← all systems · see it in The System
Pollution
The introduction of contaminants (any substance, or energy such as heat, sound, light or radioactivity) into the natural environment that cause harm; in the modern sense mainly unwanted waste of human origin released to air, land, water and the ocean, sorted by kind (air, water, soil, plastic, noise, light and others), by source (point or nonpoint), by effect on health and ecosystems, and by the regulation that answers it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | by about 1100 BCE (Greenland ice lead rising with Phoenician expansion; earliest human pollution in the sources read) |
| born precision | the record starts at 1100 BCE; earlier pollution not in the sources read |
| boundary | Inside: contaminants of human (and some natural) origin from their release into air, water, soil, the ocean, the night sky and the soundscape, through their transport and transformation, to the doses that reach people and ecosystems and the harm they do, and the monitoring and regulation that answer them, as environmental science describes them. Outside: the media themselves (atmosphere, hydrosphere, soil, ocean), the receivers (people, fish, ecosystems) and the societies whose production makes the releases; climate change is a neighbour counted apart in most of the sources read (C: C-2378). |
| nested level | Runs on the human enterprise's waste streams (economy, cities, agriculture, the chemical industry) and lands in the natural environment and in bodies; one of the triad "pollution, climate change and biodiversity loss" (Fuller 2022); its rise is part of the Great Acceleration and its residues are Anthropocene markers. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (51) published science
| deaths attributable to pollution, 2019 | 9.0 (8.12-10.0) million deaths |
| deaths from air pollution, 2019 | 6.67 million deaths |
| deaths from water pollution, 2019 | 1.36 million deaths |
| deaths from lead, 2019 | 0.90 million deaths |
| deaths from toxic occupational hazards, 2019 | 0.87 million deaths |
| deaths from modern pollution, 2019 | 5.84 million deaths |
| deaths from traditional pollution, 2019 | 3.66 million deaths |
| rise in deaths from modern pollution since 2000 | over 66 % |
| share of pollution deaths in LMICs (2015) | 92 % |
| welfare losses from pollution, 2015 | 4.6 (6.2% of global output) trillion US$ |
| lead-related IQ losses, global economic cost | almost 1 trillion US$ a year |
| WHO PM2.5 guideline | 10 to 5 micrograms per cubic metre |
| PM2.5 deaths 2015 (GEMM) | 8.9 (7.5-10.3) million deaths |
| PM2.5 deaths 2015 (GBD risk function, as given by Burnett 2018) | 4.0 (3.3-4.8) million deaths |
| cohorts pooled in the GEMM | 41 cohorts in 16 countries |
| air-pollution share of cardiovascular and stroke deaths | 19 and 21 % |
| chemicals and mixtures on the global market | about 350,000 count |
| growth of chemical production since 1950 | 50-fold ratio |
| chemical substances registered under EU REACH (Dec 2020) | about 23,000 count |
| plastic production, 2015 | 380 (from 2 in 1950) Mt a year |
| characteristic clock: plastic production growth 1950-2015 | CAGR 8.4% (about 2.5 times GDP growth) % a year |
| virgin plastics produced to 2015 | 8300 Mt |
| fate of plastic waste to 2015 | 6300 Mt: 9% recycled, 12% incinerated, 79% accumulated Mt and % |
| plastic recycled more than once | 10% of the 9% recycled |
| end-to-end yield of a second recycling pass (derived) | about 0.9% of plastic waste (9% x 10%) |
| plastic waste in landfills or the environment by 2050 (projection) | about 12,000 Mt |
| plastic particles in human blood (22 donors) | mean 1.6 micrograms per millilitre |
| share of people under light-polluted skies | more than 80% (more than 99% of US and Europe) |
| people who cannot see the Milky Way | more than one-third of humanity (60% of Europeans, nearly 80% of North Americans) |
| land area with light-polluted nights (75N-60S) | 23 % |
| natural night sky background (moonless, clear) | 22 mag/arcsec2 = 1.7e-4 cd/m2 |
| growth of light pollution 1992-2017 | at least 49 % |
| lowest noise peak arousing sleepers | 33 dB LAmax |
| healthy life-years lost to environmental noise (western Europe) | at least 1 million a year DALYs |
| noise level where terrestrial wildlife responses begin | about 40 dBA |
| fall in European SO2 emissions since the peak | 80% or more |
| fall in European ammonia emissions | 20-30 % |
| parties to the Air Convention | 51 parties |
| characteristic clock: atmospheric residence time of Hg(0) | several months to a year time |
| characteristic clock: residence of reactive and particulate mercury | hours to days time |
| settling time: transfer of mercury to largely unavailable reservoirs | centuries time |
| rise in mercury deposition since about 1850 | about 3 factor |
| rise in soil mercury pools | about 20 % |
| human over geogenic mercury emissions | 2-15 factor |
| people poisoned at Minamata | more than 2000 people |
| excess deaths, London smog 1952-53 | about 12,000 deaths |
| London smog pollution over current standards | 5-19 times |
| column ozone destroyed in the world avoided | 17% by 2020, 67% by 2065 % of 1980 |
| ODS production growth assumed in the world avoided | 3 % a year |
| Greenland ice lead record | 1100 BCE to 800 CE years |
| deaths caused by pollution (encyclopedia, 2019) | about nine million, about one in six deaths |
Open contentions (4) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1199 Have human-made chemicals pushed Earth past a safe planetary limit?
booked: The map lists the views without ruling, including that the limit is exceeded because chemicals are made faster than they can be assessed.
the other reading: as registered in research/CONTENTIONS.md - C-2348 How many people did London's 1952 smog kill?
booked: The map keeps the estimate and the rejected alternative.
the other reading: claims (reported and rejected by Bell & Davis) that the smog raised risks only during and just after the 5-9 December peak, with later excess deaths from an influenza epidemic - C-2373 How many deaths does fine-particle pollution cause?
booked: The map keeps both estimates.
the other reading: GBD integrated exposure-response function: 4.0 million (2015, as given by Burnett 2018); GEMM NCD+LRI from 41 cohorts: 8.9 million, 120% larger - C-2378 What counts as pollution?
booked: The map keeps the competing scopes.
the other reading: any contaminant including natural sources (volcanoes, wildfires) (encyclopedia: natural events can cause it); harm not required: "presence of substances and heat ... whose nature, location, or quantity produces undesirable environmental effects" (UN, as quoted); greenhouse gases are a form of pollution (fossil fuel section of the encyclopedia: "greenhouse gases are considered per se as a form of pollution"); noise not counted in some definitions
Cross-scale patterns seen here (22) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Pollution. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- conservation law plus closure (structural)
Plastic mass flows (production equals what is in use plus what is discarded, recycled or burned) predict waste only once product lifetime distributions for eight sectors close the balance (Geyer 2017). Mercury budgets likewise need residence times per reservoir. - same role, different builds (structural)
The job "cut acid emissions from power plants" done two ways: Europe by critical loads and integrated assessment models, the United States by an emissions trading programme under the Clean Air Act. Also: particles taken out of a gas stream by baghouses, cyclones, electrostatic precipitators or scrub - The carry (structural)
All three faces. Overflow passed on: tall stacks handed a local excess of sulphur dioxide to the next country downwind. The wait: mercury takes centuries to reach unavailable reservoirs, and soil and ocean pools are "not at steady-state with respect to current emissions"; chemicals: production outru - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
Pollution is the toll itself, in three forms. Material: of 6300 Mt of plastic waste only 9% was recycled and only 10% of that more than once, so a second pass keeps about 0.9% (derived); "Recycling delays, rather than avoids, final disposal"; 79% accumulated. Thermal: waste heat in cooling water war - trade one property for another (structural)
Tall stacks bought clean local air and paid with acid rain abroad. Economists set a socially optimal level of pollution where the marginal benefit of the good equals the marginal damage, each market settling at its own point; policy for climate and air quality risks "win-lose" trade-offs unless opti - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
The same noise and night light land differently by receiver: "Taxonomic groups vary in auditory capabilities"; terrestrial wildlife respond from about 40 dBA while sleeping people arouse at 33 dB peaks; for light, a "pristine" sky is set at 1% above natural, the Milky Way is lost from 688 microcande - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
In the partner: the ozone layer screens ultraviolet; the world-avoided model shows the without-it case (erythemal UV more than doubled by 2060, polar losses year-round, tropical collapse). Pollution acts on the barrier rather than being one, so partial. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Dispersal by the air was first relied on (tall stacks: the surroundings dilute and carry the sulphur away); later the job was held at the source by controls and protocols, with emissions down 80% or more. Both phases in one source; the held phase is regulation by people, so partial. - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
The Air Convention coordinated parties from 1979; critical-load maps were asked for only in 1988 and the integrated-assessment model fixed the 1994 protocol: coordination came first, the map of what each place can bear later. - lightning (partial)
Firings that changed what followed: Oden's 1967 newspaper article ("An Insidious Chemical Warfare Among the Nations of Europe"), after which acid rain became a top story and the 1979 convention followed; the London smog of 1952 (about 12,000 excess deaths). Accidents at nuclear plants or tankers can - not-diluting wins (partial)
Persistent pollutants hold on while degradable ones disperse and decay: legacy pollution long after the source stops; none of the common plastics biodegrade, so plastic made since 1950 still exists in one form or another; biomagnification concentrates toxins up trophic levels instead of thinning the - runaway from an unstable balance (partial)
The same world-avoided collapse: "The tropical cooling that triggers the ozone collapse is caused by an increase of the tropical upwelling" - a balance held until a trigger, then a run to near zero. The balance point is named only as a trigger, so partial. - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
One process, relief of nutrient limitation (growth limited by the scarce nutrient, phosphorus in fresh water), is wanted on the field and harmful in the lake: fertilizer that helps crops grow, carried by rain to water, drives blooms and oxygen loss. Same mechanism, sign of its value reversed between - smooth to sharp in finite time (partial)
In the world-avoided model, tropical lower-stratosphere ozone "remain[s] constant until about 2053 and then collapse[s] to near zero by 2058" through heterogeneous chemistry: a smooth run then a collapse in five years. A collapse to zero, not a singular value, and a model, so partial. - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Pollution is measured against a natural background set by the larger system: light pollution against the natural night sky (pristine = within 1% of it), mercury against preindustrial deposition, critical loads per place inside one convention-wide frame. Partial: the reference is set from outside the - who opens the door (partial)
The crossings into receivers show three doors: open field (particles enter whatever airway breathes them; plastic has no receiver that breaks it down), the receiver's own chemistry (reducing bacteria methylate mercury), and a port built ahead of time (the cochlea's hair cells take noise in; the eye' - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (surface)
The novel-entities boundary is "a placeholder for multiple different boundaries for NEs that may emerge" (PFAS named one); a critic adds that screening may show a chemical "requiring the definition of a new planetary boundary". Slots expected, but their properties not predicted by the structure: sur - nested ladder (surface)
Falchi's sky-brightness classes run from up to 1% above natural, to Milky Way lost, to cone stimulation with no dark adaptation: each class implies the ones below in brightness. Ordered by size (the dark twin) more than by implication, so surface. - outside-to-inside (surface)
The environment's contaminants become the body's: plastic particles in blood, lead in blood, methylmercury in the fetus. The outside phase comes first, but what moves in is a contaminant, not a gradient the body comes to hold: surface. - same toolkit, independent builds (surface)
Europe and North America built acid-rain policy from the same parts (monitoring, field experiments, deposition models; Hubbard Brook, Solling, Lake Gardsjon) into different instruments, both cutting sulphur. - seed (surface)
Synthetic organic chemistry opened about 350,000 chemicals and mixtures, a combinatorial burst whose releases are the novel entities. The seed belongs to the chemical industry, not to pollution, so surface here. - templating (surface)
The Air Convention's frame-plus-protocols module reused unchanged for sulphur, nitrogen, VOCs, POPs and heavy metals (Table 1 of Grennfelt 2020).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (23) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Ozone layer (ozone shield) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Pollution gain
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Pollution gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:sensory-environment · Pollution gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Pollution loss
- Law (rules and law) via sys:human-society · Pollution loss
- Industrial Revolution (the first, c. 1760 to c. 1840) via sys:human-society · Pollution gain
- Ocean via sys:hydrosphere · Pollution gain
- Habitat and ecosystem via sys:biosphere · Pollution gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:sensory-environment · Pollution gain
- Light (visible light) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Pollution gain
- Farming (agriculture) via sys:earth · Pollution gain
- Respiratory system via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Pollution gain
- Economy via sys:human-society · Pollution gain
- Anthropocene via sys:earth · Pollution even
- Biodiversity via sys:biosphere · Pollution gain
- Climate change via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Pollution mixed
- Fish via sys:hydrosphere · Pollution gain
- Great Acceleration via sys:human-society · Pollution gain
- Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies) via sys:natural-environment · Pollution loss
- Natural environment via sys:natural-environment · Pollution gain
- Air pollution via sys:natural-environment · Pollution even
- Materials science (the field) via sys:natural-environment · Pollution loss
- Tax via sys:natural-environment · Pollution loss
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (9)
- Lead (Pb, Z = 82)
- Light pollution (artificial light at night)
- Naval sonar and ship noise
- Air pollution
- Water pollution
- Soil contamination
- Chemical pollution (novel entities)
- Plastic pollution
- Mercury and methylmercury
Sits inside / holds (5)
expressed by (20)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Templating / Standardization
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Mapping/Modeling
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Surprise / Change-Point Detection
- Ranged Attack
- Neutralize Defenses
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Prepositioning & Latency
- Leverage Host/Amplification
- Cascade Induction
- Proactive Defense
- Self-Monitoring
- Delay/Redirection Tactics
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (27)
- Hydrosphere (Earth's planetary water, above all the early ocean)
- Ozone layer (ozone shield)
- Atmosphere of Earth
- Soil and leaf litter
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Government
- Volcano
- Sulfate-reducing microorganisms
- Ocean
- River
- Habitat and ecosystem
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Montreal Protocol
- Wildfire
- City
- Food web
- Farming (agriculture)
- Respiratory system
- Economy
- Chemical industry
- Economics (the field)
- Environmental science (the field: the practice and the environment it studies)
- Natural environment
- LRTAP Convention
- Environmental justice movement
- UN Environment Programme
- Global Burden of Disease study
Kinds (16)
- Light pollution (artificial light at night)
- Driver of biodiversity loss
- Naval sonar and ship noise
- Air pollution
- Water pollution
- Soil contamination
- Chemical pollution (novel entities)
- Plastic pollution
- Radioactive contamination
- Thermal pollution
- Visual pollution
- Litter
- Electromagnetic (radio-frequency) pollution
- Nutrient pollution
- Point-source pollution
- Nonpoint-source pollution
Notes published science
- Greenland ice holds a year-by-year record of Roman-era lead pollution: European lead emissions rose with Phoenician and Roman mining, swung with wars, and crashed with the Antonine plague in the second century, then stayed low for more than 500 years (src:mcconnell-2018).
- Light pollution hides the Milky Way from more than a third of humanity, including 60% of Europeans and nearly 80% of North Americans; in Singapore the night is so bright that the eye cannot fully switch to night vision (src:falchi-2016).
- In 1973 scientists split a Canadian lake in two with a plastic curtain and fed both halves nitrogen and carbon, but phosphorus to only one: only that half bloomed, and it settled what makes lakes go green (src:wp:eutrophication).
- Cleaning the air warms the planet: pollution particles hide some of the warming, and removing those from fossil fuels would add about 0.51 C (0.73 C for all pollution particles), up to about 2 C over North America and Northeast Asia, while saving 3.6 million lives a year (src:lelieveld-2019).
- The same soot can thicken or thin a haze: black carbon heating the top of the city's air layer keeps it shallow and traps pollution (the dome), but heating just above it stirs up a circulation that lowers ground-level PM2.5 by about 7.4% in a winter-haze model (src:wu-2025).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
pollution as environmental science describes it (reader's view: the environmental media, sources and releases, transport and transformation, exposure and uptake, effects on health and ecosystems, monitoring and meaning, regulation and control back on the sources)
- L1: The environmental media the releases enter: air, water, land, the ocean, the night sky and the soundscape
- L2: Sources and releases: point and nonpoint; industry, transport, agriculture, waste; natural sources such as volcanoes and wildfires
- L3: Transport and transformation: dispersal and long-range transport, secondary pollutants (smog, acids, methylmercury), persistence and accumulation
- L4: Exposure and uptake: what is breathed, drunk, eaten and heard; doses in blood and tissue; biomagnification up food webs
- L5: Effects: disease and premature death (about 9 million a year), and damage to ecosystems (acidified lakes, dead zones, wildlife)
- L6: Monitoring and meaning: science, monitoring, burden estimates, critical loads and boundaries; pollution read as an externality and an injustice
- L7: Regulation and control back on the sources: conventions, laws, guidelines, bans, prevention and clean-up
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L5: The burden: disease, death and damage summed across kinds; about 9 million deaths in 2019 (one in six), and ecosystems pushed away from Holocene-like conditions
- L6: Knowing and meaning: monitoring networks, burden-of-disease estimates, critical loads, planetary boundaries, atlases; and the ideas of externality and environmental justice
- L7: Response: conventions, laws, guidelines and bans that act back on the sources (the Air Convention 1979, the ozone agreements, lead out of fuel, WHO guidelines)
way in: Acid and nitrogen deposition (acid rain)
- L1: The air across borders: acid rain is transboundary
- L2: Sources: large and increasing sulphur dioxide emissions in Europe; brown coal with high sulphur content
- L3: Transformation and fall: sulphur dioxide and nitrogen oxides deposited as acids
- L4: Received: the pH of rainwater, surface waters and soils, read against each place's critical load
way in: Air pollutants (particles, ozone, oxides of sulphur and nitrogen)
- L1: The air: fine particulate matter (PM2.5), ozone, oxides of sulphur and nitrogen
- L2: Sources: motor vehicles; power plants, refineries, chemical plants and heavy industry; household solid fuels
- L3: Transformation: nitrogen oxides and hydrocarbons react in sunlight to photochemical ozone and smog
- L4: Exposure and uptake: inhaled into lung and airways, then most other organ systems
way in: Artificial light at night
- L1: The natural night: Moon, airglow, stars, Milky Way, zodiacal light
- L2: Sources: building, advertising, car-park, office, factory, street and sports lighting
- L3: Scattering: artificial light scattered in the atmosphere, skyglow seen hundreds of kilometres away
- L4: Received: sky luminance at the eye; past a level the eye cannot dark-adapt
way in: Lead
- L1: Lead in products and the environment: lead paint, aviation fuel, gasoline in some countries
- L2: Sources: ancient lead-silver mining and smelting; today battery and e-waste recycling without controls
- L3: Transport: midlatitude emissions carried through the air to Arctic ice
- L4: Dose: blood lead; toxicity down to low concentrations, perhaps no threshold
way in: Mercury and methylmercury
- L1: The atmosphere: elemental mercury stays months to a year, long enough to go global
- L2: Sources: human emissions greatly exceed natural ones
- L3: Transformation: deposited, re-emitted, and methylated by sulphate- and iron-reducing bacteria
- L4: Dose: methylmercury biomagnified up food webs and eaten in fish
way in: Noise
- L1: Sound: noise is unwanted sound
- L2: Sources: roads, aircraft, industry, sonar; growing with populations, transport and extraction
- L3: Propagation: each source with its own level, spectrum and time course
- L4: Received: cochlear hair cells (no regeneration in mammals) and arousal during sleep
way in: Nutrients (nitrogen and phosphorus): eutrophication
- L1: A body of water in which nutrients accumulate
- L2: Sources: sewage, industrial wastewater, fertilizer runoff
- L3: Transformation: algal blooms and bacterial growth deplete dissolved oxygen
- L4: Received: the limiting nutrient (phosphorus in most fresh waters, nitrogen in the sea)
way in: Ozone-depleting substances (CFCs)
- L1: Stratospheric ozone, depleted by CFCs (proposed 1974)
- L2: Sources: CFCs among the gases produced by industry
- L3: Transformation: ozone loss by CFCs and other ODSs, established in lab, field and model
- L4: Received: more ultraviolet at the surface (erythemal UV more than doubled by 2060 in the world avoided)
way in: Plastic
- L1: The environment where plastic waste now is, so widespread it is proposed as an Anthropocene indicator
- L2: Production: 2 Mt in 1950 to 380 Mt in 2015; packaging its largest market
- L3: Fate: 9% recycled, 12% incinerated, 79% accumulated; none of the common plastics biodegrade
- L4: Dose: particles of 700 nm and up found in human blood
way in: Synthetic chemicals (novel entities)
- L1: Entities not previously known to the Earth system, and elements mobilised by people
- L2: Production: about 350,000 chemicals and mixtures, output up 50-fold since 1950
- L3: Fate: persistence and mobility across scales, wide distribution
- L4: Dose: accumulation in organisms; pesticides, flame-retardants, plasticisers and dioxins linked to reproductive problems
way in: Water contaminants (sewage, industrial wastewater, runoff)
- L1: Surface waters receiving discharges
- L2: Sources: untreated sewage and chemical contaminants
- L3: Transport: surface runoff to surface waters (urban and agricultural)
- L4: Exposure: drinking water contaminated by untreated sewage
way out: Clean-up and remediation
- L1: The medium: floating waste caught in a river
- L7: Decision: remediation devices and practices (bioremediation, phytoremediation, litter traps)
way out: Control at the source: emission and effluent controls, treatment
- L1: The media: European SO2 down 80% or more since the peak
- L2: At the sources: control of emissions and effluents (scrubbers, precipitators, sewage treatment)
- L7: Decision: the Air Convention (1979) and its protocols
way out: Dispersal: tall stacks that move the pollution on
- L1: Distant media: Scandinavian surface waters acidified
- L3: Transport: emissions carried across borders
- L7: Decision: sulphur dioxide judged a local problem to be solved by tall stacks
way out: Phase-outs and bans of a substance
- L1: The media: the ozone layer spared the world-avoided losses
- L2: At the sources: lead removed from automotive fuel everywhere by 2021; phosphate detergents phased out in the 1970s
- L7: Decision: international agreements on ozone-depleting substances; national decisions on leaded fuel
way out: Prevention and waste minimisation
- L2: At the sources: reduce production and releases (proposed for novel entities)
- L7: Decision: prevention ranked above control
way out: Standards and guidelines for exposure
- L4: Exposure target: PM2.5 guideline from 10 to 5 micrograms per cubic metre
- L7: Decision: WHO tightens its global air quality guidelines
Who fills each layer
- L1: Air pollution
- L7: Air pollution