← all systems · see it in The System
Modified gravity
Theories that change general relativity's dynamics of spacetime. 'Alternatives to general relativity are physical theories that attempt to describe the phenomenon of gravitation in competition with Einstein's theory of general relativity'; in cosmology, 'covariant theories of modified gravities ... alter the dynamics of spacetime such that the modified dynamics stems to what have been assigned to the presence of dark energy and dark matter'. Clifton et al. survey 'Scalar-Tensor, Einstein-Aether, and Bimetric theories, as well as TeVeS, f(R), general higher-order theories, Horava-Lifschitz gravity, Galileons, Ghost Condensates, and models of extra dimensions'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Modified gravity (covariant dark-sector unification) |
| boundary | Inside: gravitational dynamics that differ from general relativity's: a changed Lagrangian (f(R), higher order, Lovelock, Gauss-Bonnet), added scalar, vector or tensor fields (scalar-tensor, vector-tensor, bimetric, TeVeS), extra dimensions (DGP, braneworlds), non-metric structure (torsion, teleparallelism). Outside: general relativity itself (the reference, Einstein-Hilbert action); dark energy and dark matter as substances (the rival explanation); quantum theories of gravity and unified theories (other categories of alternatives). |
| nested level | A family of rival dynamics for the gravitational field; tested against the equivalence principle, post-Newtonian parameters, strong-field and gravitational-wave data and cosmology; proposed as a replacement for dark energy, dark matter or inflation. |
| representation | True |
| scale | cosmological |
Measures (11) published science
| speed of gravity minus speed of light (GW170817) | between -3 x 10^-15 and +7 x 10^-16 fraction of c |
| GW170817 to GRB 170817A delay | +1.74 +- 0.05 s |
| post-Newtonian parameters | 10 (gamma, beta, eta, alpha_1-3, zeta_1-4) count |
| gamma and beta in general relativity | 1 and 1 dimensionless |
| free parameters of general relativity | 0 count |
| weak equivalence principle bound quoted for testing alternatives | eta < 5 x 10^-13 dimensionless |
| local Lorentz invariance bound quoted | delta < 1 x 10^-21 dimensionless |
| luminous red galaxies in the Reyes et al. test | 70,205 count |
| MOND introduced | 1983 (Milgrom) date |
| TeVeS introduced | 2004 (Bekenstein) date |
| characteristic clock: none (a family of laws); the Hubble time sets the epoch where cosmological modifications act | no value given s |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-098 Are galaxy rotation and cosmic acceleration caused by unseen matter and energy, or by gravity behaving differently?
booked: The map follows the mainstream view of unseen components (dark matter and dark energy), and keeps modified gravity alongside.
the other reading: B: modified gravity (alternatives to GR)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Modified gravity. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- red-queen (surface)
Tests tighten and theories adjust: 'As experimental tests get more accurate, the deviation of the scalar-tensor theories from general relativity is being squashed to zero'; GW170817 removed many at once. - same role, different builds (surface)
One role, the gravitational dynamics, built many ways: changed Lagrangian (f(R), Lovelock), added fields (scalar-tensor, vector-tensor, bimetric, TeVeS), extra dimensions (DGP), torsion (Einstein-Cartan).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (9) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Dark matter via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity mixed
- Dark energy via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity mixed
- Quintom dark energy (quintom scenario; hypothesised) via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity even
- Gravitational wave via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity loss
- Einstein-Hilbert action via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity mixed
- Equivalence principle via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity loss
- DGP gravity (Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati braneworld; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity even
- f(R) gravity (modified gravity; walked as a projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Modified gravity even
- General relativity via sys:written-record · Modified gravity loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (1)
floor filled by (14)
- Dark energy
- Dark matter
- Scalar field
- Gravitational wave
- Metric tensor
- DGP gravity (Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati braneworld; walked as a projected model)
- f(R) gravity (modified gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Lovelock gravity
- Bimetric gravity (Hassan-Rosen bigravity)
- Scalar-tensor theory
- MOND (relativistic forms)
- Vector-tensor theory
- Einstein-Hilbert action
- Equivalence principle
represents (1)
Kinds (24)
- Horava-Lifshitz gravity (walked as a projected model)
- Gravitational field
- Dark energy
- Einstein field equations
- General relativity
- Universe
- Gravity
- DGP gravity (Dvali-Gabadadze-Porrati braneworld; walked as a projected model)
- f(R) gravity (modified gravity; walked as a projected model)
- Horndeski gravity
- Massive gravity
- Brans-Dicke theory
- Lovelock gravity
- Einstein-aether theory
- f(T) gravity
- f(Q) gravity
- Bimetric gravity (Hassan-Rosen bigravity)
- Scalar-tensor theory
- Gauss-Bonnet gravity
- TeVeS
- MOND (relativistic forms)
- Vector-tensor theory
- Einstein-Cartan theory
- Teleparallelism
Notes published science
- One neutron-star merger settled a lot of theories: gravitational waves and gamma rays from GW170817 arrived 1.74 seconds apart, pinning the speed of gravity to light's within a few parts in 10^15 and excluding many dark-energy alternatives at once.
- MOND predicted in 1993 that a galaxy's baryonic mass grows as the fourth power of its flat rotation speed, and observation confirmed it; yet MOND-like theories still fail to reproduce galaxy clusters.
- General relativity has no free parameters; every scalar-tensor rival has at least one, and the tests keep pushing it toward the GR value.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
modified gravitational dynamics (projected model)
- L1: Field content: metric theories (a symmetric metric governs proper time; matter obeys covariant conservation of T^mu nu) with added scalar, vector or second-tensor fields; non-metric theories (Einstein-Cartan torsion, teleparallelism, gauge theory gravity)
- L2: The action changed: 'Almost every theory described in this article has an action'; GR's L proportional to R becomes f(R), R + R^2 (Starobinsky), Gauss-Bonnet, Stelle's fourth-derivative, infinite-derivative, Lovelock, or a scalar-tensor L_phi with at least one free parameter (GR has none); the original 1983 MOND had no action
- L3: Weak field: the Einstein equivalence principle filters (metric theories satisfy it); ten post-Newtonian parameters (gamma and beta equal 1 in GR; alpha_1-3 preferred-frame; zeta_1-4 and alpha_3 conservation); scalar-tensor and vector-tensor deviations from GR 'being squashed to zero' as tests improve
- L4: Strong field and waves: white dwarfs, pulsar spin-down, binary pulsars, black hole horizons; GW170817's 1.74 +- 0.05 s delay bounds the gravity-light speed difference to between -3 x 10^-15 and +7 x 10^-16 of c, excluding many theories
- L5: Cosmology: motivations 'almost all cosmological, associated with or replacing such constructs as inflation, dark matter and dark energy'; tests are rotation curves, Tully-Fisher, dwarf velocity dispersions, cluster lensing (dark matter), CMB ripples (inflation), supernovae and the age of the universe (dark energy); MOND's 1993 prediction that baryonic mass scales as the fourth power of the flat rotation speed was confirmed; Reyes et al. used 70,205 luminous red galaxies with results 'still tentative'