← all systems · see it in The System
V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule)
The mechanism of somatic recombination that 'occurs only in developing lymphocytes during the early stages of T and B cell maturation' and 'in a nearly random fashion rearranges variable (V), joining (J), and in some cases, diversity (D) gene segments', guided by recombination signal sequences under the 12/23 rule. Walked as a Seed: the rule (RSS-flanked segments, the 12/23 joining rule, the RAG cutter) plus its partial shell.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | V(D)J recombination |
| arrives | 'Originated in jawed fish approximately 500 million years ago', after the 2R genome duplication; the RAG transposon invaded a 'UrIg2' gene in an ancestor of all extant jawed fish |
| boundary | Inside: the quantum (V, D, J segments each flanked by an RSS of heptamer, 12- or 23-bp spacer and nonamer, joined only across a 12/23 pair), the machinery that cuts and joins by it (RAG1/RAG2, with Artemis and TdT at the junction), and its partial shell (RAG's transposition brake, lymphocyte-only RAG expression, CTCF loop control, the allelic-exclusion stop). Outside: the coded DNA it acts on and the code that reads its output, the ubiquitous NHEJ pathway it borrows, the lymphocytes that carry it, and the field it unpacks into. |
| nested level | A rule running in the antigen-receptor loci of developing jawed-vertebrate lymphocytes; a Seed within the genetic code; with clonal selection it re-runs blind variation and selective survival inside one body; unpacks into the adaptive immune system. |
| quantum | The RSS-flanked gene segment (V, D, J) with its 12/23 joining rule: heptamer, 12- or 23-bp spacer, nonamer. RAG1/2 cut and join segments only across a 12/23 pair. |
| scale | molecular |
| shell | Partial: CTCF-binding elements loop the loci, 'allowing the needed recombinations to happen while preventing unwanted ones'; and (Recombination-activating gene page) RAG expression is 'restricted to lymphocytes during their developmental stages'. A gate around the quantum's use more than a wall around it. |
Measures (22) published science
| Characteristic clock: when the rule runs | only during 'the early stages of T and B cell maturation', in bone marrow (B) and thymus (T); once per allele, irreversibly developmental stage |
| Human IGH segment counts (V x D x J) | 44 V, 27 D, 6 J (and 2 C): 44 x 27 x 6 = 7,128 segment combinations (our arithmetic on the source's counts) segments |
| Antibody combinations said to be possible | roughly 3x10^11 (the source flags this figure as needing a citation) combinations |
| Distinct antibody molecules per person, without antigen stimulation | more than 1 trillion molecules |
| Human genes available to encode them | fewer than 25,000 ('Millions of genes would be required') |
| RSS spacer lengths (the 12/23 rule) | 12 or 23 bp |
| RSS heptamer and nonamer lengths | 7 (CACAGTG) and 9 (ACAAAAACC) bp |
| RAG1 and RAG2 size (mouse) | 1,040 and 527 amino acids |
| RAG2 added to RAG1: recombination frequency | 1000 fold increase |
| Transposition suppression by RAG1 R848 and the RAG2 acidic hinge (in vivo) | more than 1000 fold |
| Acidic-hinge removal: transposition activity | about 100 fold increase |
| Reawakened RAG transposition: insertions in protein-coding exons | 180 of 930 (19%) insertions |
| ProtoRAG-to-RAG divergence | an estimated 700 million years |
| ProtoRAG target site duplication | 5 bp |
| ProtoRAG TIR spacer lengths (against the RSS 12/23) | 27 and 31 bp |
| Recent ProtoRAG copies in the lancelet | 11 of 13 copies arose in the last 2.7 million years Ma |
| Arrival: adaptive immunity in jawed fish | approximately 500 Ma |
| Arrival: Transib invasion of the ancestral jawed vertebrate genome | about 500; the traditional bracket for the agnathan/gnathostome split was '1001 to 590' Ma |
| ProtoRAG lineage depth (basal chordates) | some 550 Ma |
| TdT knockout mice: TCR diversity | drastic reductions (10-fold) |
| Lymphocytes in the human body (the rule's products' carriers) | about 2 trillion, '20-40% of white blood cells' |
| Characteristic clock: primary adaptive response in humans | 4-7 days |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (5)
- Recombination-activating genes (RAG1/RAG2)
- Recombination signal sequences (quanta)
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
- Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (junction writer)
- CTCF-binding elements (shell, partial)
Sits inside / holds (6)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping)
- Lymphocyte
- Vertebrate (Vertebrata)
- Non-homologous end joining (borrowed repair)
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
Trades with (valence) (9)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR) via sys:cell-lineage · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) mixed
- Genetic code (codon-to-amino-acid mapping) via sys:sequential-information · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Cell lineage (cells descended by division from a founder cell: clones, germline and soma) via sys:cell-lineage · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Adaptive immune system via sys:sequential-information · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Lymphocyte via sys:cell-lineage · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Non-homologous end joining (borrowed repair) via sys:sequential-information · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Transib transposons and ProtoRAG (the cutter's ancestor) via sys:enzyme-catalysis · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci via sys:sequential-information · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
- Chromatin via sys:sequential-information · V(D)J recombination (the 12/23 joining rule) gain
expressed by (11)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Evolvability/Plasticity Engineering (Design for Future Variation)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Risk-managed Exploration
- Resilience & Repair
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (2)
- Blind Variation + Selective Retention (BVSR)
- Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
originates in (1)
seed within (1)
Notes published science
- The immune system's variety generator is a tamed parasite, and the taming is two amino-acid-scale changes: 'RAG1 R848 and the RAG2 acidic hinge suppress RAG-mediated transposition in vivo more than 1000-fold', and reversing them 'reawakens the RAG transposase and enables widespread transposition into genes and exons in the human genome' (180 of 930 insertions in coding exons). The ancestor is still alive and jumping in the Chinese lancelet, where 11 of 13 copies arose in the last 2.7 million years.
- The grammar was already in the transposon's ends: Transib TIRs 'are structurally similar to Recombination signal sequences', with a heptamer, a spacer and a nonamer. The moth version lacks the nonamer and the lancelet version has 27 and 31 bp spacers instead of 12 and 23, so the inverted-repeat pair of a jumping gene became the 12/23 pairing rule that now keeps V from joining V.
- The repertoire is bigger than the genome that holds it: 'more than 1 trillion different antibody molecules' from 'fewer than 25,000 genes', because the rule writes sequence that is in no gene at all. Artemis opens the hairpin off-centre (palindromic P nucleotides) and TdT adds untemplated N nucleotides; take TdT away and TCR diversity falls 10-fold. The body pays for it: out-of-frame joins kill the cell, and 'there is considerable waste involved in this process'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
DNA sequence: antigen-receptor gene segments cut and joined (sequential information)
- L1: Germline antigen-receptor loci: IGH on chromosome 14 (44 V, 27 D, 6 J, 2 C), IGK on 2 and IGL on 22 (V and J, no D); TCR beta V, D, J; TCR alpha V, J
- L2: Recombination signal sequences flanking every segment: heptamer CACAGTG, spacer of 12 or 23 bp ('approximately one (12 basepairs) or two turns (23 basepairs) of the DNA helix'; sequence poorly conserved, length 'highly conserved'), nonamer ACAAAAACC
- L3: Synapsis: cleavage 'occurs preferentially in a complex containing one 12RSS and one 23RSS'; two HMGB1 molecules bend the RSSs; CTCF-binding elements loop the locus and bias which sites meet; RAG1 targeting is 'dominated by chromatin interactions'
- L4: The cut: RAG nicks between the first base of the RSS and the coding segment ('essentially energetically neutral (no need for ATP hydrolysis)'), then the freed 3' hydroxyl attacks the opposite strand, leaving a hairpin on the coding end and a blunt signal end; signal ends ligate into a circular signal joint
- L5: Junction processing: DNA-PK binds each end and activates Artemis, which opens the hairpins (off-centre opening leaves palindromic P nucleotides); TdT adds non-templated N nucleotides with a G/C preference; exonucleases trim; pol lambda and mu fill; DNA ligase IV ligates
- L6: A rearranged VDJ (or VJ) exon with the intervening DNA deleted: a paratope 'highly variable, even when the same gene segments are recombined', in-frame or not
RAG recombinase chemistry: a domesticated DDE transposase (enzyme catalysis)
- L1: RAG1 (mouse 1,040 amino acids) and RAG2 (527); cleavage activity in RAG1 residues 384-1008 and RAG2 1-387; RAG1's DDE motif (D600, D708, E962) is 'the major active site for DNA cleavage'
- L2: Signal reading: RAG1 residues 384-454 are 'a nonamer-binding region (NBR) that specifically binds the conserved nonamer', and its central domain (528-760) 'binds specifically to the RSS heptamer'; RAG2's six-bladed beta-propeller 'appears less specific'
- L3: Closed synaptic dimer: DNA binding creates 'new intermolecular interactions between two RAG1-RAG2 monomers', the two RSSs bound asymmetrically with the nonamer-binding dimer tilted toward the 12-RSS, 'which emphasizes the 12/23 rule'
- L4: Catalysis: the coding end is 'highly distorted with one base flipped out from the DNA duplex in the active center, which facilitates the hairpin formation by a potential two-metal ion catalytic mechanism'; RAG stays at the junctions until repair enzymes act
- L5: Transposition brake: 'RAG1 R848 and the RAG2 acidic hinge suppress RAG-mediated transposition in vivo more than 1000-fold'; removing the acidic hinge 'increased in vivo transposition activity ~100-fold'; R848M gives 'a striking (~8-fold) increase in transposition activity' in vitro
developing lymphocyte lineage: ordered rearrangement, allelic exclusion, clonal inheritance (cell lineage)
- L1: Developing lymphocytes in the primary lymphoid organs (bone marrow for B cells, thymus for T cells), from multipotent hematopoietic stem cells; RAG and TdT present only at these stages
- L2: Ordered rearrangement: in the heavy chain 'the first recombination event to occur is between one D and one J gene segment', then V to DJ; light chains join V to J only; TCR beta rearranges D to J then V to DJ before the alpha chain
- L3: Allelic exclusion: 'allelic exclusion is then enforced via feedback inhibition where the functional Ig gene inhibits V(D)J rearrangement of the second allele', by blocking V to D-J juxtaposition, lowering transcription and 'suppression of RAG accessibility'; in the asynchronous instructive model 'the second allele undergoes rearrangement only if the first rearrangement was unsuccessful'
- L4: Checkpoints: out-of-frame cells arrest ('the development of the cell will be arrested, and the cell will not survive to maturity'); 'If no successful rearrangement occurs on either chromosome, the cell dies'; self-reactive cells are pruned by apoptosis, or a B cell may re-run the rule (receptor editing)
- L5: Clonal inheritance: 'the gene rearrangement leads to an irreversible change in the DNA of each cell', so 'all progeny (offspring) of that cell inherit genes that encode the same receptor specificity, including the memory B cells and memory T cells'
Who fills each layer
- L1: Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
- L2: Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
- L3: Chromatin
- L6: Antigen-receptor loci: the immunoglobulin and T-cell-receptor gene-segment loci
Sources (13) published science
Allelic exclusion (Wikipedia, rev 1374450631, via Wikimedia Enterprise; read in full) (behind its links)
Central tolerance (Wikipedia, rev 1374196544, via Wikimedia Enterprise; selection and outcomes sections read) (behind its links)
Recombination signal sequences (Wikipedia, rev 1158005285, via Wikimedia Enterprise; read in full) (behind its links)
Terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (Wikipedia, rev 1378403812, via Wikimedia Enterprise; abstract and function sections read) (behind its links)
Clonal selection (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Non-homologous end joining (Wikipedia, rev 1372444836, via Wikimedia Enterprise; V(D)J, end-processing, bacteria and dysfunction sections read) (behind its links)
Genetic code (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
CTCF (encyclopedia, Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)