← all systems · see it in The System
Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle)
Core hydrogen consumed by the pp chain and by the CNO cycle with nitrogen as catalyst.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| boundary | Inside: the protons of the burning core and the two takes, the pp chain (rate-limited by the weak first step) and the CNO cycle (rate-limited by proton capture on nitrogen-14). Outside: the star's gravity and hydrostatic balance that set core temperature, the envelope, the neutrinos that leave, and the helium ash once made. |
| compete fns | fn:resource-denial-attrition |
| nested level | Built from the proton pool and the two takers; embedded in a main-sequence star's core. |
| scale | nuclear |
Measures (17) published science
| CNO share of helium made in the Sun | 1.7% fraction |
| CNO share of solar energy | 1.5% (Main sequence); about 1% (Stellar nucleosynthesis, pp chain) fraction |
| equal-share core temperature | about 17e6 (CNO), 18e6 (Main sequence), about 20e6 (pp chain) K |
| CNO dominance mass | above 1.3 (CNO, pp chain) or 1.5 (Main sequence); 1.8 and above almost entirely CNO solar masses |
| pp chain temperature dependence | ~T^4 (10% rise gives 46% more) power law |
| CNO temperature dependence | ~T^16 to T^20 (10% rise gives 350% more) power law |
| average wait of a solar-core proton before pp fusion | 9 billion years |
| pp collisions that scatter instead of fusing | more than 99.99% fraction |
| pp helium by branch (one solar model) | I 83.3%, II 16.68%, III 0.02% fraction |
| energy per helium | pp 26.73; CNO 26.73 (25.0 net of neutrinos per Stellar nucleosynthesis) MeV |
| CNO energy within inner 15% of mass | about 90% fraction |
| Sun core temperature | about 15.7e6 K |
| pp neutrino flux (Borexino 2014) | (6.6 +/- 0.7) x 10^10 cm^-2 s^-1 |
| characteristic clock: lifetime of a deuteron in the solar core | about 1 s |
| characteristic clock: lifetime of a helium-3 nucleus in the Sun | about 400 years |
| characteristic clock: 13N beta-plus half-life (a CNO step) | 9.965 minutes |
| characteristic clock: complete conversion of the Sun's core hydrogen | more than ten billion years |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (3)
Sits inside / holds (3)
Trades with (valence) (4)
- Neutrino via sys:weak-field · Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle) loss
- Proton via sys:residual-strong-force · Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle) gain
- CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle) via sys:residual-strong-force · Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle) loss
- Proton-proton chain via sys:weak-field · Competition for core protons (pp chain vs CNO cycle) loss
expressed by (3)
floor filled by (15)
- Star
- Photon
- Neutrino
- Positron (antielectron)
- W boson
- Proton
- Helium atom
- Carbon atom
- Nitrogen atom
- Competition for helium-4 in helium burning (carbon vs oxygen)
- Deuterium (hydrogen-2)
- CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle)
- Proton-proton chain
- Upper main-sequence star
- Lower main-sequence star
Notes published science
- The pp chain is a slow door: more than 99.99% of proton collisions just bounce, and the average solar-core proton waits 9 billion years. The CNO cycle side-steps that weak first step with borrowed carbon, and at 10% more temperature its output rises 350% against the pp chain's 46%.
- Above about 1.5 solar masses the CNO take stirs its own pot: its output is so concentrated (90% in the inner 15% of the mass) that the core convects and keeps carrying fresh protons in.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
gravitational field
- L1: Self-gravity balanced by the fusion pressure gradient (hydrostatic equilibrium)
- L2: CNO-dominated cores convect (CNO share above 20%); the convective zone shrinks from 20% to 8% of the mass as the star ages
- L3: Upper vs lower main sequence: the split by mass at about 1.5 solar masses (F and cooler vs A and hotter)
radiation in the stellar interior (energy transport)
- L1: Gamma rays: positrons from the weak steps annihilate almost instantly with electrons
- L2: Radiative transfer dominates where the temperature gradient is low and opacity low enough for radiation to carry the energy
- L3: Convection takes over where the gradient is steep: the CNO cycle's strong temperature sensitivity makes massive-star cores convective (radiative envelopes); Sun-like stars have radiative cores and convective envelopes (neutral, UV-opaque hydrogen outside); the lowest-mass stars convect throughout
residual strong (nuclear) force
- L1: Core protons at 4e6 K (pp onset) to above 17e6 K
- L2: Two takes: pp chain (weak first step, each deuteron lives about a second, each helium-3 about 400 years) vs CNO catalysts (slowest step proton capture on nitrogen-14)
- L3: Temperature routing: pp ~T^4, CNO ~T^16-20 (T^17 in the triple-alpha article); equal at about 17e6 K (CNO article), 18e6 K (Main sequence) or about 20e6 K (pp article)
- L4: Outcome by mass: Sun 1.5% (Main sequence) or 1.7% of helium (CNO article) from CNO; stars of 1.8 solar masses and above almost entirely CNO
weak interaction (beta-plus steps and neutrinos)
- L1: The weak nuclear force initiating the pp chain's first step: the rate-limiting reaction, extremely slow
- L2: pp beta-plus: as two protons fuse one converts into a neutron, emitting a positron and an electron neutrino (p + p -> d + e+ + nu); the average core proton waits 9 billion years
- L3: CNO beta-plus decays of the radioactive nuclei (13N, 15O); their beta-decay timescale is faster than the fusion timescale; each cycle ends with one alpha, two positrons and two neutrinos
- L4: Neutrinos escape the star carrying energy away; they interact with matter only by the weak force and gravity. pp neutrinos up to 400 keV, flux on Earth 6.1e10 per cm2 per s; CNO neutrinos first detected by Borexino (2020)
Who fills each layer
- L2: Competition for carbon nuclei (oxygen vs nitrogen)
- L3: CNO cycle (carbon-nitrogen-oxygen cycle), Proton-proton chain
Sources (6) published science
Stellar nucleosynthesis (Wikipedia) (behind its links)
Main sequence (Wikipedia, rev 1378871868, 2026-10-06) (behind its links)
Carbon (Wikipedia), formation sections (behind its links)
Proton-proton chain (Wikipedia, rev 1378375625, 2026-10-04) (behind its links)
Stellar structure (Wikipedia, rev 1310601263, 2025-09-10) (behind its links)