EVOPEDIA

← all systems · see it in The System

No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical)

A proposal for the quantum state of the universe: the no-boundary wave function, 'defined by the sum-over-histories' over 'cosmological geometries that are regular on a disk with only one boundary', from which an ensemble of classical histories and their probabilities follows. One of the models 'in which the whole of spacetime is finite', offered 'for the initial creation of the Universe in which inflation comes about naturally'. Walked as a projected model (representation), not an observed system.

Properties published scienceour proposal

Sourced fields, and our own readings.

aliasesNo-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking)
boundaryInside: the wave function of one closed universe on superspace (scale factor b and scalar field chi in the minisuperspace models) and the ensemble of classical Lorentzian histories it predicts, from origin (bounce or singularity) to fate (recollapse or eternal inflation). Outside: no boundary in the past by construction; in time, nothing before. As an idea, bounded by the papers (Hartle and Hawking 1983; Hawking 1984; Hartle, Hawking and Hertog 2008).
nested levelBuilt from compact Euclidean geometries (complex 'fuzzy instantons' as saddle points), a homogeneous scalar field and a cosmological constant. Embedded in quantum gravity (quantum cosmology) and, as an idea, in sys:science. Rung 0, hypothesised; below the first fold.
representationTrue
scalecosmological

Measures (7) published science

model parameter separating the regimesmu = 3/2 mu = (3/Lambda)^(1/2) m
minimum scalar field for classical behaviour (mu > 3/2)1.27 phi_0 (model units)
critical field separating initially singular from bouncing histories (mu > 3/2)about 1.5 phi_s0 (model units)
age used to condition the probability of long inflation14 Gyr
volume factor applied to relative probabilitiesexp(3N) N = e-folds
proposal date1983 (Phys. Rev. D 28, 2960); Hawking 1984 (Nucl. Phys. B 239, 257) year
characteristic clock: de Sitter radius near a bounceabout (H mu phi_b)^-1 model time

Cross-scale patterns seen here (3) our proposal

Shapes that recur when the same kind of problem is solved at different scales, and how each shows in No-boundary universe (Hartle-Hawking state; hypothetical). Each links to every other system that shows it.

Valence: what it trades, and with whom (10) published science

Each exchange with a neighbour, read from both sides: who gains, who pays, and what carries it.

Partners and parts published science

Built from / builds (3)

Sits inside / holds (5)

expressed by (1)

floor filled by (14)

represents (2)

Kinds (6)

Notes published science

Layers

The ways it takes in its world, where they meet, and how it acts back, each from L1 (where it meets the world) up.

mental representation: the no-boundary proposal as proposed, appraised and held

  1. L1: Proposed: Hartle and Hawking, 'Wave function of the universe', Phys. Rev. D 28, 2960 (1983); Hawking, 'The quantum state of the universe', Nucl. Phys. B 239 (1984): the no-boundary proposal 'for the initial creation of the Universe in which inflation comes about naturally'.
  2. L2: Appraisal: 'Hawking and Page later found ambiguous results when they attempted to compute the probability of inflation in the Hartle-Hawking initial state'; with a measure from classical dynamics Gibbons and Turok 'found a negligible probability for inflation'.
  3. L3: Top-down conditioning: the 'more physical, top-down question' asks for the probability of our past given 'our limited present data in a Hubble volume'; then the most probable origin may be 'a bouncing universe in which the universe was always in the semiclassical regime'.
  4. L4: Held as a test bed: 'Any viable theory of the quantum state of our universe must predict classical spacetime over the whole of its visible part from the Planck epoch to the distant future'; listed in the Big Bang article among models 'in which the whole of spacetime is finite'.

no-boundary geometry: compact Euclidean histories to classical Lorentzian ones (spacetime)

  1. L1: The no-boundary wave function Psi(b, chi) is 'defined by the sum-over-histories' of exp(-I/hbar) over 'cosmological geometries that are regular on a disk with only one boundary at which a(tau) and phi(tau) take the values b and chi', on a complex contour that makes it converge.
  2. L2: Steepest descents: the integral is approximated by extremizing histories, which 'in general ... will be complex: fuzzy instantons'; for each, I_R is the real part of the Euclidean action and -S the imaginary part.
  3. L3: Classicality condition: when S varies rapidly and I_R slowly the wave function 'predicts an ensemble of classical histories', each with probability proportional to exp(-2 I_R/hbar); classical histories outside the ensemble have zero probability.
  4. L4: Classical Lorentzian histories: 'real and Lorentzian'; extended back they 'may be singular or bounce at a finite radius'; 'Singularities in the extrapolation of classical solutions do not signal the break down of quantum mechanics but rather of the approximation ... In this sense the NBWF resolves classical singularities.'
  5. L5: Fate and arrow: 'Recollapse to a singularity and future-eternal inflation are the two possible futures'; recollapse needs large mu and an initial singularity; 'individual Lorentzian histories are generally time asymmetric although the ensemble of histories is time-symmetric'; the arrow of time may point away from a bounce on either side.

scalar field in a quadratic potential with a cosmological constant (inflaton field, minisuperspace)

  1. L1: Minisuperspace content: homogeneous, isotropic, closed geometries with scale factor b, one homogeneous scalar field chi in V = (1/2) m^2 Phi^2, and a fundamental cosmological constant Lambda; the models are labelled by mu = (3/Lambda)^(1/2) m.
  2. L2: Matter needed for classicality: 'for the more realistic case of mu > 3/2 we found a certain amount of matter (phi_0 > 1.27) is necessary for classical behavior if there is any matter at all'; a nearly empty, almost de Sitter space is not the most probable Lorentzian history.
  3. L3: Inflation selected: 'All allowed histories that behave classically at late times inflate at early times near the bounce or the initial singularity ... The NBWF and classicality imply inflation'; for mu < 3/2 the cosmological constant drives it, for mu > 3/2 the matter does.
  4. L4: Number of e-folds: 'the NBWF on its own favors a small number of efoldings'; weighting by volume (a factor exp(3N)) and requiring an age of 14 Gyr for our Hubble volume enhances the probability of a long period of inflation.

Who fills each layer

Sources (7) published science

Big Bang
Hartle, J.B., Hawking, S.W. and Hertog, T. (2008). The Classical Universes of the No-Boundary Quantum State. (arXiv:0803.1663v1, 11 Mar 2008)
Cosmic inflation (Wikipedia, 2026-10-10) (behind its links)
Kiefer 2014, Conceptual problems in quantum gravity and quantum cosmology (arXiv 1401.3578) (behind its links)
Wheeler-DeWitt equation (Wikipedia, rev 1364573116, via Wikimedia Enterprise cache) (behind its links)
Lehners, Review of the no-boundary wave function (Phys. Rep. 1022; arXiv:2303.08802v3) (behind its links)
Vilenkin, A. (1998). The quantum cosmology debate. (arXiv:gr-qc/9812027v1, 7 Dec 1998; conference talk) (behind its links)