← all systems · see it in The System
The Holocaust (the Shoah)
The genocide of European Jews by Nazi Germany and its collaborators: from the regime's seizure of power in 1933, through exclusion by law, expropriation, forced emigration, ghettoisation and starvation, to the systematic murder of around six million Jews (about two-thirds of Europe's Jews) from 1941 to 1945, chiefly by mass shooting in the occupied East and by poison gas in extermination camps in occupied Poland; carried out by the SS and police, the army, civil administrations, the railways, allied governments and local auxiliaries, against the resistance, flight and hiding of its victims and the rescue efforts of some neighbours; concurrent with the Nazi persecution and murder of Roma and Sinti, disabled people, Soviet prisoners of war and others (included under the term by some historians); and continuing after 1945 in trials, restitution, survivors' lives, testimony, memory and denial.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | sys:holocaust, The Holocaust |
| born at | 30 January 1933 (seizure of power) / 22 June 1941 (shootings in the occupied Soviet Union) |
| born precision | months |
| boundary | Inside: the persecution and murder of Europe's Jews as historians describe it: the regime's decisions and the ideology behind them; the agencies that carried it out (SS and police, Einsatzgruppen and Order Police, civil and military occupation administrations, the Reichsbahn, the camps and their staff and auxiliaries); allied and satellite governments as they handed over or withheld their Jews; the victims themselves, their councils, self-help, flight, hiding, resistance and record-keeping; rescuers; and, after 1945, trials, restitution, survivors' lives, testimony, historiography, memorials and denial. Outside: the Second World War as a whole (the frame it ran inside), Nazi Germany's other policies, the Allied and neutral world (whose news and decisions come in as channels), and the other Nazi mass crimes (Roma and Sinti, the disabled, Soviet prisoners of war, Poles), which share personnel, methods and sometimes the name: the term's scope is contested (C-2192). |
| end precision | months |
| ended at | May 1945 (Germany's defeat; the camps liberated between July 1944 and May 1945) |
| nested level | A genocide inside the Second World War and inside Nazi Germany's racial and territorial programme; built from state agencies, camps, trains, laws and people; acting on Europe's Jewish communities; running on people's labour, speech and violence (Human L7); continuing after 1945 as law, memory and a benchmark for genocide studies. |
| scale | social |
Measures (52) published science
| span of the Holocaust | 1933-1945 (persecution from the seizure of power) or 1941-1945 (systematic murder), by reading years |
| Jewish victims of the Holocaust | around 6 million (conservative 5.7 million; 5.4 million under Nazi occupation); about two-thirds of Europe's Jews, one-third of world Jewry people |
| victims in 1942 | over 3 million people |
| victims in the 100-day surge of 1942 | 1,465,211 (27 July-4 November 1942: 1,072,101 at the three Reinhard camps, 301,720 shot, 91,390 at Auschwitz), a minimum people |
| kill rate, 27 July to 4 November 1942 | 445,700 (Rwanda 1994 for comparison: 243,300) murders per month |
| Operation Reinhard duration | 21 months (March 1942-November 1943); most killing in 3 of them (14%) |
| speed-up run at the Reinhard camps | 105 days (22 July-4 November 1942) at an almost constant rate |
| proportion murdered (Kp) | 94-97% in the General Government; >99.9% in the death camps percent |
| Operation Reinhard victims | at least 1.8 million (at least 1,520,000 in and on the way to the camps, plus at least 20% shot on site) people |
| victims per Reinhard camp | Bełżec 440,823-596,200; Sobibór 170,618-238,900; Treblinka 780,863-951,800 people |
| survivors of the Reinhard camps | fewer than 150 people |
| share shot on site in the ghetto actions | at least 20 (Lublin and Kraków districts; conservative) percent |
| Treblinka stoppage, 1942 | 28 August-3 September (about a week): transports halted by overload at the camp days |
| Warsaw ghetto deportation | 22 July-12 September 1942 (about 7 weeks); 250,000 killed at Treblinka of 350,000 |
| German staff of the Reinhard camps | 121 men; a core of about 500 organisers in the East people |
| Trawniki men | almost 5,000; about 100 per 15-20 Germans in the camps people |
| Germans directly involved in killing | 200,000-250,000; 500,000 counting organisers people |
| share of deaths caused by non-Germans not under German command | 5-6 percent |
| share of Jews shot by end of 1941 | >80% in central Ukraine, eastern Belarus, Russia, Latvia and Lithuania; <25% farther west percent |
| Jewish victims shot | 1.5-2 million (and up to 225,000 Roma) people |
| largest single-day toll in a camp | about 18,400 at Majdanek in nine hours, 3 November 1943 people |
| Hungarian Jews deported, 1944 | 434,000 (March-9 July) or 437,000 in eight weeks (two figures in the same article) people |
| Warsaw ghetto density | at least 450,000 people in 3.4 km2 people per area |
| typhus infections, Warsaw ghetto | 20,160 reported; 80,000-110,000 infected (reporting about 20-25%) people |
| ghetto daily calories | official ration often no more than 200; 784-1,665 by wealth and status (December 1941) kcal per day |
| Warsaw ghetto deaths before deportation | about 118,000 unaccounted for by ration cards (445,000 to 327,073 adjusted, March 1941-July 1942) against about 70,500 registered people |
| Kristallnacht damage | 7,500 of 9,000 Jewish shops looted, more than 1,000 synagogues (or 'over 1,400 synagogues and prayer rooms'), at least 90 murdered, up to 30,000 men arrested count |
| German Jews who emigrated | 130,000 (1933-37) + 120,000 (1938-39), of 560,000 people |
| people forcibly sterilised | 400,000 (Thys: over 400,000) people |
| Aktion T4 victims | around 70,000 in the centralised phase plus about 120,000 by decentralised killing; 275,000-300,000 in all 'euthanasia' killings people |
| Soviet prisoners of war who died | 3.3 million (60%) people |
| Romani victims | at least 250,000, up to 500,000 (range 96,000-500,000; historians 'just above 200,000') people |
| Jews who survived in hiding | about 200,000 (Gerlach) people |
| Jewish partisans in the Soviet Union | 20,000-25,000 people |
| Jews in forest family camps | 10,000-13,000 people |
| emigrants helped by the JDC | 81,000 (1939-1944) people |
| Jews saved by allies' protection | about 600,000 people |
| Jewish survivors | about 1.3 million who had lived under Nazi rule or its allies people |
| concentration camp prisoners, January 1945 | >700,000, up to a third of whom died before the war's end people |
| Jewish deaths in the last months of the war | 70,000-100,000 people |
| Righteous Among the Nations recognised | 28,707 (as of January 2024) people |
| restitution and compensation paid by Germany | $86.8 billion (1945-2018) US dollars |
| Jewish property losses | about 10 billion 1944 dollars (six countries, labour excluded); about 10% of all property stolen from occupied countries US dollars (1944) |
| world Jewish population | 16.6 million (1939); 15.2 million (end of 2020) people |
| annual visitors | Auschwitz about 2 million; Treblinka under 60,000 visitors per year |
| artefacts excavated at Sobibór | over 20,000 objects |
| persistence ratios | anti-Jewish attacks in the 1920s 6 times more likely where Jews were burned in 1348-50; Nazi vote 1928 1.5 times higher; committed antisemites 2-3 times more common in the cohort raised under Nazism ratio |
| lag of medieval persistence | about 580 years (1348-50 to the 1920s) |
| Jews in Germany, 1947 | 250,000; about 25% of displaced persons camps people |
| share of Jews killed, France | 25 (most non-citizens or recent immigrants) percent |
| Warsaw Ghetto Uprising toll | at least 56,065 Jews killed or captured; 110 German casualties including 16 killed (both by Stroop's own report) people |
| Warsaw Ghetto Uprising duration | 19 April-16 May 1943 (about four weeks) days |
Open contentions (12) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-2156 Should the Allies have bombed Auschwitz?
booked: The map keeps the historians' debate open.
the other reading: it would have saved lives; it would not have impacted the Holocaust - C-2186 Does old hatred persist in places for centuries?
booked: The map books the finding with its limits.
the other reading: cultural persistence in place (Voigtlaender and Voth); other local factors not ruled out by the authors' controls - C-2187 When did the Holocaust begin and end?
booked: The map keeps the dates side by side.
the other reading: 1933-1945; 1941-1945; 1939-1945 (from the war) - C-2188 When was the decision for the Holocaust taken?
booked: The map keeps the historians' readings open.
the other reading: intentionalist: Hitler planned and ordered it, tied to the invasion of the Soviet Union; functionalist: incremental, from lower levels of party and bureaucracy in the occupied East, after earlier policies 'failed'; a decision before December 1941 (Serbian shootings, camp planning, deportation of German Jews); a decision in December 1941 or later (Hitler's 12 December statement); syntheses of both - C-2189 Is Holocaust trauma passed down the generations?
booked: The map keeps the evidence and its limits.
the other reading: psychological transmission through parenting and attachment; biological and epigenetic transmission; resilience as much as vulnerability - C-2190 What lessons does the Holocaust teach?
booked: The map lists the readings.
the other reading: memory promotes human rights and reduces prejudice (advocates of Holocaust education); the effect is disputed; memory has also been used to justify force - C-2191 How much did local people take part in the killing?
booked: The map keeps the readings side by side.
the other reading: spontaneous local violence; incited by German forces - C-2192 Who counts among the Holocaust's victims?
booked: The map keeps the definitions side by side.
the other reading: the Holocaust = the genocide of Jews only (the Shoah); the Holocaust = Nazi genocide of all groups targeted on a biological basis (Jews, Roma and Sinti, the disabled); wider still: Soviet POWs, Polish and Soviet civilians - C-2193 Was the Holocaust unique?
booked: The map keeps the debate open.
the other reading: unique or incomprehensible (popular; 'largely rejected by historians'); comparable with other genocides; an outgrowth of Western civilisation; an aberration of it - C-2194 What did the ghetto uprisings achieve?
booked: The map keeps the readings.
the other reading: the prisoners (most killed); the camps (closed early) - C-2197 How many died in Kristallnacht?
booked: The map keeps the counts.
the other reading: more than 1,000 synagogues damaged or destroyed; over 1,400 synagogues and prayer rooms destroyed - C-2227 How many Romani were killed?
booked: The map keeps the ranges.
the other reading: 96,000 (low estimate); just above 200,000 (most historians); 220,000-500,000 (USHMM); 500,000 (most activists); 1.5 million (Hancock; called 'untenable' by Fings)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (11)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- European Jews (victims of the Holocaust)
- Nazi germany
- The SS and police (Himmler; Heydrich's Reich Main Security Office)
- Einsatzgruppen and Order Police battalions
- Operation Reinhard (Bełżec, Sobibór, Treblinka, 1942-1943)
- Auschwitz-Birkenau and the concentration camp system
- Trawniki men (auxiliaries recruited from Soviet prisoners of war)
- Deutsche Reichsbahn
- The ghettos (Warsaw, Łódź and some 200 in the occupied Soviet Union)
- Jewish councils, self-help and medical organisations in the ghettos
Sits inside / holds (2)
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945)
- Nazi Germany's racial and territorial programme ('living space')
Trades with (valence) (20)
- Nationalism via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Great Depression via sys:economy · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- European Jews (victims of the Holocaust) via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) mixed
- World wars (the two world wars of the 20th century: World War I, 1914-1918, and World War II, 1939-1945) via sys:war · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- The archive and the historical record via sys:written-record · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- History (the field) via sys:written-record · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Allies of World War II via sys:mass-media · The Holocaust (the Shoah) loss
- Epidemic typhus (and cholera) via sys:epidemic · The Holocaust (the Shoah) mixed
- Deutsche Reichsbahn via sys:railway · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Aktion T4 (the murder of disabled people) via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Roma and Sinti via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) mixed
- Soviet prisoners of war via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Germany's allies and satellites (Slovakia, Romania, Hungary, Croatia, Bulgaria, Italy, Vichy France) via sys:international-system · The Holocaust (the Shoah) mixed
- Neighbours: local inhabitants, police and auxiliaries in occupied Europe via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) mixed
- Rescuers (Righteous Among the Nations and others) via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) loss
- Jewish resistance (fighting organisations, partisans, underground, documentation) via sys:human-society · The Holocaust (the Shoah) loss
- German firms and agencies that gained (Bayer, BMW, Volkswagen; SS and state agencies) via sys:money · The Holocaust (the Shoah) gain
- Physicians and the medical profession via sys:epidemic · The Holocaust (the Shoah) mixed
- Holocaust denial via sys:collective-memory · The Holocaust (the Shoah) loss
expressed by (20)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Evade Detection
- Encirclement
- Speed
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Subversion & Co-optation
- Divide & Isolate
- Quick Harm Avoidance
- Reactive Response
- Proactive Defense
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Resilience & Repair
- Deterrence
floor filled by (18)
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Collective memory
- European Jews (victims of the Holocaust)
- Railways (and canals and turnpikes)
- Nazi germany
- The SS and police (Himmler; Heydrich's Reich Main Security Office)
- Einsatzgruppen and Order Police battalions
- Trawniki men (auxiliaries recruited from Soviet prisoners of war)
- Deutsche Reichsbahn
- The ghettos (Warsaw, Łódź and some 200 in the occupied Soviet Union)
- Jewish councils, self-help and medical organisations in the ghettos
- Roma and Sinti
- Germany's allies and satellites (Slovakia, Romania, Hungary, Croatia, Bulgaria, Italy, Vichy France)
- Neighbours: local inhabitants, police and auxiliaries in occupied Europe
- Antisemitism
- Genocide convention
- Nuremberg laws
- Nuremberg trials
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- In the Warsaw ghetto, a typhus epidemic that should have got worse with winter instead collapsed in late October 1941. A 2020 model credits the ghetto's own doctors and volunteers (community kitchens, sanitary courses for hundreds, public lectures, an underground medical school) with preventing more than 100,000 infections; the residents never knew what they had achieved (src:stone-2020).
- Railway timetables, read as data, show that about 1.47 million Jews (more than a quarter of all the Holocaust's victims) were murdered in just 100 days in 1942. That is about 83% faster than the figure usually given for the Rwandan genocide, which textbooks had called three to five times faster than the Holocaust (src:stone-2019).
- German towns that burned their Jews during the Black Death in 1348-50 saw anti-Jewish attacks six times more often in the 1920s and voted more for the Nazis in 1928. The hatred did not last in the Hanseatic trading towns or in fast-growing cities (src:voigtlander-voth-2011).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
The Holocaust: Europe's Jews and the other peoples the regime targeted, through definition, concentration and deportation, to the regime's decisions and the genocide, and its memory (reader's view; historians' periods in `periods`)
- L1: Europe's Jews among their neighbours (about 500,000 in Germany, 1.7 million in conquered Poland, millions more in the East), and the others the regime targeted: Roma and Sinti, disabled people, Soviet prisoners of war, Poles
- L2: Definition and identification: laws on descent, registration, marks, neighbours who point people out
- L3: Concentration and routing: ghettos, camps on rail lines, the deportation trains
- L4: Integration on the ground: occupation administrations, killing units, local auxiliaries, Jewish councils under orders
- L5: Institutions: the regime and the SS, ministries, the Reichsbahn, allied governments; on the other side Jewish councils and self-help; after 1945 courts and memorials
- L6: Meaning: racial antisemitism, living space, policy from expulsion to murder; victims' knowledge; later memory
- L7: The genocide decided and carried out, 1941-1945; and what it became: the single deadliest genocide, the benchmark of genocide
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: Occupation administrations, SS and police in the field, often acting on their own initiative
- L5: The regime's centre: Hitler, Himmler and the SS, Heydrich's Reich Main Security Office, the ministries, the Reichsbahn
- L5: Jewish councils, community self-help, medical services and the underground
- L5: After 1945: courts, restitution bodies, archives, museums and memorial sites
- L6: Racial antisemitism and the drive for 'living space': the nation as a racial community to be purged
- L6: Policy moving from forced emigration to murder: the 'Final Solution' as the perpetrators' euphemism
- L6: What victims and bystanders knew, believed and could act on
- L6: Memory and historiography: from survivors' circles to a central place in Western historical consciousness
- L7: The genocide decided and carried out: the murder of all of Europe's Jews within German reach
- L7: What it became: the archetype and benchmark of genocide, and law built on it
way in: Allied and satellite governments
- L1: Antisemitic laws across central and eastern Europe in the 1930s-40s
- L2: Berlin asks allies for their Jews
- L3: Slovakia hands over first (58,000 in 1942)
- L4: Bulgaria declines for its prewar territory, under domestic opposition
way in: Conquest and the course of the war
- L1: Invasion of Poland, 1 September 1939
- L2: Conquest brings millions of Jews under German control
- L3: The invasion of the Soviet Union, 22 June 1941, planned as a war of extermination
- L4: December 1941: the Soviet counteroffensive and war with the United States, read by Hitler through his 1939 'prophecy'
way in: Defeat, depression and the collapse of the Republic
- L1: Defeat in 1918 and the myth of the stab in the back
- L2: The world depression and political fragmentation feed the Nazi vote
- L3: A backroom deal routes Hitler into the chancellorship
- L4: Popular support built on recovery, rearmament and annexations
way in: Definition, registration and marking
- L1: Descent as recorded: three or four Jewish grandparents
- L2: The citizenship cut: only 'German or related blood'
- L3: Locals point out who is Jewish in occupied territory
- L4: Marking: armbands in occupied Poland (1939), the yellow star in Germany (1941)
way in: Epidemic typhus and the fear of it
- L1: Typhus: a bacterium carried by the body louse
- L2: German fear of typhus, remembered from the First World War
- L3: The restricted disease area that became the Warsaw ghetto
- L4: Antisemitic hygiene discourse: Jews cast as bearers of disease
- L5: Occupation physicians in session (October 1941)
way in: Food and the planners' arithmetic
- L1: Planned starvation of the conquered East
- L2: Ghetto rations held near 200 calories a day
- L3: Food goals in the General Government routed into killing plans
- L4: Starvation read as 'more food for Germans'
way in: Inherited antisemitism and racial thought
- L1: Centuries of Christian antisemitism in Europe, then political and racial antisemitism in the 18th-19th centuries
- L2: Local memory of persecution: towns that burned their Jews in the Black Death pogroms of 1348-50 show more anti-Jewish violence in the 1920s
- L3: Schooling, the Hitler Youth, radio, print and film carry the ideology to the young
- L4: Nazi ideology: the integrating doctrine historians most often cite
- L5: Party institutions organise local anti-Jewish violence, 1933-1939
way in: Neighbours, local police and bystanders
- L1: Local pogroms in the summer of 1941
- L2: Local support or its absence decides survival in hiding
- L3: Local police as arresters in the west
- L4: Denunciation, rewarded
way in: News and the outside world
- L1: The regime expects condemnation
- L2: The Bund report on the BBC, 26 June 1942
- L3: The Allied declaration of December 1942
- L4: No photo-intelligence study of the camps; requests to bomb rail lines rejected
way in: Rail transport
- L1: The railway network that deportations ran on
- L2: The Reichsbahn's 'special trains' on a schedule
- L3: Rail shortages postpone or cancel deportations
- L4: Deportation trains a small share of rail traffic
way in: Survivors' bodies and families
- L1: Survivors carry the experience in body and mind
- L2: Parents' 'transmission' of burden, felt by their children
- L3: The stress axis: cortisol differences in offspring
- L4: Third and fourth generations: methylation linked to both stronger bonding and stronger stress reactivity
- L5: Who can speak: the social and psychological position that makes testimony possible
way in: The persecuted: their knowledge, choices and organisations
- L1: Jews in Europe for two millennia; integrated in the west, Yiddish-speaking small towns in the east
- L2: Escapes from deportation trains, most going back to the ghettos
- L3: Resistance in the broad sense: cultural life, documentation, helping others survive
- L4: Ghetto leadership trying to make the ghetto useful as labour
way in: The record: documents, testimony and ground
- L1: Records destroyed: almost nothing written survives for Reinhard
- L2: Survivors testify in courts and commissions
- L3: Oral history corpora gather the testimonies
- L4: Forensic archaeology reads the ground
way out: Armed resistance and uprisings
- L1: More than a hundred armed uprisings
- L5: Fighting organisations form in Warsaw
- L6: Uprisings when death seemed certain
way out: Deportation to extermination camps
- L1: About half of all Jewish victims die by gas
- L3: Freight cars, overcrowded; many die on the way
- L5: The first camp on a local administrator's initiative
- L7: Operation Reinhard: the plan to murder the Jews of the General Government
way out: Exclusion by law
- L1: Jews pushed out of professions and the civil service
- L5: The Nuremberg Laws (September 1935) and their decrees
- L6: About 1,500 anti-Jewish laws from many agencies
way out: Expropriation and plunder
- L1: Millions benefit
- L3: Belongings taken at the Reinhard camps exceed their costs
- L5: A special levy after Kristallnacht
- L6: Businesses expropriated to force Jews out of the economy
way out: Forced emigration
- L1: 250,000 leave by 1939; doors abroad mostly shut
- L5: Emigration taxed
- L7: The aim until 1940: force all Jews out
way out: Forced labour
- L1: Some survive inside the camps
- L5: Selection: those able to work separated from those killed
way out: Ghettoisation and starvation
- L1: Deaths from hunger before the killing began
- L3: The Warsaw wall: 3 m tall, 18 km long
- L5: Closed ghettos in the large cities
way out: Mass shootings in the East
- L1: 1.5 to 2 million Jews and up to 225,000 Roma shot
- L5: Einsatzgruppen reinforced by Order Police battalions
- L7: Orders relayed to kill more, then women and children too
way out: Remembrance, honours and education
- L1: Visitors: about 2 million a year at Auschwitz, under 60,000 at Treblinka
- L3: Memorials at the Reinhard camps only from the 1960s
- L5: Yad Vashem's commission honours rescuers
- L7: 27 January, the day of Auschwitz's liberation
way out: Secrecy and erasing the evidence
- L1: Nothing left standing at Bełżec, Sobibór and Treblinka
- L3: Prisoners marched away so they cannot testify
- L5: Records burnt
way out: Self-help against hunger and epidemic
- L1: More than 100,000 infections prevented
- L4: Sanitary courses, lectures, an underground medical school
- L5: Community kitchens feeding a quarter of the ghetto
way out: Trials, restitution and law
- L1: Much never returned
- L3: Restitution and compensation
- L5: Nuremberg: the murder of the Jews comes to take centre stage
- L7: The Genocide Convention, 1948