EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

Contract

A contract is an agreement that specifies certain legally enforceable rights and obligations pertaining to two or more parties.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

born atfor the system: since antiquity; the oldest pictured a Sumerian sale around 2600 BCE; for one contract: at acceptance (on posting, under the postal rule)
born precisioncentury (system); moment (one contract)
boundaryInside: the agreement itself: the offer and its acceptance, the consideration or consent that makes it binding, its terms (express and implied), the parties' assent and signatures, the performance it calls for, and the remedies it opens on breach. Outside: the parties who make it (sys:human, sys:corporation, sys:state for treaties), the body of law that decides which agreements bind and enforces them (sys:contract-law, a partner, inside sys:law), the courts and arbitrators who hear disputes, the market whose transactions it records (sys:market), and the world of goods, money and events it is about. Where contract stops and tort, quasi-contract or a self-enforcing deal begins is not sharp (src:wp:contract; C-3348).
nested levelA part of the law of obligations (law's private-ordering outlet, Law L7 o-private-ordering) and the unit market exchange is recorded in (Market L3, transactions). Carried by people's speech, writing and conduct (Human L7 outlets speech and movement). Economics reads firms and markets as 'both contracts' (complete contract theory) or reads the firm as what replaces contracts when they cannot be complete (Coase, Hart).
scalesocial

Measures (20) published science

Grossman and Hart work on firms versus contractsten very intense days (summer 1983)
Code of Ur-Nammu (earliest law code with fragments found)c. 2060 BC date
first known expression of pacta sunt servanda (Hostiensis)13th century AD date
Ethereum smart contracts with recursion or loops (2020 sample of 53,757)35.3 percent
Hart's coal-mine example: time into the relationship when the gap bites10 years
bonobo resumption of interrupted grooming (targeted / untargeted)80 / 83 percent
efficient breach first stated (Birmingham)1970 year
The DAO drain (June 2016)approximately 50 million US dollars
great apes resuming natural joint actions with the original partner71.0 (N = 1052) percent
"smart contract" in use by Szaboby 1996 year
US UCC threshold for a written contract for goods500 US dollars
ether exploited / share of ether at stakeat most 8,487 ETH / 0.27 ETH / percent
first formal contract theory in economics (Arrow)1960s decade
bonobo resumption of interrupted solitary activity (targeted / untargeted)50 / 66 percent
Statute of Frauds (writing required for some contracts)1677 year
vulnerable smart contracts surveyed / share exploited23,327 / 1.98 count / percent
Nobel prize for contract theory (Hart, Holmström)2016 year
oldest contract pictured (Sumerian sale of a field and house)around 2600 BCE date
software shoppers who open the EULA for at least one second0.1-0.2 percent
software companies in the EULA readership sample66 count

Open contentions (4) open contention

Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (7)

Sits inside / holds (2)

Trades with (valence) (16)

expressed by (15)

floor filled by (15)

Kinds (24)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

the boardroom (shared floors)

  1. L4: The law's tests: assent, consideration or consent, capacity, legality, certainty, intent to be bound, form; the vitiating factors
  2. L5: Performance and its governance: observation, incentives, renegotiation, the decision right in the gaps, trust and shading
  3. L6: Breach and remedy: damages, specific relief, rescission; courts, arbitrators, or code that enforces itself
  4. L7: The binding obligation: agreements must be kept; cooperation and trust made possible; risk and decision rights allocated

the contract as law and economics describe it: parties and what they exchange, up to a binding obligation acting on the world (reader's view)

  1. L1: The parties and what they exchange: goods, services, money, or promises to transfer them at a future date; people, firms and states with something the other wants
  2. L2: Offer and acceptance: mutual assent (the meeting of minds); an acceptance that mirrors the offer; intent read objectively, as a reasonable person would
  3. L3: The bargain's content: consideration (common law) or consent alone (civil law); express and implied terms; conditions, warranties; form (writing, deed, signature)
  4. L4: Validity: capacity, legality, certainty and intent to be legally bound; the vitiating factors (misrepresentation, mistake, duress, undue influence, unconscionability) that make it void or voidable
  5. L5: Performance and its monitoring: each party performs; the other observes; pay linked to informative measures; gaps met by renegotiation and by whoever holds the decision right
  6. L6: Breach and remedies: damages (expectation, reliance, liquidated, nominal), specific performance and injunction, rescission; the forum (court, arbitration, mediation) and the duty to mitigate
  7. L7: The binding obligation acting on the world: agreements kept (pacta sunt servanda); exchange across time made safe; cooperation and trust between parties who might otherwise distrust; risk shared and decision rights allocated, which shapes ownership and the boundary of the firm

way in: Breach and the injured party's claim

  1. L1: Non-performance, poor performance, part-performance, or something substantially different
  2. L2: Notice: a party may declare in advance that it will not perform (anticipatory breach)
  3. L3: Classified: a breach of condition lets the innocent party cancel; any breach causing foreseeable loss gives damages
  4. L4: Evidence: the signed document binds whether read or not; writing required for some contracts
  5. L5: The forum: court, or arbitration, mediation and negotiation as the clause provides

way in: Consideration: the value given in exchange

  1. L1: Something of value: money, goods, a service, giving up a legal right
  2. L2: It must be requested, come from the promisee, and not be past or a pre-existing duty
  3. L3: It need not match the promise in value (a peppercorn will do); in civil law consent alone binds

way in: Feeling shortchanged: the contract as reference point

  1. L1: What each party feels entitled to, set by the contract's terms
  2. L2: A party compares what it got with what it felt entitled to; discretion left by a flexible contract invites the comparison
  3. L3: Aggrievement turns into shading: performance kept within the letter of the contract but below the ideal
  4. L4: Breaking a promise carries an emotional conflict in the brain (DLPFC, ACC, amygdala)

way in: Reputation: what others say about a party

  1. L1: Past dealings, told on by others
  2. L2: Intermediaries gather and pass it on
  3. L3: Reputation as trust a party has built; a cost that can stand in for a court
  4. L4: In repeated or long relationships, trust builds and binds without the court

way in: The governing law: default rules, statutes and conventions

  1. L1: Many legal systems, each with its own contract law (common, civil, mixed, Islamic, CISG)
  2. L2: Choice of law and forum selection clauses pick which law and which forum
  3. L3: Default rules and implied terms fill the gaps; statutes limit what may be agreed (unfair terms, consumer protection)

way in: The offer and its acceptance (the other party's words, writing or conduct)

  1. L1: A party proposes: an offer addressed to a person, or to the world (a reward); an advertisement is usually only an invitation to treat
  2. L2: The offer is received in the mode it names; a revocation counts only when it reaches the offeree
  3. L3: Acceptance that mirrors the offer; a varied reply is a counter-offer and a rejection

way in: The other party's performance, observed

  1. L1: What the other party does: delivers, works, pays, takes care or not
  2. L2: Observability: the principals see each other's performance (or cannot: hidden action, moral hazard)
  3. L3: Informative measures: pay linked to every outcome that tells about the action taken, read relative to similar firms
  4. L4: Verifiability: whether a third party can confirm performance or breach

way in: The state of the world: events the contract did or did not foresee

  1. L1: Events arrive: costs and demand shift, impurities change, war or disaster intervenes
  2. L2: The contract cannot name every state of the world: it is incomplete
  3. L3: Clauses that excuse or adjust (force majeure, hardship) or a range of allowed prices
  4. L4: Who decides in the gap: the holder of the residual control right

way in: Transactions to a smart contract (code on a blockchain)

  1. L1: Signed transactions sent from wallets to the contract's address
  2. L2: The deployed code receives them at its own address; once deployed it cannot be changed
  3. L3: The code executes the terms; clauses are embedded so that breach is expensive
  4. L4: State changes and tokens move between contracts and accounts
  5. L5: Consensus secures the execution against tampering

way out: Code moves tokens (smart contract execution)

  1. L1: State changed and coins sent from one contract or account to another
  2. L6: A program enforces the terms built into the code

way out: Damages: money to the injured party

  1. L1: The injured party put where performance would have left it
  2. L6: Compensatory damages, usually expectation; liquidated damages agreed in advance; nominal damages as a record

way out: Decision rights, renegotiation and ownership (the firm's boundary)

  1. L1: Assets owned and firms' boundaries drawn; investment made or withheld
  2. L3: When the contract cannot protect an investment, buy the partner: ownership replaces contract
  3. L5: Renegotiation, or the holder of the decision right decides

way out: Performance: goods, services and money handed over

  1. L1: Goods, services, money transferred
  2. L5: Performance of what was promised
  3. L7: The obligation to perform

way out: Specific performance, injunction, rescission

  1. L1: The thing itself delivered (land, a unique painting), or the parties returned to before
  2. L6: An order to perform or refrain; or the contract set aside

way out: The written record (document, signature, deed)

  1. L1: A signed document that later readers (parties, courts) consult
  2. L4: Writing required for some contracts (land; sales over a threshold)

Sources (21) published science

Wikipedia: Contract
Wikipedia: Efficient breach (behind its links)
Hammerstein P. & Noe R. 2016, Biological trade and markets, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B 371:20150101, doi:10.1098/rstb.2015.0101 (behind its links)
Hart O (2017). Incomplete Contracts and Control. Prize Lecture, December 8, 2016 (Les Prix Nobel); also American Economic Review 107(7):1731-52, doi:10.1257/aer.107.7.1731 (behind its links)
Han TA, Pereira LM, Santos FC, Lenaerts T (2013). Good agreements make good friends. Scientific Reports 3:2695. doi:10.1038/srep02695 (behind its links)
Bakos Y, Marotta-Wurgler F, Trossen DR (2009). Does Anyone Read the Fine Print? Testing a Law and Economics Approach to Standard Form Contracts. NET Institute Working Paper 09-04 (published J Legal Studies 43(1), 2014, doi:10.1086/674424) (behind its links)
Baumgartner T, Fischbacher U, Feierabend A, Lutz K, Fehr E (2009). The neural circuitry of a broken promise. Neuron 64(5):756-70. doi:10.1016/j.neuron.2009.11.017 (behind its links)
Cuneiform law (Wikipedia, rev 1268822664, 2025-01-11, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Pacta sunt servanda (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Smart contract (behind its links)
Heesen R, Bangerter A, Zuberbühler K, Rossano F, Iglesias K, Guéry JP, Genty E (2020). Bonobos engage in joint commitment. Science Advances 6(51):eabd1306. doi:10.1126/sciadv.abd1306 (behind its links)
Heesen R, Zuberbühler K, Bangerter A, Iglesias K, Rossano F, Pajot A, Guéry JP, Genty E (2021). Evidence of joint commitment in great apes' natural joint actions. R Soc Open Sci 8:211121. doi:10.1098/rsos.211121 (behind its links)
Perez D, Livshits B (2019/2021). Smart Contract Vulnerabilities: Vulnerable Does Not Imply Exploited. arXiv:1902.06710 (USENIX Security 2021) (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Contract theory (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Standard form contract (behind its links)
Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences (2016). Contract Theory: popular science background to the Prize in Economic Sciences 2016 (Hart, Holmström) (behind its links)
Szabo N (1997). Formalizing and Securing Relationships on Public Networks. First Monday 2(9). doi:10.5210/fm.v2i9.548 (behind its links)
Trademark (Wikipedia, via Wikimedia Enterprise snapshot) (behind its links)
Hansmann H, Kraakman R, Squire R (2006) Law and the Rise of the Firm. Harvard Law Review 119:1333-1403 (Yale Law School open copy) (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Breach of contract (behind its links)
Wikipedia: Offer and acceptance (behind its links)