EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Positional (place-value) notation with zero

Positional notation, also known as place-value notation, is the property of a numeral system that the value represented by each symbol in a written numeral depends not only on its appearance but also on its position. Each symbol fits in a specific place or position, representing a power of a fixed base ... As a numerical digit, 0 plays a crucial role in positional notation: it means that the zero position does not increase or decrease the number's total value.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

aliasesPositional notation and zero
arrivesBabylonian base-60 positional system by the middle of the 2nd millennium BC (empty place shown by a space; a placeholder sign by c. 700 BC). Hindu–Arabic decimal system invented 'between the 1st and 4th centuries'. Zero used independently by the Maya.
born ataround 2000 BC (Babylonian); placeholder by about 700 BC; zero as a number around the 7th century AD (India)
born precisioncenturies
boundaryInside: the rule that a digit's value depends on its place (each place a power of a fixed base), the small digit set with 0 marking a place without value, and its own extensions (radix point for fractions, the minus sign, other bases). Outside: the glyph shapes ('in principle independent of the system itself'), the carriers (clay, ink, print, rods, knots, voltages), the minds and machines that compute with it, the calendars and measures it is bent to, and what it unpacks into (written algorithms, decimal fractions, binary circuits).
nested levelA Seed riding on writing and on human number concepts: built from a digit set, a base, the zero digit and the radix point; embedded in writing (Babylonian numerals in cuneiform, c. 2000 BC) and in the culture that copies it. Struck in several places: Babylon (base 60), China (rods, base 10), Mesoamerica (base 20, zero by 36 BC), India (1st-4th centuries), the Inca quipu. Its binary form runs on electronic circuits.
quantumA rule plus a small digit set: the value of a digit is that digit times a power of the base at its position, with 0 as the placeholder for an empty position. In Hindu–Arabic form this is 10 glyphs.
scalesocial

Measures (31) published science

values reachable with d digits in base rr^d distinct values
symbols needed for any rational number (developed Hindu-Arabic form)13 (ten digits, decimal marker, vinculum, minus sign) symbols
Babylonian non-zero digits from two wedge signs59 digits
first known positional system (Babylonian) appearsaround 2000 BC date
writing evolves from proto-writing (carrier predates the rule)3400-3100 BC date
Babylonian placeholder sign (Kish tablet, three hooks)as early as 700 BC; two slanted wedges by 300 BC date
earliest Long Count date requiring a zero placeholder (Chiapa de Corzo Stela 2)36 BC date
Bakhshali manuscript place-value leaves, radiocarbon224-383 CE date range
first written rules for computing with zero (Brahmagupta)628 year AD
oldest firmly dated zero as a decimal figure (Sambor inscription, Saka 605)683 year AD
first undisputed zero glyph in India (Chaturbhuj Temple, Gwalior)876 year AD
gap from placeholder to zero as a numberroughly 1,000 years
Maya Long Count third place value (calendar-bent radix)360 (18x20) instead of 400 place value
rod-calculus multiplication table learned by heart (nine-nine table)45 phrases
first relay implementation of binary arithmetic (Shannon thesis) and Model K1937 year
characteristic clock: carry period per placethe base: 10 (decimal), 20 (Maya, 18 in the second Long Count place), 60 (Babylonian), 2 (binary) counts per carry
characteristic clock: algorist-abacist contest in Europe12th to 16th century centuries
writing evolves from proto-writing (the carrier before the rule)between 3400 and 3100 BC date
Babylonian placeholder sign (Kish tablet, three hooks); two slanted wedgesas early as 700 BC; by 300 BC date
earliest Long Count date needing a zero placeholder (Chiapa de Corzo Stela 2)36 BC date
Maya Long Count third place value360 (18 x 20) instead of 400 place value
decimal fractions in rod calculus1st century BC date
Hindu-Arabic system inventedbetween the 1st and 4th centuries date
Lokavibhaga decimal place value with zero (internal date)AD 458 year
first rules for computing with zero (Brahmagupta)AD 628 year
oldest firmly dated zero as a decimal figure (Sambor, Saka 605)AD 683 year
Hindu numerals with zero offered in China (Gautama Siddha)718 CE year
first dated undisputed zero symbol in India (Gwalior)876 CE year
first relay implementation of binary arithmetic (Shannon) and the Model K (Stibitz)1937 year
age children know zero as the smallest numberabout 6 years
characteristic clock: placeholder to zero as a numberroughly a thousand years (placeholder in Mesopotamia; number in India around the 7th century AD)

Open contentions (2) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (6)

Sits inside / holds (2)

Trades with (valence) (10)

expressed by (10)

floor filled by (22)

represents (2)

seed within (1)

Kinds (9)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

counting tokens: rods, beads and knots set in places

  1. L1: Tokens set by hand: 'Counting rods and most abacuses have been used to represent numbers in a positional numeral system'; quipu knots tied on cords
  2. L2: Rod forms: vertical rods for 1-5, a horizontal bar for 5 (biquinary); forms alternate vertical and horizontal in neighbouring places
  3. L3: Place by column or cord position: 'For numbers larger than 9, a decimal system is used'; quipu 'encoded in a base ten positional system'
  4. L4: Zero as a gap: 'zeroes are represented by a space, which serves both as a number and a place holder value'; quipu zero 'the absence of a knot in the appropriate position'
  5. L5: Rod calculus: 'the mechanical method of algorithmic computation with counting rods', run with the 45-phrase nine-nine table; results written down additively column by column

digital electronics: bits as two voltage states

  1. L1: Two physical states: binary used 'because of its straightforward implementation in digital electronic circuitry using logic gates' and 'the noise immunity in physical implementation'
  2. L2: The bit: 'Each digit is referred to as a bit, or binary digit'
  3. L3: Place value in circuits: Shannon's 1937 thesis 'implemented Boolean algebra and binary arithmetic using electronic relays and switches for the first time in history'
  4. L4: Grouped bases: 'binary (radix 2), octal (radix 8), and hexadecimal (radix 16)' in computer science
  5. L5: Machine arithmetic: Stibitz's relay 'Model K' (November 1937) 'calculated using binary addition'

mental representation: beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions

  1. L1: Number neurons as vehicles: in monkeys, VIP neurons 'encoded empty sets as a category distinct from all other numerosities', and PFC neurons represented empty sets 'more similarly to numerosity 1'
  2. L3: Nothing as a quantity: Nieder's stage 3, where 'nothing acquires a quantitative meaning', an empty set at the low end of a number line; monkeys 'were immediately able to numerically match or order empty-set stimuli'
  3. L4: Zero as a number with rules: Brahmagupta (628) 'the first to provide rules to compute with zero' (stage 4); against it, the Greek belief 'There is no void' and 'How can not being be?'; Leibniz later read 1 and 0 as creatio ex nihilo
  4. L5: Memorised rules and tables steer calculation: 'a set of memorized rules and facts' applied to the digits; the 45-phrase nine-nine table 'learned by heart by pupils, merchants, government officials and mathematicians alike'
  5. L6: Shared number words that carry place value: 'the expression of positional value using versified Sanskrit number words'; the Babylonian system's 'structure reflects the decimal lexical numerals of Semitic languages'

mental representation: numbers, zero and digit rules held by reckoners

  1. L1: Number neurons as vehicles: monkey VIP neurons 'encoded empty sets as a category distinct from all other numerosities'; Nieder's first stage, sensory 'nothing'
  2. L3: Nothing as a quantity: 'quantitative empty sets'; children know zero as the smallest number by about age 6
  3. L4: Zero as a number with rules: Brahmagupta (628) 'the first to provide rules to compute with zero'; Ptolemy's symbol 'meant zero, not none'
  4. L5: Memorised tables steer calculation: positional notation needs 'memorization of tables'; the 45-phrase nine-nine table 'learned by heart'
  5. L6: Shared number words that carry place value: Semitic decimal number words shape the Babylonian system; the Aryabhatiya 'from place to place each is ten times the preceding'

written record: numerals as durable marks (clay, paper, print)

  1. L1: Marks on a carrier that lasts: 'a wedge-tipped reed stylus to print a mark on a soft clay tablet ... to create a permanent record'
  2. L2: The digit glyphs: two Babylonian wedge signs for 59 digits; Maya shell, dot and bar; ten Hindu-Arabic glyphs 'in principle independent of the system itself'; a digit outside the base's set is a notational error
  3. L3: Place value: 'the value represented by each symbol ... depends not only on its appearance but also on its position'; place values are powers of the base
  4. L4: The whole numeral: 0 marking places that 'do not contribute' (first a space, then a placeholder sign, then a digit), the radix point for fractions, 13 symbols for any rational number
  5. L5: Written algorithms: algorism, named after Khwarizmi's Latinised name; 'arithmetical computations are much simpler'
  6. L6: Books and teaching that spread one convention: Khwarizmi (c. 825) and al-Kindi (c. 830); Fibonacci's Liber Abaci (13th century), 'restricted to learned circles' and mostly Northern Italy until printing
  7. L7: The field's stated purpose: 'With positional notation, arithmetical computations are much simpler than with any older numeral system'

Sources (14) published science

Positional notation (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise)
0 (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise)
Hindu–Arabic numeral system (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise)
Rod calculus (Wikipedia, rev 1368689317, 2026-08-10, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Babylonian cuneiform numerals (Wikipedia, rev 1380439455, 2026-10-15, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Binary number (Wikipedia, rev 1378219065, 2026-10-03, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Nieder A. (2016) Representing something out of nothing: the dawning of zero. Trends in Cognitive Sciences. doi:10.1016/j.tics.2016.08.008 (author's open copy, Univ. Tuebingen) (behind its links)
History of writing (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Maya numerals (Wikipedia, rev 1379188262, 2026-10-08, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Algorism (Wikipedia, rev 1328536312, 2025-12-20, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Universal Turing machine (Wikipedia, rev 1377070305, 2026-09-27, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Kraut C, Pixner S (2023) Language does arithmetic: linguistic differences in children's place-value processing. Psychol Res 87:1866-1878. doi:10.1007/s00426-022-01653-3 (behind its links)
Algorithm (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot 2026-11-01) (behind its links)
Kadvany J. (2008) Computation as Grammaticalization, talk abstract, Stanford Linguistics CogSci/Coglunch, 17 January 2008 (behind its links)