← all systems · see it in The System
Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model)
'The term swampland refers to effective low-energy physical theories which are not compatible with quantum gravity'; 'the Swampland is the set of consistent-looking theories with no consistent ultraviolet completion with the addition of gravity'. The swampland conjectures are 'a set of conjectured criteria for theories in the quantum gravity landscape'.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Swampland |
| boundary | Inside (projected): consistent-looking, anomaly-free effective field theories that cannot be completed with gravity, and the criteria that mark them (no global symmetries, completeness of the charge spectrum, weak gravity, distance, de Sitter, finiteness, cobordism). Outside: the landscape of theories that are compatible with quantum gravity, which it surrounds ('the landscape is surrounded by an even more vast swampland'). |
| nested level | The complement of the string landscape within the space of effective theories coupled to gravity; a projected floor of quantum gravity; rung 1, below the first fold. |
| representation | True |
| scale | field |
Measures (8) published science
| Distance conjecture mass law | m ~ M0 exp(-lambda Delta phi) Planck units |
| Sharpened distance bound | lambda >= 1/sqrt(d-2) in d spacetime dimensions |
| de Sitter criterion | |grad V| >= c V, c of order 1 Planck units |
| Acceleration requires | lambda < sqrt(2) (w < -1/3), compatible if c < sqrt(2) in d = 4 |
| Observational bound on c | c <~ 0.6 in four dimensions |
| Gauge theories in eight dimensions | F-theory exhausts the list of consistent gauge theories |
| Characteristic clock (projected): Planck time | ~10^-43 s |
| Dates | program initiated 2005 (Vafa); weak gravity conjecture 2007 (Arkani-Hamed, Motl, Nicolis, Vafa, JHEP); distance conjecture 2007 (Ooguri-Vafa); de Sitter criterion 2018 year |
Open contentions (1) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-025 Can string theory produce a long-lived universe with positive vacuum energy like ours?
booked: The map follows the KKLT construction, in which such vacua exist, and keeps the swampland argument that rules them out alongside.
the other reading: B: metastable dS exists, so the criterion as stated fails (KKLT 2003)
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (7)
- Finiteness criteria
- No global symmetry conjecture
- Weak gravity conjecture
- Completeness of spectrum hypothesis
- Distance conjecture
- de Sitter swampland criterion
- Cobordism conjecture
Sits inside / holds (2)
- String theory (projected model of quantum gravity; candidate theory of everything)
- Quantum gravity (the Planck-scale regime of gravity; hypothetical)
Trades with (valence) (7)
- Metastable de Sitter string vacuum (KKLT type; projected model) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) even
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) gain
- Quintessence field (hypothesised alternative) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) even
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) even
- AdS/CFT correspondence (projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) gain
- Moduli space of vacua (vacuum manifold) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) even
- F-theory (projected model) via sys:gravitational-field · Swampland (effective theories with no quantum-gravity completion; projected model) even
expressed by (1)
floor filled by (11)
- String-theory vacua (the landscape; projected model)
- Black hole
- Moduli space of vacua (vacuum manifold)
- Finiteness criteria
- No global symmetry conjecture
- Effective field theory
- Weak gravity conjecture
- Completeness of spectrum hypothesis
- Distance conjecture
- de Sitter swampland criterion
- Cobordism conjecture
represents (1)
Kinds (1)
Notes published science
- The swampland is argued to be bigger than the landscape: most theories that look fine on paper would not survive adding gravity.
- Black holes act as the judges: a theory with a global symmetry fails because a black hole can swallow the charge and evaporate without giving it back.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
projected model: black-hole and charge criteria on effective theories coupled to gravity
- L1: Effective field theories coupled to gravity: 'consistent-looking', 'anomaly-free'; in quantum gravity 'a local structure of observables is emergent rather than fundamental' and 'UV and IR are closely related'
- L2: Black-hole test of symmetries: black hole formation and evaporation 'violates any conservation which is not protected by gauge symmetry': no global symmetries (also higher-form); cobordism: a domain wall must connect any two backgrounds
- L3: Completeness: 'for sufficiently high charges, any charge is realized by at least one black hole state'; follows from the absence of generalized global symmetries
- L4: Weak gravity: every black hole must decay unless protected by supersymmetry; gravity the weakest force; higher-form version: a brane exceeds the extremal charge-to-mass ratio
projected model: criteria on moduli spaces and scalar potentials
- L1: Scalar fields and their moduli space, with the canonical metric G_ij from the kinetic term
- L2: Distance: at any infinite distance a tower becomes light, m ~ M0 exp(-lambda Delta phi), with lambda >= 1/sqrt(d-2) (sharpened) and a KK or string tower (emergent string)
- L3: Finiteness: 'certain finiteness criteria as one relevant factor in identifying this boundary'
- L4: Potentials: |grad V| >= c V with c of order 1 in Planck units, which 'forbids dS vacua'; an accelerating universe needs lambda < sqrt(2); data give c <~ 0.6
- L5: Verdict: a theory is in the landscape or the swampland; Vafa 'argued that string theory suggests that the Swampland is in fact much larger than the string theory landscape'
Sources (5) published science
Swampland (physics) (Wikipedia, rev 1361592059, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache): distance conjecture
T. Weigand, TASI Lectures on F-theory (2018), arXiv:1806.01854; read abstract, introduction, section 10.1 (behind its links)
Planck units (behind its links)