← all systems · see it in The System
Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
An argument is one or more premises—sentences, statements, or propositions—directed towards arriving at a logical conclusion.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Argument (the discourse's proof) |
| born at | as early as 1700 BCE (Indian debates; the SEP supplement's earliest date) |
| born precision | centuries; origin contested |
| boundary | Inside: arguments (premises supporting a conclusion, their kinds and schemes) and argumentation (the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement), with the standards used to evaluate them (validity, strength, fallacy, critical questions) and the dialogue types they run in. Outside: the people, languages and institutions that carry it (walked as their own systems), formal logic as a field, rhetoric's other appeals, and explanations, which resemble arguments but address understanding rather than belief. |
| nested level | A practice carried by people in language, studied by philosophy, logic, rhetoric, communication, psychology and computer science; it runs on human speech and writing and inside the institutions of law, science, politics and education. |
| scale | social |
Measures (18) published science
| Aristotle's sophistical refutations | 13 kinds, in two groups (dependent and not dependent on language) |
| components of Toulmin's layout | 6 components (claim, ground, warrant, backing, qualifier, rebuttal) |
| rules of a critical discussion (pragma-dialectics) | 10 rules |
| neuroimaging studies of deductive reasoning combined | 28 studies, 382 participants (1997-2010) studies / participants |
| own arguments rejected when presented as someone else's | 56 and 58 % of participants who accepted the manipulation (two experiments) |
| steps before deference-based influence vanishes along a transmission chain | at most 3 steps (Moussaid et al. 2017, as reported) |
| share who changed to the expert's answer after first-hand evidence (pilot) | 74 % average (competence 82, confidence 58, consensus 80) |
| drop in conspiracy belief after evidence dialogues with an AI | ~20 % (2190 believers) |
| characteristic clock: durability of belief change after one AI dialogue | 2 months (still present) |
| characteristic clock: exposure period in the opposing-views field experiment | 1 month (24 retweets a day) |
| share who accepted the invitation to follow an opposing bot | 64.9 (Democrats), 57.2 (Republicans) % |
| characteristic clock: one national Deliberative Poll (America in One Room) | a long weekend; more than 500 voters; 5 issues duration / participants / issues |
| participants in the political-belief challenge fMRI study | 40 (8 political and 8 non-political statements, 5 challenges each) people |
| children in the cross-cultural reason-giving study | 360 (ages 5-9; China, Kenya, US) children |
| hours to hand-map one debate (Horn's maps on whether computers can think) | over 7,000 hours |
| argument maps in AIFdb | over 14,000 maps; over 1.6 million words; 160,000 claims; 14 languages maps / words / claims / languages |
| Athenian democracy (setting of Greek dialectic) | 508 to 322 BCE dates |
| earliest Indian debates in the sources | as early as 1700 BCE date |
Open contentions (8) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: see C-413 registry - C-1146 How much can persuasion change people's minds?
booked: The map keeps both: small average effects for one-off ads, and large effects in personalised, evidence-rich conversation.
the other reading: large effects in tailored dialogue (Costello 2024); small or no extra effect for interactivity (Altay 2022) - C-1150 What is reasoning for?
booked: The map records the argumentative theory, that reasoning evolved to make and judge arguments, as one reading, alongside the classical view that it improves knowledge and decisions.
the other reading: argumentative/interactionist theory: reasoning's primary function is argumentation (Mercier & Sperber 2017, via SEP); classical view: reasoning is mental inference, argumentation its public counterpart (SEP 1) - C-2393 Is arguing a contest or a joint search?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: adversarial, and desirably so when 'minimal' (Govier 1999; Aikin 2011); cooperative ideal; adversarial ideals optional and exclusionary (feminist critiques: Moulton 1983; Gilbert 1994); different degrees for different situations (Dutilh Novaes) - C-2394 When did argumentation begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing starts.
the other reading: an evolved human universal (Mercier & Sperber; Mercier 2018); a culturally codified practice whose universality is an empirical question (SEP 5.3); first theories only around the 6th century BCE (SEP supplement) - C-2403 Do opposing arguments backfire?
booked: The map keeps the mixed results.
the other reading: backfire: exposure to opposing arguments strengthens prior belief (Bail 2018; Taber & Lodge 2006 via SEP); no backfire: correction backfire 'failed to replicate in two recent studies' (Bail 2018's own note); good arguments change minds (Trouche 2014; Altay 2022; Costello 2024); it depends on setting: balanced, moderated deliberation vs social media streams (Fishkin 2021) - C-2408 What counts as a fallacy?
booked: The map keeps the competing definitions.
the other reading: fallacy as an invalid or erroneous form (the tradition from Aristotle); Bayesian: many 'fallacies' raise the conclusion's probability and can be good arguments (Hahn & Oaksford via SEP); is the focus on fallacies useful at all? (Massey 1981, via SEP) - C-2419 Can induction be justified?
booked: The map keeps the answers unruled.
the other reading: Hume: induction cannot be justified; Harman: induction a special case of inference to the best explanation; Norton's material theory of induction
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (10)
- Rhetoric (speech and argument)
- Audience
- Premises
- Conclusion
- Warrant, backing, qualifier and rebuttal (Toulmin's layout)
- Argumentation schemes with critical questions
- Arguers (proponent and opponent, questioner and answerer)
- Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
- Essay
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
Trades with (valence) (22)
- Amygdala via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Language (human language) via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Science (as a human social and cultural system) via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with) via sys:written-record · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:human-society · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Internet via sys:written-record · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them mixed
- Large language model via sys:written-record · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Human brain via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Democracy via sys:human-society · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Ancient Greece (the Greek city-state world across time) via sys:human-society · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Ancient China (the early Chinese states from the first Bronze Age state to the end of the Han, across time) via sys:human-society · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Ancient India (the Indian subcontinent's societies from the Indus cities to the Gupta empire) via sys:human-society · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Middle Ages via sys:human-society · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Rhetoric (speech and argument) via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Artificial intelligence via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Political science (the field: the practice and the politics it studies) via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Mathematical proof: the practice of showing that a statement follows from axioms and earlier theorems, how it is written, checked (by people and machines) and accepted, and the derivations it works on via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on) via sys:sensory-environment · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Communication: the passing of messages between senders and receivers through a channel (and, on other readings, the making of meaning between them), and communication studies, the field that studies it via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
- Essay via sys:language · Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them gain
expressed by (23)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Offline Simulation & Replay-Guided Planning
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Neutralize Defenses
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Technique-Based Identification (a.k.a. Technique-Based Detection)
- Delay/Redirection Tactics
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Deception
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (23)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- Law (rules and law)
- Human brain
- Democracy
- Deliberative democracy
- Logic: the study and practice of correct reasoning (formal and informal, across its traditions) and the valid inference it works on, together with how people actually reason
- Epistemic vigilance
- Fallacies (formal and informal)
- Deductive inference
- Inductive inference
- Abductive inference
- Premises
- Warrant, backing, qualifier and rebuttal (Toulmin's layout)
- Argumentation schemes with critical questions
- Pragma-dialectics
- Debate
- Enthymeme
- Argument mining
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
- Essay
Kinds (10)
- Informal logic
- Deductive argument
- Inductive argument
- Abductive argument
- Argument by analogy
- Transcendental argument
- World-disclosing argument
- Pragma-dialectics
- The New Rhetoric (Perelman and Olbrechts-Tyteca)
- Bayesian argumentation
Notes published science
- People are harder on their own arguments than they know: shown their own earlier argument disguised as someone else's, more than half (56% and 58%) rejected it, and they told valid from invalid better when the argument seemed not to be theirs (src:trouche-2016).
- Trust fades along a chain of people within about three hand-offs, but a logical argument is rebuilt at every step and is reported to travel with no loss; yet people who changed their minds by deferring to an expert mostly did not pass on 'an expert told me' (src:mercier-2019).
- Opposing views can push both ways: a month of opposing tweets made Republicans more conservative (src:bail-2018), while a long weekend of moderated deliberation depolarized more than 500 voters (src:fishkin-2021) and one tailored AI dialogue cut conspiracy belief by about 20% for at least two months (src:costello-2024).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
argument as philosophers and argumentation theorists describe it: reasons given and asked for in a difference of opinion, from the words exchanged to the decision acted on (reader's view)
- L1: The exchange in language: claims made and challenged in speech or writing between two or more parties, often before an audience; in logic, a symbolic formal language. Argumentation begins when a claim meets a request for reasons.
- L2: Taking it in and recognising it as argument: hearing or reading, indicator words (therefore, so, because, hence), telling argument from explanation; children give reasons more in disagreement; machines mine argument structure from text.
- L3: The structure: premises offering support to a conclusion; Toulmin's claim, ground, warrant, backing, qualifier and rebuttal; convergent and linked premises; unstated premises (enthymemes).
- L4: The kind of inference: deduction (truth-preserving, monotonic), induction and abduction (ampliative), analogy; defeasible passages and argumentation schemes (argument from expert opinion and others).
- L5: Evaluation: validity, soundness, inductive strength and cogency; fallacies (formal and informal); critical questions; attacks and undercutters; Bayesian argument strength; in people, epistemic vigilance and plausibility checking, stricter on others' arguments than one's own.
- L6: Resolution in dialogue: the difference of opinion resolved, managed or sharpened (persuasion, inquiry, deliberation, negotiation, eristic debate); consensus where background agreement exists, polarization or deep disagreement where it does not; minds changed or held.
- L7: Action on the world: decisions made legitimate by deliberation, verdicts in court, claims accepted in science, group answers adopted, and beliefs passed on to others along chains of transmission.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L3: The argument's structure: premises supporting a conclusion; claim, ground, warrant, backing, qualifier and rebuttal; convergent and linked premises; missing premises supplied.
- L4: The kind of inference and its scheme: deductive, inductive, abductive, analogical, defeasible; in the brain, a left fronto-parietal system with three subsystems for relational, categorical and propositional arguments.
- L5: Evaluation: validity and soundness, strength and cogency, fallacies and critical questions; epistemic vigilance; in the brain, medial prefrontal cortex for conclusions of arguments, default mode network and emotion regions when beliefs are challenged.
- L6: Resolution in dialogue: consensus, compromise, managed conflict, polarization or deep disagreement; beliefs changed or held.
- L7: Decision and action: legitimate democratic decisions, court judgments, scientific acceptance, group answers; beliefs handed on.
way in: Emotion: affect in argument (threat to belief and identity, anger)
- L1: Existing emotional relations between the parties; affective responses arising during argument.
- L2: Felt challenge: counterevidence against political beliefs engages the default mode network; less insula and amygdala signal in those who change their minds more.
way in: Hearing: spoken argument (conversation, debate, court, assembly)
- L1: Spoken claims and reasons: face-to-face discussion in parliament, debates, courts of law.
- L2: Heard and recognised as argument; everyday argumentative reasoning in conversation is fast and effortless.
way in: Machines: argument mining, debating systems, AI dialogue partners
- L1: Machine-produced arguments: Project Debater's speeches, a chatbot's counterarguments, GPT-4 Turbo's personalised evidence dialogues.
- L2: Read by the person; structure mined from text by machine.
way in: Sight: written argument (articles, posts, essays, argument maps)
- L1: Written arguments in scientific articles, on the Internet, in newspaper editorials; argument maps.
- L2: Read; indicator words separate premises from conclusion; implicit structure must be made explicit by analysis.
way in: Testimony and expertise: sources, experts, majorities
- L1: Information from others: experts, the more confident, the majority; most of what we know comes from others.
- L2: Cues of confidence, competence and majority weighed; first-hand experience of competence counts more than a description of it.
way in: The audience: whom the argument is meant to win
- L1: An audience that evaluates, not just the two parties; particular audiences and the universal audience.
- L2: The argument shaped to the audience's adherence.
way in: The other party: challenges, requests for reasons, counterarguments
- L1: A claim meets a request for further support; the other party disagrees or doubts.
- L2: The challenge taken in as support or attack; children give reasons more often when they disagree.
way in: Thought: prior beliefs and arguing with oneself
- L1: Preexisting beliefs and reasons already held; one can also argue with oneself. Where thoughts come from is contested (C-413).
- L2: Plausibility checking: incoming claims compared with preexisting beliefs.
way in: Tradition: taught forms, schemes and fallacy lists
- L1: Debating manuals and logic books: Aristotle's Topics and Sophistical Refutations, the Nyaya-sutra, scholastic textbooks, Whately, Toulmin, critical-thinking courses.
- L2: Learned through teaching and practice; dialogic practice transfers to individual essays.
- L3: Held as stereotyped schemes with critical questions and as lists of fallacies to spot.
way out: Deciding: votes, verdicts, group answers and policies
- L1: Acted on in the group: the right answer adopted by the group; policy attitudes changed after deliberation.
- L7: Decision made legitimate by deliberation, or the better case judged.
way out: Passing it on: a belief and its reasons handed to the next person
- L1: Handed to the next person; logical arguments recreated at each step, arguments from expertise often not given.
- L7: A newly accepted belief to be passed on, with or without the grounds for accepting it.
way out: Speaking: claims, reasons, challenges and counterarguments uttered
- L1: Spoken to the other party or the audience.
- L3: Premises and conclusion put in words with a marker.
- L6: A position chosen to defend or challenge.
way out: Writing: essays, articles, posts, judgments, argument maps
- L1: Published in articles, online, in editorials.
- L3: Structure laid out; argument maps drawn.
- L7: The case to be put on record.
Sources (27) published science
Dutilh Novaes, C. (2021, rev.) Argument and Argumentation. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (peer-reviewed reference work) (behind its links)
Bail CA et al. (2018) Exposure to opposing views on social media can increase political polarization. PNAS 115:9216-9221, doi:10.1073/pnas.1804840115 (behind its links)
Hansen, H. (2015; rev. 2024) Fallacies. Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (behind its links)
Stephen Toulmin (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01; 'Toulmin model of argument' redirects here) (behind its links)
Trouche E, Johansson P, Hall L, Mercier H (2016) The selective laziness of reasoning. Cognitive Science 40:2122-2136. doi:10.1111/cogs.12303 (behind its links)
Costello, Pennycook, Rand 2024. Durably reducing conspiracy beliefs through dialogues with AI. Science. doi:10.1126/science.adq1814 (PMID 39264999) (behind its links)
Schleihauf H et al. (2026) Children across diverse societies exchange reasons to resolve disagreements. Child Development. doi:10.1093/chidev/aacag117 (behind its links)
Lawrence, Reed 2019. Argument mining: a survey. Computational Linguistics (ACL Anthology J19-4006) (behind its links)
Logic (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Philosophical methodology (encyclopedia article, WME snapshot) (behind its links)
Stab C, Gurevych I (2017) Parsing Argumentation Structures in Persuasive Essays. Computational Linguistics 43(3). arXiv:1604.07370 (behind its links)
Domberg A, Köymen B, Tomasello M (2018) Children's reasoning with peers in cooperative and competitive contexts. Br J Dev Psychol 36:64-77. doi:10.1111/bjdp.12213 (behind its links)
Communication (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Prado J, Léone J, Epinat-Duclos J, Trouche E, Mercier H (2020) The neural bases of argumentative reasoning. Brain and Language 208:104827. doi:10.1016/j.bandl.2020.104827 (behind its links)
Kuhn D, Crowell A (2011) Dialogic argumentation as a vehicle for developing young adolescents' thinking. Psychological Science 22:545-552. doi:10.1177/0956797611402512 (behind its links)
Slonim N et al. (2021) An autonomous debating system. Nature 591:379-384. doi:10.1038/s41586-021-03215-w (behind its links)
Argumentation theory (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Informal logic (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)