EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Late Devonian mass extinction (Kellwasser and Hangenberg events), with the Carboniferous radiation it released

The Late Devonian mass extinction, also known as the Kellwasser event, was a mass extinction event which occurred around 372.15 million years ago, at the boundary between the Frasnian and Famennian ages of the Late Devonian period ... A second mass extinction called the Hangenberg event, also known as the end-Devonian extinction, occurred 13 million years later around 358.86 million years ago, bringing an end to the Famennian and Devonian. The effects of the two extinction events have historically been conflated, and both events collectively profoundly reshaped marine ecosystems. Walked here as a release: 'Those few species that survived the bottleneck were the evolutionary starting point for all vertebrates' (src:uchicago-2010).

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

boundaryInside: the extended Late Devonian crisis interval (extinction rates above background for the last 20-25 Myr of the Devonian, eight to ten distinct events), centred on its two severe pulses: the Kellwasser event at the Frasnian-Famennian boundary (372.2 +/- 1.6 Ma; two pulses about 800,000 years apart) and the Hangenberg event at the end of the Famennian (about 358.9 +/- 0.4 Ma; 100,000 to several hundred thousand years). With them: the doors and loops that broke (shelf-sea oxygen, warm shallow water, the reef system, basin isolation that fed speciation, the land flora and perhaps the ozone shield at the Hangenberg), the survivors, and the early Carboniferous refilling (sharks, ray-finned fishes, crinoids, tetrapods), through Romer's gap. Outside: the Silurian-Devonian Terrestrial Revolution that grew the forests, the mantle plumes under the Siberian and Russian platforms, Earth's long-term carbon cycle, and the Late Paleozoic icehouse that the Famennian glaciation opens.
nested levelBuilt from two main pulses (sys:kellwasser-event, sys:hangenberg-event), contested triggers (rooted forests and their nutrients; Viluy and other trap magmatism; cooling; a possible supernova or impact), the kill chains they set running (eutrophication, anoxia and euxinia; cooling, glaciation and sea-level fall; UV at the Hangenberg; invasions that stopped speciation), the losers (reef builders, placoderms, most trilobites, ammonoids nearly), and the heirs (chondrichthyans, actinopterygians, crinoids, stegocephalians). It sits in the Late Devonian of sys:devonian-period, inside sys:paleozoic-earth and the Phanerozoic Eon; the Hangenberg ends the Devonian and opens sys:carboniferous-period.
scaleplanetary

Measures (39) published science

Kellwasser event (Frasnian-Famennian boundary)372.2 +/- 1.6 (abstract: around 372.15) Ma
characteristic clock: separation of the two Kellwasser pulses (second more severe)approximately 800,000 years
Hangenberg event (end of the Famennian)about 358.9 +/- 0.4 (abstract of the Late Devonian article: around 358.86) Ma
U-Pb ash-bed ages below and above the Hangenberg Black Shale (Poland)358.97 +/- 0.11 and 358.89 +/- 0.20 Ma
characteristic clock: main Hangenberg marine extinction pulse50,000 to 190,000 years
Hangenberg event total duration100,000 to several hundred thousand years
time between Kellwasser and Hangenberg13 million (the UChicago release gives about 15 million) years
Late Devonian epoch382.7 +/- 1.6 to 358.9 +/- 0.4 Ma
Devonian Period end (consistent with the Paleozoic walk)358.86 Ma
Late Devonian extinction start (Devonian article's round figure)about 375 Ma
estimated timespan of the Late Devonian biodiversity loss500,000 to 25 million years (mid-Givetian to end-Famennian)
distinct events over the last 20-25 Myr of the Devonianeight to ten (some say up to seven), two particularly severe events
Kellwasser marine species lost (Stanley 2016)around 40 (severity contested) %
losses into the Carboniferous (McGhee 1996): marine families / genera / species22 / 57 / at least 75 %
Kellwasser and Hangenberg together: families / genera / speciesabout 19 / 50 / at least 70 %
Hangenberg marine genera lost: Bambach 2006 / McGhee et al. 2013 / Sepkoski 1996 (Famennian, all / multiple-interval)31 / 50 / >45, ~28 %
Hangenberg vertebrates lost: high-level clades / species44 / over 96 %
Hangenberg ammonoids lost: families / genera / species75 / 86 / 87 %
Kellwasser ostracod species lost worldwide / Eastern Europearound 80 / 91 %
Hangenberg pelagic ostracod species lost (local maximum)at least 50 (up to 66) %
Hangenberg conodont species lost: pelagic (local maximum) / neriticabout 40 (72) / about 50 %
placoderm families lost at the Kellwasseraround half fraction
trilobite orders lost at the Kellwasser; orders left in the Famennian3 (Corynexochida, Harpetida, Odontopleurida); 2 (Phacopida, Proetida) orders
reef extent reduction after the crisisfactor of 5,000 ratio
speciation by vicariance vs dispersal in the studied Late Devonian clades (normal: almost 3 to 1 for vicariance)28 vs 72 (range 12-50 for vicariance) %
Frasnian share of identified invasion events; Frasnian invasions correlated with transgressions68; 65 %
atmospheric CO2 before to after the F-F transitionabout 15 to 3 times present levels
plant maximum height: start to end of the Devonian30 cm to 30 m
Viluy branch area / magma volumemore than 320,000 km2 / more than 1 million km3
Viluy volcanic phases (weighted means, two estimates)376.7 +/- 3.4 and 364.4 +/- 3.4; or 373.4 +/- 2.1 and 363.2 +/- 2.0 Ma
Cerberean caldera supereruptionapproximately 374 Ma
characteristic clock: Milankovitch cycle modulating glaciation intensity40,000 years
sea-level fall in the Hangenberg middle crisis interval (Morocco)more than 100
selenium bioavailability during Middle and Late Devonian extinction eventsabout 1 % of current oceanic concentration
Romer's gap spanapproximately 360 to 345 (first 15 Myr of the Carboniferous) Ma
characteristic clock: sharks regaining size after the Hangenberg40 million years
characteristic clock: conodont diversity back near pre-extinction levelsby the middle of the Tournaisian stage
characteristic clock: reef ecosystems returnlate Tournaisian (Middle Devonian extent only in the Mesozoic) stage
Hangenberg sites with the equivalent successionover 30, every continent except Antarctica sites

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (16)

Sits inside / holds (3)

Trades with (valence) (20)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (2)

Kinds (1)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

atmosphere: carbon dioxide, climate and the ozone shield

  1. L1: Air whose CO2 falls 'from about 15 to three times present levels' through the Frasnian-Famennian transition; 'CO2 levels dropped steeply throughout the Devonian Period'
  2. L2: Cooling: positive delta-18O excursions across the F-F boundary in brachiopods from North America, Germany, Spain, Morocco, Siberia and China and in conodont apatite, 'suggesting it was a globally synchronous climatic change'
  3. L3: Carbon locked out: silicate weathering (perhaps enhanced by mountain building) and the burial of organic matter; plant carbon 'stored and buried, eventually producing vast coal measures ... which locked the carbon out of the atmosphere and into the lithosphere'
  4. L4: Ozone shield: a possible 'dramatic drop in atmospheric ozone during the Hangenberg event'; proposed breachers: water vapour convected by intense warming reacting with inorganic chlorine to make ClO, cosmic rays from a nearby supernova, or arc volcanism
  5. L5: UV reaches land life: malformed plant spores at the D-C boundary; 'evidence of ultraviolet damage to pollen and spores over many thousands of years'
  6. L6: Greenhouse to icehouse: 'the continued drawdown of organic carbon eventually pulled the Earth out of its greenhouse state during the Famennian into the icehouse that continued throughout the Carboniferous and Permian'

land surface: roots, soils, weathering and the land flora

  1. L1: Land before deep roots: 'early Devonian plants bore only rhizoids and rhizomes that could penetrate no more than a few centimeters'; maximum height about 30 cm at the start of the Devonian
  2. L2: Forests: 30 m archaeopterid trees, cladoxylalean ferns, lycopsids and progymnosperms; seeds let plants spread into 'inhospitable inland and upland areas'; deep roots 'broke up the upper layers of bedrock and stabilized a deep layer of soil, which could have reached several meters thick'
  3. L3: Weathering: 'soil promotes weathering, the chemical breakdown of rocks. This released previously untapped swathes of ions such as phosphates, which are nutrients for plants and algae'
  4. L4: Export: 'the relatively sudden input of nutrients into river water'; a Greenland lake site whose 'geochemical signals support a link between plant-led weathering, phosphorus runoff, and global cooling'
  5. L5: Land flora collapse at the Hangenberg: 'the terrestrial ecosystem collapsed at the start of the VI zone ... wiped out most or all of the Archaeopteris and R. lepidophyta floras'; plants unaffected at the main marine pulse

mantle plumes and trap magmatism (Viluy and other Late Devonian provinces)

  1. L1: Extremely widespread trap magmatism and rifting in the Russian and Siberian platforms, 'situated above the hot mantle plumes'; the Viluy triple-junction rift system formed during the Devonian
  2. L2: Viluy branch: volcanic rocks, dyke belts and sills over more than 320,000 km2 and more than 1 million km3 of magmatic material; two phases, 376.7 +/- 3.4 and 364.4 +/- 3.4 Ma (or 373.4 +/- 2.1 and 363.2 +/- 2.0 Ma); Kola and Timan-Pechora provinces for the Hangenberg; the Cerberean caldera supereruption about 374 Ma
  3. L3: Gas release: Viluy magmatism 'may have injected enough CO2 and SO2 into the atmosphere to have generated a destabilised greenhouse and ecosystem'; coronene and mercury enrichment at the Frasnes, Kellwasser and Hangenberg levels
  4. L4: Sulphate to the sea: 'Viluy Traps activity may have also enabled euxinia by fertilising the oceans with sulphate, increasing rates of microbial sulphate reduction'

ocean oxygen and sulfide (eutrophication, anoxia, euxinia, black shales)

  1. L1: Shallow and epicontinental seas: 'Sea levels in the Devonian were generally high worldwide, and much of the land lay under shallow seas'; low-nutrient reef waters
  2. L2: Eutrophication: river nutrients (and on one reading Viluy sulphate) feed harmful algal blooms; at the Hangenberg 'as oceans flooded terrestrial basins, water would have entered areas with high nutrient levels, leading to an algal bloom'
  3. L3: Oxygen consumed: decomposition of sinking algae 'uses up all available oxygen'; 'a rapid increase in the rate of organic carbon burial'; selenate converted to much less soluble selenide, selenium bioavailability down to about 1% of today's
  4. L4: Black shale and euxinia: Lower and Upper Kellwasser horizons; the Hangenberg Black Shale; photic-zone euxinia from negative Delta-199Hg and positive delta-202Hg excursions; elevated molybdenum; negative delta-238U excursions at both Kellwasser events
  5. L5: Patchiness and pacing: transgressions 'helped spread deoxygenated waters onto the continental shelf'; intensity 'modulated by Milankovitch cycles'; not omnipresent (South China oxygenation; intermittent in New York)

predators and prey in the water column (armoured fishes, sharks, ray-finned fishes, ammonoids, tetrapods)

  1. L1: The Age of Fishes: 'armored placoderms began dominating almost every known aquatic environment'; 'ray-finned fishes, sharks and tetrapods were in the minority'
  2. L2: Kellwasser losses: 'around half of placoderm families died out, primarily species-poor bottom-feeding groups'; most agnathan groups gone by the end of the Frasnian; elpistostegalians such as Tiktaalik disappear at the F-F boundary
  3. L3: Hangenberg losses: 'among vertebrates, 44% of high-level clades and over 96% of species were lost', freshwater and marine alike; all remaining placoderms die out abruptly; ammonoids lose 87% of species
  4. L4: Bottleneck: survivors 'generally small and fast-breeding'; 'only sharks less than a meter long remained'; 'those few species that survived the bottleneck were the evolutionary starting point for all vertebrates'
  5. L5: Few shell-crushers: 'the low diversity of marine fishes, particularly shell-crushing predators (durophages), at the beginning of Romer's gap'
  6. L6: The modern fish order: chondrichthyans and actinopterygians 'took over in diversity and relative abundance during the Early Carboniferous'; shell-crushers increase and armoured crinoids plummet; stegocephalians lead to amphibians and amniotes

seafloor, reefs and benthos (reef builders, microbial reefs, survivors, speciation, crinoids)

  1. L1: The great Devonian reef systems: coral-stromatoporoid reefs and microbial reefs; a barrier reef 350 km long in the Kimberley; basins of endemic shallow-marine species
  2. L2: Reef builders lost: 'the most hard-hit biological category ... were the calcite-based reef-builders ... the stromatoporoid sponges and the rugose and tabulate corals'; reef extent reduced by a factor of 5,000
  3. L3: Microbial cover: Famennian reefs 'primarily dominated by siliceous sponges and calcifying bacteria, producing structures such as oncolites and stromatolites'; after the Hangenberg a brief resurgence of microbial carbonate
  4. L4: Survivors by build and habit: productids replace atrypids and strophomenids; specialists hit harder than generalists; oxygen-stress-tolerant ostracods survive; Kellwasser trilobite survivors 'tended to prefer deep environments and tropical latitudes'; invading generalists spread between basins
  5. L5: Speciation collapse: 'vicariance, normally the most prevalent style of speciation, was essentially extinguished'; 28% vicariance vs 72% dispersal; 65% of Frasnian invasions with transgressions
  6. L6: The Carboniferous seafloor: crinoids 'drastically increase their diversity and body size' (the 'Age of Crinoids'); bryozoan diversity 'refreshed', peaking in the Visean; reefs back by the late Tournaisian, but at Middle Devonian extent only in the Mesozoic, on scleractinian corals

seawater temperature and sea level (warm-water habitat, cooling, glaciation)

  1. L1: Warm shallow seas: tropical reef organisms in shallow seas; 'the Late Devonian warmed to levels equivalent to the Early Devonian'
  2. L2: Cooling selects: the Kellwasser 'had a greater effect on shallow warm-water organisms than on cool-water organisms' and 'effects were also stronger at low latitudes than high ones'
  3. L3: Famennian glaciation: glacial deposits in Bolivia and Brazil (near the Devonian South Pole) and the Appalachian Basin; 'a prelude to the far larger and more prolonged Late Paleozoic Ice Age'
  4. L4: Sea level: a major regression in the middle crisis interval, 'more than 100 meters' in Morocco; incised valley fills where rivers cut into former floodplains; then sea-level rise as the glaciers melted
  5. L5: Warm-water specialists cut short: phacopids and cyrtosymboline phillipsiids that thrived after the Kellwasser 'would suffer during the cold snap of the Hangenberg event'; naiaditid bivalves expand from polar regions toward the equator

Who fills each layer

Sources (10) published science

Late Devonian mass extinction (Wikipedia, rev 1378694342, via Wikimedia Enterprise; read in full)
Stigall, Speciation collapse and invasive species dynamics during the Late Devonian 'Mass Extinction', GSA Today 22(1), 4-9 (2012), doi:10.1130/G128A.1 (cited in Wikipedia as 2011) (behind its links)
Romer's gap (Wikipedia, rev 1317056666, via Wikimedia Enterprise; read in full) (behind its links)
Hangenberg event (Wikipedia, rev 1360682001, via Wikimedia Enterprise; read in full) (behind its links)
Devonian (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Cowie RH, Bouchet P, Fontaine B 2022. The Sixth Mass Extinction: fact, fiction or speculation? Biol Rev 97:640. doi:10.1111/brv.12816 (behind its links)
Extinction event (Wikipedia, rev 1379759322, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache; Late Devonian section and causes read) (behind its links)
Cambrian explosion (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise; sections read: lead, developmental explanations) (behind its links)
Trophic level (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Silurian-Devonian Terrestrial Revolution (Wikipedia) (behind its links)