← all systems · see it in The System
Management
Management is the administration of organisations (businesses, nonprofits, government bodies): the process of managing their resources, and the people who do it. Fayol's classic statement: 'To manage is to forecast and to plan, to organize, to command, to co-ordinate and to control'. Organisational research studies it as a practice and as a cadre: the hierarchy of senior, middle and line managers; the theories from Taylor's scientific management (1911) and Fayol through the human relations movement (Hawthorne, Mayo), Weber's bureaucracy, McGregor's Theory X and Y, management by objectives (Drucker 1954), quality management (Shewhart and Deming's plan-do-check-act) to evidence-based management; and what managers actually do, measured in diaries and surveys (CEOs spend about 70% of their time interacting with others; management practices scored in over 11,000 firms in 34 countries). Economists now treat measured management practices as a technology that raises productivity and diffuses slowly.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Management (top and lower levels) |
| born at | late 19th century (booked; contested: C-2712) |
| born precision | decades |
| boundary | Inside: the managers of an organisation (senior management with the CEO, middle managers, line managers and supervisors) and the managerial work they do: forecasting and planning, organising, commanding or leading, coordinating and controlling, with the practices that carry it (monitoring, targets, incentives and people management, written procedures, records and reviews). Outside: the work being managed and the people doing it (who are 'managed'), the owners and boards that hire and fire senior managers, customers, rivals, the state and the wider economy. The line is blurred at the bottom (line managers 'are usually considered part of the workforce rather than the organization's management class') and where workers' self-management distributes management functions among workers. |
| nested level | Built from people in managerial roles, the hierarchy of offices that routes information and problems, and the practices and records they use; a part of every organisation, firm, business and corporation (their decision and direction floor); runs on people's minds and talk; studied as a field (business administration, public administration). |
| scale | social |
Measures (23) published science
| characteristic clock: plant manager tenure in post | 6.4 years in post, 13.0 years in the company |
| characteristic clock: CEO working week | about 50 (202 fifteen-minute blocks) hours per week |
| share of CEO time spent interacting with others | 70 percent |
| depreciation rate of managerial capital | 0.119 (s.e. 0.053) in Table 2; 12.9% in the text per year |
| adjustment cost parameter for management | 0.212 (s.e. 0.062), against 0.195 for capital parameter |
| share of CEO time on emergencies | 4 percent |
| share of CEOs mismatched to their firm | 17 (36 in lower-income vs 5 in high-income countries) percent |
| share of TFP differences accounted for by management practices | about 30 percent |
| productivity gain from adopting modern management practices (Indian textile plants, randomised) | 11 (annual profit about $230,000 higher) percent |
| share of treatment plants recording vs monitoring quality defects before the intervention | 93 recorded; 29 monitored daily or by defect type percent |
| value of a boss: output gain, 10th to 90th percentile boss | about one extra worker on a nine-member team; average boss about 1.75 times as productive as the average worker team output |
| subordinate sales change per doubling of the new manager's pre-promotion sales | -7.5 percent |
| promotion probability per doubling of sales | +14.3 relative to the base rate percent |
| persistence of a boss's effect | about one-fourth remains one year after the worker leaves the boss fraction |
| CEO span of control (direct reports) | 4.4 (median 4) in 1986; 8.2 (median 7) in 1998 positions |
| manager's span in a knowledge hierarchy | n0 = 1 / (h (1 - q0)): workers per manager, from the communication cost h and the share of problems workers solve q0 |
| pig iron loaded per man per day, before and after task management (Bethlehem) | 12.5 before; 47-48 after (47.5 by Schmidt on day one); wages $1.15 to $1.85 a day long tons per man per day |
| fuel saved by information, targets and prosocial incentives to captains | 266,000-704,000 kg ($209,000-$553,000) in eight months; treatment cost $855 per group in postage kg of fuel |
| hazard ratio for IHD per 1 SD better leadership, 4 years in the workplace | 0.61 (95% CI 0.47 to 0.80); 3122 men, 74 events, mean follow-up 9.7 years hazard ratio |
| hospital management-quality associations: positive / negative / null | 55 (49.5%) / 1 (1%) / 55 (49.5%) of 111, in 25 studies associations |
| share of US manufacturing firms with a personnel department | under 1 in 20 (1915); over one-third (1929) fraction of firms |
| management practices surveyed | over 11,000 firms in 34 countries; 18 practices scored 1-5 |
| CEO diaries | 1,114 CEOs in six countries; 42,233 activities |
Open contentions (6) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-413 Where do thoughts come from?
booked: No theory is proven, so the map lists the main ones side by side and doesn't pick one. It shows where thinking is handled in the brain, not where thoughts start.
the other reading: the theories of where thoughts come from, none proven (SPEC) - C-2453 Why do firms exist?
booked: The map keeps the competing theories.
the other reading: transaction costs; team production and monitoring; nexus of contracts; managerial and behavioural theories - C-2709 Does being watched change how people work?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: no Hawthorne effect worth the name; a real, general reactivity to being observed - C-2712 When did management begin?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: armies as the prototype (Maurice of Orange, 16th century; via Giddens); management of enslaved people in the pre-1861 US economy; older administration (no source read dates it) - C-2713 Is good management a technology or a style?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: management by design: practices contingent on the firm's setting; hospitals: about half the tested associations null - C-2720 Does promoting the best workers cost firms good managers?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: inefficient promotion decisions; promotion-based incentives worth the mismatch cost; random promotion would do better (agent-based model)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (16) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Management. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- holding / entrainment (structural)
The management system sets when its parts work and rest (Schmidt 'worked when he was told to work, and rested when he was told to rest') and controls their number through hiring, promotion and separation. - same role, different builds (structural)
The job of coordinating work is done by a command hierarchy (management), by prices across a market (Coase, via Bandiera et al.), and by workers' self-management where management functions are spread among workers. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (structural)
Before: 'almost all of the work and the greater part of the responsibility were thrown upon the men' (each worker planned and did). The cut: an almost equal division of work and responsibility between management and workmen, with planning taken to a planning department. What was built after it: a ma - templating (structural)
The same management practices (38 binary practices; the WMS's 18) work when copied: firms spread them from treated plants to their other plants; Taylor's 'one best method' standardised for every worker. - The carry (structural)
Management by exception: each worker solves the share q0 of problems their knowledge covers and passes the excess (1 - q0) to the manager above; the manager's span is set by how much overflow arrives (n0 = 1/(h(1 - q0))). Line managers in turn channel what they cannot resolve to mid-level managers. - trade one property for another (structural)
Promoting on current sales buys incentives (and avoids politicking) and pays with worse managers: firms 'appear willing to forgo a 30 percent improvement in subordinate performance'. Second form: CEO 'leaders' and 'managers' suit different firms; the wrong match costs productivity. - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (structural)
Managers take in the organisation through their own channels (records, talk, problems passed up, owners' mandate) and each CEO picks a different slice: bottom-quartile CEOs spend just over 40% of time in meetings, top-quartile 65%; most attend to insiders; leaders and managers meet different people. - who opens the door (structural)
A problem crossing from worker to manager meets a receiver placed in advance: the hierarchy exists because 'agents do not know who may know the solution', so the organisation installs the problem solver ahead of time (a port). - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Borrowed: consultants diagnosed and implemented 38 practices for five months. Held: firms spread them to their own other plants. Partial because some treated plants later lost practices when plant managers left. - partner-becomes-part (partial)
Communication technology let individuals of different skills 'abandon self-employment and form teams', with complementarities (gain/gain); no inheritance between them, so partial. - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Fayol and colleagues built a general theory of administration independently of Taylor's scientific management, from the same industrial setting; both are counted founders of modern management. Shared parts not itemised in sources read: partial. - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Two forms. Signal: every problem handed up costs the manager a communication cost h, so the hierarchy pays per hand-off. Upkeep: management capital depreciates about 12-13% a year and practices slip when the plant manager leaves, so keeping it costs continual investment. Mismatch: CEOs mismatched to - the whole sets the local reference (partial)
Management by objectives synchronises each person's goals with the organisation's and measures each against set standards: the whole fixes the reference each part is checked against. - causal ceiling (surface)
Graicunas: each added subordinate adds many potential relationships; a manager's span is bounded by time and subordinates' knowledge. Read as a time budget, not a structural limit: surface. - outside-to-inside (surface)
Personnel management moved inside firms (dedicated departments from under 1 in 20 in 1915 to over a third in 1929); self-employed problem solving moved inside hierarchies. The outside phase is not shown as a gradient in the environment: surface. - seed (surface)
Taylor's decomposition and documentation of work made later automation and offshoring easier; whether this unpacks vast new combinatorics is not shown: surface.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (12) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:human-society · Management gain
- Government via sys:human-society · Management mixed
- Computer via sys:organization · Management gain
- Market and trade via sys:human-society · Management mixed
- Labour market via sys:human-society · Management mixed
- Firm (the economic unit) via sys:market · Management gain
- Accounting (the field and practice) via sys:economy · Management gain
- Trade unions, friendly societies, cooperatives via sys:human-society · Management mixed
- Organization via sys:human-society · Management gain
- Corporation via sys:human-society · Management mixed
- Business via sys:market · Management gain
- Management consulting and business schools via sys:organization · Management gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (14)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Organization
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Hierarchy of offices
- Management accounting
- Planning department (Taylor)
- Management practices (monitoring, targets, incentives)
- Corporation
- Business
- Shareholders and managers over the use of corporate cash (the agency problem)
- Owners and managers over the firm's surplus (agency)
- Management and labour competing over methods and the gains of work
- Whose interests the corporation is run for
- Managers against shareholders (the agency conflict)
Sits inside / holds (5)
expressed by (21)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Quality Improvement/Refinement
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Encapsulation & Modularity (Abstraction)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Symbiosis/Co-Creation (Collaborative Specialization)
- Distributed Autonomy/Decentralized Execution (Subsidiarity)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Sensing/Scanning
- Hypothesis/Goal Selection
- Uncertainty Reduction/Learning
- Active Experimentation / Probing (Optimal Experimental Design)
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Effectiveness
- Triage & Prioritized Allocation
- Quality Control & Error Correction
- Bridging Supply Gaps (Store & Dormancy)
floor filled by (16)
- Firm (the economic unit)
- Organization
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Language (human language)
- Computer
- Bureaucracy
- Accounting (the field and practice)
- Hierarchy of offices
- Quality management (PDCA)
- Planning department (Taylor)
- Management practices (monitoring, targets, incentives)
- Line management (supervisors, team leaders)
- Middle management
- Senior (top) management
- Corporation
- Business
Kinds (18)
- Bureaucracy
- Public administration
- 'Leader' CEOs
- Human relations management
- Quality management (PDCA)
- Scientific management (Taylorism)
- Theory Y management
- Workers' self-management
- Theory X management
- Evidence-based management
- Nonprofit management
- 'Manager' CEOs
- Line management (supervisors, team leaders)
- Management by objectives
- Fayolism (general theory of administration)
- Middle management
- Senior (top) management
- Operations research ('management science')
wired (11)
- Accounting (the field and practice)
- Organisational culture
- Human (Homo sapiens)
- Hierarchy of offices
- Human resources
- Marketing
- Employees in positions
- Subsidiaries (in a corporate group)
- Establishments (plants, stores)
- Board of directors
- Shareholders (members)
Notes published science
- The most famous experiment in management, the Hawthorne lighting study where 'every change in light, even dimmer, raised output', turns out to be fiction: when Levitt and List found the lost data, the remarkable pattern wasn't there. Yet eighty years later, simply telling airline captains their fuel use was being studied made them fly more efficiently. (src:levitt-list-2011-hawthorne, src:gosnell-2020-captains)
- A hierarchy works like column addition: each worker solves the problems their knowledge covers and 'carries' the rest up to the manager, and the manager's team size is set by how much overflow arrives. Its purpose, the authors say, is to protect the knowledgeable 'from easy questions others can solve'. (src:garicano-rh-2006-hierarchies)
- Firms promote their best salespeople, but each doubling of a new manager's own past sales goes with a 7.5 percent drop in their team's sales; firms seem to accept losing about 30 percent of team performance to keep promotions as a reward. And employees whose managers were rated better had markedly less heart disease over nearly ten years. (src:benson-2019-peter, src:nyberg-2009-wolf)
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
management as organisational research describes it: the organisation's work to decisions acted back on it (reader's view)
- L1: The organisation's work and its world: people at work, materials, money, customers, rivals; the resources of businesses, governments and other organisations
- L2: What reaches managers: records of the work (output, quality defects, inventory, costs) and, above all, talk: meetings, calls, plant visits (70% of CEO time interacting; Mintzberg's managers 70-80% communicating)
- L3: The hierarchy that routes it: line managers and supervisors, middle managers, senior management; workers solve the common problems and pass the exceptions up (management by exception); middle managers relay goals down
- L4: Control: progress checked against plans; monitoring practices that track what goes on inside the firm; the check in plan-do-check-act
- L5: Organising and coordinating: human and nonhuman resources put in place; structure, roles, span of control, delegation to middle managers
- L6: Planning and objectives: forecasting, action plans decided in advance, strategic goals and policies, targets set and tracked, objectives shared down the line
- L7: Leading and deciding, acted back on the work: commanding (getting people to do what must be done), assigning tasks, teaching and motivating, allocating resources, hiring and promoting, speaking for the organisation
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L4: Control: progress checked against plans; monitoring (track what goes on inside, use it for continuous improvement); the check of plan-do-check-act
- L5: Organising and coordinating: structure and roles; span of control (CEO direct reports 4.4 in 1986, 8.2 in 1998); delegation to middle managers once information flows; bureaucracy's fixed rules
- L6: Planning and objectives: forecasting, strategic goals and policies, targets set and tracked, individual goals synchronised with the organisation's (MBO)
- L7: Leading and deciding: commanding, teaching and motivating, allocating resources, promoting; the CEO's behaviour type (leader or manager)
way in: Law and public scrutiny
- L1: Legislatures and courts examining how work is managed
- L2: Rules on methods: standardising allowed, stop-watch time study only with workers' consent
way in: Management knowledge: books, schools, consultants
- L1: A body of management methods in the world: Taylor's science of work, Fayol, MBO, PDCA; business schools from 1921
- L2: Carriers: consultants, degree programmes, the firm's own other plants
- L3: Diagnosis on the plant's own data: a performance database and recommendations
- L4: The practice tried and checked: implementation support, then kept or spread
way in: Market pressure: customers and rivals
- L1: Customers' orders and rivals' competition
- L2: Orders tracked by deadline; demand elasticity faced
- L3: Profits and the threat of exit: poorly managed firms cannot cover fixed cost
way in: Owners and the board: mandate from above
- L1: Shareholders vote for the board
- L2: The board sets corporate strategy and hires, evaluates and fires the CEO
- L3: The CEO implements and determines broad policy within the board's framework
way in: Problems passed up: what workers cannot solve
- L1: Workers drawing problems in production
- L2: The unsolved fraction passed on: a fraction (1 - q0) of all problems
- L3: Line managers solve or channel up what they cannot resolve
way in: Records of the work: output, quality, inventory, costs
- L1: The work's events: output made, defects, stock, energy used, costs
- L2: Recording: paper sheets, defect logs by type, daily stock records
- L3: Analysis and aggregation: a severity-weighted Quality Defects Index; by shift, loom and design; computers
way in: Talk: meetings, calls, plant visits
- L1: People in and around the organisation speaking: employees, C-suite, clients, suppliers, consultants
- L2: Meetings, plant visits, calls, video and email: 70% of CEO time; Mintzberg 70-80% communicating
- L3: Selection of who is heard: insiders over outsiders, one-to-one with core functions or multi-function high-level meetings
way in: The manager's own style and assumptions
- L1: The manager as a person: assumptions about why people work (Theory X or Y)
- L2: A behavioural type, stable after hiring: 'leader' or 'manager'
- L3: The day's plan: activities mostly planned, under 10% cancelled
way out: Direction down the line: tasks, instructions, job design
- L1: The work done as directed: when to work and when to rest
- L3: Relayed down: middle managers direct front-line managers, line managers assign tasks
- L6: Written instructions prepared in advance by the planning department
- L7: The decision of what must be done and by whom
way out: Incentives and targets: pay, targets, feedback
- L1: Effort changed: captains improved efficiency in all three flight areas
- L4: Performance measured and compared with standards
- L6: Targets and incentives set: personal targets, performance information, prosocial incentives, piece rates
way out: Resources allocated: budgets, schedules, inventory
- L1: Stocks held, orders sequenced by deadline
- L5: Inventory norms and order priorities set
- L7: Executive management sets budgets, procedures and schedules
way out: Staffing: selection, training, promotion, separation
- L1: People in jobs: hired, promoted, kept or leaving
- L5: Selection and training as a management duty (Taylor's second duty)
- L7: Promotion decisions, in practice weighted on current performance
way out: Voice outside: clients, suppliers, government, shareholders
- L1: Meetings with outsiders, usually by the CEO alone
- L7: Media and governmental relations and shareholder communication