← all systems · see it in The System
Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time)
The growth in number and kinds of mineral species on a planet or moon as its physical, chemical and biological environment changes. Hazen et al. 2008: 'The mineralogy of terrestrial planets evolves as a consequence of a range of physical, chemical, and biological processes.' Encyclopedia: 'It postulates that mineralogy on planets and moons becomes increasingly complex as a result of changes in the physical, chemical and biological environment.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | >4.56 Ga |
| born precision | stage table ('>4.56') |
| boundary | Inside: the stock of mineral species a body holds and the processes that add to it or take from it: melting, crystallisation and separation of elements; reactions with water, carbon dioxide and oxygen; subduction, uplift and mountain building; impacts; and the new reaction pathways of living organisms and, lately, of people. Outside: the elements themselves (made in stars), the heat sources, the atmosphere, ocean and organisms that change the conditions, and the human science that names and counts the species (the idea, rung 11). |
| nested level | Built from mineral species and the stages and eras Hazen et al. (2008) divide Earth's history into; embedded in planets and moons (Earth the fullest case, with the Moon, Mercury, Mars and Venus stopping at earlier stages); its layers feed the mineral-surface walk's diversification floor and the crust's new-minerals floor. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (35) published science
| mineral species, Solar System (presolar to today) | about a dozen to over 5400 species |
| prenebular ur-minerals | 12 (paper: 'approximately a dozen refractory minerals') species |
| cumulative species, stage 1 (Sun ignites) | 60 species |
| cumulative species, stage 2 (planetesimals) | 250 (paper: 'limited to ~250 different minerals found in unweathered meteorite samples'; the encyclopedia text also says '250 new minerals formed in this stage', which its own table gives as cumulative) species |
| cumulative species, stage 3 (igneous rock evolution) | 350-420 (420 for Hadean Earth's widely occurring phases, plus over 100 rare) species |
| cumulative species, stage 4 (granitoids and pegmatites) | 1000 species |
| cumulative species, stage 5 (plate tectonics) | 1500 (paper: 'an estimated 1500 different mineral species' by the Neoarchean) |
| cumulative species, stage 6 (anoxic biological world) | 1500 species |
| cumulative species, stages 7-9 (GOE, intermediate ocean, snowball) | >4000 species |
| cumulative species, stage 10 (Phanerozoic) | >5413 species |
| known mineral species, 2008 | about 4300 species |
| IMA-recognised mineral species, November 2018 | 5413 species |
| species on a volatile-poor body (Mercury, the Moon) | about 350 (paper: 'no more than ~350 species') |
| new minerals from melting cycles concentrating rare elements (stage 4) | 500 (paper: 'Pegmatites feature >550 minerals') species |
| new sulfosalt minerals with plate tectonics (stage 5) | 150 species |
| new minerals at the Great Oxidation Event | about 2500 species |
| uranyl minerals from oxidised uraninite | over 200 species |
| copper oxides and silicates | 321 species |
| share of species from oxidised and hydrated minerals | more than half of ~4300 ('more than half are oxidized and hydrated') fraction |
| share of species mediated by living organisms | more than two-thirds (paper: 'may be responsible directly or indirectly for more than two thirds') fraction |
| mineral phases formed by organisms | over 64 (paper: 'more than 60 minerals') phases |
| biominerals in the human body | over two dozen phases |
| IMA minerals primarily or exclusively from human activity | 208 species |
| inorganic crystalline compounds in the Inorganic Crystal Structure Database | over 180,000 compounds |
| oxygen level at which weathering became modern-like | 1% of the present atmospheric level fraction of PAL |
| formation temperature of the first (presolar) minerals | above 1500 degrees C |
| diamond crystallisation temperature | about 4400 degrees C |
| oldest mineral inclusions in zircon | 4.4 Ga |
| mercury-mineral hiatus | 1.8 Ga to 600 Ma (about 1.2 billion years with no new mercury minerals) |
| onset of modern plate tectonics (estimates) | 4.5 Ga to 1.0 Ga |
| major atmospheric oxidation events (Hazen et al. 2008) | around 2.2 and 0.6 Ga |
| Great Oxidation Event span (stage 7 text) | starting around 2.45 Ga, continuing to about 2.0 or 1.9 Ga (table: 2.5-1.9 Ga) |
| era dates (Earth) | planetary accretion >4.55 Ga; crust and mantle reworking 4.55-2.5 Ga; biologically mediated mineralogy 2.5 Ga to present |
| stage dates (Earth, table) | 1 >4.56; 2 >4.56-4.55; 3 4.55-4.0; 4 4.0-3.5; 5 >3.0; 6 3.9-2.5; 7 2.5-1.9; 8 1.85-0.85; 9 0.85-0.542 (text: 1.0-0.542); 10 <0.542 Ga; 'some of which overlap' |
| characteristic clock: length of a stage | about 0.3 to 1.0 billion years for stages 3-9 (stage 3 4.55-4.0 Ga; stage 8 1.85-0.85 Ga); stages 1-2 within about 10 million years (>4.56 to 4.55 Ga) Gyr |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-164 Was the iron in ancient banded rocks rusted by oxygen from cyanobacteria, or by bacteria that need no oxygen?
booked: The map keeps all the proposed routes (cyanobacterial oxygen, iron-oxidising bacteria without oxygen, and others) side by side.
the other reading: 'BIFs are not unambiguously biotic' (abiotic or anoxygenic oxidation) - C-177 When did plate tectonics begin on Earth?
booked: The map leaves the start date open and lists the proposed dates, from the Hadean to about 800 million years ago.
the other reading: 'estimates of the onset of modern plate tectonics range from 4.5 Ga to 1.0 Ga' - C-187 How long did the deep ocean stay low in oxygen and rich in iron?
booked: The map keeps all the dated readings, from 1.85 billion years to about 580 million years ago, rather than one end date.
the other reading: a sulfidic ocean that was not widespread - C-205 On what kind of mineral surface did life begin?
booked: The map treats minerals as possible helpers in life's origin and leaves open which ones: clays, metal sulfides or borates.
the other reading: clays vs transition-metal sulfides vs borates and molybdates; or no mineral role - C-219 Once a mineral disappears from Earth, can it come back?
booked: The map follows the view that mineral change is an irreversible sequence, and keeps the argument that a lost mineral could re-form under the right conditions alongside.
the other reading: Rosing 2008 (in the encyclopedia): 'mineral extinction is not truly irreversible; a lost mineral could emerge again if suitable environmental conditions were re-established' - C-220 Do peaks in the ages of ancient minerals show when they formed, or only which ones survived?
booked: The map keeps both readings: real changes in production, or simply better preservation.
the other reading: both may be preservation: 'not clear whether this is due to changes in subduction activity or preservation'; 'some of this perception may be due to poor preservation'
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (16)
- Great Oxidation Event (the oxygen crisis and what it released)
- Cryogenian Snowball Earth (Sturtian and Marinoan glaciations, and the thaw)
- Boring Billion (informal, about 1.8-0.8 Ga)
- Mineral
- Presolar grain
- Era of planetary accretion (>4.55 Ga)
- Stage 1: Sun ignites, heating nebula (>4.56 Ga)
- Stage 2: Planetesimals form (>4.56-4.55 Ga)
- Era of crust and mantle reworking (4.55-2.5 Ga)
- Stage 3: Igneous rock evolution (4.55-4.0 Ga)
- Stage 4: Granitoid and pegmatite formation (4.0-3.5 Ga)
- Stage 5: Plate tectonics (>3.0 Ga)
- Era of biologically mediated mineralogy (2.5 Ga to present)
- Stage 6: Anoxic biological world (3.9-2.5 Ga)
- Stage 10: Phanerozoic era of biomineralization (<0.542 Ga)
- Proposed stage 11: human-made minerals (Anthropocene)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (21)
- Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma) via sys:redox-gradient · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Mineral via sys:thermal-energy · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Molecular cloud via sys:gravitational-field · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Hydrosphere (Earth's planetary water, above all the early ocean) via sys:water-cycle · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Earth's crust (primordial, oceanic and continental) via sys:thermal-energy · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Planetesimal / planetary embryo via sys:gravitational-field · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression) via sys:mantle-convection · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Abiogenesis (origin of life) via sys:mineral-surface · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) even
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:water-cycle · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Sun via sys:thermal-energy · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota) via sys:redox-gradient · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers) via sys:aqueous-solution · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Seafloor sediment (marine sediment) via sys:aqueous-solution · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Cosmic dust via sys:gravitational-field · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation) via sys:redox-gradient · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) mixed
- Earth in the Hadean eon via sys:gravitational-field · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) mixed
- Great Oxidation Event (the oxygen crisis and what it released) via sys:redox-gradient · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Cryogenian Snowball Earth (Sturtian and Marinoan glaciations, and the thaw) via sys:water-cycle · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:mechanical-contact · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Vascular plants (tracheophytes) via sys:mineral-surface · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
- Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth) via sys:thermal-energy · Mineral evolution (the diversification of a planet's minerals through time) gain
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (36)
- Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma)
- Mineral
- Planet
- Earth's crust (primordial, oceanic and continental)
- Planetesimal / planetary embryo
- Mantle convection (with plate tectonics, its surface expression)
- Cell
- Olivine and pyroxene (ultramafic mantle rock)
- Calcium phosphate minerals (apatite)
- Meteorites
- Atmosphere of Earth
- Sun
- Large impactors (asteroids, comets)
- Cyanobacterium (Cyanobacteria, phylum Cyanobacteriota)
- Cambrian explosion, as a competition (predators vs prey; burrowers vs mat-dwellers)
- Cosmic dust
- Redox gradient (environmental redox zonation)
- Earth in the Hadean eon
- Earth in the Archean eon
- Magma ocean
- Hadean zircon
- Columbia (Nuna) supercontinent
- Banded iron formation (the sink written in rock)
- Mineral surfaces (rock and grain surfaces at a planet's surface)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Vascular plants (tracheophytes)
- Ice
- Evaporite
- Subduction zones (the descending limb)
- Stromatolite
- Human-made minerals
- Mineral evolution of volatile-poor bodies (Mercury, the Moon; stops at stage 3)
- Uranyl minerals
- Inorganic Crystal Structure Database
- Plankton
- Pegmatite
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
- Mineral evolution of asteroids (stops at stage 2)
- Mineral evolution of volatile-poor bodies (Mercury, the Moon; stops at stage 3)
- Mineral evolution of Mars (stage 3 reached)
- Mineral evolution of Venus (perhaps stage 4, then losses)
Notes published science
- Mercury went quiet for 1.2 billion years: no new mercury minerals from 1.8 Ga to 600 Ma, because a sulfide-rich ocean swept the mercury into cinnabar as fast as it arrived; Hazen's team also suggests the same sulfide mineralisation 'may have deterred the radiation of life for a billion years'.
- The Great Oxidation Event made about 2500 new minerals without making a single new iron mineral: iron only changed abundance, while uranium alone gave over 200 new uranyl species.
- Plankton changed the odds of a snowball Earth by moving calcium carbonate from shallow water to the deep ocean, which starved the cap carbonates that follow a snowball and 'making future snowball Earth events less likely'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
accretion and impacts: dust to planetesimals and planets (gravitational field)
- L1: Accretion: new minerals clump into asteroids and planets; dust, bombardment, heating and water raise the count to 250.
- L2: Bombardment shock and heat: ringwoodite, a major component of Earth's mantle.
- L3: The Moon-forming impact: most of the crust and mantle melted, opening the second era.
- L4: Body size and volatiles set the end point: small volatile-poor bodies stop near 350 species ('the probable end point of mineral evolution for relatively small' bodies).
crust and mantle reworking: subduction and plate tectonics (mantle convection)
- L1: Subduction carrying crust and water down at the onset of plate tectonics (dated 4.5 to 1.0 Ga by different estimates).
- L2: Fluid-rock interaction concentrating rare elements: sulfide deposits with 150 new sulfosalt minerals.
- L3: High-pressure phases from cool rock taken deep, later uplifted and exposed as kyanite and sillimanite.
- L4: Mountain building and supercontinents: a pulse of beryllium, boron and mercury minerals with the assembly of Columbia, perhaps from mineralising fluids; lead, zinc and silver reserves in Boring Billion rocks.
- L5: The record: zircon ages, nearly independent of where the crystals are found, rise and fall with the supercontinent cycle; production or preservation unclear.
heat: melting, crystallisation and the separation of elements (thermal energy)
- L1: Heat sources: the young Sun in its T Tauri phase melting nearby dust; radionuclide heating of asteroids; the Moon-forming impact melting most of the crust and mantle.
- L2: Melting: melt droplets that became chondrules; partial melting of asteroids into pyroxene- and plagioclase-rich melts; basalt remelted into granitoids.
- L3: Separation and concentration: siderophile and lithophile elements part into core and crust; incompatible elements sequestered in the melts; planetary differentiation, outgassing, fractional crystallisation and partial melting ('they increased the range of bulk compositions').
- L4: Crystallisation by thermodynamic rule: an element joins a crystal only if it lowers the energy; at high temperature elements interchange (olivine); repeated fractional melting and crystallisation and immiscible magmas (Bowen's reaction series); cooling widens temperature and pressure and allows specialised combinations.
- L5: Concentration to saturation: cycles of melting concentrate lithium, beryllium, boron, niobium, tantalum and uranium until 500 new minerals form, many in pegmatites in dikes and veins.
- L6: Keeping the stage's minerals: 60 new minerals in chondrites; eucrites and iron meteorites; mineral inclusions in zircon back to 4.4 Ga; the end point for small volatile-poor bodies (about 350).
human manufacture and redistribution (mechanical contact)
- L1: Mining and infrastructure: rocks, sediments and minerals redistributed on a scale rivalling glaciation, valuable minerals juxtaposed in ways that would not occur naturally.
- L2: Human-caused minerals: 208 IMA-recognised, most formed with mining, some where metal artefacts sank and reacted with the seafloor (abhurite from corroding tin); a proposed 11th stage.
- L3: Manufacture: synthetic gems, ceramics, brick, cement and batteries with mineral equivalents; over 180,000 inorganic crystalline compounds in the ICSD, many with none.
land surface: plants, clays and shields for early life (mineral surface)
- L1: Land before plants: 'Before the Phanerozoic, land was mostly barren rock'.
- L2: Plants on land from the Silurian: an order-of-magnitude increase in clay-mineral production.
- L3: Minerals for early life: a thin quartz layer screening ultraviolet but passing light; apatite made by fractionation and weathered to release phosphorus, perhaps needing plate tectonics.
life's reaction pathways: biomineralisation in water (aqueous solution)
- L1: New reaction pathways: organisms catalyse reactions that make minerals out of equilibrium with their surroundings, such as aragonite ('living organisms opened up new reaction pathways').
- L2: Anoxic-world traces: life may have helped precipitate massive carbonates and lay down banded iron formations, but there is no unambiguous evidence; stromatolites the clearest local biomineralisation.
- L3: Skeletons: biomineralisation widespread in the Phanerozoic; most skeletal forms in the Cambrian explosion; calcite, aragonite, apatite and opal; over 64 phases in organisms, over two dozen in the human body.
- L4: Moving and burying: plankton carry calcium carbonate from shallow to deep water, inhibiting cap carbonates; microbes turn geochemical cycles biogeochemical; organic minerals in coal and black shales.
oxidation state: oxygen at the surface and in the ocean (redox gradient)
- L1: The reduced state: multi-valence elements kept at their lowest oxidation state; siderite, uraninite and pyrite survive weathering and transport.
- L2: Oxygen arrives: photosynthetic organisms flood the atmosphere with oxygen (about 2.4 Ga; stage 7 from about 2.45 to 2.0 or 1.9 Ga; the paper's oxidation events around 2.2 and 0.6 Ga).
- L3: Modern-like weathering above 1% of present oxygen: siderite and pyrite replaced by magnetite and hematite; dissolved Fe2+ laid down in banded iron formations; abundance changes, no new iron minerals.
- L4: New oxidised species: uraninite into over 200 uranyl minerals; copper in 321 oxides and silicates; boron, vanadium, manganese and others; about 2500 new minerals; more than half of the ~4300 species are oxidised and hydrated.
- L5: Ocean redox afterwards: the oxidised surface layer slowly deepens; a sulfide-rich ocean deposits cinnabar fast, with no new mercury minerals from 1.8 Ga to 600 Ma.
volatiles: water, carbon dioxide and oxygen reacting with rock (water cycle)
- L1: Volatile supply: ice beyond the snow line; outgassing of water, CO2 and nitrogen; an ocean growing more saline.
- L2: Aqueous alteration: radionuclide heat melts ice and water reacts with olivine-rich rock (phyllosilicates, magnetite, pyrrhotite, dolomite, calcite, gypsum).
- L3: Hydration, carbonation and evaporation: hydroxides, hydrates, carbonates and evaporites; 'New minerals are formed when volatile compounds such as water, carbon dioxide and O2 react with them'.
- L4: Distinctive suites: ice caps, dry lakes and exhumed metamorphic rock each with their own minerals; in the snowballs ice is the dominant surface mineral; volatiles raise the count above the volatile-poor 350 (Hadean Earth 420 plus over 100 rare).
Who fills each layer
- L4: Earth in the Proterozoic eon (2500 to 538.8 Ma), Crystallization (nucleation and crystal growth)
Sources (4) published science
Mineral evolution (Wikipedia, rev 1378722004, via Wikimedia Enterprise; lead and stage 6-8 sections read) (behind its links)
Great Oxidation Event (Wikipedia, rev 1381612901, 2026-10-23) (behind its links)