← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA)
Both chain nucleotides; deoxyribonucleotides are made from ribonucleotides.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | before the LUCA (about 4.2 Gya, 4.09-4.33); the RNA-to-DNA transition suggested at some 4 billion years ago |
| born precision | ±0.12 Gyr for the LUCA date; the transition date is a suggestion |
| boundary | Inside: the contested stock (ribonucleotides that stay RNA's or are reduced to DNA's), the two taking sites (RNA polymerase drawing NTPs; DNA polymerase drawing dNTPs and excluding NTPs), and the returns (primers swapped out, stray ribonucleotides cut out, chains salvaged). The converter, ribonucleotide reductase, sits on the boundary: the split happens there, but it is the cell's enzyme. Outside: the rest of nucleotide metabolism and everything the two chains later do. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from a pool (sys:nucleotide, as two sub-pools) and two takers (sys:rna, sys:dna); embedded in the cell, whose enzyme meters the split; its long-time outcome is seen at the LUCA. |
| scale | molecular |
Measures (24) published science
| RNR substrates | ADP, GDP, CDP, UDP (dTDP made separately from dTMP) molecules |
| RNR classes | 3 (I iron or manganese radical, aerobic; II cobalamin; III glycyl radical, anaerobic) classes |
| dTTP concentration, mid-log LB-grown E. coli (1 fL volume) | 121 uM |
| dNTP pools with RNR overexpressed (plasmid pPS2) vs control | dATP, dCTP and dTTP roughly doubled; smaller rise in dGTP fold |
| rifampicin-resistant mutant frequency with those pools | greater than 30 fold rise |
| outcome: storage role | DNA the predominant information storage molecule; LUCA's genetic material most likely DNA qualitative |
| LUCA age (2024 study) | about 4.2 (4.09-4.33) Gya |
| ATP concentration, glucose-fed exponential E. coli | 9.6 mM |
| dATP concentration, mid-log LB-grown E. coli (1 fL volume) | 113 uM |
| dTTP concentration, glucose-fed exponential E. coli | 4.6 mM |
| total intracellular metabolite pool, E. coli | approximately 300 mM |
| dNTP pools with RNR activity doubled (plasmid pPS2) | dATP, dCTP and dTTP about two-fold; smaller rise in dGTP |
| DNA polymerase intrinsic error rate | less than one per 10^7 nucleotides added |
| replication rate, phage T4 DNA in E. coli at 37 C | 749 nucleotides per second |
| mutation rate, phage T4 DNA synthesis | 1.7 per 10^8 per base pair per replication |
| longest eukaryotic RNA chain built by RNAP | 2.4 million nucleotides (dystrophin gene) |
| rNTP molar excess over the matching dNTP, S. cerevisiae | 36 to 190 fold |
| rNMP incorporation at physiological NTP levels, yeast replicative polymerases in vitro | Pol epsilon 1 per 1,250 dNMPs; Pol delta 1 per 5,000; Pol alpha 1 per 625 rNMP per dNMP |
| rNMPs possibly incorporated per round of nuclear replication, yeast | more than 10,000 per genome per round |
| ribonucleotide incorporation by replicative DNA polymerases | about 2 per kb |
| embedded ribonucleotides in RNase H2-null mouse cells | at least 1 per 7,600 nt; about 1,300,000 per cell per nt; per cell |
| embedded ribonucleotides per human mtDNA | 36 (HeLa); 54 (fibroblasts) per genome |
| mutation-rate rise with imbalanced dNTP pools (yeast rnr1 mutants, CAN1) | 10 to 300 fold |
| sequenced bacterial genomes coding all three RNR classes | more than 5 percent |
Open contentions (2) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-296 How much of the DNA building block dTTP does an E. coli cell hold?
booked: The map keeps both values, each tied to the growth medium it was measured in: 121 µM and 4.6 mM.
the other reading: one of the two is an outlier or a units error - C-301 Did the last common ancestor of all life store its genes in DNA or RNA?
booked: The map follows the view that it most likely used DNA, and keeps the RNA-based alternative alongside.
the other reading: the LUCA was RNA-based and DNA arose in its viruses (Forterre's 'three viruses, three domains')
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (14)
- RNA via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Cell via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- DNA and genes via sys:sequential-information · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell) via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Last universal common ancestor (LUCA) via sys:sequential-information · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Nucleotide via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Mitochondrion via sys:sequential-information · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) mixed
- Virus via sys:sequential-information · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) mixed
- RNA polymerase via sys:sequential-information · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Ribonucleotide reductase via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Ribonuclease h via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Dna polymerase via sys:sequential-information · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Thymidylate synthase (the thymidine branch) via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) gain
- Competition for the prebiotic stock (life devours its own origin) via sys:metabolite-pool · Competition for nucleotides (RNA vs DNA) even
expressed by (11)
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (20)
- RNA
- Cell
- Ribonucleotide
- DNA and genes
- Metabolite pool (small molecules made, carried and turned over in a cell)
- Last universal common ancestor (LUCA)
- Nucleotide
- Virus
- DNA replication
- RNA polymerase
- Transcription factor
- Ribonucleotide reductase
- Ribonuclease h
- Dna polymerase
- Thymidylate synthase (the thymidine branch)
- dihydrofolate reductase
- folate
- nucleotide salvage
- primase
- thymidylate kinase
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
Patterns our proposal
- who opens the door (structural)
4 of 11 recorded listeners are doors the receiving system installed ahead of time (both judgement coders agree)
Notes published science
- DNA polymerase works in a crowd of the wrong letters: ribonucleotides outnumber the deoxyribonucleotides it needs (in E. coli about 9.6 mM of ATP against about 0.1 mM of dATP, from two studies). A single bulky amino acid in the active site bumps the one extra oxygen on ribose; it leaks, and a separate enzyme, RNase H2, follows behind and cuts out the strays.
- The converter that makes DNA's letters out of RNA's is switched by the two sides' own letters: ATP, RNA's letter, turns it on; dATP, DNA's, turns it off. Each of DNA's letters then tells it which letter to make next, so the four come out even.
- Every DNA chain still starts on a scrap of RNA. DNA polymerase cannot begin a chain, so primase lays a short RNA primer, DNA is built onto it, and the RNA is then cut out and swapped for DNA: a small replay of RNA coming first, at every replication.
- The mistakes become a bookmark. DNA polymerase lets about 2 ribonucleotides per thousand letters slip into new DNA; the cell cuts them out, and the cuts tell the mismatch-repair machine which strand is new. E. coli does the same job a different way, by leaving new DNA briefly unmethylated.
- When mitochondria run short of DNA letters, they use RNA letters instead to keep copying, and they keep them: each human mtDNA carries about 36 to 54. Mice that can't remove them from nuclear DNA pile up about 1.3 million per cell and don't survive past early embryo stages.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
chains growing on a template: the takers (sequential information)
- L1: The template: with helicase, RNA polymerase opens double-stranded DNA so one strand is the template; DNA polymerase cannot start a chain and extends a short RNA primer paired with the template
- L2: Selection at the active site: 'DNA polymerases must select against ribonucleotides, present at much higher levels compared with deoxyribonucleotides'; a bulky side chain blocks the 2'-hydroxyl; the exclusion is not perfect
- L3: Joining: the phosphate of the incoming triphosphate bonds to the chain; two phosphates leave as pyrophosphate and the energy of the phosphoanhydride bonds drives the step
- L4: Growth only at the 3' carbon, so chains grow 5' to 3'; DNA polymerases err less than once in 10^7 additions and proofread; RNA polymerase backtracks to cut a mismatch
- L5: Where and when chains start: a transcription factor and mediator must sit at a promoter before RNA polymerase opens DNA there; in E. coli replication is set by origin hemimethylation, the ATP to ADP ratio and DnaA
deep time: RNA before DNA, and the storage role (sequential information)
- L1: Ordering in the pathway: deoxyribonucleotides are made from ribonucleotides by removing the 2'-hydroxyl, 'As a consequence, a cell must have the ability to make RNA before it can make DNA'
- L2: RNA's weakness: the 2'-hydroxyl can attack the adjacent phosphodiester bond; uracil arises from cytosine damage, making RNA prone to mutation
- L3: DNA's advantage: 'DNA has greater stability and durability than RNA, which may explain why it became the predominant information storage molecule'
- L4: By the LUCA (about 4.2 Gya, 4.09-4.33) the genetic material was 'most likely DNA'; a minority view holds the LUCA was RNA-based
- L5: The same contest among viruses: LUCA's viruses 'were probably mainly dsDNA viruses'; a DNA virus that took a gene from an RNA virus suggests genes crossed from RNA to DNA during the transition 'some 4 billion years ago'
dissolved nucleotide pool (metabolite pool)
- L1: The shared stock: ribonucleoside di- and triphosphates (ATP, GTP, CTP, UTP; ADP, GDP, CDP, UDP) and the much scarcer deoxyribonucleotides; in E. coli ATP 9.6 mM against dATP 113 uM (two studies, different media)
- L2: RNR's allosteric activity site: ATP binding activates it, dATP binding deactivates it
- L3: RNR's specificity site: ATP or dATP admits CDP and UDP; dGTP admits ADP; dTTP admits GDP, so 'the enzyme produces an equal amount of each dNTP'
- L4: The takers draw: RNA polymerase chains NTPs, DNA polymerase chains dNTPs; 'the synthesis of damage-free DNA relies on a balanced pool of deoxyribonucleotides'
- L5: Total rate of DNA synthesis regulated 'so that DNA to cell mass is maintained at a constant ratio during cell division and DNA repair'; the RNR complex is regulated by replication and DNA-damage checkpoints (yeast)
returns to the pool: primers removed, stray ribonucleotides cut out, chains salvaged (metabolite pool)
- L1: Primase lays short RNA primers on the DNA templates (one on the leading strand, several on the lagging): RNA's monomers placed at the start of DNA's chains
- L2: Primers removed and replaced with DNA (Pol I 5' to 3' exonuclease in E. coli; Pol delta in eukaryotes) and the fragments joined by DNA ligase
- L3: Single ribonucleotides misincorporated into DNA are cut out by RNase H2 (ribonucleotide excision repair); RNase H1 needs at least four in a row
- L4: Salvage: bases and nucleosides from degraded RNA and DNA are recovered into nucleotides (uridine kinase, thymidine kinase, phosphoribosyltransferases)
- L5: De novo synthesis enters on the RNA side: purines are first made as ribonucleotides (IMP), pyrimidines as UMP and CTP; deoxyribonucleotides only follow by RNR
the thymidine branch: dUMP to dTMP to dTDP (metabolite pool)
- L1: dUMP and N5,N10-methylene tetrahydrofolate in the pool
- L2: The folate carrier: dihydrofolate reductase reduces dihydrofolate back to tetrahydrofolate with NADPH; tetrahydrofolate is needed for purine and thymidylate synthesis
- L3: Thymidylate synthase joins them by reductive methylation into dTMP, giving dihydrofolate: the sole de novo pathway for dTMP
- L4: Thymidylate kinase makes dTDP from dTMP (RNR does not make dTDP); nucleoside diphosphate kinase makes dTTP
- L5: With thymidylate synthase inhibited, deoxynucleotides become imbalanced and dUMP rises: 'Both cause DNA damage'
Sources (26) published science
Ribonucleotide (Wikipedia, 2026-07-26) (behind its links)
Deoxyribonucleotide (Wikipedia, 2026-07-25) (behind its links)
Ribonucleotide reductase (Wikipedia, rev 1375280445, 2026-09-16) (behind its links)
Nucleotide salvage (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Abiogenesis (Wikipedia, rev 1380994702, 2026-10-19) (behind its links)
Ribonuclease H (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
BioNumbers 101430: dTTP concentration in mid-log, LB-grown E. coli (1 fL volume), citing Wheeler, Rajagopal & Mathews 2005 (behind its links)
Last universal common ancestor (Wikipedia, rev 1379064710, 2026-10-07) (behind its links)
BioNumbers 104673: intracellular ATP concentration in glucose-fed exponential E. coli, citing Bennett et al. 2009 (behind its links)
BioNumbers 101427: dATP concentration in mid-log, LB-grown E. coli (1 fL volume), citing Wheeler, Rajagopal & Mathews 2005 (behind its links)
BioNumbers 104698: intracellular dTTP concentration in glucose-fed exponential E. coli, citing Bennett et al. 2009 (behind its links)
DNA replication (Wikipedia, rev 1376313272, 2026-09-23) (behind its links)
RNA polymerase (Wikipedia, WME cache) (behind its links)
Thymidylate synthase (Wikipedia, WME cache) (behind its links)
Dihydrofolate reductase (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Nucleotide (Wikipedia, rev 1374824034) (behind its links)