← all systems · see it in The System
Quantum spin chain
A line of localized quantum spins, each coupled mostly to its neighbours along one direction: 'a linear array of interacting magnetic moments' (Mourigal et al.). As a model, 'a type of model in statistical physics' whose prototype is the quantum Heisenberg model; as a thing, a chain of magnetic ions in a mineral or compound, a chain of molecules built on a surface, or a row of atoms or ions programmed as qubits. Walked here as the physical system (the chain, its ground state, excitations and phases) together with what people do with it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Quantum spin chain (large-spin antiferromagnetic chains) |
| born at | natural chains: whenever copper minerals such as azurite formed in oxidized ore zones (no date in the sources read); the model: 1928 (Heisenberg); built chains: 2017 (51 Rydberg atoms), 2021 (triangulene) |
| born precision | unknown (natural); the year (models and built chains) |
| boundary | Inside: the line of localized spins (one per site), the exchange that couples neighbours, and what they do together: the collective ground state, its entanglement, its excitations (spinons, magnons, kinks, edge spins), transport along the line, and its phases. Outside: the host crystal or array (lattice, phonons, neighbouring chains), applied fields and lasers, the heat bath, the probes (neutrons, tips, light), and the people who build, measure, model and use it. |
| nested level | built from spins carried by unpaired electrons on ions (Cu2+ spin 1/2, Ni2+ spin 1), on molecules (triangulene spin 1) or on atoms' internal levels; part of a host crystal or mineral, or of a built array; a kind of magnetized matter whose chains, coupled to neighbours, order as a 3D magnet; described by condensed matter physics; its models run on physics. |
| scale | atomic |
Measures (35) published science
| nearest-neighbour exchange Ja between Cu1 spins in CuSO4.5D2O | 0.252(17) meV |
| spinon bandwidth (maximum onset energy) in CuSO4.5D2O | 0.402(2), against the predicted (pi/2)Ja = 0.406(7) meV |
| share of spectral weight carried by two-spinon states (theory) | 71 % of the first frequency moment sum rule |
| share with two- and four-spinon states (theory) | 98(1) % |
| measured spectral weight, all spinon states, CuSO4.5D2O | 99(8) % of the prediction |
| sample temperature, CuSO4.5D2O neutron experiment | about 100 mK |
| KCuF3 exchange along the chain Jc | 33.5 meV |
| KCuF3 interchain exchange Ja,b | -1.6 meV |
| KCuF3 3D ordering temperature TN | 39 K |
| KCuF3 total magnetic bandwidth | 105 meV |
| dynamical exponent of spin transport in KCuF3 (75-300 K) | z = 3/2 (z = 2 diffusion, z = 1 ballistic) dimensionless |
| CoNb2O6 critical transverse field | 5.5 T |
| CoNb2O6 3D ordering temperature TN1 | 2.95 K |
| ratio of the two lowest modes near the critical field, CoNb2O6 | approaches (1+sqrt5)/2 = 1.618 dimensionless |
| triangulene chain exchange J (bilinear-biquadratic fit) | 18 (beta = 0.09) meV |
| edge-excitation energy against chain length, triangulene chains | A exp(-N/zeta), A = 19 meV, zeta = 4 units |
| measurement temperature of the triangulene chains (STM) | 4.5 K |
| chain length over which a qubit is sent with better than classical fidelity (2/3), unmodulated Heisenberg chain | up to 80 spins |
| wait for best transfer (receiver's pick-up time t0), within a window of 4000/J | varies with N; the window is 0 to 4000/J 1/J |
| Rydberg array size | 51 qubits |
| Rydberg atom spacing for Z2 order | 5.74 micrometres |
| Rydberg nearest-neighbour interaction | 2 pi x 24 MHz |
| Rydberg blockade radius (70S1/2, Omega = 2 pi x 2 MHz) | 9 micrometres |
| typical Rydberg sequence duration (atom loss below 1%) | about 1 microsecond |
| photons scattered per microsecond across the whole array during the laser pulse | 1.1 photons per microsecond |
| state detection fidelity (Rydberg / ground) | 93 / about 98 % |
| probability the Z2 target state is reached | 54(4) (77(6) corrected for detection) % |
| spinon mean free path in pure SrCuO2 | more than 1 micrometre |
| linarite ordering temperature TN | 2.8 K |
| azurite ordering temperature | below 1.9 K |
| NINAZ exchange J | about 125 K |
| O(3) sigma-model coupling for large-S chains | 2/S dimensionless |
| block entanglement entropy at criticality | S_L ~ ((c + c-bar)/6) log2 L + k; c = c-bar = 1/2 for the critical Ising chain, 1 for the other critical chains studied (free bosons) bits |
| first exact solution of the spin-1/2 Heisenberg chain | 1931 (Bethe) year |
| time from Haldane's preprint (1981) to its publication in another form (1983) | 2 years |
Open contentions (3) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-1784 Is the mineral azurite really a one-dimensional magnetic chain?
booked: The map books it as a chain needing extra couplings to explain it, and keeps the two-dimensional reading.
the other reading: a two-dimensional character of its magnetism (arXiv:0903.4595, title only); no consensus on the exchange magnitudes - C-1797 Why does spin in a magnetic chain spread like a growing surface?
booked: The map books the measured match, and leaves its cause open.
the other reading: its 'exact microscopic origin is still under active research'; z = 3/2 is 'consistent with' a conjecture, not derived - C-1798 Can information in a chain of ions spread faster than the usual speed limit?
booked: The map books the usual limit for short-range chains, and the faster, partly unexplained spread in long-range ones.
the other reading: long-range ion chains: propagation velocities that increase and violate the Lieb-Robinson prediction, 'in one instance' unexplained by any existing theory (Richerme et al.)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Electron
- Nickel atom
- Exchange interaction
- Copper (Cu, Z = 29)
- Spin (intrinsic angular momentum)
- One-dimensional quantum liquid vs 3D order
Sits inside / holds (4)
Trades with (valence) (14)
- Electron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain gain
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain mixed
- Neutron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain mixed
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · Quantum spin chain mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain even
- Phonon via sys:thermal-energy · Quantum spin chain loss
- Mineral via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain gain
- Quantum mechanics via sys:matter · Quantum spin chain even
- Quantum entanglement via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain gain
- Crystal via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain gain
- Magnetism via sys:electromagnetic-field · Quantum spin chain even
- Quantum computer via sys:exchange-interaction · Quantum spin chain even
- Physics (the field) via sys:sensory-environment · Quantum spin chain gain
- Condensed matter physics via sys:matter · Quantum spin chain even
expressed by (4)
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
floor filled by (18)
- Electron
- Nickel atom
- Magnon
- Quasiparticle
- Mineral
- Exchange interaction
- Copper (Cu, Z = 29)
- Spin (intrinsic angular momentum)
- Conformal field theory
- Quantum entanglement
- Crystal
- Quantum computer
- Physics (the field)
- Spinon
- Symmetry-protected topological phase
- Neutron scattering (the practice)
- Rydberg-atom array (programmable spin chain)
- O(3) nonlinear sigma model
represents (1)
Kinds (11)
- Haldane chain (integer-spin antiferromagnetic chain)
- Spin-1/2 Heisenberg antiferromagnetic chain
- Ising chain in a transverse field
- Distorted diamond chain
- Frustrated J1-J2 chain
- Spin-Peierls chain
- Single-chain magnet
- Rydberg-atom array (programmable spin chain)
- Trapped-ion spin chain
- Nanographene (triangulene) spin chain
- Spin ladder
Notes published science
- The blue copper sulphate crystals children grow in chemistry class, the same crystal that gave the very first X-ray diffraction image, turn into a quantum spin chain near absolute zero: its whole ground state is one entangled singlet, and neutrons account for 99(8)% of the predicted spinon signal (src:mourigal-2013-spinons).
- Tune a cobalt niobate chain to its critical point with a 5.5 tesla field and two magnetic particles appear whose energies approach the golden ratio, 1.618, as predicted for the exotic E8 symmetry; the domain-wall 'kinks' play the role of quarks (src:coldea-2010-e8).
- Haldane's 1981 prediction that whole-number and half-number spin chains behave differently was rejected and stayed unpublished in its first form; forty years later, chains built one carbon molecule at a time show what it implies: every unit carries spin 1, yet each end carries spin 1/2 (src:haldane-1981-spin-chains, src:mishra-2021-nanographene).
- Azurite, the blue pigment ground in ancient Egypt, is itself a natural quantum spin chain of copper ions, though how one-dimensional it really is is still argued (src:wp:azurite, src:rule-2011-azurite).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
quantum spin chain as physicists describe it (reader's view: the host and what reaches it, the local spins, exchange along the line, the collective ground state, excitations and transport, phases and universality, use and readout)
- L1: The host and what reaches it: a crystal (a mineral such as azurite or linarite, or a compound such as copper sulphate, KCuF3, CoNb2O6, NENP), a chain of molecules built on a surface, or a row of trapped atoms or ions; reached by fields, neutrons, heat, light and tunnelling electrons
- L2: The local spins: one per site, carried by an unpaired electron (Cu2+ spin 1/2, d9), by Ni2+ (spin 1), by a triangulene molecule (spin 1), or by an atom's two levels; whether the spin is integer or half-integer decides much of what follows
- L3: Exchange along the line: nearest-neighbour coupling J, ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic by its sign, isotropic or anisotropic (XXX, XXZ, XYZ, Ising), sometimes frustrated (J1-J2) or with biquadratic terms; interchain coupling weak
- L4: The collective ground state: a macroscopic singlet entangling all spins (spin 1/2), or a gapped singlet valence-bond solid (spin 1); entanglement of a block growing logarithmically at criticality
- L5: Excitations and transport: fractional spinons created in pairs, the Haldane gap and spin-1/2 ends, kinks bound into E8 mesons near the Ising critical point, magnons; ballistic heat and superdiffusive spin transport
- L6: Phases and universality: integer versus half-integer, symmetry-protected topological order, quantum critical points with conformal symmetry, integrability and its conservation laws
- L7: Use and readout: quantum state transfer, quantum simulation, a proposed resource for measurement-based quantum computation, magnetic heat conduction, and exact tests of many-body theory
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L3: The coupled line: spins coupled to nearest neighbours by exchange J (XXX, XXZ, XYZ or Ising anisotropy; ferro- or antiferromagnetic by the sign of J), with field, frustration (J1-J2) or biquadratic terms; interchain couplings weak
- L4: The collective ground state: for spin 1/2 'a macroscopic singlet entangling all spins in the chain' with power-law correlations; for integer spin a singlet with a gap and exponentially decaying correlations (a valence-bond solid); block entanglement growing as log L at criticality
- L5: Excitations and transport: spinons in pairs (a continuum; 71% of the weight in two-spinon states, 98% with four); the Haldane gap and free spin-1/2 ends; kinks confined into E8 'mesons' near the Ising critical point; magnons in the polarized state; ballistic heat and superdiffusive (KPZ) spin transport
- L6: Phases and universality: half-integer gapless versus integer gapped (Haldane; the sigma model's topological term); symmetry-protected topological phases beyond the Landau paradigm; quantum critical points with conformal symmetry and central charge; integrability with infinitely many conservation laws
- L7: Use and readout back on the world: a channel for quantum states between processors; programmable simulators of many-body physics; a resource proposed for measurement-based quantum computation; magnetic heat conduction; tests of exact theory
way in: Applied magnetic field (Zeeman coupling)
- L1: Static fields from laboratory magnets: up to the 5.5 T critical transverse field in CoNb2O6; fields large enough to align every spin in copper sulphate
- L2: The field couples to each spin's moment (the h term of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian; a transverse field 'stimulates quantum tunneling processes' between up and down)
way in: Exchange with neighbouring spins, through overlapping orbitals and bridging ligands
- L1: Neighbouring magnetic ions and the ligands between them (Cu-O-Cu bonds; carbonate and hydroxide in azurite); the coupling varies 'strongly in magnitude and sign depending on the geometry and environment of the copper oxide bonds'
- L2: The exchange interaction, from 'the combined effect of the Coulomb repulsion and the Pauli exclusion principle', ties each spin to its neighbours as J S_i.S_j
way in: Heat bath (temperature)
- L1: The bath: a dilution refrigerator near 100 mK for copper sulphate; 75-300 K for KCuF3's transport measurements
- L2: Thermal excitation of spins: 'As temperature increases and many spins are excited', the dynamics turn collective and thermal
way in: Impurities and chain breaks
- L1: Dopant atoms: NENP doped with Cu2+, or with non-magnetic Cd, Zn and Hg
- L2: A dopant breaks the chain into finite segments, whose ends 'behave like free spin 1/2 moments' in a spin-1 chain
way in: Laser and microwave drive (built chains and spin resonance)
- L1: Laser light driving trapped atoms toward Rydberg states (Rabi frequency 2 pi x 2 MHz, tunable detuning); X-band microwaves for electron spin resonance on NENP
- L2: Each atom's ground and Rydberg states act as a spin; the Rydberg blockade forbids two close neighbours from being excited together
way in: Neighbouring chains (interchain exchange)
- L1: The other chains: in KCuF3 the interchain coupling (-1.6 meV) is about twenty times weaker than the 33.5 meV chain exchange
- L2: Weak interchain exchange couples each chain's correlations to its neighbours' and orders the crystal in 3D below TN (39 K in KCuF3; 2.95 K in CoNb2O6)
way in: Neutron beams (inelastic neutron scattering)
- L1: Neutrons from a reactor (ILL, IN14) or a spallation source (SNS, SEQUOIA) sent through a cooled single crystal
- L2: The neutron's magnetic moment scatters off the spins; spinons are 'created and detected in pairs by neutron scattering'
way in: The crystal lattice: bond geometry and distortion
- L1: The lattice holding the magnetic ions; in CuGeO3 'the nn exchange constant in the CuO2 ribbon is very sensitive to the presence and position of the side group Ge'
- L2: Bond angles set the exchange ('the bond angles are more susceptible than the bond lengths'); temperature, pressure and doping change J through them
way in: Tunnelling electrons from a scanning probe tip
- L1: An STM tip above a chain built on a gold surface, at 4.5 K
- L2: Inelastic tunnelling excites spin excitations, seen as conductance steps symmetric about zero bias
way out: A quantum state delivered at the far end
- L2: Received on the far spin with a fidelity that falls with chain length; or entanglement shared for teleportation
- L3: The state propagates along the unmodulated chain under its own exchange
- L7: A sender places a state on the first spin and the receiver picks up the last spin at a chosen time
way out: Conductance steps read through the tip
- L1: Conductance steps in the tunnelling current at the excitation energies
- L5: Spin excitations and edge states of each chain length
way out: Fluorescence readout of a built chain
- L1: Fluorescence light read with 93% (Rydberg) and about 98% (ground) detection fidelity
- L7: Detect: atoms in the ground state fluoresce; Rydberg atoms are ejected and show as absent
way out: Heat carried along the chain by spin excitations
- L1: Heat handed to the bath at the cold end; the flow is limited only by extrinsic scattering (impurities, phonons)
- L5: Ballistic spinons carry heat; 'a huge magnetic heat conductivity' in pure SrCuO2
way out: Magnetization and susceptibility
- L1: Read by magnetometers as susceptibility (NENP measured from 300 K down to below 300 microkelvin)
- L4: The state's magnetization: zero in the singlet, full in the polarized state above saturation; end-chain spins add a low-temperature tail
way out: Scattered neutrons carrying the spin spectrum
- L1: Scattered neutrons counted by the spectrometer (energy resolution 0.05-0.078 meV at IN14)
- L2: Each neutron leaves with less energy and changed momentum
- L5: Spinon pairs created; the continuum's weight and shape set by the ground state