EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Historiography

Historiography is the study of the methods used by historians in developing history as an academic discipline. By extension, the term historiography is any body of historical work on a particular subject.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

born at5th century BCE (Herodotus weighing accounts; Greek historiography); Chinese professional history with Sima Qian (145-86 BCE); a field of its own in the 19th century
born precisionabout two millennia across readings (contested)
boundaryInside: the reading of historians' works as works (their sources, techniques, theories, schools and loyalties), the debates between interpretations, the theory and philosophy of history writing, and the training and standards through which this reading shapes how history is written next. Outside: the past itself and its traces (history's L1), the source criticism historians apply to primary sources (history's own L3), the archives and libraries that keep works, and the neighbouring fields it borrows from (philology, sociology, economics, anthropology, literary theory).
nested levelA part of history (the field) at its interpretation floor, carried by historians, journals and seminars; its medium is the body of historical writing that history itself produces.
scalesocial

Measures (26) published science

Citation half-life, Polish media historiography14 years
Share of citations to publications 50 years old (CIHPM)0.27 % of citations
Single-author share of history works (CIHPM)94.8 % of 15,041 works
National historiography share of publications (CIHPM)90.74 % of publications (97.10% of citations)
Polish-language share within national historiography (CIHPM)97.87 %
References in 15 history journals, 1956-2016777,894 (443,561 disambiguated) references
Span covered by US history dissertations, 1900about 75 years
Span covered by US history dissertations, 1975about 30 years
Span covered by US history dissertations, 21st century75-100 years
US history dissertations surveyed (2013)some 8,000 dissertations since the 1880s
PhD training time (US, postwar)3 to 6 years
US doctorates awarded per year, 1957 to 19738,611 to 33,755 (nearly 9% a year) doctorates (all fields)
US history professors identifying with social history, 1975 to 199531 to 41 %
US history professors identifying with political history, 1975 to 199540 to 30 %
New academic history books published in the US per year (2009-2012)16,000 books per year (average)
Prestige journal acceptance rate10 or fewer % of submitted articles
Length of a journal book review500 to 1000 words
Lag from Metahistory to engagement by professional historians1973 to 1992 (about 19 years)
Chinese dynastic histories in annals-biography form24 to 26 histories
Zhu Xi's digest of the Comprehensive Mirror249 to 59 chapters
Anglo-Saxon Chronicle kept uplate 9th century to 1154 years of continuation (one copy)
Visualizations classified in history articles4,831 instances from 14,021 images in 4,142 articles figures
ProHist-Bench400 expert questions, 10,891 rubrics, 18 LLMs evaluated items
Claims in the isnad-rijal evaluation20,000 claims from physics textbooks
Historiographer Royal posts foundedSweden 1618, England 1660, Scotland 1681 dates
First historical journalsHistorisch-Politische Zeitschrift 1831 / Historische Zeitschrift 1859 founding year

Open contentions (8) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Cross-scale patterns seen here (19) our proposal

Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Historiography. Each links to every other system that shows it.

Valence: what it trades, and with whom (16) published science

Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (7)

Sits inside / holds (2)

expressed by (19)

floor filled by (16)

represents (1)

Kinds (19)

wired (2)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

historiography: historians' works read for their sources, methods, schools and debates, up to how the practice is shaped (reader's view)

  1. L1: The body of historical writing: annals, chronicles, histories, monographs and articles, from Egypt and Mesopotamia to today's 16,000 US books a year
  2. L2: Reading a work as a work: the historian's choices visible (which facts were chosen)
  3. L3: Sources, techniques and theories of each work analysed (Ranke's critique of recent historians; Liu Zhiji's Shitong; isnad and rijal)
  4. L4: Traditions, schools and their chronology: works placed in a history of historical writing
  5. L5: Debates and revision: orthodoxy against revisionism, controversies, the review of a topic's historiography
  6. L6: Theory of history writing: facts, objectivity, narrative and tropes, scale and time (metahistory)
  7. L7: Shaping the practice: seminars, method standards, journals, approaches and scales taken up

the boardroom (shared floors)

  1. L4: Placing works in traditions, schools and time: the history of historical writing (Greek, Chinese, Islamic, Christian, Enlightenment, Rankean, Annales, Marxist...)
  2. L5: Debates and revision: orthodox against revisionist readings, controversies (the Storm over the Gentry, Carr against Elton, narrative against quantification)
  3. L6: Theory and philosophy of history writing: facts and selection, objectivity, narrative and tropes, scale and time (metahistory)
  4. L7: Shaping the practice: what students are trained to read, which methods are standard, which approaches and scales are taken up

way in: Historians' own statements of method: prefaces, programmes, letters, manifestos

  1. L1: A historian says what they do: Gibbon's 'fountain-head', Thompson's preface
  2. L2: Read as a programme: Voltaire's article 'History' in the Encyclopédie
  3. L3: Set against practice: Ranke's stated aim and its Göttingen roots

way in: Historical works: histories, annals, chronicles, monographs and articles

  1. L1: The works themselves, from early annals to today's monographs: 'any body of historical work on a particular subject'
  2. L2: Reading a work as a work: the interpretation, not the events (Herodotus already weighing accounts)
  3. L3: Analysing which sources, techniques and theories each work used (Liu Zhiji's critique; the isnad's chain of transmission)

way in: Machine-readable corpora and computational tools: images, n-grams, citation graphs, language models

  1. L1: Digitised corpora: 14,021 images from 4,142 articles
  2. L2: Tools in the workflow: LLM, mind and computational steps
  3. L3: Checked against expert standards: a benchmark of 400 expert questions

way in: Neighbouring fields: philology, sociology, geography, economics, anthropology, literary theory, physics

  1. L1: Philology's source criticism, met in the Göttingen seminar
  2. L2: Borrowing: the Annales from geography and sociology; the cultural turn from anthropology
  3. L3: Admitted or refused: cliometrics left uncited by most historians

way in: Other ways of keeping the past: oral traditions, indigenous and non-Western historiographies

  1. L1: Societies that kept their history orally
  2. L2: First dismissed by colonial-era historians, then admitted (Dike, UNESCO's General History of Africa, 1981-2024)
  3. L3: Tested against other evidence: criteria for confirming events in oral and material tradition

way in: Records of the profession: journals, seminars, departments, dissertations and surveys of historians

  1. L1: Universities and research centres where history is written
  2. L2: Journals as forums of exchange, from the 19th century
  3. L3: Counts and surveys: who identifies with which field, what span dissertations cover

way in: References and citation data: footnotes, reference lists, citation indexes

  1. L1: Reference lists of history journals: 777,894 references from 15 journals, 1956-2016 (Colavizza)
  2. L2: Citation indexes, general (Web of Science) and built ad hoc for history (the CIHPM)
  3. L3: Bibliometric analysis: bibliographic coupling networks, half-life, Price index

way in: Sight (Human channel): the historiographer reading pages and screens

  1. L1: Pages, catalogues and screens browsed in libraries and archives

way in: The historian's present: events lived through and the questions they raise

  1. L1: Events: two world wars and upheavals behind the Annales; 1968 ending their hegemony
  2. L2: Lived through: the covid-19 pandemic as a historian's lesson
  3. L3: Turned into questions put to the past: Carr's dialogue

way in: Thought (Human inner channel): the historian's own conceptualising

  1. L1: How the historian's frame arrives is contested (C-413); White holds the historian creates the field at the level of conceptualising

way out: Historiographical writing: reviews, state-of-the-field essays, histories of historical writing

  1. L1: The historiographic literature in the record
  2. L5: Book reviews by recognised scholars
  3. L7: A field surveyed

way out: Journals and peer review

  1. L1: Articles published to the field
  2. L5: Confidential evaluation; prestige journals accept 10 percent or fewer
  3. L7: Founding journals that carry an approach (Historische Zeitschrift 1859, Annales 1929)

way out: Method standards: rule books and the standard of source-based history

  1. L1: Philology's textual criticism made the standard of historical writing (history's L3)
  2. L3: Rule books: Bernheim (1889), Langlois & Seignobos (1898)
  3. L7: Ranke sets the standard

way out: Methods and labels carried to other fields: the Whig label, algorithmic historiography, isnad for AI

  1. L1: Citation lineages drawn by program
  2. L3: A method mapped onto another system
  3. L7: A historiographical label used in other fields

way out: Training: the research seminar and the PhD

  1. L1: PhDs trained in research seminars write the next histories
  2. L4: Training in primary sources in archives
  3. L7: Ranke's seminar teaching and archival research

Sources (18) published science

Historiography (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01)
Guldi J, Armitage D. 2014. The History Manifesto, ch. 2 'The Short Past: or, the retreat of the longue duree'. Cambridge University Press, open access CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. doi:10.1017/9781139923880 (behind its links)
Colavizza G. 2018. A diachronic study of historiography. arXiv:1807.01795 (preprint) (behind its links)
Source criticism (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
History (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01, revision 1382189844) (behind its links)
Kolasa WM. 2012. Specific character of citations in historiography (using the example of Polish history). Scientometrics 90(3):905-923. doi:10.1007/s11192-011-0553-0 (behind its links)
Držaić K. 2025 (v2 2026). The Question of the Narrative in Historiography: Between the Annales School and Hayden White. Open Research Europe 5:259. doi:10.12688/openreseurope.20777.2 (behind its links)
Chen X, Zhang Y, Zheng W, Ma C et al. 2026. How Historians Use Visualization: A Corpus-Driven Mixed-Methods Study. arXiv:2605.01456 (preprint) (behind its links)
Gao L, Wang Z, Cai Y, Deng J et al. 2026. Can LLMs Act as Historians? Evaluating Historical Research Capabilities of LLMs via the Chinese Imperial Examination. arXiv:2604.24690 (preprint) (behind its links)
Raja AZ. 2026. Grading the Narrators: An Isnad-Rijal Framework for Claim-Level Provenance in Multi-Agent Knowledge Systems. arXiv:2607.24117 (preprint) (behind its links)
Armus D. 2023. When the present can help refine interpretations of the past: covid-19 in real time and the historiography of epidemics. Hist Cienc Saude Manguinhos 30 Suppl 1:e2023041. doi:10.1590/S0104-59702023000100041 (behind its links)
Anandhu S, Anupama Nayar CV, Aneesh AS. 2026. Epistemicide and colonial knowledge: a contrapuntal reading of Nair historiography in South India. Frontiers in Sociology 11:1907593. doi:10.3389/fsoc.2026.1907593 (behind its links)
Henriot C. 2025. The AI-Augmented Research Process: A Historian's Perspective. arXiv:2508.01779 (preprint) (behind its links)
Ten Hagen SL. 2019. How 'Facts' Shaped Modern Disciplines: the fluid concept of fact and the common origins of German physics and historiography. Historical Studies in the Natural Sciences 49(3):300-337 (arXiv:1906.08008) (behind its links)
Historiography of science (Wikipedia, rev 1382153751, 2026-10-26, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Wikipedia: History of political science (behind its links)
Hamacher DW. 2014. Are Supernovae Recorded in Indigenous Astronomical Traditions? arXiv:1404.3253 (behind its links)
Leydesdorff L. 2010. Eugene Garfield and Algorithmic Historiography: Co-Words, Co-Authors, and Journal Names. arXiv:1005.5444 (preprint) (behind its links)