← all systems · see it in The System
Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet)
'A causal set C is said to be manifold-like if C has a continuum approximation' (Surya); 'If, on average, the number of causal set elements mapped into a region of the manifold is proportional to the volume of the region then the embedding is said to be faithful. In this case we can consider the causal set to be manifold-like' (WP).
Properties published scienceour proposal
Sourced fields, and our own readings.
| aliases | Manifold-like causal set |
| boundary | Inside: a causal set whose order matches the causal order of some Lorentzian manifold and whose element count in each region matches its volume ('Order ~ Causal Order', 'Number ~ Spacetime Volume'), with the non-locality that comes with it. Outside: non-manifold-like causal sets (KR posets, bilayer posets, semi-orders), the dynamics that would select it, and matter fields on it. |
| nested level | A kind of sys:causal-set; built from its elements and links; its continuum approximation is a sys:lorentzian-manifold. Field scale, rung 1, hypothetical. |
| scale | field |
Measures (8) published science
| mean element count in a region of volume v | <n> = rho_c v elements |
| fluctuation | delta n = sqrt(n); delta n/<n> = 1/sqrt(rho_c V) elements; ratio |
| probability of at least one nuclear-size void (~10^-60 m^4) in a Minkowski region the size of the present universe (Dowker et al 2004) | order 10^84 x 10^168 x e^(-10^72) probability |
| valency of an element | infinite links |
| KR posets (non-manifold-like competitors): number | ~2^(n^2/4) posets of n elements |
| KR layer sizes | ~n/4 bottom, ~n/2 middle, ~n/4 top elements |
| causal structure share of the d = 4 metric | 9/10 (count supplies the missing 1/10) fraction |
| characteristic clock: discrete proper time, the length of a longest chain between comparable elements; no physical rate given | 1 element per chain step element/step |
Cross-scale patterns seen here (2) our proposal
Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet). Each links to every other system that shows it.
- same role, different builds (partial)
The continuum's volume built as an integral of the metric, or as a count of elements. - not-diluting wins (maybe)
Manifold-like causal sets are a vanishing fraction of all n-element posets (KR posets grow as ~2^(n^2/4)), so a dynamics must let measure beat entropy: 'the dominance of measure over entropy is important'.
Valence: what it trades, and with whom (6) published science
Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines) via sys:spacetime · Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet) even
- de Sitter spacetime via sys:spacetime · Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet) even
- Minkowski spacetime via sys:spacetime · Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet) even
- Sprinkled causal set (Poisson sprinkling into a Lorentzian manifold) via sys:spacetime · Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet) gain
- Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime) via sys:spacetime · Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet) even
- Causal set grown by classical sequential growth via sys:spacetime · Manifold-like causal set (continuum-like causet) even
Partners and parts published science
Built from / builds (2)
- Causal set element (hypothetical discrete event)
- Causal link (nearest-neighbour relation in a causal set)
Sits inside / holds (2)
floor filled by (7)
- Four-dimensional Lorentzian manifold (events and world lines)
- Causal set theory (causal sets programme; walked as a projected model)
- Causal set element (hypothetical discrete event)
- Minkowski spacetime
- Sprinkled causal set (Poisson sprinkling into a Lorentzian manifold)
- Causal link (nearest-neighbour relation in a causal set)
- Causal set d'Alembertian (BD operator)
represents (1)
Kinds (3)
- Causal set (causet; hypothetical discrete spacetime)
- Sprinkled causal set (Poisson sprinkling into a Lorentzian manifold)
- Manifold-like causal set with a fibre
Notes published science
- A random discrete spacetime is guaranteed to have holes somewhere if it is infinite, but the odds of even one nuclear-size hole in a universe-sized region are about e^(-10^72).
- Of all possible discrete orders, almost all are 3-layer 'KR posets' with only three moments of time; spacetimes like ours are a vanishing sliver the dynamics must find.
- Lorentz invariance survives discreteness in every single random realisation, not just on average, which a Euclidean random lattice cannot do.
Layers
The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.
manifold-like causal set: discrete order with a continuum approximation (hypothetical)
- L1: Elements uniformly distributed with respect to the spacetime volume measure (a regular lattice 'cannot do the job since it is not regular in all frames')
- L2: Order ~ Causal Order: the order matches the causal ordering of the manifold
- L3: Number ~ Spacetime Volume: <n> = rho_c v; Poisson fluctuations delta n = sqrt(n), so voids are possible; for d > 2 the Poisson distribution 'does the best job' (Saravani and Aslanbeigi 2014)
- L4: Order invariants read geometry: Myrheim-Meyer and midpoint-scaling dimension; geodesic length ~ proper time; a nonlocal discrete d'Alembertian approximating Box - R/2 in curved spacetimes, giving the BD action
- L5: Uniqueness and limits: the Hauptvermutung (unique up to approximate isometry); infinite valency and graphical non-locality (no Cauchy hypersurface); emergent continuum regions 'bounded both spatially and temporally'