← all systems · see it in The System
End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released
The Triassic Period ended with a mass extinction, which was particularly severe in the oceans; the conodonts disappeared, as did all the marine reptiles except ichthyosaurs and plesiosaurs. About 23% of all families, 48% of all genera (20% of marine families and 55% of marine genera) and 70% to 75% of all species became extinct. These extinctions within the Triassic and at its end allowed the dinosaurs to expand into many niches that had become unoccupied. Walked here as a release: the crisis, the doors that broke, who came through and why, and the radiation that filled the space.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the crisis at the Triassic-Jurassic boundary and its release. That is the CAMP's gas reaching the atmosphere and ocean; the doors that broke (carbonate building by reefs and shelled animals; warmth and light on land in volcanic winter); the losers (pseudosuchians except crocodylomorphs, conodonts, ceratite ammonoids, large temnospondyls, most synapsids, tropical reefs); the survivors (insulated dinosaurs, crocodylomorphs, pterosaurs, mammaliaforms, a handful of psiloceratid ammonites, conifers and cycadeoids); and the Early Jurassic radiation into the emptied niches. Outside: Pangaea's rifting and the mantle that set the trigger; the Mesozoic Earth the event sits in; the later Toarcian crisis. |
| nested level | Built from a trigger (the Central Atlantic magmatic province, a large igneous province at Pangaea's rift), two pools (land and marine ecospace), losers and survivors among vertebrate and invertebrate lineages. It sits at the boundary between Triassic and Jurassic Earth, inside the Mesozoic era. Its radiation feeds the Jurassic-Cretaceous 'Age of Dinosaurs'. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (27) published science
| base of the Jurassic (end of the Triassic) | 201.4 Ma |
| extinction date (encyclopedia) | 201.3 Ma |
| land extinction (end-Triassic extinction, ETE) | 201.6 Ma |
| large mafic magma bodies established (intrusive CAMP) | 201.635 +/- 0.029 Ma |
| first Culpeper Basin pulse (Mount Zion Church Basalt) | 201.566 +/- 0.031 Ma |
| CAMP last eruption (infobox) | 201.36 +/- 0.02 Ma |
| CAMP 40Ar/39Ar span; Moroccan lavas | 202 to 191; 199.5 +/- 0.5 (Recurrent unit 197 +/- 1) Ma |
| clock: CAMP eruptive pulse | no more than 100 years |
| clock: pulses spread over (eruptive phase) | about 600,000 years |
| clock: sedimentation between pulses (Midland Formation; Turkey Run) | about 40,000; 550,000 years |
| clock: volcanic winter | >10 (plausibly) years |
| clock: dinosaur dominance after the event | 135 million years |
| CAMP magmatism duration (other reading) | about 1 million years |
| CAMP area; eruptive volume | about 11 million (Triassic page: about 10 million); 2 to 6 million km2; km3 |
| losses, all life | 23% of families, 48% of genera, 70-75% of species fraction |
| losses, marine (three readings) | 20% families and 55% genera / 22% families and about half of genera / 46-72% of genera fraction |
| losses, marine life (Mesozoic page) | 34 % |
| Manicouagan impact melt; lead before the boundary | 214 +/- 1; about 10 +/- 2 Myr Ma; Myr |
| earlier extinction pulses (disputed) | end-Carnian/Norian about 228 Ma; basal archosauromorphs about 215 Ma; 'separated by 12 to 17 million years' |
| dinosaur-crurotarsan coexistence before the event | about 30 million years |
| Brusatte disparity dataset | 64 taxa, 437 characters |
| oldest dinosaurs (Santa Maria; Ischigualasto) | 233.23; 231-230 Ma |
| Junggar Basin palaeolatitude (lake ice) | 71.1 +/- 3.8 degrees N |
| Late Triassic to earliest Jurassic CO2 | generally above 2000 (estimates 1000 to 6000) ppm |
| CO2 warming predicted from CAMP | about 3 to 5 degrees C |
| largest tropical theropod maximum size increase | about 20 % |
| Rhaetian Cool Interval; Early Jurassic Cool Interval | 209-201; 199-183 Ma |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (11)
- Earth in the Mesozoic era
- Coral reef
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life)
- Dinosaurs (Dinosauria)
- Conodonts (stem-cyclostome jawless vertebrates)
- Ammonoids (bottleneck and rediversification)
- Central Atlantic magmatic province (CAMP; trigger)
- Pseudosuchians (losers, bar crocodylomorphs)
- Crocodylomorphs (surviving pseudosuchians)
- Mammal (class Mammalia)
- Terrestrial ecospace
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (10)
- Earth in the Mesozoic era via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Coral reef via sys:aqueous-solution · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Pangaea via sys:mantle-convection · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Dinosaurs (Dinosauria) via sys:thermal-energy · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Conodonts (stem-cyclostome jawless vertebrates) via sys:aqueous-solution · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Ammonoids (bottleneck and rediversification) via sys:aqueous-solution · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Central Atlantic magmatic province (CAMP; trigger) via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Pseudosuchians (losers, bar crocodylomorphs) via sys:thermal-energy · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Mammal (class Mammalia) via sys:thermal-energy · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released gain
- Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers) via sys:trophic-network · End-Triassic (Triassic-Jurassic) mass extinction, and the dinosaur radiation it released even
expressed by (1)
slides to (2)
- Ammonoids (bottleneck and rediversification)
- Dinosaurs vs pseudosuchians for Late Triassic land niches
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- The survivors had their coats on before winter came: at about 71 N, lake ice-rafted grains show freezing Arctic winters even under >2000 ppm CO2, and insulated dinosaurs were already living there. When CAMP's sulphur brought volcanic winters, large uninsulated reptiles (>1 m) died and the insulated dinosaurs walked through (Olsen 2022).
- The killer came as a strobe, not a blow: four CAMP pulses, each lasting no more than about 100 years, spread over about 600,000 years, with roughly 40,000 years between the first two, long enough for rift lakes and new ecosystems to settle in before the next pulse.
- Luck over superiority: across about 30 Myr side by side, dinosaurs had lower disparity and no faster evolution than the crurotarsans (64 taxa, 437 characters); they were 'the beneficiaries of two mass extinction events, and some good luck' (Brusatte 2008). In the sea the same bottleneck shape: every later Jurassic and Cretaceous ammonite descends from a handful of psiloceratid genera.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
atmosphere and climate: CAMP carbon and sulphur, volcanic winter then warming
- L1: The atmosphere receiving CAMP's large scale injection of carbon and sulphur
- L2: Sulphate gas forms sulfuric acid aerosols that absorb heat and cause substantial cooling: volcanic winters, 'plausibly extreme and long in duration (>10 years)', with lowered light
- L3: Carbon dioxide warming: the End-Triassic Thermal Event; CO2 bubbles in CAMP basalts show deep CO2 degassing
- L4: Sequence: the magmatism 'precipitated volcanic winters. This was followed by longer-term climate warming and ocean acidification'
- L5: Land extinction at 201.6 Ma: large-bodied (>1 m) terrestrial archosauromorphs went extinct during the initial CAMP eruptions
body heat and cold: insulation, endothermy and volcanic winter
- L1: Freezing winters in the forested Arctic despite very high CO2: lake ice-rafted grains (0.1 to 15 mm) in Junggar Basin mudstones at about 71 N
- L2: Insulation: non-avian dinosaurs primitively insulated (protofeather-like covering, inferred by phylogenetic bracket); mammaliaforms with fur and a higher metabolic rate
- L3: Before the crisis, insulated dinosaurs used Arctic vegetation; Triassic sauropodomorphs primarily inhabited cooler regions
- L4: Volcanic winter selects: large uninsulated reptiles die; small basal crocodylomorphs survive, possibly by burrowing
- L5: Dinosaurs expand in size and range (largest tropical theropods about 20% bigger) and dominate land communities for the next 135 Ma
land food webs and niches: guilds emptied and refilled
- L1: Plant food: no evidence of a mass extinction of plants at the boundary (but a complete sporomorph turnover in Greenland); surviving conifers and cycadeoids go on to dominate the Mesozoic
- L2: Herbivore guild: aetosaurs gone; sauropods become the dominant large herbivores in the Jurassic
- L3: Carnivore guild: rauisuchians, phytosaurs and ornithosuchids gone, 'leaving dinosaurs with little terrestrial competition'
- L4: Incumbency: dominance passes 'rarely because the newly dominant group is superior ... but usually because an extinction event eliminates the old, dominant group'; mammaliaforms 'could not compete in the large terrestrial vertebrate niches that dinosaurs monopolized'
- L5: Dinosaurs 'increasingly dominant, abundant and diverse' for the next 150 million years; crocodylomorphs radiate into different niches
mantle and magma: CAMP sills, dikes and flood basalts at Pangaea's rift
- L1: Pangaea under net extensional pull (slab pull from Panthalassa and Paleotethys subduction); rift valleys from about 247 Ma over old Rodinia and Pangea suture zones
- L2: Magma uses the zones of weakness as an easy route to the surface; well-established large mafic magma bodies by 201.635 +/- 0.029 Ma, about 100,000 years before the eruptions (intrusive start)
- L3: Four eruptive pulses, each no more than 100 years, spread over about 600,000 years; 2 to 6 million km3 over about 11 million km2; dikes up to 800 km long
- L4: The period of rifting came to an end with the emplacement of the CAMP around 201 Ma, followed by seafloor spreading and the opening of the Central Atlantic Ocean
seawater carbonate chemistry: acidification and the calcifiers
- L1: Seawater taking up CAMP's 'massive and rapid' CO2 release
- L2: Carbonate saturation falls: tentative evidence for a global paucity of carbonate across the extinction interval; full surface-ocean undersaturation possible but improbable
- L3: Calcification by reef builders and shelled animals: the extinction 'particularly selective against acid-sensitive organisms'; sessile filter feeders and photosymbiotic organisms among the most severely affected
- L4: Tropical reef ecosystems collapse; effects greatest at tropical latitudes and more severe in Panthalassa; 46%-72% of marine genera lost; conodonts and ceratite ammonoids die out
- L5: Release and refill: a handful of psiloceratid genera become ancestral to all later ammonites and diversify explosively; brachiopod orders rebound; reefs expand again only in the Late Jurassic