← all systems · see it in The System
Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule)
The meiotic rule set: homologous chromosomes pair and exchange genetic information by homologous recombination, 'a programmed process in which DNA may be cut and then repaired', forming at least one crossover per chromosome; homologues assort independently and are halved to haploid in two divisions; two haploid gametes then fuse into a diploid zygote. 'Thus, alternating cycles of meiosis and fertilization enable sexual reproduction.' Walked as a Seed: the rule plus its shell.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Meiotic recombination (sex) |
| arrives | Present in LECA (~2 Ga); 'first appeared around 2 billion years ago in the Proterozoic' in the eukaryote record; oldest fossil evidence Bangiomorpha, Stenian, ~1.05 Ga |
| born at | with the early eukaryotes (more than 2.2 billion years ago for eukaryotes); oldest fossil evidence 1,047 Ma (Bangiomorpha) |
| born precision | undated; contention C-273 |
| boundary | Inside: the rule as carried out in a germ cell: pairing of homologues, programmed breaks and their repair as crossovers or conversions, the two divisions that halve the chromosome number, and the fusion of two haploid gametes that closes the cycle; its shell is the synaptonemal complex and cohesin axes that hold the homologues in register. Outside: the somatic body, the genes and alleles it shuffles, the signals that start and pause it, and the selfish loci and parasites that press on it. |
| nested level | A generative rule on the germ cell lineage (sys:cell-lineage) of eukaryotic cells, shuffling the coded sequence the genetic code makes readable; a Seed within seed:genetic-code and within BVSR. |
| quantum | The meiotic rule set: pair homologues, cross over by homologous recombination, assort independently, halve to haploid, fuse two gametes. It is a copyable method, carried by a core set of meiotic genes (Spo11 starts the breaks). |
| scale | cellular |
| shell | Partial: the germline (meiosis confined to the cells that form gametes; Weismann's germ/soma distinction, which the source says is now known to be less clean). The synaptonemal complex is the local scaffold, not a shell. |
Measures (43) published science
| Characteristic clock: prophase I duration (mouse) | 13 of 14 days of meiosis |
| Characteristic clock: dictyate arrest of human oocytes | formed at 3-4 months of gestation; arrest 'may last for decades' years |
| Outcrossing frequency, wild yeasts (S. cerevisiae, S. paradoxus) | about once every 50,000 cell divisions per cell division |
| Outcrossing rate, natural C. elegans | about 1 % |
| programmed double-strand breaks per meiosis (mouse) | around 300 breaks |
| double-strand breaks per meiotic cell (yeast, mouse, human) | >=200, of which about 5-30% become crossovers (1-2 crossovers per human chromosome) breaks |
| Share of breaks that become crossovers | ~5-30 (organism-dependent) % |
| Crossovers per human chromosome | 1-2 crossovers |
| Recombinations per meiosis, human maternal vs paternal | about 42 vs about 27 events |
| female to male recombination ratio (human) | about 1.6-fold more in females ratio |
| Recombination per physical distance (human average) | 1 Mb = 1 cM (1% recombination frequency) cM/Mb |
| recombination hotspot length | about 1,000-2,000 bp |
| Homologue co-alignment distance (mouse), then synapsis | ~400 then ~100 nm |
| Chromosome-set combinations per human gamete from independent assortment alone | 2^23 = 8,388,608 (computed from the source's 23 pairs; not quoted) combinations |
| Information gain per generation bound (MacKay, simplified model) | asexual: 1 bit; sexual: sqrt(G), G = genome size in bits bits per generation |
| Germline vs somatic mutation frequency | 5-10-fold lower in gametogenesis |
| Double-strand breaks per human cell per cell generation | about 50 breaks |
| Induction of mating and meiotic spores by H2O2 (S. pombe) | 4 to 18 fold |
| Deleterious mutation rates against Kondrashov's threshold (1 per genome per generation) | S. cerevisiae 0.0027, N. crassa 0.0030 per genome per replication; C. elegans 0.036 per effective genome per sexual generation |
| Two-fold cost: share of offspring that are males unable to bear young | 50 % |
| Arrival: sexual reproduction in the eukaryotic fossil record | around 2 Ga (Proterozoic); a later date of around 1.2 Ga from Bangiomorpha has also been presented |
| Arrival: oldest fossil evidence of sexual reproduction (Bangiomorpha pubescens, Hunting Formation, Stenian) | 1,047 (+13/-17) Ma |
| Arrival: sex 'evolved over' | 1.2 Ga |
| Eukaryote origin | more than 2.2 Ga (Origin and function of meiosis); approximately 2 Ga (Horandl & Speijer) |
| Human live births with a genetic disorder; share from new germline mutations | about 5%; of these about 20% |
| homologue spacing | ~400 nm at leptotene (mouse); ~100 nm at synapsis |
| prophase I share of meiosis (characteristic clock) | 13 out of 14 days in mice |
| crossovers per human meiosis | maternal about 42; paternal about 27 on average crossovers |
| physical to genetic distance (human average) | 1 Mb corresponds to 1 cM Mb per cM |
| centimorgan | markers separated once per 100 meiotic products (once per 50 meioses) definition |
| human chromosome sets | 23 pairs (46) in diploid cells; 23 in each gamete chromosomes |
| crossover drop in an MSH4 hypomorph (yeast) | 30% genome-wide reduction |
| SPO11 proteins per double-strand break | 2 (one per strand) proteins |
| meiosis induced by hydrogen peroxide (fission yeast) | mating and meiotic spores up 4 to 18-fold |
| double-strand breaks per human cell per generation | about 50 breaks |
| oldest fossil of sexual reproduction (Bangiomorpha pubescens) | 1,047 Ma (the article's date template gives error 0.013/-0.017) million years ago |
| first appearance of sex in the eukaryotic record | around 2 billion years ago; a later date of around 1.2 billion years (Bangiomorpha) 'has also been presented' |
| eukaryotes' origin | more than 2.2 billion years ago |
| two-fold cost of sex (Maynard Smith's example) | 100 organisms give 50 offspring if sexual, 100 if asexual |
| human oocyte formation and arrest | formed at 3-4 months of gestation; dictyate arrest 'may last for decades' time |
| microtubule organising centres in mouse oocytes | approximately 80 MTOCs |
| Mendel's pea plants | some 28,000, cultivated 1856-1863 plants |
| maize Ab10 knob | a 150-base pair heterochromatic region bp |
Open contentions (4) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-270 Where did meiosis, the cell division behind sex, come from?
booked: The map keeps both origins (from bacterial DNA exchange or from ordinary cell division) alongside the oxygen-stress idea.
the other reading: the other origin; 'There are two conflicting theories on how meiosis arose' - C-271 What is sex for: repairing DNA, making variety, or escaping harmful mutations?
booked: The map records the repair that is seen, and leaves the evolutionary reason open since there is no consensus.
the other reading: sex is kept mainly for variation (Weismann 1885) or against mutation build-up; 'There is no current consensus' - C-272 Why has sexual reproduction lasted so long?
booked: The map records the Red Queen idea (sex helps hosts keep pace with parasites) with its supporting cases and its counter-case in geckos, and keeps other explanations alongside.
the other reading: the court jester (abiotic factors) or other explanations - C-273 When did sexual reproduction first appear?
booked: The map uses the oldest fossil evidence, Bangiomorpha at 1,047 million years ago, and notes that sex itself is likely older; the 2 billion and 1.2 billion year figures are kept alongside.
the other reading: around 2 billion years (Evolution of sexual reproduction); 'around 1.2 billion years ago' for Bangiomorpha (the same article's older figure)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (13) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- holding / entrainment (structural)
The follicle holds the oocyte's division: cumulus cGMP 'halts meiosis' for years, and an LH spike releases it; the oocyte keeps its own hold going by raising NPR2 in cumulus cells. - same role, different builds (structural)
Starting the exchange (a break) is met by different builds: SPO11; X-ray damage that rescues spo11 mutants; uracil base-excision repair in S. pombe and C. elegans; nicks and gaps in rad2 mutants; social amoebae that lost Spo11 yet keep meiotic sex. - seed (structural)
A rule (pair, break, invade, cross over, assort, halve, fuse) that reshuffles coded units every generation in every sexual lineage: 'chromosomes and alleles segregate and recombine in every generation'; 2^23 chromosome-set combinations per human gamete before crossover. - templating (structural)
One pattern across eukaryotes ('diverse eukaryotes share a common pattern'); the SC 'shows very little structural variability ... despite some significant protein differences'; RecA's orthologs do the same job in meiosis. - who opens the door (structural)
PRDM9 places H3K4me3 and H3K36me3 at its motif ahead of time, 'essential for its role in DSB positioning'; SPO11 then cuts there, and ZCWPW1 is 'the first protein directly positioned by PRDM9's dual histone marks'. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
On the transformation origin: bacteria take DNA from the surroundings and recombine it; meiosis pairs two parental genomes held inside one cell, with the same enzyme family (RecA, RAD51, DMC1). - red-queen (partial)
Sex kept against parasites: sexual hosts 'continually "running" (adapting) to "stay in one place"'; snail and C. elegans studies support it, geckos do not. - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
Fair segregation is a 50:50 balance; a driver tips it, and 'If a driver is left unchecked, this may lead to population extinction as the population would fix for the driver'. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
The two halves of the cycle mirror each other: meiosis halves the set and fertilisation doubles it; Geodakyan: 'the sexual process ... creates (increases) diversity of genotypes, and the second [sexual differentiation] decreases it by half'. - barrier-gates-complexity (surface)
Shugoshin, the 'guardian spirit', keeps centromeric cohesin through anaphase I, which lets the division run in two steps (homologues, then sisters). - lightning (surface)
A programmed double-strand break: one cut, after which the chromosome is repaired as a crossover or a conversion and is not the same. - not-diluting wins (surface)
GC-biased gene conversion raises GC content wherever recombination is frequent: high-recombination regions such as the pseudoautosomal regions have high GC. - outside-to-inside (surface)
Same sighting as a partition moving in: the donor DNA outside the bacterium becomes the homologue inside the eukaryotic nucleus.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (17) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping) via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma) via sys:cell-lineage · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- DNA and genes via sys:electromagnetic-field · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Eukaryotic cell via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Mitochondrion via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) mixed
- Multicellular organism via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Germ cell (germline) via sys:cell-lineage · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Reactive oxygen species (the damage pressure) via sys:aqueous-solution · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) mixed
- Meiotic drivers (selfish alleles that subvert the rule) via sys:cytoplasm · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) loss
- Parasites (the Red Queen partner) via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) mixed
- Horizontal gene transfer via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Chromatin via sys:enzyme-catalysis · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) even
- Plant seed via sys:cell-lineage · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- Life cycle (biological life cycle) via sys:cell-lineage · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
- genealogy (descent as a medium) via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) even
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring) via sys:sequential-information · Meiotic recombination (sexual reproduction's shuffling rule) gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Chromosome
- Germ cell (germline)
- SPO11 (break maker; quanta)
- RecA/RAD51/DMC1 recombinase family (strand exchange; quanta)
- Synaptonemal complex (scaffold)
- Cohesin and Shugoshin (sister cohesion)
- Life cycle (biological life cycle)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Eukaryotic cell
- Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
expressed by (13)
- Recombination/Composition
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Search/Foraging
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Reactive Response
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Enclave/Segregation
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Scheduled Build-and-Dismantle (On-Demand Structure)
floor filled by (31)
- Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma)
- Chromosome
- Multicellular organism
- Germ cell (germline)
- SPO11 (break maker; quanta)
- RecA/RAD51/DMC1 recombinase family (strand exchange; quanta)
- Synaptonemal complex (scaffold)
- Cohesin and Shugoshin (sister cohesion)
- Reactive oxygen species (the damage pressure)
- Gamete
- Zygote
- Life cycle (biological life cycle)
- Chromosomal crossover
- Gene conversion
- PRDM9
- Holliday junction
- MSH4/MSH5
- Shugoshin
- Kinetochore
- Spindle apparatus
- CDK1 and cyclin B (MPF)
- Oocyte
- Cumulus cell
- Luteinizing hormone
- Granulosa cell
- Polar body
- Fertilisation
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
- genealogy (descent as a medium)
- Heredity (how traits pass from parents to offspring)
- Evolution (biological evolution across time)
represents (1)
seed within (1)
Kinds (9)
- Two-divisional meiosis (the usual form)
- One-divisional meiosis (parabasalids and oxymonads)
- Achiasmate meiosis (e.g. silkworm oocytes)
- DNA repair theory of meiosis
- Red Queen hypothesis (sex kept against parasites)
- Muller's ratchet (sex kept against mutation build-up)
- Origin of meiosis from prokaryotic transformation
- Origin of meiosis from mitosis
- Endogenous-ROS origin of meiotic sex (Hörandl and Speijer)
wired (1)
Notes published science
- The shuffle is the tether: the crossover that mixes your mother's and father's genes is also the rope the cell pulls on to check the chromosomes are lined up. 'Establishing tension ordinarily requires at least one crossover per chromosome pair.' Hundreds of breaks are made (about 300 in a mouse meiosis), only 5-30% become crossovers, but every chromosome gets at least one.
- Social amoebae lost the break-making enzyme Spo11 and still have sex. One proposal: life in stressful soil breaks their DNA anyway, so the outside world does the cutting. X-rays rescue spo11 mutant yeast the same way.
- A human egg can wait in the first meiotic division for decades, holding four copies of the genome, and its own surrounding cells keep it paused with cGMP; the egg even boosts the signal that keeps itself on hold.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
DNA sequence: homologous recombination between parental chromosomes (sequential information)
- L1: Two homologous chromosomes, one from each parent, each replicated in premeiotic S phase into two identical sister chromatids held by cohesion
- L2: Programmed breaks: in vertebrates PRDM9 marks sites (H3K4me3, H3K36me3); SPO11, related to topoisomerases, cuts both strands (around 300 per meiosis in mice), at hotspots of 1,000-2,000 bp
- L3: Resection to 3' single-stranded tails coated by the meiosis-specific DMC1 and the general RAD51, which invade the homologue (homology search and strand exchange)
- L4: Resolution: most breaks repaired without crossover (gene conversion, SDSA); a subset, at least one per chromosome, become crossovers through double Holliday junctions bound by MSH4/MSH5 (class I MLH1/MLH3; class II MUS81)
- L5: Recombinant chromatids: 'each chromosome has the complete set of information it had before, and there are no gaps'; new allele combinations; some new mutations at break repair; GC-biased gene conversion
chromosome mechanics in the dividing cell: synapsis, spindle and cohesion (cytoplasm)
- L1: Each chromosome forms a linear array of loops mediated by cohesin on an axial element (leptotene)
- L2: Synaptonemal complex: lateral elements (SYCP3, SYCP2) zipped by transverse filaments (SYCP1) to about 100 nm, from a recombination nodule; disassembled after pachytene
- L3: Chiasmata hold each bivalent; kinetochore microtubules from both poles attach (bipolar attachment); random orientation of each bivalent is the physical basis of independent assortment
- L4: Tension check: the cell does not progress to anaphase until all chromosomes are bi-oriented; in meiosis tension ordinarily needs at least one crossover per pair plus cohesin
- L5: Anaphase I: arm cohesin degraded while Shugoshin protects centromeric cohesin, so homologues (not sisters) separate; anaphase II cleaves the rest
ploidy cycle along the germ cell lineage: halving and fusion (cell lineage)
- L1: Germ cells: the population of a multicellular organism's cells that develop into gametes; meiosis occurs only in eukaryotes
- L2: Entry and hold: premeiotic S phase, then prophase I, the longest phase (13 of 14 days in mice); human oocytes arrest in prophase I (dictyate) from before birth, for decades, with four genome copies
- L3: Meiosis I halves the chromosome number (reductional division)
- L4: Meiosis II separates sister chromatids with no DNA replication between: four haploid cells (sperm, spores, pollen), or in female animals one ovum and polar bodies
- L5: Fertilisation: two haploid gametes, ordinarily from different individuals, fuse into a diploid zygote with two copies of each chromosome
- L6: Life cycles built around the alternation: diplontic (meiosis makes gametes, as in humans), haplontic (the zygote undergoes meiosis at once), haplodiplontic (alternation of generations)
signals that start, pause and resume meiosis (aqueous solution)
- L1: Signals around the germ cell: nutrients and nitrogen, oxidative stress (hydrogen peroxide, heat shock), hormones (FSH, LH), retinoic acid, natriuretic peptide type C from mural granulosa cells
- L2: Receivers and second messengers: NPR2 on cumulus cells makes cGMP, which diffuses into the oocyte and inhibits PDE3A; oocyte GPR3/12 raises cAMP; PKA activates WEE2; in yeast IME1 'is regulated according to inputs like nutrition'
- L3: Decision: CDK1 activity suppressed holds the arrest; a luteinising hormone spike releases it; cyclin B synthesis and degradation set entry to metaphase and anaphase
- L4: Response: meiosis enters or resumes (germinal vesicle breakdown, spindle assembly); in facultatively sexual microbes stress switches growth to meiotic sex
Who fills each layer
- L3: Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma), Plant seed
- L4: Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
- L5: Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma), Plant seed, genealogy (descent as a medium)