← all systems · see it in The System
Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers)
An interval of time beginning approximately 538.8 million years ago in the Cambrian period, during which a sudden radiation of complex life occurred, lasting between 13 and 25 million years and resulting in the divergence of most modern metazoan phyla. Walked here as the contest it was fought through: 'arms races between predators and prey', 'more general mechanisms of coevolution', and burrowers that 'broke down and weakened the microbial mats'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the contested marine ecospace (seafloor substrate, the microbial mats that sealed it, the water column above) and the taking and holding layers of the contestants: predators' eyes, borers and shell-crushers; prey's armour, spines, shells and shelters; burrowers' bioturbation; mat-bound fauna (mat encrusters, mat scratchers, mat stickers, undermat miners). Outside: the conditions that set the contest's terms but are not contestants: atmospheric and ocean oxygen, ocean calcium, alkalinity and phosphorus, continents and glaciations, the deep and harsh refuges the contest did not reach. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from a pool (marine ecospace, and the mat substrate within it) and takers that are animal lineages (mostly bilaterians, with sponges and cnidarians present from the Ediacaran) against the Ediacaran biota and the mats themselves. It runs on bodies built by the developmental toolkit and on the nervous system's senses, and is gated by dissolved oxygen. Embedded in the marine biosphere of the early Paleozoic; continues as one long radiation into the Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event. |
| scale | ecological |
Measures (26) published science
| start of the Cambrian (2022 chart) | 538.8 Ma |
| clock: duration of the explosion | 13 to 25 million years |
| elevated rates ended by base of Cambrian Series 2 (first trilobites) | 521 Ma |
| Ediacaran biota flourished before the Cambrian | 40 million years |
| Ediacaran biota range | about 600 to 538.8 Ma |
| Ediacaran assemblages (Avalon / White Sea / Nama) | 575-565 / 560-550 / 550-542 Ma |
| first traces on and under mats | about 565 Ma |
| Cloudina and Namacalathus mineralised tubes | 549-542 Ma |
| Budd's Tube world / Rusophycus world | 550-536 / 536-521 Ma |
| earliest trilobite fossils | about 530 Ma |
| oldest certain fossil eye (Schmidtiellus reetae); first possible eyes | about 530; about 555 Ma |
| clock: time for a vertebrate eye from a photoreceptor patch (pessimistic model) | less than 364,000 years |
| predation pressure on stromatolites and acritarchs since | about 1250 Ma |
| mineralisation defending algae from single-celled predators | about 750 Ma |
| carnivores absent below | 0.34 (about 15 uM) mL/L dissolved O2 |
| modern oxygen minimum zone threshold | <0.5 (22 uM) mL/L dissolved O2 |
| small shelly fossil size | mostly 1 to 2 mm |
| living animal phyla never found as fossils | two-thirds of 30-plus phyla |
| living species that are animals | three quarters (most of the rest formed by coevolution with animals) fraction |
| bilaterian share of known animal species | over 98% fraction |
| Qingjiang biota (518 Ma): specimens; share of species new | more than 20,000; about half |
| Neoproterozoic Oxygenation Event interval | about 850 to 540 Ma |
| atmospheric O2 before / early Neoproterozoic / Cryogenian interglacial | <0.1% / >13% / possibly ~50% PAL |
| first evidence of biomineralization; sponge-grade calcite skeletons | about 750; about 630 Ma |
| mineralized skeletons produced for the past | 550 million years |
| mollusc shell calcium carbonate by weight | 95-99 % |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (7) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- who opens the door (structural)
a port installed ahead of time: the embryo region's competence to read whichever Hox gene is expressed there (the source names the outcome, not the receptor) - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
The microbial mat sealed the sediment (anoxic, H2S-rich); once burrowers broke it, oxygen entered and 'a wider range of organisms' could live there, 'creating new niches and the scope for higher diversity'. Breaking a barrier opened complexity, the mirror of the sponge sighting (no barrier kept spon - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Precambrian organisms used the same elements as later skeletons 'for a different purpose, perhaps to avoid the inadvertent precipitation of calcium carbonate from the supersaturated Proterozoic oceans'; a magnetite pathway of the bilaterian ancestor may have been 'duplicated and modified in the Camb - lightning (partial)
Runaway after a threshold: an arms race is 'often described as an example of positive feedback'; carnivory appears only above an oxygen floor (absent below 0.34 mL/L); the burst runs 13-25 Myr and stops when niches are full and 'incumbents usually had the advantage'. Charge, threshold, discharge, ex - red-queen (partial)
Van Valen: 'the evolutionary progress of one species deteriorates the fitness of coexisting species, but because coexisting species evolve as well, no one species gains a long-term increase in fitness'; predator and prey 'were one of the two to stop evolving, it would go extinct'. The Cambrian artic - not-diluting wins (surface)
Before the Cambrian, plankton droppings and corpses had drag about equal to their weight and were destroyed before reaching the seabed; larger mesozooplankton made packets that sank fast, delivering concentrated energy and nutrients to the floor and burying carbon (more oxygen). The packet that does not disperse wins the delivery. Shape only: not a density that stays constant while others dilute. - outside-to-inside (surface)
Oxygen moved from the water into the sediment by bioturbation instead of being held out by the mat; H2S retreated to deeper layers.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (13) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota) via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Dioxygen (O2) via sys:aqueous-solution · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Bacterium (bacterial cell) via sys:aqueous-solution · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Biofilm via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Sponge (Porifera) via sys:aqueous-solution · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Developmental genetic toolkit (evo-devo gene toolkit) via sys:sequential-information · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Bilaterian animal (Bilateria) via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Ediacaran biota via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life) via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma) via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event (GOBE) via sys:seafloor-sediment · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) even
- Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers) via sys:trophic-network · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
- Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) via sys:aqueous-solution · Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Biofilm
- Sponge (Porifera)
- Cnidarian (Cnidaria)
- Developmental genetic toolkit (evo-devo gene toolkit)
- Nervous system
- Bilaterian animal (Bilateria)
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life)
- Ediacaran biota
- Earth in the Paleozoic era (Cambrian to Permian)
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (10)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Overcome Barrier
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Resilience & Repair
floor filled by (3)
- Marine ecospace (the sea's modes of life)
- Trophic network (food webs: who eats whom, from primary production through consumers to decomposers)
- Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time)
reflects (13)
- Photon
- Dark energy
- Inflaton field
- Cell
- Eukaryotic cell
- Competition for a cell's machinery (phage vs cell)
- Competition for biofilm nutrients (related strains)
- Sponge (Porifera)
- Neuron (nerve cell)
- Developmental genetic toolkit (evo-devo gene toolkit)
- Adaptive immune system
- Bone
- Vertebrate brain
Notes published science
- The burrowers ate the floor they stood on: 'this burrowing led to the downfall of the mats they were feeding on', and the same churning ended the conditions that made Burgess Shale fossils, so the winners erased the record of the contest.
- One number for a predator: carnivores vanish from a community below 0.34 mL/L of oxygen (Sperling 2013). Oxygen sets when the fight can start, the arms race sets what it makes.
- Armour from a chore: Precambrian cells handled the same elements to avoid accidental calcium carbonate precipitation in supersaturated seas, and a magnetite sensing pathway may have been rebuilt into shells.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
developmental toolkit (Hox and regulatory genes)
- L1: The genetic architecture that could have played a role in the explosion, already well established by the Cambrian (Precambrian metazoan and molecular evidence)
- L2: Hox genes control which organs individual regions of an embryo develop into
- L3: A minor change (a different Hox gene expressed in a region) can make a major phenotypic change (a limb becomes an eye)
- L4: A large range of disparity from a limited set of genes; triploblastic embryos form three layers early in development (gut, skin, muscles and organs)
- L5: Horizontal gene transfer: the gene for a critical biomineralisation protein came from a bacterium into sponges
light (vision)
- L1: Light in shallow seas; before eyesight, hunting and evading were close-range affairs using smell, vibration and touch
- L2: Photoreceptor cells, probably long before the explosion; first possible eye fossils ~555 Ma; oldest certain eye Schmidtiellus reetae ~530 Ma
- L3: Pit eyes by the Cambrian; diverse eyes in the Emu Bay and Burgess Shales; prey eyes on the side of the head for a wide field of view
- L4: Predators 'could see their prey from a distance'; prey need new defensive strategies
- L5: Armour, spines and similar defences 'may also have evolved in response to vision'; in lightless caves, diversity of animal forms tends to decrease
seafloor sediment and its mat cover (mechanical contact, bioturbation)
- L1: Ediacaran seafloor: microbial mats lining a less water-logged, almost anoxic substrate
- L2: Meiofauna between sand grains dislodge grains and disturb the resistant biomats; vertical burrows (Skolithos, Diplocraterion) and arthropod traces (Cruziana, Rusophycus) penetrate the sediment
- L3: Bioirrigation (oxygen into the sediment) versus biomixing (grains moved, organic matter carried down, can lower oxygen); predominantly biomixing on both sides of the boundary
- L4: Predation and shelter: borings in Cloudina shells, shell-crushing, burrowing to hide; armour and shelters arise together (the 'Verdun Syndrome')
- L5: Mats restricted to harsh, rocky or deep refuges; undermat miners extinct by the mid Cambrian; helicoplacoids extinct; stalked eocrinoids and edrioasteroids survive; Burgess-type preservation ends
seawater chemistry (dissolved oxygen, H2S, calcium)
- L1: Seawater and pore water carrying O2, H2S and dissolved ions (calcium surge from ridges or erosion; rising alkalinity; low Ediacaran phosphorus)
- L2: Oxygen uptake set by absorbing surface against body volume; carnivores absent when O2 <0.34 mL/L
- L3: Biomineralisation: calcium carbonate shells (Cloudina, earliest calcifying organisms), phosphate and silica skeletons
- L4: Food webs: higher oxygen supports more complex food webs and widespread carnivory
- L5: Escalatory arms races driven by the newly evolved carnivores
water column and biological pump (plankton, droppings, burial)
- L1: Seawater carrying microscopic plankton
- L2: Early Cambrian mesozooplankton filtered microscopic plankton from the seawater; the first herbivorous mesozooplankton were probably larvae of benthic animals
- L3: Droppings and corpses large enough to fall fairly quickly carried energy and nutrients to mid-levels and the sea floor; fecal matter in aggregate form increased nutrients in deeper waters (2026 coprolite study)
- L4: Remains sinking uneaten to the sea floor could be buried, taking carbon out of circulation
- L5: With carbon removed (it readily combines with oxygen), breathable oxygen in the seas increases
Who fills each layer
- L1: Seafloor sediment (marine sediment)
- L2: Seafloor sediment (marine sediment)
- L3: Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time), Seafloor sediment (marine sediment)