← all systems · see it in The System
Art history (the field)
Art history is an academic discipline devoted to the study of artistic production and visual culture throughout human history. Art historians use a historical method or a philosophy, such as historical materialism or critical theory, to analyze artworks.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Art history |
| born at | about 280 BC (Xenokrates of Sicyon, traced through Pliny's Natural History); independently 6th century China; 1550 (Vasari) or the 19th century (the discipline) |
| born precision | contested, about two millennia |
| boundary | Inside: art historians' practice of finding, examining, identifying, describing, interpreting and writing about works of art (connoisseurship, technical art history, provenance research, formal analysis, iconography and iconology, the theoretical schools, historiography), the catalogues raisonnés, databases and histories it writes, and its professional bodies and journals. Outside: the works of art themselves and their makers (sys:visual-art, painting, sculpture), the museums, archives and art trade that hold and move them, conservation science's laboratories, art criticism (value judgements on single works) and aesthetics (a branch of philosophy), which the discipline is 'distinguished from', and the publics, markets and states that use what it finds. |
| nested level | A human practice (rung 11), a branch of history, carried by art historians, conservators and scientists in universities, museums and the trade; it runs on the visual art that humans make (sys:visual-art's L7 shared use) and on the record (archives); its output (attributions, histories, exhibitions) runs on into the market, museums, teaching and law. |
| scale | social |
Measures (23) published science
| Viewing time per painting at first viewing (museum) | 33.9 seconds (mean; 225 visitors, six Richter paintings) |
| Viewing time per painting, Smith and Smith 2001 (as reported) | 27.2 seconds (mean) |
| Viewing time per painting with returns | 50.5 seconds (mean, returns added) |
| Viewing distance at first viewing | 1.75 m (mean) |
| Paintings skipped per visitor | 2.5 of 6 paintings |
| Share of displayed paintings a visitor looks at (attention per hand-off) | 0.58 fraction (derived: (6 - 2.5) / 6) |
| Visitors observed | 225 people |
| Agreement between observers on how moving an artwork is | 0.13 ± 0.17 mean pairwise correlation (16 observers, 109 artworks) |
| Minimum age of the oldest known representational art | 51,200 years (minimum, laser-ablation U-series) |
| First edition of Vasari's Lives | 1550 year |
| First book titled a history of art | 1764 year (Winckelmann, History of Art in Antiquity) |
| Lag from Vasari's Lives to Michelet's 'Renaissance' | 285 years (derived: 1835 - 1550) |
| Rembrandt Research Project span | 1968-2014 (46 years) |
| Signed Rembrandt self-portraits after the RRP | 0.5 fraction of the number before |
| Lag between canvas radiocarbon date and the date on the work | 2-5 years |
| Trotter's forgery sales | 52 sales, 1981-1988 |
| Harvest years of the binder's oil seeds | 1958-1961 or 1983-1989 calendar years (bomb-peak calibration) |
| Paint sample dated | <200 micrograms (paint chip) |
| Sample needed by early radiocarbon dating | tens of grams |
| Paintings in the entropy-complexity corpus | almost 140,000 paintings over nearly a millennium |
| Landscape paintings in the composition corpus | 14,912 paintings |
| Stroke-level attribution accuracy | 70-90% (strokes); above 80% (drawings); 100% fakes detected in most settings accuracy |
| Drawings and strokes in the attribution dataset | 300 drawings; over 80,000 strokes count |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: positions listed under C-413 - C-500 Where does our sense of beauty in art come from?
booked: The map lists the main theories of aesthetic response and rules none.
the other reading: other theories listed under C-500 - C-545 Are uranium dates for cave art reliable minimum ages?
booked: The map uses the published dates as minimum ages, as the authors report them, and keeps the concern that uranium loss can make them too old alongside.
the other reading: uranium leaching can make ages too old - C-2153 When did authors come to own their work?
booked: The map keeps the readings of when authorship became property.
the other reading: authorship largely made by readers and institutions (an authority's opinion 'weighed heavily on whether a painting was to be considered genuine') - C-2455 When did art history begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Vasari's Lives (1550) as 'the first true history of art'; the academic discipline of the 19th century - C-2456 Who decides who painted a picture?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: the connoisseur's eye, learned by looking, as the core skill (Grosvenor, as reported); technical analysis as 'a modern connoisseurship' that supersedes it; an authority body (the RRP) whose opinion decides genuineness; Morelli's quarrel: each side disparaging the other - C-2475 Does Panofsky's iconology still stand?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: criticised since the mid-1950s (Pächt, Alpers, as reported); the iconography/iconology distinction not generally accepted
Cross-scale patterns seen here (13) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Art history (the field). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- nested ladder (structural)
Panofsky's three strata: primary subject matter (13 men at a table), conventional subject matter (the Last Supper), intrinsic meaning (a synthesis: why this way, for this patron). Each rung presupposes the one below ('If we stopped at this first stratum...'); 'it was important to consider all three - red-queen (structural)
Forgers against authenticators. Both sides improve: dating and analysis 'have made the identification of forged artwork much simpler', while forgers are 'often proficient in the current methods of art forgery authentication' and reverse-engineer them (old canvases scraped by van Meegeren, supports b - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, telling who made a work and when, done by unrelated builds: the connoisseur's eye on 'diagnostic minor details' such as ears (Morelli), documents (provenance, 'essentially a matter of documentation'), physics (bomb-peak radiocarbon of the binder; dendrochronology), elemental imaging (macro- - templating (structural)
Modules swapped between systems and still working: Morelli's method came from medicine's reading of 'numerous symptoms', moved to Italian paintings, and was applied by others to Greek vases and the Persepolis reliefs 'with results that further confirmed its validity'; radiocarbon and synchrotron X-r - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Borrowed: early writing about art was done by makers themselves (Xenokrates, a sculptor; Chinese canon-makers 'were artists themselves'; Vasari, a painter). Held: from the 19th century an academic discipline of its own; technical study likewise moved from conservation labs ('an auxiliary science') t - causal ceiling (partial)
What did not survive cannot be read by any method: the Sulawesi scene is 'the earliest known surviving example'; Benjamin's aura (presence in time and space) is said to decay as the original time and space grow harder to apprehend. Dark twin checked: relative dating that 'may fail in proving a forge - partner-becomes-part (partial)
Conservation science began as a partner (the first scientist employed to study fine art, at the Fogg; 'technical studies' at Harvard in the 1930s) and became a part of art history: 'These technical studies entered the discipline art history in the first half of the twentieth century', later 'an inde - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Writing a canon of worthy artists arose in Greece and, 'similar, though independent', in 6th-century China: shared parts (writing, a ranked list of makers, principles of painting) in separate builds with the same result. - The carry (partial)
Overflow passed on: a museum shows only what its walls hold; 'Most of a museum's collection is typically locked away', so the excess waits in storage. The wait: the Rembrandt Research Project ran 46 years (1968-2014) to settle one painter's corpus. No source names a rate-limiting step. - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Material form: a work handed down through time arrives altered; The Night Watch 'embodies four centuries of material history' with 'numerous chemical and mechanical alterations'; arsenic pigments have turned to mimetite, a 'greyish haze'. Attention form, with a number: in a six-painting room visitor - who opens the door (partial)
Doors opened from the inside, ahead of time: museums decide what leaves storage; expert meetings bring works together 'in real life'; scanning laboratories and pro-active provenance registers are set up before the work arrives. Storage is a closed door to most people. - lightning (surface)
A stored difference released at once: van Meegeren's 1945 confession (made to escape a treason charge) suddenly turned 'the finest Vermeer ever' into a forgery and made his own works valuable, which drew new forgers; Nochlin's essay 'helped to ignite' a field. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (surface)
The cut the field drew between fine and decorative arts ('Western definitions of the fine and decorative arts'), which set what was studied first. No symmetric before is shown in the sources read.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (19) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Painting via sys:electromagnetic-field · Art history (the field) gain
- Sculpture via sys:electromagnetic-field · Art history (the field) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Art history (the field) gain
- Religion via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Art history (the field) gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) mixed
- Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Art history (the field) gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) mixed
- Renaissance (European period and cultural movement, c. 14th-17th centuries) via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) gain
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) mixed
- Culture via sys:sensory-environment · Art history (the field) gain
- Authentication via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) gain
- The archive and the historical record via sys:written-record · Art history (the field) gain
- History (the field) via sys:written-record · Art history (the field) gain
- Museum via sys:visual-art · Art history (the field) gain
- Art conservation and conservation science via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) gain
- Art forgery (forgers) via sys:human-society · Art history (the field) mixed
- Cave painting via sys:visual-art · Art history (the field) gain
- Art of ancient Egypt via sys:electromagnetic-field · Art history (the field) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Forgers against authenticators of seals, documents, art, goods and money
- Connoisseurship
- Technical art history
- Provenance research
- Formal analysis
- Iconography and iconology
- Catalogue raisonné
- Professional bodies (College Art Association and others)
- Forgers and authenticators over buyers' trust
Sits inside / holds (5)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- History (the field)
- Museum
- Ancient Greek art
- Chinese art
expressed by (22)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Hypothesis Portfolio / Multiple Hypothesis Tracking
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Technique-Based Identification (a.k.a. Technique-Based Detection)
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (24)
- Painting
- Sculpture
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Visual art (drawing, painting, sculpture)
- Pigment (ochre, hematite, manganese oxide, charcoal)
- Architecture
- Authentication
- The archive and the historical record
- History (the field)
- Museum
- Connoisseurship
- Technical art history
- Provenance research
- Formal analysis
- Iconography and iconology
- Catalogue raisonné
- Professional bodies (College Art Association and others)
- Feminist art history
- Marxist art history
- Vienna School of art history
- Art market (the trade)
- Art conservation and conservation science
- Rembrandt Research Project
- Cave painting
Kinds (9)
- History (the field)
- Technical art history
- Feminist art history
- Marxist art history
- Visual culture studies
- Design history
- Museum studies
- Vienna School of art history
- Chinese art-historical writing
Notes published science
- The forger's tell was the atom bomb: a 'Sarah Honn' folk painting dated 1866 sat on a genuinely old canvas, but the linseed oil in its paint carried extra carbon-14 from 1950s-60s nuclear tests, so the seeds were harvested in 1958-1961 or 1983-1989. A paint chip under 200 micrograms was enough (src:hendriks-2019-forgery-radiocarbon).
- An arms race with no winner: as dating got better, forgers learned the tests and bought old canvases (van Meegeren scraped old paintings to reuse them), so scientists started dating the paint itself; still, 'Many forgeries still escape detection' (src:hendriks-2019-forgery-radiocarbon, src:wp:art-forgery).
- Half a minute per masterpiece: at a Gerhard Richter show, visitors stood about 1.75 m away and looked about 34 s per painting, skipped 2.5 of 6 pictures, and more than half came back to one they had rushed (src:carbon-2017-museum-viewing).
- We barely agree on what moves us: 16 viewers rating 109 artworks agreed with each other at only 0.13, yet the works that moved a person most switched on the brain's default-mode regions linked to thinking about oneself (src:vessel-2012-brain-on-art).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
art history: works of art read as evidence, from the object to histories of art (reader's view)
- L1: Works of art and visual culture as objects and evidence: paintings, drawings, sculpture, architecture and their materials, from the oldest surviving representational art (at least 51,200 years) to the present; each object carries its own material history ('four centuries' for The Night Watch)
- L2: Access and keeping: museums, galleries, archives, collections and the trade hold the works; conservation keeps them in a condition good enough to be examined
- L3: Examination: the trained eye (connoisseurship, Morelli's trifling details) and the instrument (X-radiography, infrared, macro-XRF, microsamples, dendrochronology, radiocarbon); the object as primary source
- L4: Identification: attribution, dating, authentication and provenance; the catalogue entry
- L5: Description and analysis: form and style by comparison (Wolfflin), iconography of the subject (Panofsky's first and second strata)
- L6: Interpretation: iconology and context (patrons, society, the mode of production, gender), the schools, periods and the canon
- L7: Histories of art in use: histories and catalogues written, exhibitions made, attributions given to the trade and the courts, conservation and restitution decided, teaching
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Identification: who made the work, when, where, from what, and whose it has been (attribution, dating, authentication, provenance); the catalogue entry
- L5: Description and analysis: form and style (line, shape, colour, texture, composition; comparison of works), and iconography (the subject: Panofsky's first and second strata)
- L6: Interpretation: iconology (intrinsic meaning), context (patrons, society, politics), the theoretical schools, periods and the canon
- L7: Histories of art and their uses: the narrative written (Vasari to the survey), the catalogue raisonné published, the exhibition made, the attribution given to owners, courts and the trade
way in: Corpora: digitised collections read by computation
- L1: Digitised collections: almost 140,000 paintings over nearly a millennium; 14,912 landscapes; 300 drawings with over 80,000 strokes
- L2: Datasets chosen to stand for 'the canonical historiography of Western art'
- L3: Measures from local pixel order and partitions: permutation entropy, statistical complexity, compositional proportion; stroke features
- L4: Classification: strokes attributed to artists, fakes detected
way in: Documents: provenance records, contracts, inventories, books of secrets
- L1: Records of ownership, custody and location; artists' treatises and books of secrets
- L2: Archives, sale catalogues and museum registers searched; pro-active registers for works that changed hands 1933-1945
- L3: Documentary criticism: the chain of custody assembled ('essentially a matter of documentation')
way in: Handling: the object examined in the hand and under the stereo microscope
- L1: The physical object: support, ground, paint surface, frame
- L2: Naked-eye observation and stereo microscopy
- L3: Reading physical clues: tools and methods out of period, artificial ageing, drilled 'worm' holes
way in: Looking: the work seen by the trained eye (connoisseurship)
- L1: Light from the painted, drawn or carved surface, met in the gallery or the study room
- L2: The eye's fixations on the work: drawn to salient regions, varying with the viewer's appreciation and knowledge
- L3: Trained looking: the artist's specific traits against the era's; Morelli's trifling details (ears, hands) that copyists miss
way in: Sampling: microsamples analysed for materials and absolute dates
- L1: The work's materials: canvas fibres, panel wood, pigments, oil binder; microsamples under 500 micrograms
- L2: Laboratory analysis: accelerator mass spectrometry radiocarbon, dendrochronology, GC-MS, synchrotron nano-tomography
- L3: Dates and compositions: a terminus post quem from the earliest date of a material, or an absolute date (bomb-peak carbon)
way in: Technical imaging: X-rays, infrared, ultraviolet and spectral maps
- L1: Radiation outside visible light passing through or re-emitted by paint layers
- L2: Noninvasive instruments: MA-XRF, MA-XRPD, reflectance imaging spectroscopy, X-radiography, infrared reflectography
- L3: Element and pigment maps; hidden earlier paintings, underdrawings, repairs, degradation products
way in: Testimony: expert meetings, debriefings, dealers' and artists' accounts
- L1: Experts speaking in front of the works
- L2: Structured elicitation of expert judgement with a final debriefing
- L3: Coding the experts' argumentation
way in: The beholder's response: how a work moves the viewer
- L1: The work in view and the viewer's body (the beholder Winckelmann put at the centre)
- L2: Sensory and emotional reactions integrated with personal relevance
- L3: Valuation: striatal activity tracks ratings; frontal default-mode regions step up only for the most moving works; viewers agree little (0.13)
way in: The literature: earlier art-historical writing and catalogues
- L1: Texts about art: Pliny's Natural History, Vasari's Lives, Winckelmann, the journals
- L2: Libraries and research institutes (the Warburg library became an institute)
- L3: Reading critically: Vasari's 'many factual errors'
- L4: Catalogues raisonnés and corpora used as the reference for identification (the RRP's corpus)
way in: The present's questions: movements, claims and the market
- L1: Movements and claims in society: second-wave feminism; restitution of looted and colonial-era objects; commercialisation of art
- L2: The profession's forums: the 1972 College Art Association panel; conferences
- L3: A new question framed (Nochlin: why no great women artists?; which works changed hands under the Nazis?)
- L4: Collections searched for gaps: provenance research for 1933-1945
- L5: Re-reading the canon: critical re-readings of single works and of the canon
way in: Thought: the art historian's own reasoning, theory and imagination
- L1: Prior knowledge and the frameworks brought to the work (historical materialism, critical theory, psychoanalysis)
- L4: Cultural knowledge applied to what is seen (Panofsky's second stratum)
- L5: Synthesis: 'what does it all mean?' (Panofsky's third stratum)
way out: Attribution and authentication given to owners, the trade and courts
- L1: The work's standing and price in the trade
- L4: The opinion or certificate attached to the work; the evidence of a forgery handed to investigators
- L7: The judgement: genuine, studio, copy or forgery
way out: Conservation decisions: the examined work treated, stabilised or left
- L1: The object's materials kept as close to original condition as possible
- L4: Treatment plan from the technical findings (Operation Night Watch)
- L7: The decision to treat, informed by condition
way out: Exhibition and teaching: works chosen, hung, labelled and shown
- L1: The work in the gallery, met by visitors for about half a minute each
- L5: Display and selection: most of the collection stays in storage
- L7: Curatorial choice of what to show
way out: Provenance findings acted on: restitution and public disclosure
- L1: Ownership settled: the chain of custody judged morally and legally
- L4: Registers and labels made public
- L7: The finding that a work was looted, or of colonial origin
way out: Writing: histories, monographs, catalogues raisonnés, journals
- L1: The text in the record: the Art Bulletin, Art Journal, Art History, the Rembrandt Database
- L4: The catalogue entry: title, date, dimensions, medium, attribution
- L7: The history decided: a narrative of progression (Vasari) or of styles without names (Wolfflin)