← all systems · see it in The System
Superconductivity
Superconductivity is 'a set of physical properties observed in superconductors: materials where electrical resistance is exactly zero and magnetic fields are expelled from the material'; walked here as the phenomenon (zero resistance, flux expulsion, pairing) together with its theories and the practice of describing and using it.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| born at | first seen 8 April 1911 (mercury at 4.2 K, Kamerlingh Onnes); natural kind hypothesised inside neutron stars (no date in the sources read) |
| born precision | the day (laboratory); unknown (natural) |
| boundary | Inside: the paired, condensed carriers of a material below its critical temperature, field and current, and what they do (zero resistance, flux expulsion, quantised flux, tunnelling). Outside: the bath, the applied fields and currents, and the people who measure, explain and use it. The superconductor walk holds the material state; this walk holds the phenomenon, its theories and practice, and points at the state's floors. |
| nested level | a set of properties of the superconducting state of matter (sys:superconductor); described by condensed matter physics; its theories run on physics |
| scale | atomic |
Measures (35) published science
| mercury critical temperature (the first superconductor) | 4.2 K |
| time from discovery to microscopic theory | 46 (1911 to 1957) years |
| cuprate doping dome | onset ~5%, optimum ~16%, end ~27% holes per Cu doping x |
| believed ceiling for conventional Tc | 30 (broken by MgB2 at 39 K, 2001) |
| pair correlation range | of the order of 10^-4 cm |
| nuclear spin relaxation just below Tc | rises by more than a factor of two ratio |
| flux quantum | 2.07 x 10^-15 T m^2 |
| brain magnetic fields (MEG) | about 100 (10 fT spinal cord to ~1 pT alpha band) |
| SQUID magnetometer noise | as low as 1 fT/sqrt(Hz) |
| refrigeration efficiency at 4.2 K | 0.0028 net (about 360 W per W; Carnot minimum 68.4 W/W) usable out / sent in |
| extraction power per watt at 1.8 K (LHC) | about 1000 (Carnot minimum 161.8) W/W |
| qubit operating temperature | about 10 mK |
| transmon coherence time | 50 to 100 microseconds |
| time to energize a laboratory superconducting magnet | several minutes |
| LHC 2008 resistive zone growth | 1 V at 9 kA in less than one second |
| magnets damaged in the 2008 LHC incident | at most 5 quadrupoles and 24 dipoles magnets |
| vortex avalanche size (de Gennes) | typically 50 lines or more vortices |
| vortices in a critical state | several million vortices |
| Josephson junctions in the NIST one-volt standard | 20,208 junctions |
| economic activity resting on superconductivity (2014) | about 5 billion (MRI about 80%) euros |
| LK-99 claimed Tc | >= 400 (claim); resistance drop traced to Cu2S transition near 385 K |
| H3S (sulfur hydride) critical temperature at high pressure | 203 K |
| highest cuprate Tc cited (ambient / high pressure) | 133 / 164 K |
| LaH10 critical temperature (record claimed) at ~170 GPa | ~250 K |
| LaH10 predicted Tc range (first-principles) | 240-320 K |
| LaH10 upper critical field at zero temperature (suggested) | 120 T |
| nucleon pairing critical temperature in neutron stars (order) | 1e9 K |
| nucleon pairing gap in neutron-star matter (about) | 1 MeV |
| first iron-based superconductor Tc (LaFeAsO:F, Feb 2008); later up to | 26; 55 K |
| Gravity Probe B rotor London moment (equivalent uniform field at 80 Hz) | 5e-5 G |
| Gravity Probe B SQUID readout resolution | 1 mas in 10 hr spin direction |
| magnetic flux quantum h/2e | 2.08e-15 Wb |
| Zurek-Kibble scaling exponent for spontaneous fluxoids (Nb loop) | 0.62 ± 0.15 dimensionless |
| MRI share of global helium consumption | 22 % |
| liquid helium in a bath-cooled MRI magnet | several hundred to several thousand L |
Open contentions (8) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-315 Does the standard theory of superconductivity explain why magnetic fields are pushed out?
booked: The map follows the standard view that the theory predicts it, and keeps the minority argument that it does not alongside.
the other reading: Hirsch: BCS is unable to explain the Meissner effect - C-321 Is the Higgs mechanism a kind of superconductivity of empty space, or just an analogy?
booked: The map treats it as the same mechanism carried over from superconductors to particle physics, and keeps the 'only an analogy' view alongside.
the other reading: the Higgs mechanism as a kind of superconductivity of the vacuum - C-338 Is a superconductor topologically ordered, or simply a state of broken symmetry?
booked: The map uses the topological-order reading for a superconductor with a real electromagnetic field, and keeps the usual broken-symmetry reading alongside.
the other reading: Z2 topological order vs broken symmetry - C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: the positions listed in C-413 - C-1242 Is the avalanche behaviour of magnetic flux in superconductors 'self-organised criticality'?
booked: The map records the avalanches and leaves the self-organised-criticality reading open, as it is still debated.
the other reading: the critical state as self-organised criticality, or not ('Whether real piles follow the SOC scheme is still subject to debate'; thermally triggered flux jumps differ) - C-1244 What makes electrons pair up in copper-oxide superconductors?
booked: The map treats the mechanism as unsettled, listing magnetically driven pairing as the leading account with the alternatives alongside.
the other reading: phonon-assisted or other mechanisms; Hirsch's single hole-based theory; 'still substantially unsolved' (Keimer et al.) - C-1263 Can one theory explain all superconductors?
booked: The map uses the accepted standard theory for conventional superconductors and treats unusual ones case by case, keeping the minority one-theory view alongside.
the other reading: Hirsch: BCS fundamentally flawed, one alternative theory for all superconductors - C-1611 Are the high-pressure hydrogen compounds really superconductors?
booked: The map books the reported results and keeps the critique that the data may not show superconductivity at all.
the other reading: Hirsch and Marsiglio: the observations rule out conventional superconductivity; either nonstandard superconductors or, they think more likely, not superconductors at all
Cross-scale patterns seen here (25) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Superconductivity. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- borrowed-then-held (structural)
a magnet's current is first driven by an outside power supply (borrowed); once energised, a superconducting persistent switch closes the winding into a loop, the supply is turned off, and the loop holds the current and field itself for months (held). The same move at the cooling: bath-cooled MRI bor - lightning (structural)
a quench or flux jump: stored magnetic energy released all at once; at the LHC (19 September 2008) a resistive zone reached 1 V at 9 kA in under a second, an arc punctured the helium enclosure, and up to 29 magnets needed repair - runaway from an unstable balance (structural)
two runaways: the normal Fermi sea is unstable to pairing under any attraction (Cooper), and flux jumps run away by positive feedback between vortex motion and heat - same role, different builds (structural)
the job of binding fermions into pairs is done by different glues: the electron-phonon interaction in metals, van der Waals forces between He3 atoms, the nuclear force in nuclei and neutron stars (Cooper); and by repulsion with a sign-changing gap in cuprates (Keimer) - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
cooled through Tc (the named cut), the condensate picks a phase where the normal state had none; its universal properties (Meissner effect, flux quantisation, zero resistance) are 'rooted in the nature of the broken symmetry'. Monaco 2009 sees the cut directly: a fast quench cannot choose one phase - templating (structural)
Landau's 1933 free-energy expansion, made for a wrong theory of superconductivity, became the template reused for water's critical point, liquid crystals, magnets and cosmic inflation; BCS seeded the Anderson-Higgs reading used to predict the Higgs boson - The carry (structural)
overflow passed on: in Bean's critical state each pinning centre holds a vortex up to its maximum force, the excess is pushed on, and over-critical slopes relax in avalanches of typically 50 lines or more (de Gennes's sand hill). The wait face: magnets are ramped over minutes because fast changes ca - The Payment to Entropy (structural)
inside the condensate a DC hand-off pays no resistive toll; the toll is paid outside instead, at the refrigerator: cooling 1 W at 4.2 K costs about 360 W (net efficiency 0.0028), about 1 kW at 1.8 K; Carnot alone asks 68.4 W/W at 4.2 K. Form: thermal, moved from the wire to the wall plug - the whole sets the local reference (structural)
each stretch of a ring reads its own local phase; going round the loop the readings must add to a whole number of turns, so the whole fixes what the parts can hold: the trapped flux is exactly the winding number, in units of h/2e. After a fast quench the local phases do not close into one uniform ph - trade one property for another (structural)
the transmon qubit buys insensitivity to charge noise (coherence 50-100 us) and pays with anharmonicity (about -200 MHz, a few percent of the level spacing) - barrier-gates-complexity (partial)
a thin insulating barrier between two superconductors is what makes the Josephson effects: the voltage-frequency link that realises the volt with 20,208 junctions, and the junction 'as a valve for Cooper pairs' that makes qubits. Partial: the sources read do not set out the without-barrier case - causal ceiling (partial)
how far one patch of a cooling ring can agree with another is set by causality, not by our instruments: 'causality prevents the system from adopting a uniform phase', and the domains left 'reflect the causal horizons' (Kibble-Zurek). Partial: the ceiling is on the parts' agreement, read through trap - conservation law plus closure (partial)
Ampere's law ties field to current but does not say what current a superconductor carries; the second London equation closes it, and together they give the Helmholtz equation whose solution decays within the penetration depth (the Meissner effect) - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (partial)
Ashcroft (1968) and later first-principles calculations predicted where high-Tc conventional superconductors sit (light, hydrogen-rich, under pressure); H3S was predicted at ~80 K and found at 203 K, and LaH10 was predicted at 240-320 K and reported at ~250 K. The slots were predicted with their pro - outside-to-inside (partial)
an applied field, first outside the sample, enters a type II superconductor as an internal lattice of quantised flux tubes (normal cores in supercurrent tornadoes); in neutron-star cores the star's field threads the proton superconductor this way. Partial: a partition moves inside, but the system do - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
one process, the BCS gap equation with an effective interaction: an attractive interaction gives a same-sign gap (conventional); a purely repulsive, momentum-dependent one gives a sign-changing (d-wave) gap - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
separate material families (cuprates 1986, iron pnictides 2008, organics, heavy fermions) each build the same phase diagram: a superconducting dome that appears once magnetism is suppressed by doping or pressure. Shared parts (layers, suppressed magnetic order), separate assemblies (copper-oxygen pl - smooth to sharp in finite time (partial)
as temperature falls smoothly the resistance 'abruptly disappeared' at 4.2 K (mercury) and drops sharply to zero in H3S: a finite parameter at which a property reaches an exact limit (zero) rather than only falling steeply. Partial: no source read states the singularity in so many words - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (partial)
a superconducting loop counts the magnetic field in flux quanta and reads brain fields of ~100 fT under an Earth field near 10^-4 T: a slice of the field no human channel takes in - who opens the door (partial)
the SQUID loop and junctions are built and cooled ahead of time, a port waiting for flux to arrive - coordination-before-mapping (surface)
millions of pairs act as one (persistent current, flux expulsion) with no map of anything: coordination by a shared quantum state. Surface: a physical condensate, where a map could not exist - holding / entrainment (surface)
all pairs share one phase: the condensate is one state that fixes each pair's phase ('a pure quantum mechanism of macroscopic scale'). Surface: no division, death or count of parts is set, and the Josephson volt array is locked to a shared outside microwave drive (the dark twin) - nested ladder (surface)
a superconductor is a perfect conductor and more: London showed it is a perfect diamagnet, so the Meissner state implies zero resistance but a perfect conductor need not expel flux. Surface: a two-rung order, read from the London brothers' distinction - partner-becomes-part (surface)
two electrons bound by an attraction act as one Cooper pair, a new composite carrier. Surface: no inheritance, and pairs break and re-form - seed (surface)
the BCS pairing idea unpacked into nuclei, neutron stars, helium-3 and the Anderson-Higgs reading; Landau's expansion for it became a general template. Surface: an idea opening fields, not a quantum unpacking combinatorics in the system itself
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (13) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Large Hadron Collider (LHC) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity even
- Electron via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity gain
- Electromagnetic field via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity mixed
- Neutron star via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity gain
- Helium atom via sys:thermal-energy · Superconductivity gain
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · Superconductivity loss
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity even
- Phonon via sys:acoustic-wave · Superconductivity gain
- Crystal via sys:acoustic-wave · Superconductivity gain
- Competition: superconductivity vs antiferromagnetic order (cuprates) via sys:matter · Superconductivity mixed
- Electric circuit via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity even
- Tokamak via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity gain
- Condensed matter physics via sys:electromagnetic-field · Superconductivity gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (2)
expressed by (3)
floor filled by (16)
- Large Hadron Collider (LHC)
- Electron
- Helium atom
- Phonon
- Cooper pair
- Quantum vortex
- Superconductor (the superconducting state of matter)
- SQUID
- Crystal
- Josephson junction
- Superconducting magnet
- Physics (the field)
- Condensed matter physics
- Superconducting qubit
- Critical state (Bean)
- Tokamak
represents (2)
Kinds (12)
- State of matter
- Electricity
- London theory (1935)
- Ginzburg-Landau theory (1950)
- BCS theory (1957)
- Eliashberg theory
- Pairing from repulsion (Hubbard and t-J models, d-wave)
- Hirsch's alternative theory for all superconductors
- Einstein's molecular conduction chains (1922)
- Bohr-Kronig sliding electron crystal (1932)
- Bloch-Landau spontaneous currents (1933)
- Kibble-Zurek mechanism
Notes published science
- A superconducting current in a gravimeter in Belgium ran for 28 years, 7 months and 27 days (1995-2024) with no power source: a hand-off that paid no measurable toll to entropy, because an energy gap larger than the lattice's thermal energy keeps the electrons from being scattered (src:wp:superconductivity).
- On the very day superconductivity was found (8 April 1911, mercury at 4.2 K), the same run also showed helium turning superfluid at 2.2 K, and nobody noticed: two quantum wonders in one experiment, one of them missed (src:wp:superconductivity).
- Landau's 1933 theory of superconductivity was wrong, but the free-energy expansion he made for it became Landau theory, now used for water's critical point, liquid crystals and even cosmic inflation; Einstein, Bohr, Heisenberg and Feynman all tried and failed before BCS, 46 years after the discovery (src:schmalian-2010-failed-theories).
- A wire with zero resistance still pays its toll, just somewhere else: keeping 1 W of heat out at 4.2 K costs about 360 W at the wall, and about 1 kW at the LHC's 1.8 K (src:parma-2015-cryostat-design).
- Gravity Probe B tested Einstein with gyroscopes read through superconductivity: a spinning niobium-coated ball makes its own tiny magnetic field (the London moment), and a SQUID on a superconducting loop could tell a change of one milliarcsecond in its spin direction over 10 hours (src:everitt-2011-gpb).
- Cool a superconducting ring fast and it cannot agree with itself: causality stops it picking one phase all the way round, and the mismatch gets frozen in as a whole quantum of magnetic flux, the same mechanism proposed for defects in the early universe (src:monaco-2009-fluxoid).
- Iron was the element nobody tried, because magnetism was thought to kill superconductivity; when iron compounds superconducted in 2008, they turned out to follow the same dome as the copper oxides: switch the magnetism off, and pairing appears (src:paglione-greene-2010-iron).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
superconductivity as physicists describe it (reader's view: the cold material and what reaches it, pairing, the condensate, zero resistance and flux expulsion, the critical limits, the theories, the uses)
- L1: The cold material and what reaches it: conduction electrons in a metal or compound, held in a cold bath (4.2 K helium in 1911), reached by heat, lattice vibrations, fields, currents and radiation
- L2: Pairing: any attraction makes the Fermi sea unstable to correlated pairs (phonon exchange in conventional superconductors; pairing from repulsion with a sign-changing order parameter proposed for cuprates)
- L3: The condensate: one coherent pair state with a gap, a macroscopic wave function (the Ginzburg-Landau order parameter)
- L4: Zero resistance and flux expulsion: perfect diamagnetism within the penetration depth, flux quantisation, vortices, Josephson tunnelling
- L5: The limits and breakdown: critical temperature, field and current; the critical state of pinned vortices; flux jumps and quenches
- L6: The theories: London, Ginzburg-Landau, BCS, Eliashberg; cuprate pairing unsettled; dissent kept
- L7: Uses and the search: magnets, SQUIDs, the volt, qubits; new superconductors sought, false alarms tested
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L3: The condensate: electrons bound in pairs condense into one coherent state with an energy gap and a single phase, 'a pure quantum mechanism of macroscopic scale'; two almost independent fluids (pairs and quasiparticles) above zero temperature
- L4: The electromagnetic response: zero DC resistance; flux expelled within the penetration depth (perfect diamagnetism); flux through a loop quantised; vortices of quantised flux in type II; two lengths, coherence length and penetration depth
- L5: The limits: critical temperature, field and current; the critical state, where pinning holds vortices up to the critical current density; flux jumps and quenches when the limits are crossed; the doping dome
- L6: The theories: London (1935), Gorter-Casimir, Ginzburg-Landau (1950), BCS (1957), Eliashberg, Josephson (1962), the Anderson-Higgs reading; unconventional (cuprate) pairing still unsettled; the failed theories kept as history
- L7: Use and search: magnets (MRI, accelerators), SQUIDs (MEG), the Josephson volt, superconducting qubits; the hunt for new and warmer superconductors, false alarms included
way in: Applied magnetic field
- L1: An applied field, from the Earth's ~10^-4 T down to brain fields of about 100 fT
- L2: The field couples to the condensate's charge-2e phase through the vector potential (Ginzburg-Landau); it is screened within the penetration depth or enters as vortices
way in: Composition, doping and pressure
- L1: Charge-reservoir layers that add or remove electrons from the CuO2 planes; mercury, niobium alloys, MgB2, cuprate ceramics
- L2: Doping sets the carrier count: superconductivity sets in near 5% holes per copper, peaks near 16% and vanishes near 27%
way in: Electromagnetic radiation (microwaves, light)
- L1: Electromagnetic radiation falling on the superconductor; microwave signal lines into qubit packages
- L2: Absorption shows the pair state's interference (coherence) effects: near Tc dominated by quasiparticle scattering; at low temperature only quanta that create quasiparticle pairs out of the condensate are absorbed
way in: Electron-electron repulsion and spin correlations (the proposed glue in cuprates)
- L1: Strong on-site repulsion (the Hubbard U) in the CuO2 planes; at one electron per site a Mott insulator, 'a traffic jam of electrons', with antiferromagnetic exchange between neighbouring spins
- L2: Approximate solutions of the doped Hubbard model point to d-wave pairing: interactions with large momentum transfer near the antiferromagnetic vector promote pairing with a sign-changing order parameter
way in: Heat from the surroundings (the thermal bath and heat leaks)
- L1: The bath the sample sits in: liquid helium at 4.2 K (Kamerlingh Onnes, 1911), superfluid helium at 1.8 K (LHC magnets), a dilution refrigerator stage at about 10 mK (qubits); heat leaks in from room temperature
- L2: Thermal excitation across the gap: excited electrons become quasiparticles, easily scattered; the gap varies with temperature and exists only below Tc
way in: Lattice vibrations (phonons): the pairing glue in conventional superconductors
- L1: Vibrations of the crystal lattice; the ion mass sets their frequencies (the isotope effect, 1950)
- L2: Phonon exchange gives a net attraction between electrons near the Fermi surface; with phonon dynamics (Eliashberg) the attraction is retarded and the gap frequency-dependent
way in: Measurements reaching physicists (resistance, magnetisation, spectra)
- L1: Signals from the sample: resistance dropping to zero in mercury at 4.2 K; magnetisation; flux through pick-up coils
- L2: Instruments: pick-up coils, micro Hall probes and high-resolution magneto-optical imaging
- L3: Computer-controlled data acquisition made vortex avalanche statistics measurable
- L4: Claims posted and published (LK-99: two arXiv preprints, a journal paper and a patent application)
- L5: Replication and test: attempted replications of LK-99, then papers from major labs by mid-August 2023; a 2020 claim retracted in 2022
way in: The lattice's nuclear spins (and sound) probing the electrons
- L1: Nuclear spins relax by giving energy to the conduction electrons; ultrasound is absorbed by them
- L2: Below Tc the nuclear relaxation rate rises by more than a factor of two while sound attenuation drops sharply: the pair state's coherence factors, one sign for each probe
way in: Thought (physicists' ideas about the phenomenon)
- L1: An idea arrives: Einstein's molecular conduction chains (1922), Kronig's sliding electron crystal, Landau's free-energy expansion in the current
- L4: Ideas worked into theories by analogy: Landau's and Bloch's proposals 'motivated by the theory of ferromagnetism'
- L5: Tested against others and experiment: Bohr withdrew his article at proof stage after Bloch's criticism
way in: Transport current and voltage (from a power supply or a circuit)
- L1: A current fed in from a power supply, ramped gently (minutes for a laboratory magnet; 10 A/s for the LHC dipole circuit)
- L2: Pairs carry the current with no voltage; across a thin insulator they tunnel (Josephson), the junction acting as a valve for Cooper pairs
way out: Field shaped back on the world: expelled, screened, trapped, or made by a magnet
- L1: Magnet windings in persistent mode keep their field for months
- L4: Screening currents expel the applied field; pinned vortices trap it (levitation holding up to 70,000 times the superconductor's weight, the flux-pinning page says)
way out: Instruments and machines built on it (MRI and accelerator magnets, SQUID magnetometers, qubits)
- L1: SQUIDs pick up the ~100 fT fields the brain makes
- L7: Built for a purpose: MRI systems, about 80% of a ~5 billion euro activity (2014); MEG arrays reading the brain; qubit processors
way out: Josephson output: voltage to frequency, flux to voltage
- L1: The NIST one-volt standard: 20,208 junctions in series
- L4: A junction ties voltage and frequency together precisely; in a SQUID loop, flux quanta set the output
way out: Lossless current into the circuit
- L1: A current in a closed superconducting loop persists with no power source
- L4: Zero resistance: no voltage needed to keep a current flowing
way out: Stored energy dumped as heat (quench, flux jump)
- L1: Heat into the helium bath; at the LHC in 2008 an arc punctured the helium enclosure and helium was released
- L5: Part of the coil goes resistive; moving vortices dissipate heat
way out: Theories published, taught and tested
- L1: Papers and lectures reaching readers (Nobel lectures, reviews, preprints)
- L6: Theories written up; Schmalian's point that they 'emerge quite differently from how they are taught'