← all systems · see it in The System
Essay
An essay is, generally, a piece of writing that gives the author's own argument, but the definition is vague, overlapping with those of a letter, a paper, an article, a pamphlet, and a short story.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 1572 (begun) / 1580 (Essais published) |
| born precision | year |
| boundary | Inside: the short prose piece in which a writer gives and tries out their own reasoning (its text, its kinds and forms) and the practice of writing, revising and reading it; outside: the writers and readers who carry it, the books, periodicals, magazines, screens and exam papers it travels on, and the schools, universities, examination boards, employers and markets that ask for it, judge it or sell it. |
| nested level | a form of literature (short nonfiction prose of the author's own argument); written by people, published in books and periodicals, set and graded in schooling |
| scale | social |
Measures (26) published science
| Montaigne began composing | 1572 year |
| Essais first edition | 1580 year |
| span of Montaigne's writing and revising | approximately 1570 to 1592 years |
| chapters in the Essais | 107 (three books) chapters |
| Bacon's first essays | 1597 (ten essays); later 1612, 1625 year |
| first use of 'essayist' | 1609 year |
| Spectator number length | approximately 2,500 words |
| Spectator original run | 555 numbers, daily from 1 March 1711 |
| Spectator daily circulation | approximately 3,000 copies |
| eight-legged essay required | 1480s decade |
| eight-legged essay abolished | 1905 year |
| official reprinting of model essays | 1587 year |
| UC admission essays analysed | 240,000 essays, 60,000 applicants (November 2016) |
| variance in SAT explained by essay content and style | R² nearly 50% in some models |
| admissions essays analysed for function words | more than 50,000 essays, 25,975 applicants (2004-2007) |
| teachers' rating of Logic and composition (0-6): humans / ChatGPT-3 / ChatGPT-4 | 3.64 / 4.29 / 4.64 mean score |
| essay topics in the human-AI comparison | 90 topics |
| participants, LLM essay-writing EEG study | 54 (18 in session 4) people |
| contract cheating, historical international average | 3.52% (65 studies, 54,514 respondents) % of students |
| students admitting paying for assignments since 2014 | 15.7% % of students |
| start of automated essay scoring | 1966 (Project Essay Grader) year |
| time to develop writing skill (telling to crafting) | at least two decades years |
| exam essay time | two or three hours |
| creative writing EEG workshop length | 16 weeks |
| reflective-writing review: articles included | 199 of 33,076 abstracts articles |
| Montaigne's kidney stones begin | 1578 (age 45) year |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: - C-3194 Did the eight-legged essay hold back imperial China?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: caused 'cultural stagnation and economic backwardness' (later Chinese critics); defended as better than poetry for testing 'prosaic literacy'; tested coherence and basic logic - C-3197 What counts as an essay?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a 'prose composition with a focused subject of discussion' or a 'long, systematic discourse'; Huxley: 'a literary device for saying almost everything about almost anything'; Locke's Essay 'not an essay at all ... in the technical sense'; verse essays (Pope); 'essay' as synonymous with 'article' through journals - C-3198 Where did the essay begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: Montaigne the first author to call his works essays (src:wp:essay); zuihitsu existed in Japan 'several centuries before' the European essay (src:wp:essay); the eight-legged essay's roots in Wang Anshi's jingyi (11th century) (src:wp:eight-legged-essay); Plutarch's Moralia as a model Montaigne drew on (src:wp:essay) - C-3199 Does the five-paragraph essay help or hinder students?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a first essay type for secondary school; a 'deficit model' that risks creativity and critical thinking (Brannon; Wesley; Nunnally) - C-3216 Does writing essays with AI cost the writer thinking?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: a lasting 'cognitive debt' from LLM reliance (Kosmyna et al. 2025); a small sample (54; 18 in session 4) and EEG connectivity as an indirect measure of learning; LLM essays rated higher in quality by teachers (Herbold et al. 2023): what is lost by the writer may not be lost in the text - C-3234 How many people read The Spectator?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: each number 'read by thousands of Londoners, about a tenth of the capital's population' (Addison's estimate); only the ~3,000 copies are counted
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- English literature
- Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
- Literary prose
- Thesis and its supporting arguments
- Commonplaces and quotations
Sits inside / holds (3)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- Education
- Literature
Trades with (valence) (19)
- English literature via sys:written-record · Essay gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Essay gain
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with) via sys:written-record · Essay gain
- University via sys:human-society · Essay gain
- Medicine (the field it serves) via sys:written-record · Essay gain
- Large language model via sys:written-record · Essay mixed
- Human brain via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Essay gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Essay gain
- School via sys:human-society · Essay gain
- Photography via sys:electromagnetic-field · Essay gain
- Literature via sys:written-record · Essay gain
- Rhetoric (speech and argument) via sys:sensory-environment · Essay gain
- Film (media arts) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Essay gain
- Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them via sys:language · Essay gain
- The imperial examination system via sys:human-society · Essay mixed
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on) via sys:written-record · Essay gain
- Periodicals (magazines and newspapers) via sys:written-record · Essay gain
- Essay mill (contract cheating) via sys:market · Essay loss
- Automated essay scoring via sys:written-record · Essay mixed
expressed by (18)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Hypothesis Portfolio / Multiple Hypothesis Tracking
- Offline Simulation & Replay-Guided Planning
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (22)
- English literature
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- University
- Printing press
- Large language model
- Human brain
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- School
- Reading
- Book
- Literature
- Rhetoric (speech and argument)
- Film (media arts)
- Argument: premises offered in support of a conclusion, and argumentation, the practice of giving and asking for reasons in doubt or disagreement, as philosophy and argumentation theory describe them
- The imperial examination system
- Philosophy (the field: the practice and the questions it works on)
- Literary prose
- Periodicals (magazines and newspapers)
- Five-paragraph essay
- Eight-legged essay
- Essay mill (contract cheating)
- Automated essay scoring
Kinds (22)
- Argumentative essay
- Expository essay
- Narrative essay
- Descriptive essay
- Compare and contrast essay
- Cause and effect essay
- Dialectic essay
- Reflective essay
- Familiar essay
- Personal essay
- Critical essay (literary criticism)
- Lyric essay
- Periodical essay
- Five-paragraph essay
- Eight-legged essay
- Zuihitsu
- Admissions essay
- Employment essay (KSA, ECQ)
- Essay film
- Photo essay
- Video essay
- Verse essay
Notes published science
- Montaigne never deleted himself. Across three editions (1580, 1588, and the margins he wrote in his own hand before his death in 1592) he kept adding to his essays but left the old passages standing, 'even when they conflict with his newer views', so one book holds three layers of the same mind arguing with itself. (src:wp:essays-montaigne)
- College essays carry the family's income in their words. In 240,000 University of California admission essays, what students wrote about and how they wrote it lined up with household income more strongly than SAT scores did, and the essays alone predicted SAT scores with an R² of nearly 50% in some models. (src:alvero-2021-essay-income)
- The form that standardised a civil service for four centuries spread through pirated study guides. Chinese printers sold successful eight-legged examination essays as models in the 16th century; the government approved the practice in 1587, and the format held until it was abolished in 1905. (src:wp:eight-legged-essay)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
essay: from the writer's trial of thought to the reading public and the classroom (reader's view)
- L1: The text in a medium: Montaigne's Essais in books (1580, 1588, 1595), periodical numbers of about 2,500 words (The Spectator, 1711-1712), magazines and op-ed pages, exam scripts and application forms, screens; film, photo and video essays in other media
- L2: The short prose piece: brief by tradition (Huxley), usually prose; school and exam formats fix its parts (five paragraphs; eight legs) and length (2,000-5,000 words for longer academic essays)
- L3: Kind and structure: formal and informal; Huxley's three poles (personal, objective, abstract); the kinds (argumentative, expository, narrative, descriptive, reflective, familiar, dialectic...); thesis, body, conclusion; argument components and relations
- L4: Composing and reading the text: planning, generating and reviewing under working-memory limits; preparation and generation stages in the brain; readers taking in the text
- L5: The trial (essai): the writer's own reasoning tried out on the page, 'attempts' to put thoughts into writing, an inquiry 'from different points of view'; thinking and writing 'practically twins'; knowledge told, transformed or crafted
- L6: Judgment and the self: the author's own argument and self-portrait ('I am myself the matter of this book'), weighed by readers, teachers, admissions readers and scoring machines; what the essay is taken to show about its writer
- L7: The essay's culture and its action on the world: essayists and their canon, periodicals and magazines, schools, examinations, admissions and job applications; selecting people, convincing publics, keeping a literate culture's scaffold
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The trial (essai): the writer's own reasoning tried out in prose; planning, generating and reviewing under limited working memory; knowledge told, transformed for the author, or crafted for an imagined reader
- L6: Judgment and self: the author's own argument and self-portrait weighed by readers, teachers, admissions readers and scoring machines; what the essay shows of its writer (ownership, class, mastery)
- L7: The essay's culture: essayists and canon, periodicals and magazines, schools, examinations and admissions, essay mills and detectors; acting back by selecting people and convincing publics
way in: Books: the tradition read (Plutarch, Lucretius, Sextus; earlier essayists)
- L1: Books read: Plutarch's Moral works in Amyot's new French translation
- L3: Quotations carried into the essay from Greek, Latin and Italian texts
- L4: Models of the form taken in: Bacon read Montaigne; Franklin's style from the Spectator; Pyrrhonian passages on Montaigne's library beams
way in: Demand: institutions and publics calling for essays (periodicals, schools, universities, examinations, employers)
- L1: The call for essays: admissions, exams, magazines, federal job applications (KSAs)
- L2: Set lengths and schedules: a daily number of about 2,500 words; 555 numbers
- L3: Readership and market: about 3,000 copies read in coffeehouses
- L4: Model essays printed as guides for candidates
- L6: Selection: essays used to select applicants and to assess merit for government service
way in: Experience: the scene the essayist observes (daily life, the coffee house, travel)
- L1: Daily life and the scene observed: the London coffee house scene; observations of daily life
- L2: Notes and commonplaces: passages and observations collected
- L3: Anecdote and description: the personal pole looks at the world 'through the keyhole of anecdote and description'
- L4: Long-term memory retrieved while composing
way in: Feedback: comments, grades and critics' judgments on drafts and published essays
- L1: Comments from a feedback community (Essay Forum) and teachers
- L2: Ratings on a rubric by teachers
- L3: Contemporaries' judgment: the self as subject read as self-indulgent
- L4: Reviewing: the writer's own check of the text, limited by working memory
way in: Hearing: the essay heard (a narrator reading an essay in an essay film; video essays)
- L1: A narrator's voice reading an essay over film
way in: Machine reading: essays read as data by scoring engines and text analysis
- L1: Essays as a corpus: 240,000 admission essays from 60,000 applicants
- L2: Features: function words almost invisible to reader and writer; topics and dictionary categories
- L3: Scores from features: automated essay scoring since 1966
- L4: Argument components labelled at the token level
- L5: Prediction: grades from categorical language; SAT scores and income from content and style
way in: Reader's eyes: the essay taken in on the page or screen
- L1: Light from the page: a daily number of about 2,500 words; a book; a screen
- L5: The reader's recognition of another's reasoning (Emerson on Montaigne)
way in: The assignment: a prompt, a set title, a format, a time limit
- L1: The prompt or set title: eight prompts, answer any four (UC, 2016); the eight-legged essay's pre-assigned title and rhyming word
- L2: The prescribed format: the five-paragraph essay; the eight legs
- L3: Rules and rubric: sentence and word limits, structure, rhyme; identity clues to be avoided; rubric criteria scored 0-6
- L4: Working memory under the time limit: planning, generating and reviewing each constrained by working memory
way in: The body: the essayist's own sensations (Montaigne's stones, sleep, digestion, appetite)
- L1: The writer's own body: kidney stones from 1578, sleep, digestion, appetite
- L4: Attention held on the body without diagnosis: 'the method of suspended diagnosis'
way in: Thought: thoughts arriving to be tried
- L1: Thoughts that occur to the writer ('thoughts just occur to us: we do not truly control them', Montaigne's view)
- L4: Preparation ('brainstorming'): premotor cortex, bilateral IFG and left temporal language areas
way in: Tools: search engines and LLMs supplying text
- L1: Text from a tool: an LLM's output or search results
- L3: The machine's style: more nominalisations and sentence complexity
- L4: The writer's brain with a tool: cognitive activity scales down with tool use; weakest connectivity with an LLM
way out: Publishing: books, periodical numbers, magazines, op-eds
- L1: Essays in magazines with an intellectual bent
- L7: Periodicals as storehouses of essayists' work
way out: Revising: layers added, nothing removed
- L1: The Bordeaux Copy: 'C' additions in Montaigne's own hand
- L2: Additions that keep earlier, conflicting text
- L5: Revising previously published essays and composing new ones
way out: Selecting and grading people by their essays
- L1: Applicants and candidates admitted or passed over
- L6: Class encoded in content and style shapes what readers see
- L7: Essays used to assess merit for government service; admission essays to select applicants
way out: The essay in other media: film, photographs, video
- L1: Linked photographs; videos on YouTube
- L7: The essay form extended to film
way out: Writing the essay
- L1: The manuscript or typed text; a book of essays
- L2: The short prose piece in its form
- L4: Generation: text composed (after preparation; then revision)
- L5: Deciding what to say and how to say it
Sources (19) published science
Essays (Montaigne) (Wikipedia; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)
Kellogg RT (2008) Training writing skills: A cognitive developmental perspective. Journal of Writing Research 1(1):1-26. doi:10.17239/jowr-2008.01.01.1 (open access) (behind its links)
Eight-legged essay (Wikipedia; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)
Stab C, Gurevych I (2017) Parsing Argumentation Structures in Persuasive Essays. Computational Linguistics 43(3). arXiv:1604.07370 (behind its links)
English literature (Wikipedia, rev 1381089443, 2026-10-19; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Zuihitsu (Wikipedia; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)
Five-paragraph essay (Wikipedia; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)
The Spectator (1711) (Wikipedia; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)
Awdry R, Ives B (2023) International Predictors of Contract Cheating in Higher Education. J Acad Ethics. doi:10.1007/s10805-022-09449-1 (PMC8990678, CC BY) (behind its links)
Bair H (2026) The first reader: Montaigne and the body's particularity. Palliat Support Care 24:e179. doi:10.1017/S1478951526102995 (PMC13312349, CC BY) (behind its links)
Michel de Montaigne (Wikipedia; via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)