← all systems · see it in The System
Proton-proton chain
The proton-proton chain, also commonly referred to as the p-p chain, is one of two known sets of nuclear fusion reactions by which stars convert hydrogen to helium. It dominates in stars with masses less than or equal to that of the Sun. 'The proton-proton chain is, like a decay chain, a series of reactions. The product of one reaction is the starting material of the next reaction.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Proton proton chain |
| boundary | Inside: the reaction sequence from two protons to helium-4 in a stellar core: the weak first step (p + p or pep), the strong captures, the helium-3 branch point and the beryllium-7 fork, and the energy as gamma rays, positrons and kinetic energy. Outside: the star whose weight sets the core temperature, the neutrinos once they leave, the helium ash once made, and the rival CNO cycle that draws on the same protons. |
| nested level | A reaction chain built from protons and the light nuclei it makes on the way; embedded in the cores of main-sequence stars (dominant up to about one solar mass), with its second step also running alone in protostars and brown dwarfs. |
| scale | stellar |
Measures (25) published science
| energy per helium-4 (net, whole chain) | 26.73 (26.732 for pp I) MeV |
| mass converted to energy | 0.7 % of the four protons |
| first step Q (p + p -> d + e+ + nu) | 0.42 (1.442 including annihilation) MeV |
| astrophysical S-factor of p + p | ~4e-22 keV b |
| collisions that scatter instead of fusing | more than 99.99 % |
| characteristic clock: average wait of a solar-core proton before fusing | 9 billion years |
| characteristic clock: lifetime of a deuteron in the solar core | about 1 s |
| characteristic clock: lifetime of a helium-3 nucleus in the Sun | about 400 years |
| characteristic clock: complete conversion of the Sun's initial core hydrogen | more than ten billion years |
| chain completions in the Sun | 9.2e37 per second |
| protons converted in the Sun | 3.7e38 per second (of ~8.9e56 free protons); 6.2e11 kg/s |
| peak power density at the Sun's centre | about 276.5 W/m3 |
| share of the Sun's energy | about 99 (CNO 0.8-1.5) % |
| helium-4 by branch (one solar model) | I 83.3, II 16.68, III 0.02 % |
| energy lost to neutrinos by branch | I 2.0 (2.2 in the table), II 4.0, III 28.3 % |
| branch temperature ranges | pp I 10-18, pp II 18-25, pp III above 25 MK |
| onset temperature | about 4 MK |
| temperature dependence | about T^4 (10% rise gives 46% more) power law |
| pep : pp frequency in the Sun | 1:400 ratio |
| hep share in the Sun | about 0.3 ppm |
| neutrinos from deuteron synthesis | 91.65 (92.86 in AGSS09) % of pp-chain neutrinos |
| pp neutrino flux at Earth | 6.1e10 (Borexino 2014: (6.6 +/- 0.7)e10; SSM (5.98 +/- 0.04)e10) cm^-2 s^-1 |
| Borexino pp-neutrino rate | 144 +/- 33 per day (predicted 131 +/- 2) |
| dominance mass | up to about 1 (CNO above about 1.3) solar masses |
| deuterium-burning thermostat temperature in protostars | about 10^6 (rate ~T^11.8) K |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (4) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Proton-proton chain. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- borrowed-then-held (structural)
The chain's second step first runs on deuterium the Big Bang left: in protostars 'deuterium is the most easily fused nucleus available' and fusion 'can also proceed from primordial deuterium'; once that supply is gone ('after a few million years'), the main-sequence chain makes its own deuterons thr - same role, different builds (structural)
One job, hydrogen to helium, two builds: the pp chain is 'one of two known sets of nuclear fusion reactions by which stars convert hydrogen to helium', the other the CNO cycle; the pp chain goes through a weak step between two protons, the CNO cycle through borrowed carbon, nitrogen and oxygen. - same shape, opposite sign (structural)
pp and pep 'can be seen as two different Feynman representations of the same basic interaction, where the electron passes to the right side of the reaction as a positron': one emits a positron, the other captures an electron, and both make a deuteron and a neutrino. - who opens the door (partial)
Each floor installs the receiver for the next: the weak step makes a deuteron that waits about a second for a proton, the deuteron step makes a helium-3 that waits about 400 years; pp II/III need a helium-4 already present ('pre-existing 4He'), placed by earlier cycles or the Big Bang.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (12) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle) via sys:weak-field · Proton-proton chain gain
- CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle) via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain mixed
- Star via sys:gravitational-field · Proton-proton chain gain
- Positron (antielectron) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Proton-proton chain gain
- Electron neutrino via sys:weak-field · Proton-proton chain loss
- Proton via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain gain
- Helium atom via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain mixed
- Sun via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain gain
- Lithium atom via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain gain
- Beryllium atom via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain gain
- Quantum tunnelling via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain gain
- Nuclear fusion via sys:residual-strong-force · Proton-proton chain gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (13)
- Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle)
- Positron (antielectron)
- Electron neutrino
- Proton
- Beryllium-8 resonance
- Deuterium (hydrogen-2)
- Helium-3
- Lithium-7
- Beryllium-7
- Boron-8
- Deuterium fusion
- pp chain against CNO cycle for a core's protons
- Competition for the core's protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle)
Sits inside / holds (3)
expressed by (8)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Templating / Standardization
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Internal Coordination/Regulation
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Redundancy & Diversity
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (25)
- Proton
- Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle)
- Star
- Electron
- Photon
- Positron (antielectron)
- Electron neutrino
- W boson
- Helium atom
- Beryllium-8 resonance
- Competition for helium-4 in helium burning (carbon vs oxygen)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Deuterium (hydrogen-2)
- Helium-3
- Lithium-7
- Solar neutrinos
- pp IV (hep) branch
- pep reaction
- Lower main-sequence star
- Beryllium-7
- Boron-8
- Deuterium fusion
- Quantum tunnelling
- Diproton
- Nuclear fusion
Kinds (8)
- pp I branch
- Nucleosynthesis
- Hydrogen fusion
- Nuclear fusion
- pp II branch
- pp III branch
- pp IV (hep) branch
- pep reaction
wired (1)
Notes published science
- The Sun's pace is set by the weak force: more than 99.99% of proton collisions just bounce, the average core proton waits 9 billion years, and the bottleneck's S-factor (4e-22 keV b) is about 10^22 times smaller than the CNO cycle's. That weak-force tax is why a Sun-like star lasts ten billion years instead of exploding.
- Each step builds the door for the next one: the weak step makes a deuteron that waits one second for a proton; that step makes a helium-3 that waits 400 years. And before any star could make its own deuterons, protostars ran the chain's second step on deuterium left over from the Big Bang, as a thermostat holding them near a million degrees while they grew.
- The branches sign their work: each one writes a different neutrino energy (0.42, 0.861, 1.44, 14.06, 18.8 MeV), so a detector underground can read which branch ran. Comparing neutrinos with light, Borexino found 'the Sun releases the same amount of energy currently as it did a 100,000 years ago'.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
electromagnetic field: gamma rays and annihilation heating the core
- L1: Gamma photons: 'the positron will annihilate with an electron from the environment into two gamma rays'; each strong capture (d + p, 3He + 4He, 7Be + p) also emits a gamma
- L2: Thermalisation: 'Energy released as gamma rays will interact with electrons and protons and heat the interior of the Sun. Also kinetic energy of fusion products ... adds energy to the plasma'
- L3: Support: 'This heating keeps the core of the Sun hot and prevents it from collapsing under its own weight as it would if the sun were to cool down'; in the Sun 99% of the power comes from the innermost 24% of the radius; maximum power density about 276.5 W per cubic metre
gravitational field: the host core that sets the temperature
- L1: The host core held by self-gravity in hydrostatic equilibrium: 'The temperature and density of this core are at the levels necessary to sustain the energy production that will support the remainder of the star'
- L2: Temperature picks the branch: pp chain onset about 4 MK; below 10 MK slow; pp I dominant 10-18 MK, pp II 18-25 MK, pp III above 25 MK; rate about T^4 (a 10% rise gives 46% more)
- L3: Where it runs: up to a third of the star's radius and half its mass; above 0.35 solar masses the core is radiative, so 'there is little mixing of fresh hydrogen into the core or fusion products outward'; dominant in stars up to about the Sun's mass (the lower main sequence, F-type and cooler)
residual strong (nuclear) force: the chain's strong steps
- L1: Core protons above about 4 million K crossing their mutual Coulomb barrier by tunnelling: fusion 'can occur only if the kinetic energy (temperature) of the protons is high enough'; reactions happen near the Gamow peak
- L2: Deuterium fusion: d + p -> helium-3 + gamma + 5.493 MeV, 'mediated by the strong nuclear force ... extremely fast by comparison to the first step': each new deuteron lives about one second in the Sun's core
- L3: Branch point at helium-3, which lives about 400 years: pp I (3He + 3He -> 4He + 2p + 12.859 MeV, via beryllium-6), pp II and III (3He + 4He -> 7Be + gamma + 1.59 MeV), pp IV or hep (3He + p -> 4He + e+ + nu, about 0.3 ppm in the Sun)
- L4: Beryllium-7 fork: electron capture to lithium-7, then 7Li + p -> 2 4He + 17.35 MeV (pp II); or proton capture to boron-8, beta-plus to excited beryllium-8, which splits into two helium-4 (pp III, 18.209 MeV for the last stages)
- L5: Net: 4 protons + 2 electrons -> helium-4 + 2 electron neutrinos, 26.73 MeV per helium-4; 0.7% of the protons' mass converted to energy; about 99% of the Sun's energy output
weak interaction: the bottleneck and the neutrinos
- L1: W exchange inside a two-proton encounter: the first step 'is the rate-limiting reaction and is extremely slow due to it being initiated by the weak nuclear force'
- L2: p + p -> deuteron + positron + electron neutrino + 0.42 MeV (1.442 MeV with the annihilation). The usual result is a diproton that 'almost immediately' decays back to two protons; more than 99.99% of collisions scatter; the average core proton waits 9 billion years; S(0) about 4e-22 keV b against 3.5 keV b for the CNO bottleneck
- L3: Each start and branch writes its own neutrino energy: pp up to 0.42 MeV; pep (p + e + p -> d + nu, 1 per 400 pp in the Sun) a sharp 1.44 MeV line; beryllium-7 electron capture 0.861 MeV (90%) or 0.383 MeV (10%); boron-8 up to 14.06 MeV; hep up to 18.8 MeV
- L4: The neutrinos escape: they 'do not interact significantly with matter and therefore do not heat the Sun's interior'; pp I, II and III lose 2.0%, 4.0% and 28.3% of their energy this way; about 91% of solar neutrinos come from the pp reaction; flux at Earth 6.1e10 per cm2 per s; Borexino measured pp neutrinos in 2014 and pep neutrinos in 2012