← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin)
Life today would 'instantly devour or absorb' the prebiotic organic stock, which closes the abiogenesis gate behind it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | with the first life: between 4.32 and 3.48 Gya; LUCA around 4.2 Gya |
| born precision | hundreds of millions of years |
| boundary | Inside: the organic stock in surface water (amino acids, nucleobases, sugars and the short polymers made from them, in ponds, hot-spring pools, ice-melt pools and vent pores), what fills it (synthesis by UV, discharges, impact shocks and redox; delivery by comets, meteorites and dust), what concentrates or dilutes it (wet-dry cycles; seawater dilution at vents), and the takers' drawing layers (RNA chains taking nucleotides; heterotrophic first life using the organics). Outside: the takers' own insides (genetics, membranes, enzymes), the Sun and the planet's interior as energy sources, and the autotrophs that later make organic carbon from CO2. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | A Compete triangle on the young Earth: the pool is the prebiotic soup (Oparin-Haldane), filled by abiogenesis chemistry and by delivery from space; the takers are RNA replicators (hypothesised first) and heterotrophic cells. Embedded in the Hadean-Archean surface waters. Still running in Darwin's sense: any organics made today are 'instantly devoured or absorbed'. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (28) published science
| age of the Earth | 4.54 Gya |
| window in which life most likely emerged | 4.32 to 3.48 Gya |
| LUCA age (2024 study) | about 4.2 (4.09-4.33) Gya |
| chemical events between the pre-RNA world and near-LUCA, just involving RNA | over 30 events |
| outcome: surviving lineage | one: all subsequent life forms descend from the LUCA lineages |
| autocatalytic set of ribozymes produced by molecular competition (in vitro evolution): self-replication time | about 1 hour |
| Darwin's letter to Hooker | 1 February 1871 date |
| soup's time window | around 3.7 to 4.0 billion years ago Gya |
| window for life's emergence | between 4.32 and 3.48 Gya |
| LUCA's age | around 4.2 Gya (4.09-4.33 Gya), 2024 study; molecular clock 'prior to 3.9 Gya' |
| organic delivery by meteorites during the Late Heavy Bombardment | up to five million tons per year t/yr |
| cosmic dust falling on Earth today | 40,000 t/yr |
| prebiotic organic production at hydrothermal vents | 10^8 kg/yr (estimate) |
| RNA autocatalytic set replication time | about an hour |
| characteristic clock: draw-down to scarcity | not given in the sources read: the turn from abundant organic carbon to 'more scarce than inorganic carbon' is undated |
| Miller-Urey amino acids | over 40 different amino acids in re-analyses of the 1953 experiment kinds |
| RNA folding temperature limit | folding hindered above 30 C |
| Archaean surface temperature (reconstructions) | 0-40 C |
| young Sun's luminosity | about 25% weaker than today |
| time for RNA polymers after meteorite deposition (model) | less than a few years yr |
| RNA polymers likely appeared before (model) | 4.17 Gya |
| cross-replicating RNA enzyme doubling time | about 1 hour |
| LUCA's age (divergence-time analysis) | ~4.2 Ga (4.09-4.33 Ga) |
| net organic production in an intermediate atmosphere ([H2]/[CO2] about 0.1) | some three orders of magnitude lower than for reducing atmospheres relative |
| phosphate in carbonate-rich lakes | >1 molal (theory and experiment); Goodenough and Last Chance Lakes can exceed 50 mM total P on drying molal / mM |
| phosphate in most natural waters | generally limited to micromolar levels M |
| protein families traced to LUCA | 355 of 286,514 clusters (~0.1%) families |
| host-parasite RNA replication experiment | 43 rounds, 215 hr (earlier run); regular oscillation in rounds one to ~35 of the long run |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-172 How did the last common ancestor of all life get its food?
booked: The map keeps both main views without ranking them: a self-feeding ancestor living on carbon dioxide, or one that fed on ready-made organic matter.
the other reading: early cellular life autotrophs on CO2 at vents or geothermal ponds; 'Alternative theories of an autotrophic origin of life contradict this theory'; papers for the alt: LUCA 'anaerobic, CO2-fixing, H2-dependent' supporting 'an autotrophic origin of life' (Weiss 2016); LUCA 'an anaerobic autotroph using the WLP' that may also have grown organoheterotrophically (Moody 2024); the first heterotrophs ate 'cell mass' (Schoenheit 2016) - C-181 Was RNA the first molecule to carry genetic information?
booked: The map follows the widely accepted RNA world, and keeps the idea of an earlier pre-RNA molecule alongside.
the other reading: a pre-RNA molecule first (TAP, melamine, barbituric acid candidates) - C-182 Did natural chemical gradients at deep-sea vents power the first cells?
booked: The map keeps the vent-gradient idea as one possibility, alongside a hot-spring origin on land.
the other reading: vent mineral pores concentrate it (vent walk, thermophoresis in cracks) - C-300 Was there a real spike of impacts on the early Moon and Earth (the Late Heavy Bombardment)?
booked: The map lists it as a hypothesised spike 4.1-3.8 billion years ago, and keeps the sampling-artefact and longer-bombardment readings alongside.
the other reading: an artefact of sampling; an extended bombardment - C-307 Was early Earth's atmosphere rich in hydrogen gases, or closer to neutral?
booked: The map follows the current consensus of a weakly reducing or neutral atmosphere, and keeps the strongly reducing view of the classic experiments alongside.
the other reading: a strongly reducing atmosphere (Oparin-Haldane, Miller-Urey) - C-357 Could life on Earth have started more than once?
booked: The map follows Darwin's view that one origin closed the door, since later starts would be eaten, and keeps the possibility of several origins alongside.
the other reading: if life arises readily, 'it may well have formed many times on Earth itself', with shadow biospheres past or present (Davies et al. 2009)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (8) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- lightning (structural)
The contest's Resource Denial is met as the by-product of feeding, as a fire burns a seedbed: trivially met. - not-diluting wins (structural)
'In contrast to the dilution that inevitably would occur in a global salty ocean, potential organic reactants can accumulate and be concentrated' in small freshwater pools; material in the ocean 'will be dispersed into a dilute solution that cannot support chemical reactions'; products in membranous - red-queen (structural)
Host and parasitic RNAs in a lab replication system: the parasite free-rides the host's replicase, host and parasite oscillate, and 'successive counter-adaptive evolution (i.e. evolutionary arms races)' follows; host lineages and parasite lineages both persist and diversify ('at least two and three - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
Life needs 'a shielded environment with influx from UV-exposed sources'; without the shield, UV is 'harmful and sterilising'. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Organic carbon first borrowed from the surroundings (the soup; heterotrophic first life) and later made inside (autotrophs, 'evolutionary pressure to become autotrophic'), then held inside again by engulfing autotrophs. - outside-to-inside (partial)
'Monomers transition from a dilute, disorganized state in aqueous solution to a highly concentrated and organized state in the multilamellar lipid matrix.' - partner-becomes-part (partial)
Competing RNA chains turn cooperative and end inside the first protocell; later heterotrophs engulf autotrophs into symbiosis. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
The same UV both makes the stock (synthesis, the U+C pair) and destroys it and early life ('harmful and sterilising').
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (14) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Earth via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Abiogenesis (origin of life) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- RNA via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Protocell via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) mixed
- Cell via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell) via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Last universal common ancestor (LUCA) via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Hydrothermal vent (alkaline, Lost City type, with black-smoker variants) via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) mixed
- Comet via sys:mechanical-contact · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) even
- Sun via sys:electromagnetic-field · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) mixed
- Cosmic dust via sys:gravitational-field · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Earth in the Hadean eon via sys:water-cycle · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
- Primordial (prebiotic) soup via sys:aqueous-solution · Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Abiogenesis (origin of life)
- RNA
- Protocell
- Amino acid
- Cell
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell)
- Nucleotide
- Sun
- Primordial (prebiotic) soup
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (3)
floor filled by (19)
- Abiogenesis (origin of life)
- RNA
- Protocell
- Amino acid
- Cell
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell)
- Nucleotide
- Hydrothermal vent (alkaline, Lost City type, with black-smoker variants)
- Comet
- Calcium phosphate minerals (apatite)
- Ozone layer (ozone shield)
- Sun
- Cosmic dust
- Earth in the Hadean eon
- Primordial (prebiotic) soup
- Autotroph
- Hot spring (geothermal setting)
- Carbonate-rich lake (phosphate-holding setting)
- Pond seepage (a non-living drain on the stock)
represents (1)
same pair (1)
Kinds (2)
Notes published science
- Darwin's devouring shows up at the scale of a single element: phosphate-rich lakes 'may have preferentially formed on the prebiotic Earth because of carbonic acid weathering under CO2-rich atmospheres and the absence of microbial phosphate consumption' (Toner & Catling 2020). Before life the lakes could hold over a molal of phosphate. Once there were eaters, that store was gone.
- The first parasite is a copy that dropped its own tool. In a lab RNA system, a deletion mutant 'which lost the encoded replicase subunit gene' replicates 'by freeriding the replicase provided by the host RNA', and the two then fought 'evolutionary arms races' (Furubayashi et al. 2020). The contest for the stock repeats inside the stock, over the enzyme.
- Maker and eater can be one pathway run two ways: LUCA's acetogenesis made organic carbon 'and it may also have run the metabolism in reverse', and modern acetogens grow 'autotrophically on H2 (and CO2) or heterotrophically' (Moody et al. 2024).
- Darwin saw the lock in 1871: a warm little pond might once have made the first protein compound, but 'at the present day such matter would be instantly devoured or absorbed, which would not have been the case before living creatures were formed'. Life closes the door it came in by, which is one reason we cannot watch it start again.
- Eating the soup may have invented its replacement: early heterotrophs did well 'until organic carbon became more scarce than inorganic carbon, providing a potential evolutionary pressure to become autotrophic'. Then the eaters ate the makers, and later took them inside as partners.
- The same young Sun built the stock and burned it. UV is 'necessary for the formation of the U+C nucleotide base pair' and also 'harmful and sterilising', so the sources' answer is a shielded pool fed from an exposed one.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
delivery from space (comets, meteorites and dust)
- L1: Infall: cosmic dust (40,000 t a year today), meteorites and comets; during the Late Heavy Bombardment up to five million tons of organics a year by meteorites (contested event)
- L2: What arrives: glycine from comet Wild 2 and meteorites; nucleobases and sugars in meteorites; uracil in Murchison likely formed in space
- L3: Impact synthesis: an asteroid-impact simulation produced all four components of RNA (2014)
- L4: Into the pool, but perhaps unusable: molecules from space 'too reduced to have been fermented or too heterogeneous to support microbial growth'
geothermal heat (hot springs and geysers)
- L1: Geothermal heat warming groundwater into hot springs; hot springs could have been abundant on Hadean volcanic land
- L2: Influx: deep waters plus surface runoff with eroded sediments; apatite weathering supplies phosphate, scarce in Archaean oceans but concentrated in lakes
- L3: Organics brought in by interplanetary dust, extraterrestrial projectiles, or atmospheric or geochemical synthesis; photocatalytic sulfide precipitates absorb harmful UV
- L4: Wet-dry cycles concentrate substrate solutions enough for spontaneous biopolymers; RNA-like polymers made in wet-dry cycling with UV and encapsulated in vesicles
- L5: Periodic pressure variations (geysers, tides) cause periodic phase transitions, keeping the reaction environment in a constant non-equilibrium state
organic carbon between eaters and makers (metabolite pool)
- L1: Organic carbon in the environment: oceans and shallow waters rich in organic molecules for primitive heterotrophs
- L2: Uptake and fermentation: heterotrophs take organic carbon they cannot make; bases, amino acids and ribose the first fermentation substrates; heterotrophic microbes likely arose at low H2 partial pressures
- L3: Scarcity: heterotrophy paid 'until organic carbon became more scarce than inorganic carbon', a pressure to become autotrophic; a heterotroph-only world has 'no way to regenerate the metabolite'
- L4: Replenishers: heterotrophy 'works well in tandem with other species that replenish the depleted substrate'; after autotrophs evolved, heterotrophs fed on them; autotrophic and heterotrophic cells engulfed into symbiosis
- L5: Mineralisation: heterotroph respiration converts organic compounds to inorganic forms; N, S and P removed first (H2S, NH4+)
prebiotic organics in water (aqueous solution)
- L1: The stock: simple organics in surface water (Darwin's warm little pond with ammonia and phosphoric salts; Haldane's 'hot dilute soup'), around 3.7-4.0 Gya
- L2: Inflow: synthesis by impact shocks, UV, redox coupling and discharges, or delivery from interstellar dust and the solar nebula; a weakly reducing or neutral atmosphere lowers the yield
- L3: Concentration or loss: wet-dry cycles concentrate and drive condensation; ice keeps polymers longer; vents dilute ('little residence time'); hydrolysis breaks RNA back to nucleotides
- L4: First draw (hypothesised): free nucleotides join chains that outgrow their breakdown; RNA sets with higher replication output take a larger share of the stock (natural selection)
- L5: Devoured: living matter takes the stock as it forms, so it no longer accumulates ('instantly devoured or absorbed'); the door to a second origin closes behind the first
ultraviolet sunlight (free-energy inflow)
- L1: Radiation from a young Sun, likely greater in UV, reaching the surface with no ozone layer
- L2: Synthesis: UV on water, CO2 and ammonia makes sugars and protein materials (Haldane); discharge through a reducing gas makes amino acids (Miller-Urey; over 40 kinds on re-analysis)
- L3: UV is needed for the U+C nucleotide pair, by partial hydrolysis and nucleobase loss
- L4: UV is harmful and sterilising; life needs 'a shielded environment with influx from UV-exposed sources' (under ice, water, clay, regolith)
- L5: UV can be harmful and sterilising; life needs a shielded environment with influx from UV-exposed sources (e.g. water within and under ice, connected to exposed areas through cracks)
Sources (14) published science
RNA world (Wikipedia, rev 1378837125, 2026-10-06) (behind its links)
Heterotroph (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Primordial soup (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Late Heavy Bombardment (Wikipedia, rev 1374601530, 2026-09-13) (behind its links)
Last universal common ancestor (Wikipedia, rev 1379064710, 2026-10-07) (behind its links)
Pearce BKD, Pudritz RE, Semenov DA, Henning TK (2017) Origin of the RNA world: the fate of nucleobases in warm little ponds. PNAS 114:11327. doi:10.1073/pnas.1710339114 (behind its links)
Lincoln TA, Joyce GF (2009) Self-sustained replication of an RNA enzyme. Science 323:1229. doi:10.1126/science.1167856 (behind its links)
Moody et al. 2024, The nature of the last universal common ancestor and its impact on the early Earth system, Nat Ecol Evol (doi:10.1038/s41559-024-02461-1) (behind its links)
Toner JD, Catling DC (2020) A carbonate-rich lake solution to the phosphate problem of the origin of life. PNAS 117:883. doi:10.1073/pnas.1916109117 (behind its links)