← all systems · see it in The System
Great Depression
The worldwide economic collapse of 1929-1939 as economic historians describe it: a contraction that began in the United States in 1929, deepened through waves of banking panics (1930-1933) and the world financial crisis of 1931, and spread among countries chiefly through the rebuilt interwar gold standard, with falling prices, output, trade and employment; recovery began in most countries from 1933, earliest where countries left gold, and in many accounts ended only with rearmament and the Second World War. Its causes, its span and what ended it stay contested; walked as the economic process together with the policy responses and the social and political effects historians attach to it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 1929 (crash 24-29 October 1929) |
| born precision | year (start contested: the Fed's 1928 tightening; declining spending before the crash) |
| boundary | Inside: the contraction and recovery of 1929-1939 as a process in the world economy: the crash and the banking panics, the gold flows and exchange crises that carried it between countries, the fall of prices, output, trade and employment, and the decisions of central banks, treasuries, legislatures and households that shaped its course (staying on or leaving gold, tariffs, relief, the New Deal, rearmament), with its effects on families, farms, health and politics. Outside: the economies, states and peoples it ran through (each with its own walk), the interwar settlement it inherited (war debts, reparations), the Dust Bowl drought's natural ocean drivers, the regimes and the war that came after it. |
| end precision | contested: the 1933 trough, 1936 (Gold Bloc's end), 1939 (mobilisation in Europe), late 1941 (U.S.) |
| ended at | 1939 (encyclopedia span) |
| nested level | Built from the 1929 world economy's banks, stock exchanges, central banks, firms, farms and households acting under the interwar gold standard; a period of the world economy's history (one 'depression' among the downturns that name was given to); a driver of the interwar road to the Second World War. |
| scale | social |
Measures (42) published science
| Span (as the encyclopedia dates it) | 1929 to 1939 years |
| Wall Street crash, October 1929 | -11% (24 Oct), -12% (28 Oct), -11% (29 Oct) percent per day |
| Shares traded on Black Thursday and Black Tuesday | 12.9 million; about 16.4 million shares per day |
| Stock market loss, September 1929 to July 1932 | 85 percent of value |
| Dow Jones Industrial Average, 1929-1932 | 381 to 198 (two months, 1929); 294 (April 1930); low 41 (1932) index points |
| U.S. monetary contraction (Friedman and Schwartz) | 35 percent |
| Share of monetary gold held by the United States and France | about 60 percent |
| U.S. monetary base to reserves (BASE/RES) | 1.871 (June 1928), 1.759 (June 1929), 1.626 (June 1930) ratio |
| U.S. money multiplier (M1/BASE), 1929 | close to four ratio |
| Money growth gap, gold versus non-gold countries (1931-1935) | about 5 (t = 3.26) percentage points per year |
| Reichsbank reserve losses, June 1931 | 150 million (first week), 540 million (second week), 150 million (19-20 June) marks |
| Gold withdrawals from London, summer 1931 | 2.5 million pounds per day |
| Smoot-Hawley tariff on dutiable imports | 40 to 47 (relative import prices up 6) percent |
| World trade volume, 1929-1932 | -25 (1929-1932); -16 (Q3 1931 to Q3 1932) percent |
| World trade, 1933 against 1929 | one-third fraction of 1929 level |
| Share of world trade through clearing arrangements, 1937 | 12 percent |
| Industrial production change 1929-1932 | U.S. -46, U.K. -23, France -24, Germany -41 (wholesale prices -32/-33/-34/-29; foreign trade -70/-60/-54/-61) percent |
| World GDP fall 1929-1932 | about 15 (U.S. 30) percent |
| U.S. contraction 1929-1933 | real output -25% or more; prices -33%; unemployment 3.2% to 25% percent |
| U.S. unemployment rate, 1933 | 25 percent |
| U.S. banks failed by 1933 | 9,000 of 25,000 banks |
| Deposits frozen in failed or unlicensed U.S. banks, April 1933 | about 7 billion U.S. dollars |
| Anti-system party vote share, interwar democracies, before and after 1929 | mean under 4% to almost 11%; median under 2% to over 7%; Germany about 13% (1928) to almost 60% (November 1932) percent of votes |
| Fascist vote, defeated powers of 1914-1918 against others, after 1928 | +18 percentage points |
| Birth rate, 14 major countries, 1930 and 1935 | 19.3 to 17.0 (-12%) births per 1,000 population |
| Warm-season record-high to record-low ratio, U.S., 1930s | 2.5 (Canada 2.0, Sweden 2.9, Germany 1.6, Russia 1.5) ratio (1 = stable climate) |
| Share of Dust Bowl agricultural cost recovered by adjustment | 14 to 28 percent |
| Counterfactual U.S. real GNP without monetary expansion | about 25% lower (1937); nearly 50% lower (1942) percent |
| U.S. real GNP growth in the recovery | over 8 (1933-1937); over 10 (1938-1941) percent per year |
| U.S. unemployment, 1937 and 1938 | 14.3 to 19.0 (5 million to more than 12 million) percent |
| Recession of 1937-1938, duration | 13 months |
| WPA workers employed | more than 8.5 million workers |
| Federal share of U.S. relief spending | 2 (1932) to 79 (1935) percent |
| Infant deaths averted per extra dollar of relief per head | 0.16 infant deaths per 1,000 live births |
| U.S. suicide maxima over a century | the 1910s and the 1930s decades |
| Epigenetic age acceleration per 1 SD in-utero wage decline | GrimAge +0.380 SD; DunedinPoAm 0.449 SD standard deviations |
| Chile GDP, 1932 against 1929 | less than half fraction of 1929 |
| Belgian Congo peanut price | 125 to 25 centimes |
| U.S. federal expenditure, share of GDP, 1929 | 3 (debt ratio 20% to 40% of GNP under Hoover) percent |
| Settling time after leaving gold (wholesale prices) | about 1-2 years: leavers' prices stabilised in 1932-1933 and rose on average from 1934 |
| Banking panic clock (Mississippi, fall 1930) | failure rates diverged within the four months after Caldwell's collapse (7 November 1930) |
| Market slide, crash to bottom | October 1929 to 8 July 1932 (about 33 months) |
Open contentions (7) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1072 Do economies return to full employment on their own?
booked: The map doesn't rule. It records the Keynesian reading that they don't, alongside the Austrian, monetarist and classical views.
the other reading: - C-1101 Was the Treaty of Versailles too harsh?
booked: The map lists the readings side by side: too harsh, too lenient, or a compromise that satisfied no one.
the other reading: - C-2169 Did the Great Depression make people healthier or sicker?
booked: The map keeps both findings: deaths fell, yet those in the womb aged faster.
the other reading: population health improved in the recession; mortality procyclical (Tapia Granados and Diez Roux; Fishback et al.); suicides peaked in the 1930s (de Lacy et al.); long-run harm: in-utero exposure and faster epigenetic aging (Schmitz and Duque), against earlier null results they cite; relief spending lowered infant mortality and suicides (Fishback et al.) - C-2180 What caused the Great Depression?
booked: The map lists the causes and rules none.
the other reading: monetary: banking crisis and a 35% monetary contraction the Fed allowed (Friedman and Schwartz; Bernanke 2002); Keynesian: an autonomous fall in spending, especially investment and 1930 consumption (Temin; Keynes); the interwar gold standard as transmission and constraint (Eichengreen, Bernanke and James); debt deflation and the credit channel (Fisher; Bernanke); the crash itself as main cause, or as a symptom of trends already under way; Smoot-Hawley and protection as an aggravator; Austrian: the 1920s credit boom (Hayek, Rothbard); Marxist: capitalism's inherent instability; inequality and underconsumption (Catchings and Foster); a productivity shock and excess capacity (Hubbert, Bell) - C-2181 When did the Great Depression begin and end?
booked: The map keeps the spans side by side.
the other reading: ending at the 1933 trough when recovery began in most countries; ending only with U.S. mobilisation for war (late 1941) or wartime full employment; starting with the Fed's 1928 tightening or the 1929 downturn before the crash; for France, running later (hit around 1931; slow recovery) - C-2237 How much did the Smoot-Hawley tariff worsen the Depression?
booked: The map keeps it contested.
the other reading: a large aggravator: two-thirds of American economic historians (1995 survey); 'among the most catastrophic acts' (U.S. Senate site); more limited: dutiable tariff only from 40 to 47 percent, relative import prices up 6 percent; the spark for the trade collapse was the 1931 financial crisis (Eichengreen and Irwin) - C-2247 What ended the Great Depression?
booked: The map lists the explanations and rules none.
the other reading: monetary expansion from gold inflows (Romer: nearly all U.S. recovery before 1942); leaving gold and reflation (Eichengreen and Sachs; Bernanke); New Deal spending (the common Keynesian view; never large enough, Keynes); a change of expectations with Roosevelt's regime change (Temin, Wigmore, Eggertsson); rearmament and the Second World War (the common view among economic historians); revisionist: the New Deal prolonged it (NIRA and NLRA price fixing)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Household
- Commercial banks (creators of most money)
- Central bank
- The interwar gold standard (gold-exchange standard, 1925-1936)
- Federal Reserve System (its twelve district banks)
- New York Stock Exchange (the Wall Street crash)
- New Deal (1933-1939)
- Dust Bowl (1930s Great Plains drought and erosion)
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (23)
- President of the United States · Great Depression loss
- Central bank via sys:economy · Great Depression gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Great Depression gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:human-society · Great Depression mixed
- Government via sys:human-society · Great Depression mixed
- Climate system (climate) via sys:climate-system · Great Depression loss
- Family (the human family as a system) via sys:human-society · Great Depression mixed
- Money via sys:money · Great Depression mixed
- Market and trade via sys:market · Great Depression gain
- Farming (agriculture) via sys:human-society · Great Depression gain
- Supply and demand via sys:market · Great Depression gain
- United States (the country across time) via sys:human-society · Great Depression gain
- Soviet Union via sys:world-trade-web · Great Depression even
- China via sys:central-bank-reserves · Great Depression even
- Nationalism via sys:mental-representation · Great Depression loss
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:human-society · Great Depression loss
- Economy via sys:economy · Great Depression mixed
- Economics (the field) via sys:mental-representation · Great Depression mixed
- The Holocaust (the Shoah) via sys:economy · Great Depression even
- The interwar gold standard (gold-exchange standard, 1925-1936) via sys:central-bank-reserves · Great Depression loss
- Colonialism via sys:human-society · Great Depression mixed
- Globalization via sys:economy · Great Depression mixed
- International trade via sys:economy · Great Depression mixed
expressed by (15)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (23)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Government
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Climate system (climate)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Money
- Household
- Commercial banks (creators of most money)
- Labour market
- World trade web
- Farming (agriculture)
- Central bank
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945)
- Keynesian economics
- Economy
- Nazi germany
- Economics (the field)
- The interwar gold standard (gold-exchange standard, 1925-1936)
- Federal Reserve System (its twelve district banks)
- New York Stock Exchange (the Wall Street crash)
- New Deal (1933-1939)
- Debt deflation (Fisher; Bernanke's credit channel)
Kinds (7)
- The Great Contraction (monetarist reading)
- The fall in spending (Keynesian reading)
- Golden fetters (gold-standard reading)
- Debt deflation (Fisher; Bernanke's credit channel)
- Austrian reading (Hayek, Rothbard)
- Inequality and underconsumption (Catchings and Foster)
- Marxist reading
Notes published science
- One state, two central banks: a 1913 line split Mississippi between the Atlanta and St. Louis Federal Reserve districts. In the 1930 bank panic Atlanta lent to troubled banks and St. Louis did not, and banks failed less on the Atlanta side even within 50 miles of the border, a natural experiment in whether a central bank can stop a run (src:richardson-troost-2006-mississippi).
- The Depression's health paradox: in the United States, deaths fell and life expectancy rose by several years during 1930-1933 (only suicides went up), yet people who were in the womb in the worst years show faster-ageing DNA when tested at 75-84 (src:tapia-granados-2009-life-death, src:schmitz-duque-2022-epigenetic).
- A bank's failure left a trail into the Holocaust: where Germany's 1931 failing bank had more exposure, Nazi votes surged, and after 1933 pogroms and deportations were more frequent in those same places, worst where anti-Semitism had a history (src:doerr-2022-banks-hitler).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the Great Depression as economic historians describe it: the world economy's people, farms, banks and gold, through prices, runs and gold flows, to central banks, governments and households, to doctrines and the regimes chosen (reader's view; historians' phases in `periods`)
- L1: The world it touches: the 1929 world economy's people, farms, factories, banks and gold, with the United States the largest economy
- L2: The doors in: share prices and margin accounts, bank deposits, central banks' gold windows, crop and wholesale prices, customs schedules, ballots
- L3: Routing: the gold standard as transmission, correspondent banking, hot money and capital flight, tariff retaliation
- L4: Integration: money, prices and output fall together in almost every country; debt deflation; mass unemployment
- L5: Institutions (the board): central banks, governments, banks and firms, households
- L6: Meaning: doctrine and expectations (sound money, real bills, liquidationism; optimism or pessimism)
- L7: Purpose and action: the regimes chosen (gold or reflation, protection, relief, rearmament) and the political order (democracy or dictatorship)
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Banks, exchanges and firms: lenders, brokers and employers, tightening credit and cutting jobs
- L5: Central banks under the gold standard's rules: the Federal Reserve and its twelve districts, the Bank of England, the Reichsbank, the Bank of France
- L5: Governments, treasuries and legislatures: budgets, tariffs, relief, emergency decrees
- L5: Households, farmers and workers: spending cut, debts paid down, money hoarded, gardens, boarders and mutual aid
- L6: Doctrine and expectations: gold-standard orthodoxy and sound money, real bills and liquidationism, confidence and pessimism, with more than one possible equilibrium of the money supply
- L7: The regime chosen: stay on gold or leave, defend or devalue, austerity or reflation, protection or not, relief and reform, and the political order itself
way in: Ballots, parties and the street
- L1: Voters in hard times
- L2: Elections: the Nazi Party at 18.3% in September 1930; moderates lose seats
- L3: Parties and electoral rules: existing extremist parties and low hurdles to representation route the anger
- L4: Vote shares: anti-system parties' mean share up from under 4% to almost 11% after 1929; in Germany almost 60% by November 1932
way in: Depositors' confidence (bank deposits and runs)
- L1: Deposits in some 25,000 U.S. banks in 1929, 9,000 of which were gone by 1933
- L2: The bank's door: deposits payable on demand, with no deposit insurance (two equilibria: confidence or a self-confirming run)
- L3: Contagion through correspondent networks: Caldwell and Company (7 November 1930) and the Bank of United States (December 1930)
- L4: Panics raise the currency-deposit and reserve-deposit ratios: the money multiplier falls
way in: Drought, heat and dust on the Great Plains
- L1: Decadal Pacific (IPO) and Atlantic (AMO) sea-surface anomalies start and hold the drought
- L2: The Dust Bowl drought of 1932-1939 on the Plains, with heat records not equalled until recently
- L3: Bare, ploughed soil dries, heats and blows away in dust storms
- L4: Land values and farm revenues fall immediately, substantially and persistently
way in: Economic doctrine and forecasts
- L1: Say's law and the equilibrating market: most economists failed to grasp the severity
- L2: Forecasts heard: Fisher's 'permanently high plateau', Babson's crash warning, Hayek's February 1929 paper
- L3: Advisers route doctrine into policy: Mellon the liquidationist kept until 1932
- L4: Rival theories reach policy makers: Catchings and Foster's underconsumption theory influences Hoover, Wallace, Douglas, Eccles
way in: Gold and exchange reserves moving between central banks
- L1: The world's monetary gold, some 60% held by the United States and France
- L2: Each central bank's gold window: money tied to its gold reserves and the official price of gold
- L3: Price-specie flow and hot money: losing gold forces money and prices down
- L4: The money-gold ratio collapses while monetary gold keeps growing
way in: Goods crossing borders (tariffs, quotas, exchange controls)
- L1: Exports and imports: U.S. exports fall from about $5.2 billion (1929) to $1.7 billion (1933)
- L2: Customs houses: tariffs, import quotas and exchange controls
- L3: Retaliation: Smoot-Hawley answered by Canada and European countries
- L4: World trade volume falls 25% 1929-1932, 16% in the year after Britain's devaluation
way in: International loans, war debts and reparations
- L1: Germany depended heavily on U.S. loans
- L2: New American loans that funded Dawes and Young plan repayments end after the crash
- L3: The Creditanstalt fails (May 1931); short-term money is withdrawn from Germany
- L4: The Hoover Moratorium and the standstill freeze reparations and Germany's foreign liabilities
way in: Prices of crops, goods and assets (deflation)
- L1: Crops, raw materials and manufactures, with primary-producing regions most exposed
- L2: Crop prices fall up to 60%; wholesale prices fall about a third in the four largest economies
- L3: Debts stay at the same dollar amount while prices and incomes fall 20-50%
- L4: Over-indebtedness and deflation feed each other: beyond a limit the economic boat capsizes
way in: Share prices and margin loans (the stock market)
- L1: Shares bought in the boom, much of it on margin, as speculation
- L2: The exchange's prices and brokers' margin accounts (10% margin: $9 lent for every $1)
- L3: Margin calls force selling: loans called that could not be paid back
- L4: Investors ruined, billions lost, many stocks unsaleable at any price
way in: Work and wages (the labour market)
- L1: People at work: U.S. unemployment from 3.2% to 25%, 1929-1933
- L2: Hiring and layoffs: wages cut, workers laid off despite Hoover's appeals
- L3: Sticky nominal wages carry the nominal shock into real wages and jobs
- L4: Mass unemployment, highest in the U.S., Britain and Germany
way out: Livelihoods, homes, farms and bodies
- L1: Hoovervilles; migration; mortality falls while suicides rise; in-utero exposure ages bodies decades later
- L3: Farms change hands; families move off the Plains
- L5: Firms cut wages, lay off workers, postpone investment
way out: Money: defend the parity or leave gold and reflate
- L1: Prices and output: leavers recover, stayers stay in slump
- L3: Money growth about 5 points a year lower in gold countries, 1931-1935
- L5: Central-bank lending to banks in panic (the Atlanta Fed's discounts) or not (St. Louis)
- L6: Leaving gold frees money to reflate; staying forces further deflation
- L7: Britain leaves gold in September 1931; Japan and the Scandinavians follow; the U.S. in 1933; the Gold Bloc in 1935-1936
way out: Rearmament and autarky
- L1: Rearmament stimulates European economies, 1937-1939
- L5: Japan's deficit spending goes into munitions
- L7: Nazi Germany presses ahead with rearmament and autarky, which could only partly be accomplished without expansion
way out: Relief, recovery and reform (the New Deal and its counterparts)
- L1: Infant mortality and suicide lower where relief was higher; 8.5 million WPA workers build roads and buildings
- L3: Relief spending: federal share from 2% (1932) to 79% (1935)
- L5: Bank holiday, deposit insurance (FDIC), securities regulation
- L7: The First New Deal's 3 R's: relief, recovery, reform
way out: The political order: extremism, emergency rule and dictatorship
- L1: Pogroms and deportations more frequent where the 1931 banking crisis hit
- L5: Rule by decree under Hindenburg, bypassing the Reichstag; street violence
- L7: Many democracies in Europe and Latin America overthrown, most famously Germany in 1933
way out: Trade barriers: tariffs, quotas and exchange controls
- L1: World trade at a third of its 1929 value by 1933
- L3: Exchange controls and clearing: 12% of world trade by 1937
- L5: Average U.S. tariff on dutiable imports from 40 to 47 percent
- L7: Hoover signs Smoot-Hawley (June 1930)