← all systems · see it in The System
Emotional contagion
Emotional contagion is a form of social contagion that involves the spontaneous spread of emotions and related behaviors. Such emotional convergence can happen from one person to another, or in a larger group. Hatfield, Cacioppo and Rapson (1993): "the tendency to automatically mimic and synchronize expressions, vocalizations, postures, and movements with those of another person's and, consequently, to converge emotionally".
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the spread itself, a sender's expressed emotion (face, voice, posture, movement, chemical cue, written post) and the receivers whose expressions and feelings converge on it, one to one or across a larger group. Outside: empathy, which adds individuation (telling one's own feeling from the other's); deliberate social influence, which social-contagion definitions exclude ("the recipient does not perceive an intentional influence attempt"); and strangers, to whom contagion spreads least. |
| nested level | A process carried by bodies: built from automatic mimicry, mirror and shared-affect circuits (premotor mirror neurons, insula, anterior cingulate, amygdala), oxytocin signalling and chemical alarm cues; one of the two broad divisions of social contagion (with behavioural contagion). Seen in fish (zebrafish fear contagion), birds and reptiles (contagious yawning), rodents, dogs, wolves, primates and humans, and in crowds and online networks. |
| scale | social |
Measures (21) published science
| characteristic clock: one yawn | usually 6 |
| characteristic clock: yawn-contagion window (mothers and fetuses after a yawn video) | 2 min |
| characteristic clock: mass psychogenic illness episode | for most cases, under 12 hours to days h-days |
| onset of contagious yawning before birth | 7 months gestation |
| fetal mouth-opening after mother speaks or sings, from | 25 weeks gestation |
| age below which contagious yawning is not reliable in children | 6 years |
| age above which dogs catch human yawns | 7 months |
| dogs yawning when a stranger yawned | 21 of 29 dogs |
| monkey inferior frontal and parietal neurons with mirror properties | about 10 % |
| freshwater fish species in Ostariophysi (Schreckstoff users) | about 64 % |
| all fish species in Ostariophysi | 27 % |
| Facebook experiment participants | 689,003 users |
| Facebook experiment duration | 1 week (January 11-18, 2012) |
| effect: positive words when positive content reduced | B = -0.1% (d = 0.02) % of words |
| effect: negative words when negative content reduced | B = -0.07% (d = 0.02) % of words |
| happiness: more likely happy with a happy friend within a mile / a happy next-door neighbour | 25 / 34 % |
| happiness spread reach | up to three degrees of separation |
| fire-walk sample: fire-walkers / related spectators / unrelated spectators | 12 / 9 / 17 people |
| Dodds et al.: variance explained by power and by danger | 45.5 each % |
| Dodds et al.: first two SVD dimensions of valence-arousal-dominance ratings | 90.9 % |
| mass psychogenic illness: patients reporting headache (nine outbreaks, 1980-1990) | 67 % |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (7) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Emotional contagion. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- who opens the door (structural)
Familiarity installs the receiver: yawn contagion greatest to kin, then friends, acquaintances, strangers, even for heard-only yawns; rodents for cagemates but not strangers; fire-walk heart rates aligned only for related spectators ("predicted by prior association"). - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Schreckstoff "evolved as a defense against environmental stressors such as pathogens, parasites, and UVB radiation and ... was later co-opted by predators and prey as a chemical signal"; selection for the alarm response is primarily at the level of the receiver. - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
Members converge on one state peer to peer with no map or central picture: spontaneous spread, simple and complex contagion by thresholds, emotional synchrony. - lightning (partial)
Runaway spread with no regulation: yawning is "a typical example of echopraxia and positive feedback"; dancing manias "sometimes for weeks", laughing or crying "to the point of death"; but mass psychogenic illness is transient, with rapid onset and recovery. - same role, different builds (partial)
Contagious yawning "may have evolved several times in different lineages": in budgerigars it does not seem related to social closeness, unlike primates and wolves; and in fish the alarm spreads by smell (Schreckstoff) or by seen distress (oxytocin). - holding / entrainment (surface)
The yawn is thought to synchronize mood in gregarious animals and to signal fatigue "in order to synchronize sleeping patterns and periods" (a theory). - same shape, opposite sign (surface)
One feed, two valences: reducing positive content lowered positive and raised negative posts; reducing negative content did the reverse.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (14) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Vertebrate (Vertebrata) via sys:aqueous-solution · Emotional contagion gain
- Online social network (Facebook News Feed, Twitter) via sys:written-record · Emotional contagion gain
- Mammal (class Mammalia) via sys:electrochemical-gradient · Emotional contagion gain
- Primate social group via sys:electromagnetic-field · Emotional contagion gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Emotional contagion gain
- Domestic dog (Canis familiaris) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Emotional contagion gain
- Social contagion via sys:mental-representation · Emotional contagion gain
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions) via sys:mental-representation · Emotional contagion gain
- Family (the human family as a system) via sys:mental-representation · Emotional contagion gain
- Emotion (feelings) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Emotional contagion gain
- Music via sys:acoustic-wave · Emotional contagion gain
- Dance via sys:electromagnetic-field · Emotional contagion gain
- Nonverbal communication via sys:sensory-environment · Emotional contagion gain
- Teacher via sys:sensory-environment · Emotional contagion even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (6)
- Automatic mimicry
- Mirror neuron system
- Amygdala
- Oxytocin signalling
- Contagious yawning
- Schreckstoff (fish alarm substance)
Sits inside / holds (1)
expressed by (8)
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Amplification/Scale-Up (Manufacture & Distribution)
- Sensing/Scanning
- Frontier Outposts / Sensing Extension
- Social Learning / Public Information Use
- Quick Harm Avoidance
- Validation of Identity/Intention
floor filled by (7)
- Circulatory system
- Social contagion
- Mental representation (beliefs, meanings, feelings and shared intentions)
- Family (the human family as a system)
- Music
- Nonverbal communication
- Teacher
Kinds (3)
Notes published science
- What spreads best sits on Dodds's danger axis: unpleasant emotions and high-energy displays are the most contagious (src:wp:emotional-contagion), and danger is 'nearly an equal mix of negative valence and positive arousal' (Dodds et al.). Keysers et al.: contagion evolved 'to prepare animals for dangers by using others as sentinels'. Contagion reads as a danger-sharing network, while large corpora show a 'safety bias' toward low-danger words.
- The door is the bond: yawns spread most to kin, then friends, acquaintances, strangers, even when only heard; fire-walk heart rates aligned only for related spectators; rats share pain with cagemates, not strangers. But budgerigars catch yawns regardless of closeness, so the same spread was built more than once, with and without that door.
- It starts before birth and runs deep: fetuses yawn when their mother watches someone yawn (from 7 months gestation, 2026 Current Biology, via src:wp:emotional-contagion), and in zebrafish oxytocin is 'both necessary and sufficient' for catching another fish's fear. Seed check said no: contagion collapses many states into one (convergence), the opposite of a Seed's unpacking.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
bodily arousal: heart rate and body temperature
- L1: Heart rate and body temperature in each body
- L2: Mother hens watching a chick in danger: heart rate increased, body temperature increased (stress-induced hyperthermia) only when the chick's behaviour matched the perceived threat
- L6: Shared arousal: "a strong alignment among the heart rates of fire-walkers and related spectators" that "did not extend to non-related spectators"
chemosignals in air: fear and disgust sweat
- L1: Chemosignals in sweat collected from men while they watched a fear-inducing or a disgust-inducing film
- L2: Women exposed to the sweat: sniffing and eye-scanning changed in accordance with sensory acquisition (fear sweat) or sensory rejection (disgust sweat)
- L3: Receivers produced fearful facial expressions to fear sweat and disgusted expressions to disgust sweat
chemosignals in water: alarm substance (Schreckstoff)
- L1: Schreckstoff released into water only when the sender incurs mechanical damage; a mixture including hypoxanthine-3N-oxide (from club, 'alarm substance', cells) and chondroitin sulfate fragments from mucus
- L2: Detected by the olfactory system; chondroitin sulfate activates a subset of olfactory sensory neurons; the nitrogen oxide group is the main chemical trigger
- L3: Receivers perceive a greater predation risk; young brook sticklebacks make the association less readily than adults (learning or development unclear)
- L4: Antipredator response in the receivers
- L5: Conditional production: metabolically expensive; male fathead minnows cease production in the breeding season, controlled by androgens
electrochemical signalling in receivers' brains (mirror and shared-affect circuits)
- L2: Mirror neurons: about 10% of neurons in monkey inferior frontal and inferior parietal cortex respond to both performed and observed actions; mirror neurons for mouth actions and facial gestures (Ferrari)
- L3: Shared-affect regions: anterior insula, anterior cingulate cortex and inferior frontal cortex are active when people experience an emotion and when they see another experiencing it; pain mirror neurons in the rat anterior cingulate, whose deactivation reduced emotional contagion
- L4: Amygdala: creates the pathway for emotional contagion; basal areas including the brain stem re-create in one person the physiological state of the other
- L5: Oxytocin: necessary and sufficient for observer zebrafish to imitate distress; striatum and lateral septum (homologous to rodent regions) receive direct projections from preoptic oxytocinergic neurons
light: faces, bodies and expressions seen
- L1: Light from the sender's face, eyes, posture and movements: "expressions, vocalizations, postures, and movements"; observing another person's yawning face (especially their eyes)
- L2: The receiver perceives the emotional expressions of the sender; contagion relies mainly on non-verbal communication
- L3: Automatic mimicry: "if someone smiles at you, you smile back"; the observer activates a motor representation of the observed facial expression that could lead to facial mimicry
- L4: The receiver's own expression, now shown to others: "One good gaper makes seven others gape"; convergence from one person to another or in a larger group
- L5: Display rules: organisational or occupational rules about the feelings workers should and should not display; surface-acted displays give poor contagion
mental representation: affect, social comparison and shared feeling
- L2: Affect: negative events elicit stronger and quicker responses, so unpleasant emotions are more likely to spread; the same valence shown with high energy spreads more | Dodds et al.: words' meaning is better described by power and danger; danger is nearly an equal mix of negative valence and positive arousal
- L4: Afferent feedback: "our own emotional experiences change based on the non-verbal signals of emotion that we give off"; facial feedback: only the weak version has substantial support (small effects)
- L5: Social comparison: people check whether their emotional reaction is congruent with those around them and use it as social information; recognizing emotions and acknowledging their origin can avoid contagion
- L6: Emotional synchrony between individuals; a group emotion forms and shapes cohesiveness, morale and rapport; leaders are more contagious than other members
- L7: Crowds: "the propensity for individuals in a crowd to unquestioningly follow the predominant ideas and emotions of the crowd" (Le Bon); organisational emotion cultures; mass psychogenic illness in cohesive groups
sound: voices, cries and heard yawns
- L1: Vocalizations and sounds: talking on the phone to someone who is yawning; mother hens sound vocal alarms when a chick is in danger
- L2: Heard yawns: the social asymmetry in contagious yawning remains when only yawns that are heard, but not seen, are considered
- L3: The mirror system also responds to the sound of actions (Keysers and colleagues 2002); a neuron firing when the monkey rips paper fires when it hears paper ripping
touch: body contact after another's distress
- L1: Body contact: bonobos sought more body contact after watching an event distress other bonobos than after their own stressful event; dogs approached a crying person, sniffing, licking and nuzzling
- L5: Consolation: comfort given mostly to kin and close ones (chimpanzees); mother-reared bonobos sought more contact than orphans
written record: posts and news feeds
- L1: Status updates and posts in the Facebook News Feed, read by friends; emails and chats
- L4: Readers' own posts: when positive content was reduced, positive words fell (B = -0.1%) and negative rose; when negative content was reduced, the reverse
- L5: Feed filtering: posts with positive or negative emotional content withheld from the News Feed (the one-week experiment, January 11-18 2012)
Who fills each layer
- L5: Social contagion