← all systems · see it in The System
Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay)
'When the false vacuum decays, the lower-energy true vacuum forms through a process known as bubble nucleation. In this process, instanton effects cause a bubble containing the true vacuum to appear. The walls of the bubble (or domain walls) have a positive surface tension, as energy is expended as the fields roll over the potential barrier to the true vacuum.'
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Bubble nucleation |
| boundary | Inside: the bubble of lower-energy vacuum and its wall (finite thickness, positive surface tension gamma), the energy balance that sets a critical radius R_c = sqrt(3 gamma / 4 Delta Phi), the tunnelling rate per volume, the wall's acceleration to nearly c past R_c, what happens to particles entering the wall. Outside: the false vacuum it consumes (sys:false-vacuum), the instanton (bounce) that carries the tunnelling (sys:instanton), the seeds that lower the barrier (black holes, strings, monopoles). |
| nested level | The decay floor of sys:false-vacuum and sys:quantum-vacuum (their floor 5); carried by sys:instanton; its wall is a domain wall; its kinds include membrane nucleation (walked, projected) and Coleman-De Luccia tunnelling (with gravity). |
| scale | field |
Measures (8) published science
| critical radius | R_c = sqrt(3 gamma / (4 Delta Phi)) length |
| barrier height | Phi_c = 3 gamma / (4 R^2) - Delta Phi energy |
| tunnelling rate per unit volume (large barrier) | omega ~ (1/gamma) sqrt(2 Phi_c / hbar) exp(-Phi_c / hbar) per volume per time |
| Hawking-radiation window before a binary merger (proposed test) | ~10 ms |
| wall speed after R_c | approaches c extremely quickly v/c |
| first laboratory observation (ferromagnetic superfluid, ultracold atoms) | 2024 (Nat. Phys. 20, 558) year |
| dates of the theory | Stone 1976; Frampton 1976; Coleman 1977; Callan-Coleman 1977; Coleman-De Luccia 1980; Guth 1981; Linde 1983 (finite temperature) year |
| characteristic clock: mean wait for a nucleation in the Standard Model vacuum (the vacuum lifetime) | 10^139 (central), > 10^58 (95%) years |
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
Sits inside / holds (2)
Trades with (valence) (6)
- False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) gain
- Higgs field via sys:higgs-field · Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) gain
- Black hole via sys:gravitational-field · Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) gain
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow) via sys:thermal-energy · Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) gain
- Membrane nucleation (Brown-Teitelboim neutralization; projected model) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) even
- Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling) via sys:quantum-vacuum · Bubble nucleation (false vacuum decay) gain
floor filled by (13)
- False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum)
- Metastable de Sitter string vacuum (KKLT type; projected model)
- Black hole
- Thermal energy (heat, temperature and heat flow)
- Science (as a human social and cultural system)
- Anti-de Sitter spacetime
- True vacuum (global minimum)
- 't Hooft-Polyakov monopole
- Minkowski spacetime
- Cosmic string
- Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling)
- Domain wall (the bubble wall)
- Thermal bubble nucleation (finite temperature)
represents (1)
Kinds (4)
- Schwinger pair creation (field neutralization one dimension down)
- Coleman-De Luccia tunnelling (vacuum decay with gravity)
- Membrane nucleation (Brown-Teitelboim neutralization; projected model)
- Thermal bubble nucleation (finite temperature)
Notes published science
- In 2024 physicists watched false-vacuum bubbles nucleate in a cloud of ultracold atoms and found the rate matched instanton theory: a cosmic doomsday process run safely on a lab bench.
- A growing bubble has no gravity of its own: the negative energy inside is exactly paid for by the kinetic energy of the wall.
- Merging black holes might briefly brew true-vacuum bubbles whose debris would evaporate as Hawking radiation in the last 10 milliseconds before the merger: a proposed test.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
bubble nucleation (own: a bubble of true vacuum in the false)
- L1: Seed region: 'if a small region of the universe by chance reached a more stable vacuum'; 'instanton effects cause a bubble containing the true vacuum to appear'.
- L2: Energy balance: the interior gain 'tends as the cube of the bubble's radius', the wall cost 'is proportional to the square of its radius'; barrier Phi_c = 3 gamma / 4R^2 - Delta Phi; critical radius R_c = sqrt(3 gamma / 4 Delta Phi); 'smaller bubbles tend to shrink, while larger bubbles tend to grow'.
- L3: Tunnelling rate per unit volume for a large barrier: omega ~ (1/gamma) sqrt(2 Phi_c / hbar) exp(-Phi_c / hbar); seeds lower the barrier.
- L4: Growth: past R_c 'the bubble's wall will begin to accelerate outward'; its speed 'approaches the speed of light extremely quickly'; 'The bubble does not produce any gravitational effects because the negative energy density of the bubble interior is cancelled out by the positive kinetic energy of the wall.'
- L5: Wall and what crosses it: finite thickness, comparable to R_c when the barrier is much smaller than the energy difference (thick-wall instantons, 2022); 'Elementary particles entering the wall will likely decay to other particles or black holes'; trapped remnants: Fermi balls, Q-balls that 'eventually collide and decay either into black holes or true-vacuum particles'.
bubbles in curved spacetime (gravitational field)
- L1: Zero-energy bubble needed: 'For the vacuum to decay, building a bubble of total energy zero must be possible. In the absence of gravitation, this is no problem ... In the presence of gravitation, though, the negative energy density of the true vacuum distorts geometry within the bubble'.
- L2: Interior geometry: AdS, collapsing in 'microseconds or less'; or 'ordinary Minkowski space' for decay to a vanishing cosmological constant.
- L3: Seeds and fates: black holes as nucleation seeds (2015); bubbles collapsing into primordial black holes (2017); spinning holes stabilise (2019); merging binaries 'could provide the conditions to create bubbles of true vacuum' (2021).
thermal nucleation (finite-temperature decay)
- L1: A hot bath: the early universe or a laboratory superfluid at finite temperature.
- L2: Thermal activation over the barrier: 'Decay of the false vacuum at finite temperature' (Linde 1983); 'Small bubbles of true vacuum can be inflated to critical size by providing energy'.
- L3: Observed in an analogue: 'we observe bubble nucleation in isolated and highly controllable superfluid atomic systems, and we find good agreement between our results, numerical simulations and instanton theory' (Zenesini et al. 2024).
Who fills each layer
- L2: Domain wall network
- L3: Instanton (QCD vacuum tunnelling)
- L4: False vacuum (metastable electroweak vacuum)
Sources (5) published science
Zenesini et al., Observation of false vacuum decay via bubble formation in ferromagnetic superfluids, Nat. Phys. 20, 558 (2024), doi:10.1038/s41567-023-02345-4 (abstract) (behind its links)
Instanton (Wikipedia, rev 1375222432, via Wikimedia Enterprise) (behind its links)