← all systems · see it in The System
Geology (the field)
Geology is a branch of natural science concerned with the Earth and other astronomical bodies, the rocks of which they are composed, and the processes by which they change over time.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | 1778-1779 (the word fixed); 1785 (Hutton's Theory of the Earth) |
| born precision | about two centuries, by contention |
| boundary | Inside: the practice of geologists (fieldwork and mapping, rock and mineral description, stratigraphy and fossils, relative and absolute dating, geophysical sounding, laboratory and numerical experiment, remote sensing and planetary missions, the shared record of maps, the time scale and journals, and its applications) together with the solid Earth it studies (rocks, minerals, unlithified deposits, structures, and the processes that make and change them) and other rocky bodies read the same way. Outside: the physics, chemistry and biology it borrows from, the mining, petroleum, engineering and water industries that apply it, and the governments and companies that fund it. |
| nested level | A human practice at rung 11, part of science, carried by geologists and their surveys, laboratories and commissions; its subject, the solid Earth, is rung 5 and its record reaches back to the first Solar System material at 4.567 Ga. |
| scale | social |
Measures (36) published science
| Age of the Earth | 4.54 (formation); 'approximately 4.5 billion years old' Ga |
| First Solar System material | 4.567 Ga |
| Kelvin's age of the Earth (1862) | 20 to 400 million years |
| Kelvin's 1863 calculation: central value and bounds | 96 (bounds 24 and 400) Ma |
| Earth's average surface heat flux | 80 (continents about 60) mW m-2 |
| Ages consistent with the present heat flux in Perry's convecting-interior model (lid 100 or 50 km) | any age up to 2 Ga |
| Holmes's first lead-isotope date (1911) | 1.6 billion years |
| Holmes's age of the Earth (1940s) | 4,500 ± 100 million years |
| Lag from Kelvin's estimate to the 1921 consensus | about 59 (1862 to 1921) years |
| Lag from Wegener's proposal to the 1965 symposium | 53 (1912 to 1965); about 20 from post-war evidence to acceptance years |
| Variability geologists will record against publish (strike, experiment 1) | record threshold c = 20.14; publish threshold c = 10.15 (arrays: record the 4 least variable, up to ~20 degrees SD; publish the 2 least, up to ~10 degrees) degrees of strike scatter |
| Geologists in the variability experiments | 97 in three experiments (45 experts in experiment 1, mean 23.07 years post-bachelor's experience) people |
| Interpretations of one synthetic seismic image | 412; 21% correct tectonic setting; 23% found the three main fault strands interpretations, percent |
| Incorrect interpretations by experience | students 76%; 15+ years 76% percent |
| U-Pb precision on a 206Pb/238U ratio | about 1% (1980); about 0.02% from a single measurement (2021); target from 0.1% toward 0.01% on an age percent |
| Zircon needed for one U-Pb date | 2 mg, thousands of grains (1980); a single grain or fragment of a few micrograms (2021) mass |
| Procedural Pb blank | 200 pg (1980); 100-300 fg (2021) mass |
| Range of the dating clocks | radiocarbon: younger than about 60,000 years; U-Th: a few years to about 700,000 years; U-Pb: older than about 1 million years |
| Erosion rate, drainage basins (10Be) | mean 218; median 54 m per million years |
| Erosion rate, outcrops (10Be) | mean 12; median 5.4 m per million years |
| Published 10Be erosion rates compiled | 1,599 from 87 sites measurements |
| Martian inner core radius | 613 ± 67 km |
| Jack Hills zircon ages | 4.3 to 3.3 Ga |
| SiO2 of the melts the Jack Hills zircons grew from | 59 ± 6 (range 51 to 68) wt% |
| Jack Hills zircon crystallisation temperature | 700 ± 50 degrees C |
| Onset of sustained plate tectonics (Cawood et al.) | 3.2 to 2.5 Ga |
| Oldest oceanic lithosphere | younger than 200 Ma |
| Oldest continental lithosphere | as old as 4 Ga |
| Share of plate driving force from slab pull | some 80 percent |
| Field geology in Apollo crew training | almost 25% of crew training time (many hundreds of hours) percent |
| Anthropocene GSSP candidate sites | 12; Crawford Lake chosen (239Pu at about 15 cm = 1950) sites |
| Majority needed at each step of ratification | 60 percent |
| Humans born before 1950 ('Holocene living fossils' had the proposal passed) | more than 310 million, almost 4% of the population people |
| Oldest preserved geological map | 1150 BCE (Turin papyrus) date |
| Maclure's survey crossings of the Alleghenies | some 50 (1807-1809) crossings |
| Age of maps still relied on for field work | 50-100 years |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-177 When did plate tectonics begin on Earth?
booked: The map leaves the start date open and lists the proposed dates, from the Hadean to about 800 million years ago.
the other reading: Hadean (andesitic Jack Hills melts, Turner et al. 2020); Neoproterozoic (less than 1 Ga) - C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: the positions listed at C-413 - C-1820 When did the human-dominated age of the Earth begin?
booked: The map marks about 1950 as the leading Earth-system candidate and keeps every other proposed start beside it; the formal epoch was rejected in 2024.
the other reading: an Anthropocene event, time-transgressive (Gibbard et al.); a Holocene stage/age; an era, the 'Anthropozoic' - C-2176 Who made the first geological map?
booked: The map keeps the claims side by side.
the other reading: Smith's 1815 map as the first national geological map ('by far the most accurate of its time'); Maclure's 1809 map, which 'antedates William Smith's geological map of England by six years' with a different rock classification - C-2178 When did geology begin as a field?
booked: The map keeps the starts side by side.
the other reading: Theophrastus's On Stones (372-287 BCE); Agricola's De Natura Fossilium (1546), 'seen as the founder of geology as a scientific discipline'; Steno's three principles of stratigraphy (17th century); the word: Aldrovandi 1603, or Escholt's Geologia Norvegica (1657); Lomonosov's On the Strata of Earth (1763), 'the first narrative of modern geology' - C-2196 Did radioactivity really prove Kelvin wrong?
booked: The map books one paper's finding against the popular story, kept as a contention.
the other reading: the popular story: radioactivity both dated the Earth and showed Kelvin wrong by adding internal heat; Kelvin's range read as 20-400 million years (encyclopedia) or as 96 Ma with bounds of 24 and 400 Ma (England et al., from Kelvin 1863)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (12)
- Mineralogy
- Petrology
- Stratigraphy
- Structural geology
- Geochronology
- Geophysics (seismology and survey)
- Planetary geology
- Economic and engineering geology
- Geologists
- Geological maps
- Geologic time scale (deep time)
- Kelvin's physics against the geologists over the Earth's age
Sits inside / holds (5)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Earth sciences
- Stratigraphy
- Geologic time scale (deep time)
Trades with (valence) (20)
- Mineral via sys:mineral · Geology (the field) gain
- Igneous rock via sys:earth-crust · Geology (the field) gain
- Metamorphic rock via sys:earth-crust · Geology (the field) gain
- Anthropocene via sys:earth-crust · Geology (the field) gain
- Cosmic rays via sys:cosmic-rays · Geology (the field) gain
- Earth's crust (primordial, oceanic and continental) via sys:earth-crust · Geology (the field) gain
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite) via sys:planet · Geology (the field) gain
- Earth via sys:earth-crust · Geology (the field) gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Geology (the field) gain
- Radioactive decay via sys:radioactive-decay · Geology (the field) gain
- Chemistry (the field: the practice of chemists and the structure of substances and their reactions it works on) via sys:mental-representation · Geology (the field) gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:human-society · Geology (the field) gain
- Plate tectonics via sys:mental-representation · Geology (the field) gain
- Mars via sys:seismic-wave · Geology (the field) gain
- Fossil via sys:fossil · Geology (the field) gain
- Physics (the field) via sys:mental-representation · Geology (the field) gain
- Great Acceleration via sys:human-society · Geology (the field) mixed
- Biology (the field) via sys:fossil · Geology (the field) gain
- Stratigraphy · Geology (the field) gain
- Geologic time scale (deep time) · Geology (the field) gain
expressed by (27)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Search/Foraging
- Mapping/Modeling
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Multi-Scale Data Fusion / Triangulation
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Hypothesis Portfolio / Multiple Hypothesis Tracking
- Offline Simulation & Replay-Guided Planning
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Proactive Defense
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (29)
- Igneous rock
- Metamorphic rock
- Fossil fuel
- Earth's crust (primordial, oceanic and continental)
- Moon (Earth's natural satellite)
- Earth
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Mineral
- Seismometer
- Rock
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Plate tectonics
- Mass spectrometry
- Stratigraphy
- Geochronology
- Planetary geology
- Economic and engineering geology
- Geologists
- Geological maps
- Geologic time scale (deep time)
- Engineering geology
- Hydrogeology
- international commission on stratigraphy
- uniformitarianism
- drill core
- earthtime consortium
- geological survey
- landsat
- petrographic microscope
represents (1)
Notes published science
- The popular story says radioactivity proved Kelvin wrong about the Earth's age. Three geophysicists showed in 2007 that it did not: put the Earth's radioactive heat into Kelvin's sums and the answer barely changes. The real flaw had been pointed out in 1895, a year before radioactivity was discovered, by Kelvin's former assistant John Perry: a convecting interior keeps the surface warm for billions of years. Perry was ignored, and with him an early argument for moving continents (src:england-2007).
- Shown one synthetic seismic image whose true structure was known, only 21% of 412 geoscientists named the right tectonic setting, and students got it wrong exactly as often as people with 15+ years' experience: 76% each (src:bond-2007).
- Geologists are pickier about what they publish than about what they write down: in one experiment experts would record strike readings with up to about 20 degrees of scatter but publish only up to about 10, even though they read the scattered data accurately. What never gets written down, the authors note, is 'effectively lost' to science (src:wilson-2025).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
geology: the Earth's rocks and processes observed, ordered in time, interpreted and used (reader's view)
- L1: The solid Earth and other rocky bodies: rocks, minerals, unlithified deposits and structures, and the processes that make and change them, from the first Solar System material at 4.567 Ga to now
- L2: Ways in: the geologist in the field (hammer, hand lens, compass), drill cores, geophysical surveys and seismometers, microscopes, microprobes and mass spectrometers, satellites and planetary missions
- L3: Data: strike-dip measurements and notes, samples and thin sections, fossil lists, isotope ratios, seismic images, 10Be concentrations; what is recorded becomes data and the rest is lost
- L4: Order in space and time: the geological map (units, contacts, faults, folds) and the relative ages (superposition, cross-cutting, faunal succession) and absolute ages placed on it
- L5: Interpretation: framework models built by applying concepts (uniformitarianism, the tectonic settings of plate tectonics) to limited data, through the interpreter's prior knowledge
- L6: The shared record and its standards: published maps and papers, the geological time scale and its chart fixed by golden spikes and commission votes, shared tracers and reference materials
- L7: Earth history told and put to use: the age and story of the Earth, minerals and hydrocarbons found, water located, hazards warned of, ground engineered, past climate read, other worlds explored
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Ordering in space and time: the geological map with its units, contacts and structures, the stratigraphic column, and absolute ages placed on them
- L5: Interpretation: framework models built by applying concepts (uniformitarianism, plate tectonics and its tectonic settings) to the ordered data; rival concepts held side by side
- L6: The shared record and its standards: published maps and papers, the geological time scale (the chart, golden spikes, commission votes), shared tracers and reference materials
- L7: Earth history told and put to use: the Earth's age and story, resources, water, hazards, engineering, past climate, other worlds
way in: Cosmic rays: 10Be built up in surface rock
- L1: Cosmic rays making exotic nuclides in surface rock
- L2: In situ 10Be measured in outcrops and river sediment since the mid-1980s
- L3: 1,599 published erosion rates compiled and normalised
- L4: Erosion rates: basins faster than bare outcrops
way in: Emotion: deep time felt
- L1: An unconformity seen at Siccar Point: the abyss of time
way in: Field: outcrops walked, measured and mapped
- L1: Solid Earth materials at the outcrop: rock units, contacts, beds, faults and folds
- L2: The geologist's eye and hands, with a hand compass for planes (strike and dip) and lines (trend and plunge)
- L3: Measurements and notes, kept or let go by the geologist's own tolerance for variability (record above about 20 degrees of scatter rarely, publish above about 10 degrees rarely)
- L4: The geological map: observations synthesised into units, contacts and structure symbols
way in: Hand tests: minerals scratched, broken, tried with a magnet and tasted (touch and taste)
- L1: Minerals: elements and compounds with a definite composition and ordered atomic arrangement
- L2: Touch and taste: hardness by scratching, breakage, a magnet, the tongue (halite tastes of salt)
- L3: Properties noted one test at a time: colour, hardness, breakage, magnetism, taste
- L4: Identification: the mineral named
way in: Isotope clocks: radioactive decay read in zircon and other minerals
- L1: Parent and daughter isotopes locked in a mineral once it cools through its closure temperature
- L2: Chemical abrasion and isotope dilution thermal ionization mass spectrometry (ID-TIMS), with a shared tracer
- L3: Isotope ratios to about 0.02% from a single grain
- L4: An absolute age, applied to the relative order
way in: Microscope and microprobe: light and electrons through rock
- L1: Minerals in thin section, each with its own optical behaviour
- L2: The petrographic microscope and the electron microprobe
- L3: Compositions spot by spot within single crystals
- L4: Pressures and temperatures of formation, by experiment and fluid inclusions
way in: Other bodies: field crews, landers and seismometers on the Moon and Mars
- L1: Other rocky bodies, without plate tectonics or water erosion to wipe their record
- L2: Astronauts trained as field geologists; InSight's seismometer on Mars
- L3: Samples with their context; core-transiting seismic phases (PKKP, PKiKP)
- L4: Geologic context from mapping; Mars's inner core about 613 km in radius
way in: Satellites: the surface seen from orbit
- L1: The Earth's surface and the structures that reach it
- L2: Satellites in orbit taking wide-scope images (Landsat, NASA and USGS, from 1972)
- L3: Satellite images supplied for geological analysis
- L4: Units mapped and rock types correlated over whole regions; plate motions tracked
way in: Seismic waves: the subsurface and the deep interior sounded
- L1: Seismic waves crossing the Earth, timed on arrival
- L2: Boreholes and seismic surveys, each sampling a limited volume
- L3: Seismic images and arrival-time data, limited in space and resolution
- L4: A layered Earth: a liquid outer core and a solid inner core; faults and horizons in the subsurface
way in: Strata and fossils: layers read in order, fossils matched from place to place
- L1: Sedimentary layers stacked in order, with their fossils
- L2: Measured sections and drill cores brought to the laboratory
- L3: Fossil content logged bed by bed
- L4: Relative age by faunal succession: each formation placed in the stratigraphic column
way in: The written record: maps, papers and books of other geologists
- L1: Maps and papers in the record, some 50-100 years old and still used
- L2: Read in the field and the library (Darwin read Lyell aboard the Beagle)
- L3: Other scientists' data met indirectly, in papers and talks
- L4: What arrives is the data without much of its variability
way in: Thought: concepts and prior knowledge brought to the data
- L1: Training, experience and a limited set of geological concepts
- L4: Heuristics and rules of thumb from experience, the source of cognitive bias
way out: Engineering: ground for tunnels, bridges and buildings
- L1: Ground cut and loaded
- L2: Tunnels that stand, sturdy foundations
- L7: Geological factors addressed in engineering works
way out: Hazards: building codes and warning systems
- L1: Settlements built and warned accordingly
- L2: Codes and warnings
- L7: Prevent loss of property and life
way out: Missions: crews and instruments sent to other worlds
- L1: Samples taken from the lunar surface
- L2: Crews trained in the field, almost 25% of Apollo training time
- L7: Field geology training before new planetary targets
way out: Publishing: maps, papers and the time scale
- L1: The record read by later geologists
- L2: Maps coloured by unit, strike-dip symbols placed; data chosen for publication
- L6: National maps of whole countries
way out: Resources: ores and hydrocarbons found and extracted
- L1: The crust with ore and hydrocarbons taken out
- L2: Mines and wells
- L5: Basins read for their history and the present position of their rock units
- L7: Locate and manage the Earth's resources
way out: Water: groundwater found and watched
- L1: Groundwater drawn
- L2: Wells
- L7: Locate groundwater and watch contaminants
Who fills each layer
Sources (22) published science
History of geology (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Stratigraphy (encyclopedia) (behind its links)
Geologic time scale (Wikipedia; Hadean rows, divisions and GTS2012 proposal sections) (behind its links)
Geochronology (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Portenga E.W. & Bierman P.R. 2011, Understanding Earth's eroding surface with 10Be, GSA Today 21(8):4-10, doi:10.1130/G111A.1 (behind its links)
Bi, Sun et al. 2025, Seismic detection of a 600-km solid inner core in Mars, Nature (doi:10.1038/s41586-025-09361-9; PMC12408336, CC BY) (behind its links)
Cawood, Hawkesworth, Pisarevsky et al. 2018, Geological archive of the onset of plate tectonics, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A doi:10.1098/rsta.2017.0405 (behind its links)
Hodges & Schmitt 2019, Imagining a new era of planetary field geology, Science Advances 5, eaaz2484 (doi:10.1126/sciadv.aaz2484; PMC6739106, CC BY-NC) (behind its links)
Rull 2024. The 'Anthropocene': alea iacta est. EMBO Reports 25:939-943 (doi:10.1038/s44319-024-00065-1) (behind its links)
Geologic map (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Geologist (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Uniformitarianism (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Igneous rock (encyclopedia, WME cache enwiki-Igneous_rock.md) (behind its links)
Metamorphic rock (encyclopedia, WME cache enwiki-Metamorphic_rock.md) (behind its links)