 years earlier; about 252.76 Ma, about 820,000 years before the South China marine extinction |
| Glossopteris flora collapse in Australia, before the boundary | about 370,000 years |
| decline of marine species richness ahead of ecosystem collapse (one study) | about 61,000 years |
| ostracod and brachiopod extinctions separated by | 670,000 to 1.17 million years |
| end-Capitanian crisis before the PTME | 7-10 million years |
| Lystrosaurus share of some earliest Triassic land vertebrate faunas | as much as 90 % |
| post-extinction foraminifer mean body size relative to before | 15 % |
| brachiopod recovery begins (Meishanorhynchia) | 250.1 +/- 0.3 Ma |
| characteristic clock: ammonoids exceed pre-extinction diversity | two million years after the crisis |
| characteristic clock: seafloor communities low in diversity | about 4 million years after the event |
| Paris biota local rebound | around 1.3 million years |
| characteristic clock: recovery to the Middle Triassic (one estimate) | 10 million years |
| characteristic clock: worldwide recovery of gymnosperm forests | about 4-5 million years |
| characteristic clock: lacustrine ecosystems recover | about 10 million years |
| characteristic clock: full recovery of terrestrial vertebrate fauna (Benton) | 30 million years |
| marine ecological recovery still ongoing (one study) | 50 million years after the extinction |
| global marine diversity back to pre-extinction values | about 75 million (Middle Jurassic) years |
| insect orders extinct; greatly reduced | eight or nine; ten orders |
| insect fossil-record gap, late Permian to early Triassic | about 15 million years |
| sessile share of marine animals: before / Mesozoic | about two-thirds / about half fraction |
| complex to simple marine communities after recovery | nearly three to one ratio |
| Karoo Basin terrestrial vertebrates extinct in the 300,000 years before the boundary (one study); due to the PTME (another) | 69; 54 % |
| peat-producing plants locally extinct at the boundary, eastern Australia | about 95 % |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (5) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same shape, opposite sign (structural)
The Cambrian substrate revolution run backwards: in the Cambrian, burrowers broke the mats and opened the sediment; in the earliest Triassic, with bioturbators gone, mats spread again (MISS, microbial reefs) in ecosystems 'denuded of bioturbators that would have otherwise prevented their widespread - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
Two barriers in play. The ozone shield weakened and UV reached plants (malformed spores). And the mats, back as a seal over the seafloor, were also a shelter: 'post-extinction microbial mats played a vital, indispensable role in the survival and recovery of various bioturbating organisms', whose ret - lightning (partial)
Charge, threshold, runaway, exhaustion: carbon stored in Tungus basin rocks is fired by sills; inputs 'overwhelming inorganic carbon sinks'; reinforcing loops (warm saline bottom water, phosphate recycling, silicate-sink loss) carry it; the hyperthermal lasts as long as 500,000 years and decays. Unl - red-queen (partial)
The recovery turned into an arms race: increased predation pressure and durophagy 'led to the Mesozoic Marine Revolution'; prey answered by infaunal habit, mobility, sculpture and autotomy, while sessile forms that could not reattach were 'picked off as easy prey'. - same role, different builds (partial)
Oxygen transport by different molecules decided survival: 'organisms that relied on haemocyanin or haemoglobin for transporting oxygen were more resistant to extinction than those utilizing hemerythrin or oxygen diffusion'. Two different builds of the same role both came through; the other builds of
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (20) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Atmospheric methane (the methane reservoir of Earth's air) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released loss
- Nickel atom via sys:aqueous-solution · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released mixed
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life) via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Earth in the Mesozoic era via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released even
- Hydrosphere (Earth's planetary water, above all the early ocean) via sys:aqueous-solution · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Dioxygen (O2) via sys:redox-gradient · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Bacterium (bacterial cell) via sys:redox-gradient · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Biofilm via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Methanogen (partner species, a cell) via sys:redox-gradient · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian) via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released even
- Paleozoic evolutionary fauna via sys:aqueous-solution · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Siberian Traps (trigger) via sys:mantle-convection · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Modern evolutionary fauna (radiation) via sys:seafloor-sediment · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Archosaurs (dinosaurs, crocodylomorphs, pterosaurs) via sys:mineral-surface · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Vascular plants (tracheophytes) via sys:mineral-surface · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released gain
- Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers) via sys:trophic-network · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released even
- Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls) via sys:mineral-surface · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released even
- Hydrogen sulfide via sys:redox-gradient · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released loss
- Igneous rock via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Permian extinction (the Great Dying), with the Triassic recovery it released loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (12)
- Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
- Bacterium (bacterial cell)
- Biofilm
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life)
- Paleozoic evolutionary fauna
- Siberian Traps (trigger)
- Modern evolutionary fauna (radiation)
- Lystrosaurus (disaster taxon on land)
- Therapsids (dicynodonts, therocephalians, cynodonts)
- Terrestrial ecospace
- Archosaurs (dinosaurs, crocodylomorphs, pterosaurs)
- Vascular plants (tracheophytes)
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (2)
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- The setting made the killer: 'the unique setting of the Siberian Traps over these deposits is likely the reason for the severity of the extinction'. A similar province, Choiyoi at 40% the size, only took out one regional flora; the Siberian sills cooked a basin of coal, carbonate and salt, and the switch to sills 'coincides with the main onset of the extinction'.
- Recovery waited for rivals: early Triassic seafloors recovered slowly because there were too few species to compete, then 'explosively accelerated in the Anisian' through niche crowding, a loop that fed on itself. Competition was the engine of rebuilding, not the brake.
- The Cambrian rewound: with the burrowers gone, microbial mats crept back over the seafloor and the land, and they sheltered the first burrowers to return, which then ended them again. Meanwhile the winners of the first hours were the oldest kinds of life: sulfate reducers and green sulfur bacteria, whose sunlit sulfide biomarkers show the poison reached the surface of the sea.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
atmosphere chemistry and radiation (CO2, SO2, halogens, ozone, UV)
- L1: Air carrying the volcanic gases worldwide: CO2 from about 400 to 2,500 ppm, 3,900-12,000 Gt C added to the ocean-atmosphere system
- L2: Greenhouse warming: global average surface temperature from about 18.2 C to as much as 35 C, the hyperthermal lasting as long as 500,000 years; a lag of 12,000-128,000 years after emissions in one study; stronger El Nino events
- L3: Sulfur aerosols and ash: dust clouds and acid aerosols blocking sunlight and disrupting photosynthesis; brief but severe cooling; acid rain as the aerosols washed out
- L4: Ozone shield: production may have fallen 60-70%, raising UV flux 400% at the equator and 5,000% at the poles; destroyed by halogens, organohalogens, sulfate aerosols, methane and perhaps H2S
- L5: UV and acid reach life: malformed spores with more UV-B absorbing compounds; positive delta-33S anomalies from photolysis of volcanic SO2; acid rain 'may have killed land plants and mollusks and planktonic organisms with calcium carbonate shells'
heat and aerobic scope (warming, oxygen solubility, metabolic demand)
- L1: Warm water: low-latitude surface waters up about 8 C (conodont apatite, South China); Iran's tropical seas from 27-33 C to over 35 C; Gondwana high-latitude air up about 10-14 C
- L2: Warming 'would reduce the solubility of oxygen in seawater, causing the concentration of oxygen to decline'; warm saline bottom water depleted in oxygen and nutrients spreads through the deep ocean
- L3: Aerobic scope: model simulations reproduce the warming and oxygen loss and test survival with the Metabolic Index, a measure of aerobic scope
- L4: Biogeography: modelled aerobic habitat loss predicts lower extinction intensity in the tropics, confirmed in the fossil record; high-latitude organisms 'are unable to escape from warming, hypoxic waters at the poles'
- L5: Lethal heat on land: a tetrapod gap may have existed from the Induan until the early Spathian between about 30 N and 40 S; 'the Early Triassic was the hottest portion of the entire Phanerozoic'
land surface, soil and vegetation (weathering, acid rain, erosion, forests, food chains)
- L1: Pangaea's land surface: deserts across the interior; aridity 'well underway even before the PTME as a result of the coalescence of the supercontinent'
- L2: Acid on land: CO2 in soil and SO2 in rain; elevated Ba/Sr ratios in earliest Triassic soils; vermiculitic clays in Shansi; mercury and other heavy metals raising mutagenesis in surviving plants
- L3: Roots lost: rivers switch from meandering to braided, 'signifying the widespread demise of rooted plants'; soil erosion carries terrestrially derived organic sediment into the sea
- L4: Forests gone: Glossopteris collapse in Australia about 370,000 years before the boundary; Cordaites and gigantopterid forests collapse; wildfires; the Early Triassic coal gap; lycophyte pioneers (Pleuromeia, Tomiostrobus)
- L5: Food chain unwinds upward: 'aridity-induced extinctions that progressively ascended the food chain'; high herbivore mortality drove carnivore extinctions; large herbivores suffered most
- L6: Recovery on land: gymnosperm forests in about 4-5 Myr; lakes in about 10 Myr; land vertebrates complete only after about 30 Myr (Benton), when the first dinosaurs and mammals had risen; archosaurs displace therapsids
mantle plume and sill intrusion (Siberian Traps magmatism)
- L1: A mantle plume rising until it reached the bottom of the Earth's crust, producing volcanic eruptions through the Siberian Craton
- L2: Flood basalt in 'a few enormous pulses of magma, as opposed to more regular flows'; lava over 2,000,000 km2; about 20% of the output pyroclastic ash thrown high into the atmosphere
- L3: Sills intruding the Tungus Syneclise: Early-Mid Paleozoic carbonates and evaporites and Carboniferous-Permian coal-bearing rocks, which 'when heated ... may emit large amounts of greenhouse and toxic gases'; intermediate magma temperature optimised CO2 release
- L4: Volatile release: 8.5 x 10^7 Tg CO2, 4.4 x 10^6 Tg CO, 7.0 x 10^6 Tg H2S, 6.8 x 10^7 Tg SO2 (Yang 2013); up to 70% of lithospheric halogens, about 18 teratonnes of HCl; mercury, nickel, cobalt, arsenic; coal-fly ash
- L5: Emplacement style sets the dose: the change from flood basalt to sill-dominated emplacement 'coincides with the main onset of the extinction'; sills cannot be weathered to sequester CO2, as subaerial basalts are
- L6: Recurrence: 'massive Siberian Traps activity recurred multiple times during the Early Triassic', linked to the Smithian-Spathian, Olenekian-Anisian, Middle-Late Anisian and Anisian-Ladinian crises
ocean oxygen and sulfide (anoxia, euxinia, nutrients)
- L1: Oxygenated and anoxic zones of Panthalassa and Tethys; evidence for anoxia appears at the extinction through most of both oceans (pyrite framboids, uranium and nitrogen isotope excursions, laminated sediments)
- L2: Nutrients in: soil erosion, faster weathering and runoff, and direct Siberian iron and phosphorus 'triggering bioblooms and marine snowstorms'; upwelling of nutrient-rich deep water off South China
- L3: Respiration of sinking organic matter lowers deep oxygen; 'deep water anoxia tends to increase the recycling efficiency of phosphate, leading to even higher productivity'
- L4: Euxinia: sulfate-reducing bacteria thrive and make hydrogen sulfide; green sulfur bacteria biomarkers (isorenieratane) show sulfide in the photic zone; negative mercury isotope excursions
- L5: Oxygen-minimum zones migrate (deep water organisms first, then shallow, then bottom); reexpansions until the late Spathian 'periodically setting back and restarting the biotic recovery'; Panthalassan pelagic anoxia as late as the Anisian
seafloor sediment and benthos (bioturbation, mats, reefs, benthic communities)
- L1: Permian seafloor: about two-thirds of marine animals sessile and attached; complex and simple communities equally common
- L2: Bioturbators 'extremely severely affected, as evidenced by the loss of the sedimentary mixed layer in many marine facies'
- L3: Microbial cover returns: microbial reefs common across shallow seas in the earliest Triassic; microbially induced sedimentary structures with opportunistic bivalves and vertical burrows; mats 'played a vital, indispensable role in the survival and recovery of various bioturbating organisms'
- L4: Disaster taxa: species-poor, cosmopolitan faunas dominated by Claraia, Unionites, Eumorphotis, Promyalina, Lingularia, Earlandia; low guild diversity; a flat latitudinal diversity gradient; Lilliput-sized survivors
- L5: Competition-paced recovery: slow in the Early Triassic because low diversity meant low competition; explosive in the Anisian through niche crowding, 'a positive feedback loop enhancing itself'; recurrent stress capped complexity until the Spathian
- L6: The modern fauna: about half of marine animals sessile, the rest free-living; complex communities outnumber simple ones nearly three to one; predation and durophagy lead to the Mesozoic Marine Revolution, now thought to start in the Anisian
seawater carbonate chemistry (CO2, pH, calcification)
- L1: Seawater taking up CO2, which is 28 times more soluble in water than oxygen
- L2: Acidification: pH down by up to 0.7 units; an extreme aragonite sea; a carbonate production crisis a few thousand years after volcanic emissions began; most extreme at mid-latitudes
- L3: Hypercapnia in bodies: 'relatively modest but sustained increases in CO2 concentrations hamper the synthesis of proteins, reduce fertilization rates, and produce deformities in calcareous hard parts'
- L4: Selectivity: heavily calcified taxa with low metabolic rates and weak respiratory systems lost about 81% of genera; animals with high metabolism, good respiration and non-calcareous hard parts had negligible losses (conodonts lost 33%); haemocyanin or haemoglobin users outlasted hemerythrin or diffusion users
- L5: Persistence: highly elevated CO2 through the Early Triassic 'would have impeded the recovery of biocalcifying organisms'; minimal biomineralisation once recovery began, despite inorganic carbonates being deposited
Who fills each layer
- L2: Seafloor sediment (marine sediment)
- L4: Hydrogen sulfide, Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation)