← all systems · see it in The System
Weathering
The deterioration of rocks, soils and minerals through contact with water, atmospheric gases, sunlight and biological organisms, in situ (distinct from erosion, which transports the material); physical (mechanical) or chemical, with biological weathering as the living form of both.
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Weathering (physical, chemical, biological) |
| born at | continental weathering feedbacks likely by 3.8-3.6 Ga (Greber 2025); paleosols as old as the Archean (over 2.5 Ga); seafloor weathering possibly earlier (not dated in the sources read) |
| born precision | ~0.2 Gyr |
| boundary | Inside: rock, regolith, soil minerals and seafloor basalt being broken down and chemically altered where they lie, together with the water films, pore and fracture networks and reaction surfaces where agents meet mineral, down to the weathering front. Outside: the agents' sources (atmosphere, rain, ice, organisms, people) and the transport that carries the products away (erosion, rivers, groundwater). |
| nested level | A surface process of the rock cycle and the long-term (carbonate-silicate) carbon cycle, working in the critical zone between the air and fresh bedrock; built from physical, chemical and biological mechanisms acting on mineral surfaces. |
| scale | planetary |
Measures (34) published science
| Soil formation time | 100-1,000 years |
| Silicate thermostat response time | >10^6 years |
| Seafloor basalt density loss | about 15% per 100 million years fraction per time |
| pH of unpolluted rain | around 5.6 (acid rain 4.5 or even 3.0) pH |
| Volume increase of water on freezing | 9.2 % |
| Realistic upper frost-wedging pressure; granite tensile strength | 14; about 4 MPa |
| Ice segregation most effective temperature | -4 to -15 °C |
| Unloading stress toward a free surface | up to 35 MPa |
| Weathering speed-up in live versus sterile soil | 2 times (albite, muscovite) |
| Weathering speed-up under lichen | 3-4 times (hornblende granite, New Jersey) |
| Soil CO2 raised by roots | up to 30 % of soil gas |
| Chemical index of alteration range | 47 (unweathered upper crust) to 100 (fully weathered) CIA |
| Continental cover of sedimentary rock (weathering's product) | 66 % of continents |
| Paleosol layers in the Willwood Formation | over 1,000 in 770 m over 3.5 Myr layers |
| Share of Earth's carbon in the rock reservoir | 99.6 % |
| e-folding temperature of continental silicate weathering | 17-48 (inversion, 90% credible); 5-15 generally assumed K |
| Rise in continental weatherability since 100 Myr ago | 1.7-3.3 times |
| Basalt share of silicate weathering flux | one-third of flux from ~10% of silicate area fraction |
| Carbon moved to the lithosphere by silicate weathering | 47-72 MtC per year |
| CO2 released by rock organic carbon oxidation | 68 (+18/-6) MtC per year |
| Solid-Earth degassing | 79 ± 9 MtC per year |
| Share of Tibetan silicate CO2 sink offset by sulfuric-acid carbonate weathering | ~58 % |
| Net weathering CO2 drawdown as share of river CO2 emission (Qinghai-Tibet Plateau) | about 35 (15 continuous permafrost; >100 patchy) % |
| Rise in Mackenzie sulfate flux with 2.3 C warming | 45 (mainstem); 167 (Peel River) % |
| Weathering products retained in secondary minerals (Iceland) | Ca 30-67; Mg 45-81; Si 90-95 % of silicate weathering input |
| Mafic rock share of long-term silicate weathering flux | 15-30% (0.08-0.18 Gt CO2 per year) fraction |
| Acid deposited at Hubbard Brook since 1900 | 44.3 keq per hectare |
| Rise in phosphorus weathering flux at the Permian-Triassic | 93 ± 20 (2σ) % |
| Phosphorus liberation inflection | ~12 °C (CIA ~80) |
| Terrigenous share of ocean silicon, 3.8-3.6 Ga | near zero to 32 ± 15 % |
| Land area below which continental weathering is supply-limited | 1-1.5 % of surface |
| Phanerozoic global temperature range from weathering indices | 10-30 °C |
| Potential CO2 removal by enhanced rock weathering by 2050 | 0.5-2 Gt CO2 per year |
| Long-term cooling by CAMP flood-basalt weathering | 1-2 °C |
Open contentions (13) open contention
Where sources or readings disagree. Both stay on the map.
- C-194 How does frost break rock?
booked: The map keeps both mechanisms, and follows the growing evidence that ice lenses growing in cracks matter more than simple freezing expansion.
the other reading: frost wedging by volumetric expansion - C-208 Did deep-rooted plants speed up or slow down the weathering of rock?
booked: The map follows the view that trees and their fungal partners sped up silicate weathering and drew down carbon dioxide, and keeps the opposite readings alongside.
the other reading: plants raise weathering; compensating effects leave intensity unchanged - C-212 How strongly does rock weathering keep Earth's climate in check?
booked: The map treats silicate weathering as Earth's long-term thermostat, and keeps the findings that it may be weaker or less steady than thought alongside.
the other reading: 'a relatively insensitive rock weathering feedback, allowing for large temperature swings' (encyclopedia); no global correlation of weathering rate with temperature (Gaillardet, cited by Krissansen-Totton) - C-521 Do lichens wear rock down or protect it?
booked: The map keeps both: lichens can speed weathering several times over, and can also wrap and protect rock grains. A study finding little effect is kept alongside.
the other reading: lichen matrices protect and slow weathering - C-548 What mainly controls how fast rock weathers over long times: temperature or rainfall?
booked: The map follows the finding that temperature has mostly dominated over the last 480 million years, with rainfall dominant during the Pangea supercontinent.
the other reading: temperature control; hydrology (runoff) control - C-2154 How much does basalt weathering pull CO2 from the air?
booked: The map keeps the size of the effect contested.
the other reading: removal computed from base-cation loss assuming all alkalinity reaches the ocean - C-2202 Did flood basalt weathering cool the planet?
booked: The map keeps it contested.
the other reading: basalt weathering drove some coolings - C-2246 How strong is the weathering thermostat?
booked: The map keeps both readings.
the other reading: stabilising thermostat; relatively insensitive feedback - C-2553 How much of the land is sedimentary rock?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: 73% of land; ~64% of surface incl. metasediments - C-2554 Does weathering rock take carbon in or give it out?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: silicate weathering the governing long-term sink - C-2942 Why did the Hubbard Brook streams carry more calcium for decades after the forest was cut?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: temporary mining of soil minerals - C-3157 Does thawing permafrost weathering release carbon or store it?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: on the Qinghai-Tibet Plateau thaw raises net weathering drawdown, which may outpace river CO2 emission (Zhang 2026) - C-3171 Did the rise of the Himalayas cool the planet through weathering?
booked: The map keeps the competing readings; none is ruled.
the other reading: later studies questioned it; Tibetan silicate weathering 'not anomalous' and ~58% offset by sulfide-driven carbonate weathering (Liu 2025); uplift exposes rock organic carbon whose oxidation releases CO2 (Zondervan 2023)
Cross-scale patterns seen here (19) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Weathering. Each links to every other system that shows it.
- not-diluting wins (structural)
As mobile elements leach out, the immobile ones stay: in granite soil titanium triples and ferric iron rises tenfold; under intense leaching only bauxite (aluminium) is left; the CIA measures exactly this. - same role, different builds (structural)
Prying rock apart from inside a crack is done by growing ice lenses, growing salt lenses, plant roots and lichen hyphae, and by thermal expansion: one job, unrelated builds. - borrowed-then-held (partial)
Mineral nutrient release is done for ecosystems by abiotic weathering; regrowing forests take it up as their own job, investing photosynthate belowground to amplify weathering when phosphorus runs short. Both phases are in the sources, but not as one lineage's history. - conservation law plus closure (partial)
Carbon inputs must balance outputs on long timescales, but the balance alone does not fix CO2; it is closed by the weathering law (an e-folding temperature or a runoff dependence), whose form is the open question. - coordination-before-mapping (partial)
The planet's climate is held in a 10-30 C range for 539 Myr by countless local weathering sites each reacting to its own temperature and runoff, with no model of the whole. - lightning (partial)
Stored strain released at once: exhumed rock under up to 35 MPa toward a free surface shatters into sheets (and spalls in mines and quarries); thermal shock cracks rock immediately, though rarely. - nested ladder (partial)
Weathering products form a ladder of intensity: basalt goes to montmorillonite, then kaolinite, and only with intense leaching to bauxite; reaching each rung implies the ones below (kaolinite to bauxite only with intense leaching, as river water is in equilibrium with kaolinite). - same shape, opposite sign (partial)
One reaction run both ways: CaCO3 + H2CO3 -> Ca(HCO3)2 dissolves limestone on land and takes up CO2; its exact reverse, Ca2+ + 2HCO3- -> CaCO3 + CO2 + H2O, precipitates carbonate in the sea and releases it. The dark-twin rule is met at the level of one reaction (not 'weathering' in general). - same toolkit, independent builds (partial)
Plants, mycorrhizal fungi, lichens and bacteria each weather minerals with the same kit (protons, organic acids, chelating molecules, CO2), built in separate lineages. - symmetry breaking (name the cut) (partial)
Buried rock is pressed from all sides; exhumation removes load on one side, and 'the differential stress directed toward the unbuttressed surface' picks one direction, so fractures open parallel to the surface. - templating (partial)
One module, crystal growth fed by capillary films, works unchanged for ice and for salt: 'As with ice segregation, the surfaces of the salt grains draw in additional dissolved salts through capillary action'. - The carry (partial)
The wait: silicate weathering 'quickly becomes kinetically limited with increasing mineral supply', so fresh rock passes through faster than it can react; the other face, supply limitation, is reactions running to completion and waiting for new rock (below 1-1.5% land area on the early Earth). Overf - The Payment to Entropy (partial)
Weathering's alkalinity pays a toll at each hand-off from soil to groundwater to river: secondary clays and carbonates take up 30-67% of Ca, 45-81% of Mg and 90-95% of Si in Icelandic catchments (export efficiency about 0.33-0.70 for Ca), and marine calcification hands one of the two CO2 back. Form: - trade one property for another (partial)
Faster erosion buys fresh mineral supply and pays with weathering intensity ('weatherable material spends less time in the weathering zone'); landscapes settle at different points, from supply-limited lowlands to kinetically limited mountains. - who opens the door (partial)
At bare rock the door is open field (defects and dislocations built into the crystal); where roots and hyphae press acids against a grain, the living side has placed the opening ahead of time. - namespace completeness (the map predicts its gaps) (surface)
The order minerals crystallise in (Bowen's series) predicts the order they weather in, from bond strengths; the table is 'only a rough guide' (illite, silica are exceptions). - outside-to-inside (surface)
A broken sandstone shows chemical weathering 'progressing inward' from its surface: the oxidising surface environment moves into the rock as a rind. - runaway from an unstable balance (surface)
Without its water the thermostat stops: Venus lost its water, stopped removing CO2 and ran away into a greenhouse; carbon left unbalanced would give a runaway icehouse or excess CO2 within 10-100 Myr. No balance point is shown to be unstable, so surface. - Umwelt: each system carves its own slice of one shared medium (surface)
Of the shared surface world, weathering takes in only water, acids, oxygen, heat swings, ice, salts, unloading, organisms and people's work; light acts mainly as heat (UV matters for wood and plastics, not rock).
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (19) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Glacier via sys:aqueous-solution · Weathering gain
- Gravitational field via sys:gravitational-field · Weathering gain
- Bacterium (bacterial cell) via sys:biosphere · Weathering gain
- Atmosphere of Earth via sys:atmosphere-of-earth · Weathering gain
- Water cycle (hydrologic cycle) via sys:water-cycle · Weathering gain
- Soil and leaf litter via sys:soil · Weathering even
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · Weathering gain
- Fungi (yeasts, molds and mushrooms: absorptive eukaryotes with chitin walls) via sys:biosphere · Weathering gain
- Human (Homo sapiens) via sys:electromagnetic-field · Weathering even
- Mineral via sys:mineral-surface · Weathering gain
- Plant (kingdom Plantae) via sys:biosphere · Weathering gain
- Ocean via sys:aqueous-solution · Weathering even
- River via sys:aqueous-solution · Weathering even
- Lichen via sys:biosphere · Weathering gain
- Rock via sys:mineral-surface · Weathering gain
- Human society (from local community up to societies) via sys:mechanical-contact · Weathering gain
- Plate tectonics via sys:earth-crust · Weathering gain
- Sedimentary rock via sys:sediment · Weathering even
- Erosion via sys:weathering · Weathering gain
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (8)
- Mineral surfaces (rock and grain surfaces at a planet's surface)
- Aqueous solution
- Carbonic acid (H2CO3)
- Clay minerals (secondary, charged sheets)
- Regolith (the weathering profile: soil, saprolite, weathered rock)
- Joints, cracks and pores in rock
- Rock cycle
- Soil formation against erosion for the soil profile
Sits inside / holds (4)
expressed by (7)
- Generation/Synthesis
- Recombination/Composition
- Scaffolding/Enablement (Meta-Tooling)
- Niche Construction (alter environment)
- Interoperability/Transduction (Bridging)
- Resource Denial/Attrition
- Quality Control & Error Correction
floor filled by (24)
- Atmosphere of Earth
- Water cycle (hydrologic cycle)
- Soil and leaf litter
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Mineral surfaces (rock and grain surfaces at a planet's surface)
- Carbonic acid (H2CO3)
- Carbonate-silicate cycle
- Plant (kingdom Plantae)
- Ocean
- River
- Climate system (climate)
- Physical (mechanical) weathering
- Human society (from local community up to societies)
- Groundwater and aquifers
- Clay minerals (secondary, charged sheets)
- Biological weathering
- Chemical weathering
- Biosphere
- Erosion
- Regolith (the weathering profile: soil, saprolite, weathered rock)
- Joints, cracks and pores in rock
- Sulfide (pyrite) oxidation
- Critical zone
- Rock cycle
represents (1)
Kinds (5)
- Physical (mechanical) weathering
- Biological weathering
- Chemical weathering
- Seafloor weathering
- Enhanced (rock) weathering
wired (2)
Notes published science
- Rock can breathe out as well as in. When mountains lift up old seabed mud, the ancient carbon locked in it oxidises and releases about 68 million tonnes of carbon a year, as much as or more than silicate weathering pulls down; in about a third of the world's big river basins, weathering is a net source of CO2 (src:zondervan-2023).
- When the forests died at the end of the Permian, 252 million years ago, the planet lost part of its thermostat: without deep roots, weathering slowed, and the CO2 from the Siberian eruptions kept Earth hot for more than a million years (src:wei-2026).
- Ice cracks rock less by expanding than by pulling: a liquid film a few molecules thick on ice crystals draws water in from warmer rock, so ice lenses grow and pry the rock apart, up to ten times harder than freezing expansion would (src:wp:weathering).
- A cut forest digs for its dinner: after Hubbard Brook's 1983-84 clear-cut, the regrowing trees sped up mineral weathering for nearly 40 years to get phosphorus, paying with the soil's ability to buffer acid rain (src:bernhardt-2025).
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
the boardroom (shared floors)
- L3: The weathering mechanisms where every agent meets mineral: dissolution, hydrolysis and carbonation, oxidation, hydration (chemical); frost, thermal fatigue, unloading, salt growth, root and hyphal prying (physical); chelation and acids (biological). Cracking and chemistry go hand in hand.
- L4: The weathering profile (regolith): primary minerals turned into secondary clays and oxides, a resistate residue, solutes leached; down the column the profile reaches the weathering front; the chemical index of alteration runs 47 to 100.
- L5: The rate regime: supply-limited (reactions run to completion for lack of fresh rock) or kinetically limited (fresh rock passes through faster than it can react), set by erosion, temperature, runoff, lithology and life; temperature or hydrology may lead.
- L6: Export and landscape: alkalinity and solutes leave through groundwater and rivers (attenuated on the way by secondary minerals), loosened material goes to erosion, soils and landforms remain.
- L7: The long-term carbon cycle and Earth's habitability: silicate weathering (on land and seafloor) balances volcanic outgassing on >1 Myr timescales as a thermostat, while sulfide and rock-organic-carbon oxidation return CO2; weathering is also the main phosphorus source for life.
way in: Acid deposition (sulfur and nitrogen oxides)
- L1: Sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides from volcanoes and fossil fuels made into strong acids in rain
- L2: Acid hydrogen ions deposited on catchments strip nutrient cations
way in: Carbon dioxide (as carbonic acid)
- L1: Atmospheric CO2, and soil CO2 raised by roots and decay
- L2: CO2 dissolves in rain and soil water as carbonic acid, the main source of protons
way in: Freezing water in rock
- L1: Water in pores and cracks freezing, expanding by 9.2%
- L2: Premelted films feed ice lenses by capillary action (ice segregation); frost wedging only in small tortuous saturated fractures
way in: Fresh rock supply (uplift and denudation)
- L1: Uplift raises rock; erosion strips the cover and delivers fresh minerals to the near surface
- L2: Faster denudation shortens the time material spends in the weathering zone
way in: Heat and temperature change
- L1: Air and ground temperature, diurnal and seasonal swings, wildfire
- L2: Temperature sets reaction kinetics (an e-folding temperature) and, in buttressed rock, thermal stress
way in: Human work (quarrying, building, grinding and spreading rock)
- L1: People quarry, build with stone, mine, and spread crushed silicate rock on farmland
- L2: Grinding raises reactive surface area
way in: Life (roots, fungi, lichens, bacteria)
- L1: Organisms on and in rock and soil: roots, mycorrhizal fungi, lichens, mosses, bacteria
- L2: Chelating compounds, organic acids, CO2, hyphal plucking and root pressure at the mineral surface
way in: Oxygen
- L1: Atmospheric oxygen reaching iron-, sulfide- and organic-carbon-bearing rock near the surface
- L2: Reduced minerals and rock organic carbon exposed by denudation meet oxygen
way in: Salts in evaporating water
- L1: Saline solutions seeping into cracks and evaporating, in arid climates and along coasts
- L2: Salt grains draw in more dissolved salt by capillary action and grow lenses that press on the rock
way in: Seawater through ocean crust
- L1: Seawater circulating through upper oceanic crust in low-temperature, off-axis systems
- L2: Basalt dissolves and releases calcium; carbonate precipitates in veins and pores
way in: Unloading (overburden removed)
- L1: Erosion or a retreating glacier removes the rock above a deeply formed body
- L2: The outer rock expands; stress toward the unbuttressed surface opens sheets parallel to it
way in: Water (rain, soil and pore water)
- L1: Rain, meltwater and soil water reaching exposed rock and regolith
- L2: Water films on fresh crystal faces: surface ions attract water; H+ bonds to exposed oxygen and OH- to exposed cations
way out: CO2 drawn down (the silicate sink)
- L1: Less CO2 in the air (47-72 MtC a year moved to the lithosphere)
- L3: Carbonic acid consumed by silicate weathering; bicarbonate made
- L7: On >1 Myr timescales silicate weathering consumes CO2 and stabilises climate
way out: CO2 released (sulfide and rock organic carbon oxidation)
- L1: CO2 to the air (about 68 MtC a year from rock organic carbon)
- L3: Sulfuric acid from pyrite dissolves carbonate; rock organic carbon oxidises
- L6: In uplifting mountains of young marine sediment, weathering is a net CO2 source in about a third of major basins
way out: Landforms
- L1: The land surface itself
- L6: Landscapes made by weathering, erosion and redeposition: arches, limestone pavement, tafoni, exfoliation sheets
way out: Loosened material handed to erosion
- L1: Grains for wind, water, ice and gravity to move
- L4: Fragments, sheets and grains (granular disintegration, sheet separation, exfoliation)
- L6: Weathered and cracked rock is ready for transport
way out: Nutrients to living things
- L1: Nutrients in soil water and the sea
- L4: Released nutrients taken up through mycorrhizal fungi and roots
- L7: Apatite dissolution is the main phosphorus source for land and sea ecosystems
way out: Regolith and soil
- L1: Soil, built in 100-1,000 years
- L4: Residue and secondary minerals make the profile
way out: Solutes and alkalinity to rivers and the ocean
- L1: Runoff carries the products to the ocean, where calcifiers use them
- L4: Leaching carries solutes out of the profile
- L6: Alkalinity leaves the watershed, attenuated along the way
way out: Weathered buildings and monuments
- L1: Statues, monuments and ornamental stonework damaged
- L3: Stone, brick and concrete weather like exposed rock, faster under acid rain
weathering as geologists describe it (agents at the surface, mineral surfaces, reactions and cracking, the weathering profile, the rate regime, export and landforms, the long-term carbon cycle)
- L1: The agents at Earth's surface: water, carbon dioxide and oxygen, heat and its swings, ice, salts, organisms, people
- L2: Mineral surfaces, pores and cracks where the agents meet the rock; hydration of the crystal surface comes first
- L3: The mechanisms: chemical, physical and biological
- L4: The weathering profile: secondary minerals, residue, soil and saprolite down to the weathering front
- L5: The rate regime: supply-limited or kinetically limited; temperature, runoff, erosion, rock type and life
- L6: Export and landscape: alkalinity and solutes to rivers, loosened grains to erosion, soils and landforms
- L7: The long-term carbon cycle and habitability: the silicate thermostat, CO2 release by oxidation, phosphorus for life