EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on)

Metaphysics is the branch of philosophy that examines the basic nature or most fundamental structure of reality.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

aliasesMetaphysics (core branch)
born atbooked: Upanishads from the 7th century BCE; Taoism and the pre-Socratics in the 6th century BCE (intuitive roots contested, C-3023)
born precisioncenturies
boundaryInside: the practice of metaphysics (general metaphysics or ontology; special metaphysics: metaphysical cosmology, rational psychology, natural theology; applied metaphysics and meta-metaphysics), its topics (existence and categories, particulars and universals, possibility and necessity, space, time and change, causation, mind and free will, identity, truth and truthmakers), its methods (a priori intuition, thought experiments, conceptual analysis, eidetic variation, the transcendental method, naturalized metaphysics, theoretical virtues), the traditions and people who carry it, its critics, and the intuitive ontology people bring to it (object permanence, essentialism, felt agency and passage), booked through the channels. Outside: knowledge and justification as such (sibling walk epistemology), ethics (sys:ethics), logic (sys:logic), the sciences' own work (sys:physics, sys:psychology), theology's revealed doctrine (sys:religion).
nested levelA core branch of philosophy (philosophy L6, theory and tradition); it runs on people (human L6: thought, language) and acts back through texts, teaching, formal ontologies in databases, experimental designs in physics, legal and medical concepts, and AI governance.
scalesocial

Measures (29) published science

OBO registry in 2018: active / in use / obsolete / orphaned145 / 5 / 45 / 6 of 201 count
Upanishads first written7th century BCE
pre-Socratic metaphysics6th century BCE
Plato's life427-347 BCE years
Aristotle's life384-322 BCE years
title 'Metaphysics' coined after Aristotlesome two centuries years
'metaphysics' enters Englishmid 1500s date
Aristotle's categories10 count
Kant's categories12 in 4 classes count
free will vs divine foreknowledge debatedmore than 15 centuries
lay free-will study sample1,571 participants
Bell test 2015: CHSH S (bound 2)2.42 ± 0.20 dimensionless
Bell test 2015: separation1.3 km
Bell test 2015: trials245 count
Bell test 2015: p for a local-realist model0.039 probability
Bell test 2026 (time-bin): CHSH S2.583 ± 0.002 (over 265 standard deviations past the bound) dimensionless
debate on the nature of reality since quantum theorymore than 80 years
Bell test 2026: separation49.0 ± 0.7 m
brain time-drift study2 people, 30 consecutive days
self-initiated movement delay in the taskon the order of several seconds
cats tested / trials18 / 108 count
Stage 6 object permanence in human infants18-24 months of age
cats finding the visibly hidden toy44% of trials; 42% of non-finders made no attempt
BioPortal ontologies and terms (April 2021)over 800 / close to 10 million count
active OBO Foundry ontologies (May 2021)175 count
OBO ontologies fully passing textual definitions19 (about 11%) count
OBO registry commits / developers (May 2021)3045 / 113 count
Norwegian court decisions studied55 count
consensus report on disease1994 year

Open contentions (9) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (9)

Sits inside / holds (4)

Trades with (valence) (22)

expressed by (17)

floor filled by (17)

Kinds (14)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

metaphysics: reality as met in experience, intuition and the sciences, through concepts and arguments, to rival theories, the categories of being and a picture of reality put to use (reader's view)

  1. L1: Reality as met: existence, objects and properties, possibility, space and time, change, causes, minds
  2. L2: Intake: rational intuitions, common-sense beliefs, scientific theories, texts
  3. L3: Clarifying: conceptual analysis, truth-bearers and truthmakers, logical form and ontological commitment
  4. L4: Argument and theory choice: thought experiments, axioms, eidetic variation, theoretical virtues
  5. L5: Rival theories on each topic (special metaphysics and the topics): universals, modality, time, causation, mind, free will, identity
  6. L6: General metaphysics (ontology): being and the system of categories; meta-metaphysics above it
  7. L7: A picture of reality as first philosophy, used across fields (applied metaphysics)

the boardroom (shared floors)

  1. L4: Argument and theory choice: intuitions, thought experiments, axioms and deduction, conceptual analysis, the sciences' commitments, weighed by theoretical virtues (Ockham's razor, explanatory power); carried out in people's brains
  2. L5: Rival theories on each topic: particulars and universals, composition, modality, space and time, persistence, causation, mind and body, free will, identity
  3. L6: General metaphysics: being as such and the system of categories (Aristotle's 10, Kant's 12); with meta-metaphysics, which asks whether and how any of it can be known or means anything
  4. L7: A picture of reality, held as first philosophy and put to use: in philosophy (ethics, religion), the sciences, and applied ontologies in AI, medicine and law

way in: Everyday experience of things, change and causes (sight, touch, hearing)

  1. L1: Concrete things met in space and time: rocks, tables, organisms that persist, change and act on each other
  2. L2: Intuitive ontology built in development: object permanence (Stage 6 at 18-24 months in human infants; Stages 4-5 in many mammals and birds) and learned causal overhypotheses
  3. L3: Common-sense belief: tables exist, things endure; used as a check on theories

way in: Language and logic (hearing and reading statements)

  1. L1: Statements: 'a tomato is red', 'there are horses'
  2. L2: Truth-bearers taken in: statements and mental representations that can be true or false
  3. L3: Logical form and commitment: existential quantifiers read as ontological commitments; concepts decomposed

way in: Questions from other fields: medicine, law, data, AI

  1. L1: A case: is fibromyalgia a disease for disability benefit? how to record a failed plan in a database?
  2. L2: The question raised: what kind of thing is a disease, a plan, an agent?
  3. L3: Framed in the field's terms: naturalist (value-neutral) vs normativist (value-laden) concepts of disease; realizable entities

way in: Rational intuition and imagined cases (thought)

  1. L1: An imagined situation or a candidate principle (a zombie twin; the dinosaurs alive in another world)
  2. L2: The intuition: a non-inferential impression that a claim or principle is correct
  3. L3: Axioms and self-evident principles stated, ready for deduction

way in: Scientific theories and experiments (physics first)

  1. L1: The physical world: distant electron spins, clocks, frames of reference
  2. L2: Experiments built from metaphysical principles: Bell tests (S = 2.42 over 1.3 km, 2015; S = 2.583, 2026), a switched-off quantum clock
  3. L3: Theories read for their ontological commitments; more than one metaphysics fits each theory

way in: Sorting the world into kinds (sight, hearing: what people say kinds are)

  1. L1: Kinds met: cows and pigs, people and groups, water and tigers
  2. L2: The essence placeholder in children: blood, and later DNA, fill it
  3. L3: Natural kinds discovered by science vs social kinds as constructions

way in: The felt choice (free will as lived)

  1. L1: A self-initiated movement with no cue, after a delay of several seconds
  2. L2: The readiness potential: spontaneous subthreshold fluctuations cross a decision threshold
  3. L3: Lay judgment: incompatibilist intuitions with belief in an indeterministic world

way in: The felt passage of time

  1. L1: Days pass: hippocampal and entorhinal connectivity patterns drift, more distant days more distinct (two people, 30 days)
  2. L2: An intrinsic temporal context signal: 'time stamps' for episodic memories
  3. L3: The sense of passage taken as a pre-theoretical intuition for the A-theory (rebutted as evidence by B-side critics)

way in: The written tradition (sight: reading)

  1. L1: Texts across cultures: Upanishads (from the 7th century BCE), Taoist and pre-Socratic writings (6th century BCE), Aristotle's Metaphysics
  2. L2: Edited and named: an editor (likely Andronicus) titled Aristotle's book 'after the Physics'
  3. L3: Reconciled and reread: Boethius between Plato and Aristotle; Kant's reworking taken up by later idealists

way in: Theology and lay religious belief

  1. L1: Doctrine: divine foreknowledge and sovereignty (Calvin, the Catechism, the Qur'an's 'alim')
  2. L2: Theological fatalism argued for more than 15 centuries (Augustine, Boethius, al-Ghazali, Averroes)
  3. L3: Lay belief, measured (n = 1,571): Christian denominations alike; Muslims keep free will abstractly, deemphasize it in concrete cases

way out: Concepts of disease and personhood used by courts and clinics

  1. L1: People's benefits decided: 55 recent decisions read, drifting value-neutral
  2. L5: A 1994 consensus report becomes the court's guideline; the fibromyalgia decision (a jury of seven) a precedent
  3. L7: A concept of disease: value-neutral (Boorse) or value-laden (Sedgwick, Engelhardt), or hybrid (Wakefield)

way out: Formal ontologies in information systems

  1. L1: Biological data annotated and integrated: BioPortal's over 800 ontologies and close to 10 million terms
  2. L3: Principles turned into automated checks over 175 active ontologies (May 2021)
  3. L5: Shared principles for domain ontologies: open, common format, unique identifiers, relations reused
  4. L7: Upper categories (Basic Formal Ontology, SUMO) handed to computer and biomedical scientists

way out: Free will and agency turned into design constraints for AI

  1. L1: Law and regulators that presuppose agency; AI systems built and judged
  2. L7: Free will naturalized as Responsible Autonomy: six capacities

way out: Free will read into blame and punishment

  1. L1: What people do to wrongdoers
  2. L3: Judgments of free will, control, blame and punishment in concrete cases (low vs high duress)
  3. L7: Free will tied to moral responsibility

way out: Questions handed to physics as experiments

  1. L1: The physical world measured
  2. L3: An experiment designed: entangled spins 1.3 km apart, 245 trials; a quantum clock read by counterfactual measurement
  3. L5: A metaphysical principle (local realism; substantival vs relational time) stated so a test can decide

way out: Writing treatises and papers

  1. L1: The text, edited and titled by others and read for over two millennia
  2. L7: A system written down (Aristotle's Metaphysics, Leibniz's monadology, Lewis's modal realism)

Who fills each layer

Sources (20) published science

Metaphysics (encyclopedia article, WME snapshot 2026-11-01)
Philosophy (encyclopedia article, WME snapshot 2026-11-01)
Hensen B et al. Experimental loophole-free violation of a Bell inequality using entangled electron spins separated by 1.3 km. arXiv:1508.05949 (Nature 526, 682) (behind its links)
Duncan WD et al. Concretizing plan specifications as realizables within the OBO foundry. J Biomed Semantics 2024. doi:10.1186/s13326-024-00315-0 (behind its links)
Von Wachenfeldt V, Hofmann BM. The concept of disease in the Norwegian National Insurance Court. Scand J Public Health 2024. doi:10.1177/14034948221128868 (behind its links)
van Wassenhove V, Kanter BR, Viganò S, Bordas R. A Passage of Time Signal in the Human Brain. eNeuro 2026. doi:10.1523/eneuro.0406-25.2025 (behind its links)
Free will (encyclopedia article, WME snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Jackson R et al. OBO Foundry in 2021: operationalizing open data principles to evaluate ontologies. Database 2021. doi:10.1093/database/baab069 (behind its links)
Mehrez A, Machery E. Free will in the eyes of Muslims and Christians. PNAS Nexus 2026. doi:10.1093/pnasnexus/pgag212 (behind its links)
Vijayadharan K et al. Postselection-loophole-free Bell test under strict spacetime constraints. arXiv:2608.28190 (behind its links)
Schurger A, Sitt JD, Dehaene S. An accumulator model for spontaneous neural activity prior to self-initiated movement. PNAS 2012. doi:10.1073/pnas.1210467109 (behind its links)
Forman J, Rowe JS, Leavens DA. Object permanence in domestic cats (Felis catus) using violation-of-expectancy by owner and stranger. PLOS ONE 2025. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0312225 (behind its links)
Arroyo RW, Arenhart JRB. Realism and metaphysics in quantum mechanics. arXiv:2012.03071 (behind its links)
Vassallo A, Hoefer C. The Metaphysics of Machian Frame-Dragging. arXiv:1901.10766 (behind its links)
Strelchuk S, Woods MP. Measuring time with stationary quantum clocks. arXiv:2106.07684 (behind its links)
Bassler M, Pennartz CMA. Overcoming essentialism: evaluation of theories of consciousness by the lawful regularities they predict. Neurosci Conscious 2026. doi:10.1093/nc/niag069 (behind its links)
Kampourakis K, Fux M. Ancestry inferences from DNA testing results: The problem of sociogenetic essentialism. Hist Philos Life Sci 2025. doi:10.1007/s40656-025-00670-w (behind its links)
Verschure PFMJ. The six capacities of responsible autonomy: naturalizing free will in biological and artificial systems. Phil Trans R Soc B 2026. doi:10.1098/rstb.2026.0001 (behind its links)
Epistemology (encyclopedia article, WME snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Mind–body dualism (encyclopedia article, WME on-demand 2026-11-20) (behind its links)