← all systems · see it in The System
Aristotle
Aristotle (384-322 BC) was an ancient Greek philosopher and polymath (src:wp:aristotle): walked as historians and philosophers describe him, the life as the ancient biographies and records allow, the Lyceum and its library, the treatises on logic, nature, the soul, ethics, politics, rhetoric and poetics (about a third of his output; the published dialogues lost), the corpus as it was carried down through Theophrastus, Neleus' cellar, Andronicus' edition, the commentators and the Arabic and Latin translations, and its reach through later science and thought.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 384 BC |
| born precision | year (first half of the Olympiad year 384/383) |
| boundary | Inside: Aristotle of Stagira (the life as the sources allow), the research and teaching he led at the Lyceum, the works attributed to him (the surviving treatises, the lost dialogues and drawings, works of doubtful authorship as such), the corpus as it was carried down, and its reach (commentary, translation, teaching, testing). Outside, as partners: Plato and the Academy, the Macedonian court and Alexander, Athens and its courts, Theophrastus and the later Peripatetics, the animals and informants he learned from, the translators, scholastics and scientists who took him up or against. |
| nested level | A person (Human) and a member, then founder and head, of schools (Plato's Academy, the Lyceum: L3). His works are part of ancient Greek philosophy (L7). What runs on him: Aristotelianism, scholasticism, the Peripatetic commentary tradition, virtue-ethics revivals, Tinbergen-style four-question frames. |
| scale | social |
Measures (22) published science
| Lifespan | 62 (aged 61-62) years (384-322 BC) |
| Years at the Academy | nearly 20 years (c. 367 to 348/347 BC) |
| Teaching and research at the Lyceum (characteristic clock) | 12 years |
| Student administrator rotation | 10 days |
| Theophrastus as head of the Lyceum | 36 years |
| Surviving share of his output | about one third (main article); one fifth lost in the library's travels (Lyceum article) fraction |
| Works listed by Diogenes Laertius | 156 titles, about 400 books, 445,270 lines titles / books / lines |
| Lyceum library (rolls) | 10,000 papyrus rolls (Aristotle's and Theophrastus' library) |
| The library's wait in the cellar | about 150 years |
| Time practically unknown in the Latin West | c. AD 600 to c. 1100 (except the Boethius Organon) centuries |
| Animal species distinguished | about 500 species |
| Constitutions collected | 158 constitutions of city-states |
| Books translated by Gerard of Cremona | 87 books (many of them Aristotle's) |
| Syllogism types | 256 distinct types, 24 valid |
| Earth's size in On the Heavens | 400 thousand stadii stadii ("a bit too much, but a correct order of magnitude estimate") |
| Tenure of syllogistic as the standard logic | until 1879 (Frege's Begriffsschrift) year |
| Aristotle's comet: duration seen | more than 10 weeks (early 372 BC) |
| Aristotle's comet: tail | 60 degrees long; over 0.8 AU in space degrees / AU |
| Papers using scala naturae language | 1,287 of 67,413 (1.91%) papers in 16 top journals, 2005-2010 |
| History of Animals character matrix | 147 taxa, 161 characters; tested against one million random trees taxa / characters / trees |
| Aristotle illusion decoded from fMRI | 68.4 % classification accuracy (illusion vs reverse illusion, best CNN) |
| Projectile theory in use | approximately 1700 years before 14th-century guns |
Open contentions (20) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: see the registry - C-1152 Is rhetoric an art or a kind of flattery?
booked: The map keeps Aristotle, Isocrates and Cicero's view of rhetoric as an art beside Plato's charge of flattery.
the other reading: see the registry - C-1906 When did biology begin as a field?
booked: The map books the 19th century for the unified field and keeps earlier starts beside it.
the other reading: see the registry - C-2375 When did political science begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing starts.
the other reading: see the registry - C-2580 What did Aristotle mean by catharsis?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: see the registry - C-2685 Did Alexander send Aristotle animal specimens?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: no such gifts (the claim rests on a source the encyclopedia marks for better sourcing); the large sum of money said to be donated (same flag) - C-2686 Was Aristotle's library really hidden in a cellar for 150 years?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: many copies of the major works already circulated in Athens, Alexandria and Rome, so the cellar was not the only line (main article) - C-2687 When did Aristotle return to and leave Athens?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: main article: Lyceum period 335-323, death and flight in 322; Lyceum article: school founded 334, flight 323 - C-2688 Are Aristotle's surviving works his lecture notes?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Ammonius Hermiae: deliberately obscure, to stretch good minds and put off empty ones; some are notes by his students - C-2689 Was Aristotle charged with impiety?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: he fled for fear of a trial with no charge brought (Aelian); the charge and the paean story are later inventions - C-2690 Why did Aristotle leave the Academy?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: the traditional story alone; politics alone - C-2691 Why did Aristotle's physics last so long?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: dogma that slowed science (the common view Rovelli argues against); a very good empirically grounded theory, correct in its domain (Rovelli) - C-2693 Did Aristotle anticipate natural selection?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Darwin: 'natural selection shadowed forth' - C-2694 Did Aristotle mean his rules of motion as quantitative laws?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Carteron's 'extreme view': force basically qualitative - C-2695 How much of Aristotle's writing survives?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: one fifth lost in the library's travels (Lyceum article: a different base, the library's rolls); Diogenes Laertius' list (156 titles, 445,270 lines) as the base, some misattributed - C-2696 Was Aristotle trying to classify animals?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: philosophers of science: not interested in taxonomy; zoologists: important contributions to taxonomy and nomenclature - C-2697 In what year did Aristotle see his comet?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: 371 BC (encyclopedia) - C-2707 Do Tinbergen's four questions descend from Aristotle's four causes?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: expanded from Mayr's proximate/ultimate distinction (Nesse 2019, which does not mention Aristotle) - C-2719 Why were Aristotle's followers called Peripatetics?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: from his habit of walking while teaching (Lyceum article; a legend perhaps from Hermippus, says the Peripatetic school article) - C-2739 Was Aristotle's logic superseded or extended?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: monadic and inadequate for mathematics (the common view); sufficient for multiple generality (Protin 2022, preprint)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Plato and Aristotle: standing among later scholars
- Succession to Plato's Academy (347 BC)
- Corpus Aristotelicum (the surviving works)
- Organon (the six logical works)
- The exoteric works (lost dialogues)
- Anatomai (lost anatomical drawings)
- Aristotle's biology
- Ancient Greek philosophy
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Ancient Greece (the Greek city-state world across time)
- The Academy
- The Lyceum (Peripatetic school)
- Ancient Greek philosophy
Trades with (valence) (19)
- Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies) via sys:human-society · Aristotle gain
- Metaphysics (the branch of philosophy: its practice and the questions about reality it works on) via sys:sensory-environment · Aristotle gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Aristotle gain
- Middle Ages via sys:earth · Aristotle gain
- Scientific Revolution (the 16th-17th-century change in how Europeans investigated and understood nature) via sys:human-society · Aristotle loss
- Rhetoric (speech and argument) via sys:sensory-environment · Aristotle gain
- Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason via sys:language · Aristotle gain
- Classical mechanics (Newtonian mechanics: bodies, forces and motion, and the practice of describing them) via sys:sensory-environment · Aristotle loss
- Biology (the field) via sys:biosphere · Aristotle gain
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies) via sys:human-society · Aristotle gain
- The Academy via sys:human-society · Aristotle gain
- Theophrastus via sys:human-society · Aristotle gain
- Alexander the Great via sys:human-society · Aristotle mixed
- Athens (city and courts) via sys:human-society · Aristotle mixed
- Kingdom of Macedon via sys:human-society · Aristotle gain
- The Pyrrha lagoon and the seas of Lesbos (their animals) via sys:sensory-environment · Aristotle gain
- Drama (the literary form) via sys:written-record · Aristotle gain
- Plato via sys:acoustic-wave · Aristotle gain
- Ancient Greek philosophy via sys:sensory-environment · Aristotle gain
expressed by (18)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Hypothesis Portfolio / Multiple Hypothesis Tracking
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Quick Harm Avoidance
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (18)
- Ethics (moral philosophy: the study and the morality it studies)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Human brain
- Book
- Ancient Greece (the Greek city-state world across time)
- Middle Ages
- Scientific Revolution (the 16th-17th-century change in how Europeans investigated and understood nature)
- Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
- The Academy
- Corpus Aristotelicum (the surviving works)
- Theophrastus
- Averroes (and Al-Kindi, Al-Farabi, Ibn Sina)
- The Lyceum (Peripatetic school)
- Kingdom of Macedon
- The Pyrrha lagoon and the seas of Lesbos (their animals)
- Plato
- Andronicus of Rhodes
- Ancient Greek philosophy
Kinds (2)
wired (3)
Notes published science
- The word 'metaphysics' was never Aristotle's: an editor, likely Andronicus of Rhodes, put his book after the Physics about two centuries later, and the shelf position became the field's name (src:wp:metaphysics).
- One of the most influential books of Arabic philosophy, the 'Theology of Aristotle', was really an adapted translation of parts of Plotinus' Enneads: a label lost in the hand-off from Greek to Arabic (src:sep-arabic-islamic-greek).
- Aristotle wrote that octopus males use a special arm to mate; nobody believed him (he half-doubted it himself) until 19th-century biologists found the fishermen who told him were right (src:wp:aristotles-biology, src:wp:aristotle).
- His physics wasn't simply wrong: in air or water a heavier body really does settle into a faster fall, and Rovelli shows Aristotle's falling-body rules are Newton's physics in the limit of motion through a fluid, missing only a square root (src:rovelli-2015-aristotle-physics).
- His ladder of nature is still in the journals: of 67,413 papers in 16 top journals from 2005-2010, 1,287 (1.91%) used 'higher' and 'lower' organism language, and crossing two fingers on one pencil still makes you feel his illusion of two (src:rigato-minelli-2013-great-chain, src:lee-2025-aristotle-illusion).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
Aristotle as historians and philosophers describe him: from the world he drew on, through observation, testimony and the Academy, his school and his method, to the treatises, the corpus as it was carried down, and its reach through later science and thought (reader's view)
- L1: The world he drew on: Stagira and the Macedonian court, Athens, the Academy, the seas and lagoons of Lesbos and Assos, the sky, the Greek cities, the philosophies before him
- L2: Intake: his own observation and dissection, informants (fishermen, beekeepers, travellers), collected constitutions, reading and criticising predecessors
- L3: The schools: twenty years in the Academy; the Lyceum with its library, collections and student research projects
- L4: Method: data gathered, patterns found across groups, causes inferred (material, formal, efficient, final); logic as the tool of demonstration
- L5: The works: logic (Organon), physics, biology, psychology (On the Soul), metaphysics, ethics, politics, rhetoric, poetics
- L6: The corpus as carried down: the library's journey, Andronicus' edition, commentators, translations, Bekker
- L7: Reach: 'The First Teacher', 'The Philosopher', the scholastic curriculum, the sciences that broke with him and those that returned to him
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Inquiry: Aristotle at work, where earlier philosophy, the Academy, his own looking, informants, the sky and the Earth, the collections, the cities and courts, Greek speech, family life and his own thinking meet; data gathered, patterns found across groups, causes inferred (the four causes), logic used as the tool
- L5: The works as made: the treatises (logic, physics, biology, the soul, metaphysics, ethics, politics, rhetoric, poetics), mostly lecture aids; the published dialogues and the anatomical drawings, now lost
- L6: The corpus as carried down and established: Theophrastus, Neleus' cellar, Apellicon, Sulla's seizure, Andronicus' edition, the commentators, the Arabic and Latin translations, Bekker
- L7: Reach: 'The First Teacher' and 'The Philosopher'; Aristotelianism and scholasticism; logic until Boole and Frege; the break with Galileo and Harvey; Darwin, Tinbergen, homology; virtue ethics and eudaimonia research; the five senses in everyday speech
way in: Commentators, editors and translators
- L1: Copies circulating in the Lyceum, Alexandria and Rome; the recovered library
- L2: Copying and gap-filling (Apellicon), editing (Andronicus)
- L3: Commentary as the way in: Boethus to Alexander of Aphrodisias, the Neoplatonists, Philoponus, the Byzantines
- L4: Translation into Syriac and Arabic, then Latin; the Greek manuscripts returned to the West
- L5: Editions: Bekker's Berlin edition (1831-1870), whose page numbers became the standard references
way in: Earlier Greek philosophy (the Presocratics and Plato in writing and teaching)
- L1: The philosophies before him: Empedocles' four elements, Democritus, Anaxagoras, Plato's dialogues
- L2: Taking up earlier doctrines: the four elements of Empedocles tied to the four sensible qualities, aether added
- L3: Criticism of a predecessor's view in his own terms (Plato's Timaeus on the soul)
way in: Family and personal life
- L1: A physician's family of the Asclepiadae; parents dead young; wife Pythias, partner Herpyllis, children Pythias and Nicomachus
- L2: His son named after his father (the Nicomachean Ethics bears the name)
way in: Greek speech, poetry and lore (Homer, the tragedians, proverbs, riddles)
- L1: Spoken and sung Greek: epic, tragedy, oratory, proverbs, the Delphic riddles, Aesop
- L2: Collecting and reading: an annotated Iliad for Alexander; Sophocles' Oedipus as the model tragedy
- L3: Speech and poetry analysed into kinds and parts: three appeals, three genres, six elements of tragedy
way in: Informants' reports (fishermen, beekeepers, travellers)
- L1: People with specialised knowledge and travellers from overseas
- L2: Reports taken down: fishermen on the octopus's hectocotyl arm
- L3: Reports weighed against his own reasoning: the arm granted for attachment, denied for generation
way in: Later testers of his claims (scientists and scholars)
- L1: Natural philosophers and scientists who checked him against nature, from Herophilus to modern zoologists and physicists
- L2: Tests: Herophilus on the brain, Philoponus on motion, Harvey on the heart, Galileo on falling bodies
- L3: Confirmations: the hectocotylus (19th century), octopus camouflage, snorkelling elephants; his falling-body rules recovered from Newtonian drag
- L4: Re-readings by modern methods: phylogenetic tests of his characters; the physics as an approximation
- L5: Verdicts on the whole: from Medawar's 'farrago' to Darwin's 'old Aristotle'
- L6: The verdicts carried into the corpus as it is read (editions with commentary, histories of science)
way in: Own observation and dissection (sight, touch, the opened egg)
- L1: The animals of Lesbos and the Pyrrha lagoon, fishermen's catches; plants at Assos
- L2: Looking and dissecting: the hen's egg opened to see the heart beat
- L3: Descriptions in diagnostic characters, with drawings (the lost Anatomai)
way in: Plato's Academy (twenty years of teaching and debate)
- L1: The Academy in Athens, entered at about eighteen
- L2: Study, research and lecturing: 'mind of the school'
- L3: Plato's forms taken in and turned: universals exist only in particulars
- L4: Universals located in each particular (the form of apple in each apple)
way in: Political life of the Greek cities (constitutions, Athens, Macedon)
- L1: The Greek city-states and their constitutions; Athens, where he lived as a metic
- L2: A research project collecting 158 constitutions
- L3: Constitutions compared and classified (the Constitution of the Athenians the one that survives)
way in: The Macedonian court and other patrons (Philip, Alexander, Hermias)
- L1: His father's place at the court of Amyntas; Hermias at Assos; Philip II's invitation
- L2: Invitations taken up: tutor to the thirteen-year-old Alexander
- L3: Court questions brought into the work: kingship, colonies, the treatment of the conquered (the works for Alexander are lost)
way in: The changing Earth and sea (geology, the water cycle)
- L1: Coasts, rivers, volcanoes and the sea
- L2: Observations and reports: the Nile delta growing since Homer, an Aeolian island upheaved; seawater evaporated
- L3: Change read beyond one lifetime: geological change too slow to watch
way in: The school's collections and library (manuscripts, maps, specimens)
- L1: Manuscripts, maps and museum objects; plant and animal specimens (some said to come from Alexander)
- L2: Collecting philosophical works for the library; specimens gathered on campaign (contested)
- L3: The library as a research store, 10,000 rolls by Theophrastus' time
way in: The sky seen by eye (eclipses, comets, the Milky Way)
- L1: Light from the Moon, comets and stars
- L2: Naked-eye observing: the comet of early 372 BC followed for more than ten weeks
- L3: Arguments from what is seen: a circular shadow at different hours means a sphere
way in: Thought (inner): reasoning with images
- L1: The thinking person (Human's thought channel); where thoughts come from is not settled
- L2: Thinking with images: 'We cannot think without imagery' (his own account, De Memoria)
- L3: Sensation kept apart from thought (his view; the distinction itself)
way out: Teaching at the Lyceum (lectures, research projects)
- L1: Voices in the Lyceum's gymnasium and colonnade (peripatos)
- L3: Cooperative research: students assigned historical or scientific projects
- L4: Lecturing in the morning to students, to the public afterwards
way out: The school and the will (succession, library, estate)
- L1: The school continuing under a series of heads until Sulla destroyed it in 86 BC
- L3: A will naming Antipater executor
- L6: Works left to Theophrastus, his successor
way out: Tutoring and counsel to rulers
- L1: The Macedonian court: Alexander, nobles such as Ptolemy and Cassander perhaps at his lectures
- L3: Taught at Mieza: ethics, politics, Homer and Euripides probably
- L5: Views on rule and the conquered: eastern conquest urged; a strongly ethnocentric attitude to Persia
way out: Writing (treatises and dialogues on papyrus)
- L1: Papyrus rolls
- L3: Into the library: hundreds of books on papyrus scrolls
- L5: Treatises and dialogues composed, mostly 335-323 BC