← all systems · see it in The System
Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules)
The laws are arranged in casuistic form of IF (crime) THEN (punishment) - a pattern followed in nearly all later codes. ... [The entries are] arranged according to two principles ... 'opposition' - whereby a variable in one entry is altered to make another entry - and 'pointillism' - whereby new conditions are added to an entry, or paradigmatic series pursued, to generate a sequence.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Written law code (IF–THEN template) |
| arrives | Ur-Nammu c. 2100 BC (Ur-Nammu reigned 2112–2095 BC), 'the oldest known surviving law code'; Hammurabi c. 1753 BC. Earlier Urukagina reforms are known but not extant. Private land-sale documents date from the early 3rd millennium BC. |
| boundary | Inside: the casuistic entry (a protasis giving the case, opening 'if', bound to an apodosis giving the remedy), the two generating moves that make new entries from old (opposition, pointillism), the value rules for the remedy slot ('one crime, one punishment', silver fines or talion, class-graded remedies), and the shell: the prologue-epilogue frame with its divine grant and curse on defacers, the enacting ruler and the scribes who copied it. Outside: the codes' particular contents (debt relief, prices, rabies), the courts and judgments of the field (which rarely cited the codes), the script and surfaces, the silver it prices in, and the gods invoked. |
| nested level | A Seed within writing (booked; the scribal list rule is a rival parent). Arrives c. 2100 BC with the Code of Ur-Nammu ('the oldest known surviving law code'), with earlier Ebla material c. 2400 BC; unpacks into Lipit-Ishtar, Eshnunna, Hammurabi, Middle Assyrian, Hittite and biblical collections. The field (law) predates it by centuries and also ran without it (Egypt). |
| quantum | The casuistic rule template, 'IF (crime) THEN (punishment)', written down as a canon of entries. The stele or tablet is the carrier; the king is the codifier. |
| scale | social |
| shell | The barrier is written into the canon itself: the epilogue (lines 3360'–3641', the end of the text) 'invokes the wrath of the gods on any man who disobeys or erases his pronouncements', and Ea is implored 'to confuse any defacer of his stele'. A divine guarantee in the prologue (rule granted 'by the gods') and the basalt stele back it up. |
Measures (19) published science
| earliest surviving law code | Code of Ur-Nammu, c. 2100 BC (Ur-Nammu reigned 2112-2095 BC); 'three centuries older than the Code of Hammurabi' date |
| earlier, not extant or partial | a code of law found at Ebla c. 2400 BC; reforms of Urukagina c. 2350 BC (not extant) date |
| tariff clauses before Ur-Nammu (Ebla-Mari treaty) | 'Breaking a man's arm - 10 shekels of silver'; 'Tearing off a Mariote's beard - twenty shekels' (Arkhipov and Kogan 2026, Journal of Cuneiform Studies 78.1) |
| cuneiform law timeline | Ur-Nammu c. 2060 BC (as this page gives it); Lipit-Ishtar c. 1934-1924 BC; Eshnunna c. 1800 BC; Hammurabi c. 1758 BC; Assyrian law c. 1500-1300 BC; Hittite laws c. 1500-1400 BC date |
| Laws of Eshnunna tablets | copies of an older source dated c. 1930 BC; nearly sixty sections preserved date / sections |
| Code of Ur-Nammu laws | 57 laws, some 30 reconstructable |
| Code of Lipit-Ishtar provisions | almost fifty preserved, about half the code; total length about that of Hammurabi's provisions |
| Code of Hammurabi text | about 4,130 lines; prologue 300, epilogue 500, curse list 281 lines; laws numbered to 282 |
| Code of Hammurabi manuscripts | over 50, from Susa, Babylon, Nineveh, Assur, Borsippa, Nippur, Sippar, Ur, Larsa and more; copies up to 1,000 years after the stele manuscripts |
| Hittite laws | c. 1650-1500 BCE; CTH 291-292 listing 200 laws; copies in Old, Middle and Late Hittite (empire ca. 1650-1100 BCE) laws / date |
| omen series in the same IF form (Summa alu) | 120 clay tablets; over ten thousand omens |
| Ur-Nammu units | 1 mina = 60 shekels; 1 shekel = 8.3 g weight |
| Ur-Nammu tariffs | eye knocked out: half a mina; foot cut off: 10 shekels; tooth: 2 shekels; kidnapping: imprisonment and 15 shekels; perjury: 15 shekels silver |
| court record against the code | 'only one case out of thousands extant that might be said to revolve around a point of law' (Roth); no Mesopotamian legal document explicitly references the Code cases |
| China: first codification evidence | bronze inscriptions, 536 BC; Qin and Western Han codes 221-9 BC preserved entire date |
| Iroquois constitutional wampum | 117 articles; union of the five nations dated 1142 in the source |
| characteristic clock: a new royal collection | Ur-Nammu c. 2100 BC, Lipit-Ishtar 1934-1924 BC, Eshnunna c. 1930 BC, Hammurabi c. 1753 BC: one new collection every one to two centuries (interval derived from the sourced dates) years between codes |
| characteristic clock: the code as a set text | copied and studied by scribes 'for over a millennium'; in a late Babylonian (7th-6th century BC) list of literary and scholarly texts years |
| characteristic clock: Lipit-Ishtar's year name | 'The year in which Lipit-Ishtar established justice in the lands of Sumer and Akkad' (one regnal year named for the stele, as Roth argues) |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (6) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- seed (structural)
One slot format (if case, then remedy) plus two generating moves (flip a variable; add a condition or follow a series) 'let entries be generated infinitely': 57 laws in Ur-Nammu, 282 in Hammurabi, about 200 in the Hittite laws, and over ten thousand omens in Summa alu, whose entries begin 'Summa ... - templating (structural)
The casuistic form recurs code to code in four languages: Sumerian tukun-be 'if' (Lipit-Ishtar), Akkadian summa (Hammurabi; Eshnunna's 'summa awilum - If a man...' in 23 paragraphs), Hittite case laws ('If anyone tears off the ear ... 3 shekels'), and Exodus 21 (the goring ox, Hammurabi 250-252 and - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Retribution first done by the injured party or his kin ('feuds and vendettas'), then held by the rule and an enforcing body that ensures 'this was the only punishment' (an origin idea the source calls 'a common one'). - same role, different builds (partial)
Law held as a fixed set of articles on different carriers: cuneiform stelae and tablets (c. 2100 BC on), Chinese bronze inscriptions (536 BC), and Iroquois constitutional wampum, 'each component symbolizing one of the many laws within the 117 articles'. - who opens the door (partial)
The text's own epilogue installs the door to an illiterate hearer: a wronged man is to have the stele read aloud and know his rights, 'given the inaccessibility of scribal education'. - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
The same remedy slot filled toward the victim or onto the offender: Ur-Nammu 'institutes fines of monetary compensation for bodily damage', while Bertman finds that 'where earlier collections are concerned with compensating victims, the Code is concerned with physically punishing offenders' (talion)
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (11) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Corpus Juris Civilis (Justinian's codification: Codex, Digest, Institutes, Novels) via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- Law (rules and law) via sys:mental-representation · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) mixed
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:acoustic-wave · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- Religion via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with) via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) mixed
- Money of account (the unit of account: number applied to exchange) via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- Scribes (the literate guild that keeps and copies the code) via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary) via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) gain
- Insurance via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) even
- Risk management via sys:written-record · Written law code (the casuistic IF-crime-THEN-penalty template and its entry-generating rules) even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Law (rules and law)
- Casuistic entry (protasis case bound to apodosis remedy)
- Opposition and pointillism (the entry-generating moves)
- Lex talionis (the remedy-scaling rule)
- Prologue-epilogue frame with divine grant and curse (the textual shell)
- Scribes (the literate guild that keeps and copies the code)
- Written penalties against private vengeance for the retribution of wrongs
- The code against royal misarum-decrees for the authority judges cite
Sits inside / holds (4)
- Corpus Juris Civilis (Justinian's codification: Codex, Digest, Institutes, Novels)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- State (polity); the nation state its predominant modern form
- Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary)
expressed by (13)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Trail-Marking / Externalized Memory (Stigmergy)
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Physical/Virtual Barrier
- Self-Monitoring
- Validation of Identity/Intention
- Deterrence
floor filled by (2)
seed within (2)
- Writing (the practice of marking language on a surface, and the script plus rules it works with)
- Glossators' reading method (gloss and commentary)
Kinds (6)
- Code of Ur-Nammu
- Code of Lipit-Ishtar
- Laws of Eshnunna
- Code of Hammurabi
- Hittite laws (Code of the Nesilim)
- Covenant Code (Exodus 20:22-23:19)
Notes published science
- The law's biggest child may be fortune-telling. Hammurabi's entries are made the way Mesopotamian scholars made omen lists, by flipping one variable or adding one condition. The omen series Summa alu ('If a city is situated on a height') uses the same 'if' form and runs to over ten thousand omens on 120 tablets, against Hammurabi's 282 laws. The generator even wrote a case nobody needed: goats used for threshing (law 270), because the list of farm animals said a goat came next.
- The code's shell is written into the text itself. The epilogue spends 281 lines cursing anyone who erases the stele, calling on each god's own power ('may Adad ... deprive him of the benefits of rain'). An Elamite king took it as plunder anyway and had seven columns polished off. The more than 50 other copies, kept alive by a millennium of trainee scribes, gave most of the lost text back.
- The Seed lost its first contest. No surviving Mesopotamian court record cites the code, while 'numerous judgments cite royal misarum-decrees', and Roth knows only one case in thousands that turns on a point of law. The template thrived in the classroom and in later codes (Hittite, Exodus 21's goring ox) more than in the courts of its own king.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
mental representation: the conditional rule held by scribes, judges and hearers
- L3: Legal concepts: dinum and dittum 'can denote the law in general as well as individual laws, verdicts, divine pronouncements and other phenomena'; misarum both law in general and a royal decree
- L4: The conditional held as a structured content: sequence of action by -ma 'and'; the durative 'may express intention'; Eshnunna's laws 'composed in a mode that facilitated memorizing' (Goetze; Yaron: 'the ease of remembering the text')
- L5: Other minds in the rule: 'The laws also recognized the importance of the intentions of a defendant'
- L7: A shared tradition: Westbrook's 'fairly consistent tradition of "ancient Near Eastern law"', 'largely customary law'; lists 'central to Mesopotamian science and logic' (list science shared with omen lists, king lists and god lists)
sound: the stele read aloud to a wronged man
- L1: The epilogue's hope that 'any wronged man who has a lawsuit' may have the laws of the stele read aloud to him (3240'-3256')
written record: casuistic entries on stele and tablet (the IF-THEN template)
- L1: Carriers: a basalt stele 2.25 m tall (Hammurabi); a diorite stele placed in Nippur (Lipit-Ishtar); sun-baked tablets 20 by 10 cm (Ur-Nammu, Nippur); a clay cylinder of the Ur III period (MS 2064)
- L2: Signs: about 4,130 lines of cuneiform in Old Babylonian Akkadian (Sumerian for Ur-Nammu and Lipit-Ishtar), 'vertically arranged ... within boxes placed in bands side by side from right to left', already antiquated
- L3: The entry: a conditional sentence with 'the case detailed in the protasis ("if" clause) and the remedy given in the apodosis ("then" clause)'; the protasis begins summa (Akkadian) or tukun-be (Sumerian), 'except when it adds to circumstances already specified in a previous law'
- L4: Entry generation and order: 'opposition' (a variable in one entry altered to make another) and 'pointillism' (conditions added, paradigmatic series pursued) by which entries are 'generated infinitely'; entries grouped by area (laws 1-5 administration of law to 278-282 slaves)
- L5: Value rules for the remedy slot: 'one crime, one punishment'; silver fines for bodily damage (Ur-Nammu) or lex talionis (Hammurabi 196, 200); remedies graded by class (awilum, muskenum, wardum)
- L6: The shell: prologue and epilogue 'in ring composition around the laws' (300 and 500 lines), divine grant of rule, a 281-line curse on defacers; enacted 'in the name of a ruler'; copied in the scribal curriculum, over 50 manuscripts
- L7: Stated purpose: 'to prevent the strong from oppressing the weak'; 'truth and justice' (kittam u misaram); that a wronged man may hear the stele 'and know his rights'