EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest)

Share of the ensemble: 'the mechanism of universe generation employed in EI would, if true, overwhelm the ensemble of universes created', because of 'the vast numbers of universes created with a very short time scale'; Smolin replies that selection can apply to the sub-ensemble with many black-hole ancestors.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

aliasesCompetition over the ensemble of universes (black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation)
boundaryInside (as projected): the pool (the ensemble E of universes), the two generators that add to it (black-hole bounces with small heritable changes; bubble nucleation in eternally inflating space), their rates and scales (astrophysical black holes vs grand-unified-scale inflation), the share each holds, and the way a member is counted (ancestry N; the sub-ensemble with N > N0). Also inside, as a rival round of the same contest, the black-hole source question (astrophysical holes vs holes nucleated in de Sitter space, Vilenkin). Outside: the anthropic and mediocrity principles and the measure problem (ideas about how to count, rung 11), and the empirical tests of CNS (neutron-star masses: C-021, the CNS walk).
compete fnsfn:speed
nested levelBuilt from its pool (sys:multiverse) and takers (sys:cosmological-natural-selection, sys:eternal-inflation); embedded in the multiverse. Cosmological scale, rung 0, hypothetical, representation: true.
representationTrue
scalecosmological

Measures (8) published science

CNS hypotheses first made1992 year
offspring per black hole (CNS)1 universe
observed cosmological constant (Vilenkin argument, step 1)~10^-122 l_Pl^-2
maximal black-hole nucleation rate in de Sitter (Planck-mass hole)~ exp(-10^61) / l_Pl^4 per volume per time
Poincare recurrence time of the de Sitter vacuum~ R 10^120 time (R the de Sitter radius)
extrapolation the Vilenkin argument needs (Smolin)10^60 factor in time scale
scale below which laws are uncertain (Smolin)10^17 cm
characteristic clock: time to the first nucleated black hole (inner round)~ R 10^61 time (R the de Sitter radius)

Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal

Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Competition over the ensemble of universes: black-hole bounces vs eternal inflation (projected contest). Each links to every other system that shows it.

Valence: what it trades, and with whom (5) published science

Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (3)

Sits inside / holds (1)

floor filled by (6)

represents (1)

Kinds (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

black-hole generation of universes: the bounce side of the contest (gravitational field)

  1. L1: Black holes form in each universe (massive stars, supernovas); CNS's fitness f(p) is the average number a universe with parameters p produces
  2. L2: Generation: 'Black hole singularities bounce and evolve to initial states of expanding universes'; at each creation 'a small change in x leading to a small random change of x in P'
  3. L3: Count by ancestry: 'a property a universe will have is N, the number of ancestor universes it has from black hole bounces'; the sub-ensemble E_LN0 (N > N0), of which 'we can posit that our universe is a typical member'; the master prediction applies to it
  4. L4: Inner round (Vilenkin): in a de Sitter future the black-hole nucleation rate is maximised by a Planck-mass hole, Gamma_max ~ exp(-10^61)/l_Pl^4; the first appears at t_N ~ R 10^61 and nucleated holes then 'swamp' astrophysical ones; Smolin: this needs laws stable over scales '10^60 times bigger' and Euclidean path integrals of doubtful reliability

eternal-inflation generation of universes: the bubble side of the contest (inflaton field)

  1. L1: An inflating false vacuum at grand-unified scales, 'much higher in energy than the natural scales of nuclear and atomic physics'
  2. L2: Pocket universes: 'the infinity of pocket universes produced by eternal inflation', made 'with a very short time scale'; 'inflation is generically eternal into the future, it is not eternal into the past'
  3. L3: A random ensemble in which 'our universe is very atypical'; probabilities ambiguous ('the youngness paradox that results from a synchronous gauge regularization technique'); needs the anthropic principle and mediocrity to explain tuning
  4. L4: Share: EI 'would, if true, overwhelm the ensemble of universes created' (objection, 'voiced in conversation but not, I believe, in print')

Sources (4) published science

Smolin, L. (2006). The status of cosmological natural selection (arXiv:hep-th/0612185)
Tegmark, M. Parallel Universes (2003), arXiv:astro-ph/0302131 (behind its links)
Multiverse (Wikipedia, rev 1381320042, via Wikimedia Enterprise, fetched paced 2026-10-28) (behind its links)
Guth, A. H. Eternal inflation and its implications (2007), arXiv:hep-th/0702178 (behind its links)